YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 695 lines · added Jul 30, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

MALE SPEAKER: Good afternoon.
Welcome to Talks at Google in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Today it's my great privilege to introduce Frank Wilczek.
Dr. Wilczek is kind of a one-man who's-who in physics.
He's the Herman Feshbach Professor of physics at MIT.
And his research spans condensed matter physics, astrophysics,
and particle physics.
He was one of three recipients of the Nobel Prize in physics
in 2004 for the discovery of asymptotic freedom
in the theory of the strong interaction.
In 2012, he proposed the idea of a space-time crystal.
He's written numerous books for professional and general
audiences.
He joins us today to discuss his newest
book for general audiences, "A Beautiful Question,
Finding Nature's Deep Design."
In this book, he shows us how groundbreaking work done
by scientists throughout the ages,
including himself, has always been inspired by the idea
that the universe embodies beautiful forms characterized
by symmetry, harmony, balance, proportion, and economy that we
find aesthetically pleasing and inspiring.
The book explores how intertwined our ideas
about beauty and art are with our scientific understanding
of the cosmos.
Please join me in welcoming Frank Wilczek.
[APPLAUSE]
FRANK WILCZEK: Thank you.
Thank you.
It's very interesting to be here and to have the chance
to talk to you.
In this presentation, I'm going to do three things,
and then we'll open it up to questions.
I'm going to first present the central line of argument
in the book.
Then I'll do a brief reading.
And then I'll talk through one particular scientific chapter
that's a central part of the exposition, which
I think is very well suited to a visual presentation.
It's going to be about color and how our perception of color
relates to the concept of extra dimensions.
So let's get going.
This is the beautiful question to which the title alludes.
Does the world embody beautiful ideas?
That may sound very vague and woolly or hopelessly visionary,
but it actually is something one could
make precise and investigate empirically, I would argue.
I will look.
So this question has two sides.
What is the world, which we investigate scientifically?
And what is beauty?
Beauty we can also investigate empirically.
We can look to the historical record
and see what kind of things people have found beautiful.
There's a record of art and decoration
that tells us what people have found beautiful.
And then we can compare to see if there's non-trivial--
I think I can use that word here-- nontrivial
overlap between these two conceptions, what we find
runs the world, what is the deep structure of the laws,
and what people find beautiful on the other.
From our examination of the fundamental laws which
has reached a remarkable state of perfection
over the course of the 20th century,
we can identify what the themes are.
And I would claim that there are two basic themes that
overwhelmingly emerge from the fundamental laws of nature,
the so-called standard model or core theory
that we've come to understand.
One is symmetry, and the other is exuberance.
Now, both of these come with asterisks because the words
as used by me and used generally in science
have special meaning that's a more precise version and more
limited version than their used in common language.
So the best definition of symmetry
sounds at first sight kind of mystical,
but it actually means something very precise and very
flexible and important.
Symmetry is change without change.
So for instance, a circle is a very symmetric object,
because you can rotate it around its center and every point
on it moves, so changes, but the circle as a whole does not.
And therefore, a circle is a very special object.
If you took, say, any old triangle and did a rotation,
it would not come back to the same thing.
If you take an equilateral triangle, which
is the most symmetric version, you
can rotate it, not by any angle, but if you rotate it
through 120 degrees, it comes to the same thing.
So it has some symmetry, but less than a circle.
The virtue of this definition and what
makes it become extremely fruitful
is that you can apply it not only to objects
but to physical laws.
You can ask, for instance, whether the physical laws
look the same if you move past an object at constant velocity.
That's the key concept in the theory of relativity.
Or you can ask about the symmetry of equations.
Do you have equations that you can make transformations
of that might have changed their content but in fact don't?
So they change the appearance of the equations
but not their consequences or content.
Exuberance is not usually a technical word.
The more technical version would be
something like "economy of means"
or "emergent complexity."
And this is best shown by example.
The fundamental laws are conceptually simple
and based on high degrees of symmetry,
as I've already mentioned.
But their consequences are extremely rich.
The basic ingredients of nature, we learn,
are sort of like LEGO blocks, but very intelligent LEGO
blocks that you can stack together
in many creative, interesting ways, and nature does it.
This is how chemistry, metabolism, genetics, and also
nuclear physics and astrophysics all
can be run by the same basic equations and concepts.
Now, turning to the concept of beauty, what have people
found beautiful?
Well, take a look.
This is a mosque interior from Shiraz.
And you see lots of symmetrical elements.
You see many triangles.
You see circles.
But not only is there symmetry, but there's even
the more advanced kind of symmetry
that we use in physics, where you make symmetry
where different transformations are
made at different places in space and time.
Here, if you have a triangle over here,
its symmetry is a rotation over here around its center.
You have a triangle over there.
Its symmetry is rotation around its center.
To do full justice of the symmetry
that people have found beautiful,
you have to have this gigantic concept of local symmetry,
which is, as documented here in great detail,
the fundamental principle that allows us to construct
the basic laws of nature.
Another concept that we find is extremely
central to our understanding of the physical world
and is a sort of hidden embodiment of symmetry
is the concept of relativity.
So relativity, I've already alluded to,
is centrally the concept that you
can move past a scene at constant velocity
and it will obey the same laws of physics.
Perspective in art is the science
of how things look from different viewpoints,
different viewpoints meaning, in that case,
different places you can stand to look.
But it's the same basic idea that you
can look in different configurations, places,
or velocities and see the same underlying structure.
This is change without change.
Let's talk about it in the context of perspective,
because if you consider all the possible representations
of a scene as it's looked at from different viewpoints,
that's what the science of perspective is all about.
How can you realize the same scene
from many different viewpoints?
Then if you have that whole understanding,
that whole collection of possible representations,
moving the object, rotating it or moving it,
although it changes the object, does not
change the entire collection of ways it could look.
So you have, in this broader perspective,
a change without change, a symmetry, and the science
perspective and art and the discipline
of projective geometry and mathematics,
which are basically the same thing, or the study
of that kind of symmetry.
And people found it beautiful.
Just look.
Shortly after the science of perspective
was discovered by Brunelleschi around 1430,
it played a big role in triggering
the painting revolution of the Italian Renaissance.
This is one of the earliest masterpieces in that tradition.
And you can see the joy that Perugino took in experimenting
with perspective and how the town square is accurately
represented, and the people are so
happy to be part of an accurately portrayed town
square, and the buildings are meant
to point in interesting directions
with parallels converging at different vanishing points.
And you can see that Perugino had a great time with this,
and people found it beautiful.
And I find it-- I think you will find it beautiful.
And here's one more example, which is a little more exotic.
This is a portrait by Matisse, and it
exhibits another really strange kind of change without change.
Perspective is the idea that you can look at scenes
from different places.
Here, the idea is that you can make transformations and color
space, so changing blue into red or red
into green, at different places.
You still have the same underlying image,
but it can be a beautiful thing to look
at it from this kind of very general perspective,
now not only in the sense of changing things in space
and time, but also changing things in color space.
And that's another version of local symmetry,
now changing things and their properties that turns out
to be fundamental in constructing
our understanding of the world.
So that concludes the proof, the demonstration,
that what people find beautiful has a remarkable overlap,
remarkable concordance, with what we
find are the basic principles that run the world.
Now I'd like to read a little bit
so you can be assured as to the quality of prose in this book.
This comes towards the end, so it
alludes to some things that came before.
But I think the meanings will be clear from the context.
"Trust in beauty has often, in the past, paid off.
Newton's theory of gravity was challenged
by the orbit of Uranus, which did not obey its predictions.
But Urbain Le Verrier and also John Couch Adams,
trusting in the beauty of the underlying theory,
were led to propose the existence of a new planet,
not yet observed, whose influence might be responsible.
Their calculations told astronomers where to look,
and that led to the discovery of Neptune.
Maxwell's great synthesis, as we've seen,
predicted new colors of light, invisible to our eyes,
also not yet observed.
Trusting in the beauty of the theory,
Hertz both produced and observed radio waves.
In more recent times, Paul Dirac predicted,
through a strange and beautiful equation, the existence
of antiparticles, which had not yet been observed
but soon thereafter were.
The core, anchored in symmetry, gave us color gluons, w and z
particles, the Higgs particle, the charmed quark,
and the particles of the third family,
all as predictions prior to their observation.
But there have been failures, too.
Plato's theory of atoms and Kepler's model
of the solar system were beautiful theories
that, as descriptions of nature, utterly failed.
Another was Kelvin's theory of atoms,
which proposed that they are knots of activity in the ether.
Knots come in different forms, and they're not easily undone,
so they have, it might seem, the right stuff to make atoms.
But they aren't.
Those failures were not without fruit.
Plato's theory inspired deeper study of geometry and symmetry.
Kepler's model inspired his own great career in astronomy.
And Kelvin's model inspired Peter Tait
to develop the theory of mathematical knots, which
remains a vibrant subject today.
But as theories of the physical world,
they are hopelessly wrong.
The fate of supersymmetry is not yet decided.
Its discovery would, as I've described,
reward our trust in beauty as a guide to deep reality.
There are good reasons to think that discovery
may be imminent and beautiful reasons to hope so,
but it has not yet occurred.
We shall see.
According to the story of Doubting Thomas,
the apostle Thomas was skeptical of Jesus' Resurrection,
withholding his belief in the absence of evidence."
And now we have a quotation.
"'Except I shall see in his hands the print of the nails
and put my finger into the print of the nails and thrust my hand
into his side, I will not believe.'
When Jesus did appear to Thomas, he
allowed Thomas to examine his wounds, and Thomas believed.
Jesus said, Thomas, because thou has seen me,
thou hast believed.
And blessed are they that have not seen and yet have believed.
That story has inspired many works of art,
including Caravaggio's 'Incredulity of St
Thomas,' which I find resonant."
That's what you're seeing here.
"To me, Caravaggio's rendering conveys two profound messages
that go beyond the words of the Gospel's text.
One sees first that Jesus does not
resist Thomas' inquisitive examination
but rather welcomes it.
And one sees that Thomas is fascinated and excited
to discover that reality conforms to his deepest hopes.
Doubting Thomas is a hero and a happy man.
Those who believe without seeing are blessed
with the joy of certainty.
But it is a fragile certainty and a hollow joy.
Those whose faith is not passive but engages reality
will receive a second, more fulfilling blessing
in the harmony of belief and experience.
Blessed are those who believe what they see."
Thus endeth the second part.
And now I'd like to talk about a specific subject that
is well suited to brief presentation and very visual.
This is my favorite physicist in his prime.
This is James Clerk Maxwell.
You can see a kind of playful expression on his face,
a gleam in his eye, and a toy in his hand.
What is that strange toy?
Well, it turns out that toy is actually
a scientific instrument and one that Maxwell
used to elucidate the nature of human color perception.
This explains the principal.
You can have two bands, two angular bands,
if you like, and put colored strips of paper
around them with different lengths and different colors
and then twirl them around, taking advantage
of the persistence of vision to see if the colors match,
to see if you can reproduce how one band looks, say,
the yellow band out there, if you can reproduce
the yellow band by suitable mixtures of red and green.
And what Maxwell found in a meticulous set of experiments
extending over many years that he did largely
with his wife's help, is that he could
match any color on the outside.
So he try strips of many different colors, all
that he could find, by using just three colors
in different proportions on the inside.
We call that trichromicity, that humans can
sense three different colors.
That's the basis of computer displays, of color television,
of color photography.
You use three inks or three kinds of LEDs or three kinds
beams in general in different proportions
to make any color you like.
And here's an iconic representation of that.
And you can see that very different
looking things, for instance a mixture of red and green,
pure red and green, spectral red and green,
can give you something that's yellow even though that's
very different from the yellow of the rainbow, which
is a pure spectral yellow as a physical phenomenon.
We can represent that situation more
abstractly in a suggestive way, using a color cube.
So in one direction, you have the intensity of blue,
in another the intensity of green,
and another the intensity of red.
And by mixing them in different proportions,
you'll find on the inside of the cube
all possible colors, ending in white at the far corner,
each represented uniquely.
So in this precise sense, the space of perceptible colors
is a three-dimensional space.
Now, there's no denying the mystical appeal
of the concept of extra dimensions, its appeal
to mystics and people interested in science and popular science
ever since there have been those things.
Here's a lovely image of what extra dimensions might
be conceptually in terms of, OK, there's physical space
and you have little spaces on top.
It's really very appealing, very pretty.
If only we could experience them, though.
Well, we can and we do.
Remember, here's our color cube.
Now think about what you're seeing when
you look at a computer screen.
At every point, you're getting a sample of the color cube.
So it's almost literally that previous picture except better,
because now it's colorful.
And if you want to think about this more formally,
if you're programming a computer and you
want to tell it what to do, what kind of instructions
do you have to give?
You have to tell it at each point on the screen,
at each position x and y, at each time t, how much red,
how much green, and how much blue to output.
So these are six numbers.
And inside the program, they look pretty much all the same.
It's very hard to tell that two of them are space, one is time,
and three of them are colors.
So you are, in that very tangible sense,
also in that mathematically precise sense,
exploring a space of six dimensions,
two space in the ordinary sense, time, and three colors.
So the answer to the question, "What
do extra dimensions look like?" is you're looking at them.
So that was the little chapter of science
that I wanted to show you.
And now we can take questions.
Thank you.
[APPLAUSE]
AUDIENCE: Thank you for talk and the interesting book.
So you pointed out a number of examples
where human intuitions about symmetry and beauty
lead us to non-physical theories.
What about the flip side?
I mean, there's a lot of things that we
find beautiful that are not particularly
symmetric or beautiful.
FRANK WILCZEK: Oh, absolutely.
AUDIENCE: There's entire schools of art
founded on dissonance and disorder and things like that.
FRANK WILCZEK: Yes, the claim is not that all forms of beauty
are embodied in nature or that everything in nature or even
in the fundamental laws, which is the focus here,
is beautiful.
There are lots of loose ends in our understanding, lots
of things whose beauty is not apparent at present
and may never be apparent.
And on the other hand-- your question
is even more to the point-- there
are many forms of beauty that don't seem to be embodied
in the fundamental laws.
The beauty of the human form, moral beauty,
things that dominate, really, most of art, are not,
as far as we can tell, represented
in the fundamental laws.
But the remarkable thing is that there
are things that people have found beautiful,
some central elements of the realization of beauty and art,
not all by any means, not even most of it,
but some central elements are exactly what
we find runs the world in the central fundamental laws.
AUDIENCE: Sort of along the same lines,
are you trying to imply a causality here?
Or is it just correlation?
It seems like you're sort of cherry picking beautiful things
here, beautiful things there, and sort of ignoring the rest.
[LAUGHTER]
FRANK WILCZEK: Well, I guess if there's not complete overlap,
I have to ignore something.
But I will stand by the claim that the aspects
of physical law that I've chosen are not cherry picked.
Those are absolutely central to our fundamental understanding
of the basic laws.
Now, you might ask-- I think the spirit of your question
is, is that a coincidence, or does that go deeper?
I don't think it's an entire coincidence.
So where does our sense of duty come from?
Well, certainly part of it is we find beautiful things
that evolution wants to encourage us to enjoy and get
more of.
That's part of the feeling of pleasure
that we get from beautiful thing.
Now, we as human beings have quite a challenge
to get our sensory act in order, so to speak.
When you look out at the world, you want to interpret it,
or evolution wants you to interpret it,
as a world of three-dimensional objects you can move around in,
possibly threatening things, possibly
things you want to mate with, possibly
things you want to eat.
But the signal that arrives on our retina
is a two-dimensional image, scrambled often.
It's a very non-trivial task, as some of you may be exploring,
art of computer vision know, it's a very non-trivial task
to figure out how we do it.
Part of it has to be that we're intuitively very
good at projective geometry.
We could go back from a two-dimensional image
to the three-dimensional thing it might have produced.
But to actually codify the rules of projective geometry
and perspective was very difficult.
We don't know how we do it, but a very large part
of the human brain is devoted to prec
…

Need subtitles from another video?