Advertisement
English transcript
CESAR HIDALGO: So my name is Cesar Hidalgo
and I'm a Professor at the MIT Media
Lab, where I run a group called Macro Connections.
And today I'm here promoting this little baby.
It took me 2 and 1/2 years to give birth to it,
and it's called "Why Information Grows."
The story of the book actually is quite simple.
The idea is that the universe is made of three things-- energy,
matter, and information.
But information is the one that makes the universe interesting.
Information is the one that gives the universe
its structure, its beauty, and its complexity.
But for the most part, we have struggled
to understand where information comes from.
So what I'm going to do in the next 40 minutes
is explain to you what information is,
where it comes from, and how it manages to grow.
And to understand the origins of information,
we have to understand how information
is related to matter because, as Landauer
repeated an infinite number of times, information is physical.
It's always embodied on physical states, physical particles.
In some way, despite the physicality of information,
it is one of the latest things that we
have been able to understand from a physical perspective.
Some of the first people to start thinking about this
were people in the 19th century like Ludwig Boltzmann.
Now, Boltzmann was a famous statistical physicist, but also
a relatively sad man.
He ended his own life in 1906.
And he ended own life after having
gone through a scientific career that
was full of very fruitful results,
but also results that were sometimes
rejected by his colleagues.
Boltzmann had, for instance, advocated
for the idea of atoms, and many of his colleagues
believed that atoms were nothing more than a convenient analogy
and they should not be incorporated
into scientific theories because they were not
directly observable.
Boltzmann also was inspired by some people
that had produced great scientific results a little bit
before him.
Two of where Charles Darwin and Alfred Wallace.
And Boltzmann had seen in Darwin's and Wallace's theory
of evolution through natural selection,
an explanation of the biological origins of order.
And what he wanted to do in his life
was actually develop an explanation
of the physical origins of order.
So he tried to understand systems that were
composed of many particles.
And what he realized is that those systems eventually do not
go towards order, but go towards disorder.
That was something that also troubled him.
Because the thing is that the universe
has a tendency to average itself out.
This is known as the second law of thermodynamics.
So think about a very simple example.
I am now speaking in this room.
And as I speak in this room, I'm technically
writing on pressure waves on air.
But those pressure ways on the air are very short lived.
These pressure waves move around the room.
Basically, the particles that have differences in pressure
average out and that sound disappears,
and that information is not embodied in the air anymore.
And the same is true for a lot of physical systems.
So you take a cup of coffee and you put milk in the beginning,
you have all of these beautiful swirls that
are full of correlations and very interesting informations
and fractural structures that after a while
is just a hazy cloud in which everything is kind of mixed.
And the universe has this tendency of mixing things
in ways that are not mixable.
The thing that you cannot unmix is temperature,
and that's what Boltzmann discovered.
So the question of where order comes from
was a question that actually eluded not only Boltzmann,
but many great scientists that came after him
and tried to continue to develop the statistical physics
that Boltzmann had started.
This included Maxwell, Einstein, and Gibbs.
And the true breakthrough happened
in the first half of the 20th century
when the Russian born and Belgian
raised statistical physicist Ilya Prigogine started
to look at systems that were a bit different
than the ones that had been looked at by Boltzmann.
Prigogine realized that Boltzmann was right,
that physical systems that are composed of many particles
when left to their own devices would go to an equilibrium
state in which basically, all particles more or less
are moving willy nilly.
And even though they encode technically
a lot of information in their quantum states
or in the positions and velocities that they have,
they do not encode much order.
And Prigogine also wanted to explain
the origins of physical order, but he
realized that in order to do so, you
had to look at a little bit of a different system.
The systems that Boltzmann, Einstein, Maxwell, and Gibbs
had looked at were systems that were in equilibrium--
basically, when looking at the state of the coffee
and the milk after the milk had been in the coffee
for a long time and everything had mixed up.
Prigogine realized that what he had to look at
were systems that were out of equilibrium.
And what he realized is that the systems that
were out of equilibrium satisfied a different objective
function.
The systems that are in equilibrium maximize entropy.
The systems that are out of equilibrium, Prigogine
showed in a very particular example,
they minimize the rate of entropy production.
What does that mean?
Well, the systems are producing entropy,
but are producing as little entropy as possible.
And when the systems self organize
to produce as little entropy as possible
is where order emerges.
So the classic example of this is the bathtub whirlpool.
How many of you have used a bathtub in your lives?
I assume most of you have used a bathtub.
And you have made this observation
that when you take the plunger out
of the bathtub and the water starts racing down
the drain, at some point, there is
a little whirlpool that forms.
That whirlpool is actually a very simple form
of physical order that is emerging
in the steady state of a dynamical system that
is out of equilibrium.
Why?
Because in this whirlpool, if you think about it,
if you know the velocity of a particle,
you very much know the velocity of the particles
that are neighboring that.
They tend to be very similar.
But since these particles are correlated
and they're moving with velocities
that are similar to that of their neighbors,
they're not dissipating too much energy
because they don't have too much friction,
or interactions that are not happening
at speeds that are highly dissimilar between these two
particles.
So they're minimizing the rate at which they dissipate energy.
And in that state in which they minimize
the rate at which they dissipate energy,
order starts to emerge for free.
But the big lesson here is actually
that in order to generate physical order and information,
there is an energy cost.
You cannot produce order without spending energy.
And that's a fundamental thermodynamic relationship.
You cannot record a video on your phone when your battery is
gone.
The thing is the origins of physical order
were explained by Prigogine by looking out
of equilibrium systems does not help us explain
more complex forms of physical order,
like the ones, for instance, that we observe in our cities
or in our homes, or in the economy at large.
For that maybe we're going to need
to have a few other additional principles that
help us understand how order continues
to grow to the extent in which it's able to produce
the type of complexity that we observe
in nature and in society.
So the second ingredient for the physical origins of order
was one what was hinted at by Erwin Schrodinger in his 1944
book, "What is Life."
So Schrodinger in his book "What is Life" already acknowledges
and recognizes that life is a machine
that is going against the second law of thermodynamics.
It's minimizing entropy internally
and obviously, we are producing heat
at our seams to make sure that the entropy in the universe
at large continues to increase.
But locally, we eat food and we use
that energy to produce order.
But the thing is if we always have
to be producing order by consuming
energy, the amount of order that we would be
able to produce is very little.
So we have to have a way of saving that order, marking sure
that order endures, perseveres.
So what Schrodinger said in some sense,
one of the tricks that life had figured out to help order grow
and to help information grow was to store that information
in aperiodic crystals.
Think of proteins.
Think of DNA.
Think of RNA.
All of these molecules are actually quite stable.
DNA is very stable.
You can store it at room temperature
for a very long time.
And it's able to preserve information,
and it's able to in some way obviate
the second law of thermodynamics, at least
temporarily.
And because solids make order endure,
once you're able to store information in solids,
you don't need to be creating it all the time.
You can start recombining it and you can help order grow.
So that's the second trick.
The second trick is that you need to preserve information.
And for that, you need solids.
But there's one more trick that nature has in its
[INAUDIBLE] that helps order grow
in pockets of the universe.
This one is the capacity of matter to compute.
People tend to think of computation as something
that we invented recently.
But actually, computation started with the big bang.
Every time two physical particles interact,
they're actually exchanging information,
and that's an act of computation.
They're processing information.
And computation is actually a prerequisite of life.
So just to give you an idea of how fundamental computation is,
I'm going to use as an example a tree because people don't tend
to think of trees as computers.
But trees are computers.
They don't have consciousness like you and I,
and they cannot run MATLAB or R or Python like the digital
computers that we have built, but they can run actually
programs that maybe are even more sophisticated than those.
A tree knows how to grow its leaves
in a certain direction and its roots in a direction
of the world that it needs.
A tree knows how to turn genes on and off to fight off pests.
A tree also knows how to perform photosynthesis.
A tree knows when to shed its leaves
and when to grow them again.
These are all acts of computation
that a tree is performing because in some sense,
the tree is a computer that is building itself
from the intimacy of the cells to the totality of its larger
structure.
So for information to grow in the universe
and to exist despite the second law of thermodynamics,
the universe has three fundamental tricks.
The first one is that you need to spend some energy.
You cannot get information in an equilibrium system.
It has to get out of equilibrium system because information,
order are not free.
The second thing is that you need
to have ways of saving that information.
You need to have some sort of solid.
And here, be very in some sense general in the use of the word
"solids."
When you have spins in a hard drive,
you can also think that in some sense,
as long as those spins are stable in that hard drive,
that's a solid, too.
It doesn't have to be something like a totem in which we're
passing on cultural information by carving it on wood.
It can be actually a very general thing about something
that is not a fluid, that has a state of stasis that is
stable to thermal fluctuations.
That's what I mean by a solid here.
And finally, by using solids, energy,
matter develops the capacity to compute,
which is the capacity to recompile information.
So what we will see now is that this capacity to compute
is actually the key to make possible the growth
of information in the universe.
But it also has made the growth of information
in the universe very difficult.
So what I'm going to do next is I'm
going to take these three fundamental mechanism
and I'm going to look now at society and the economy.
And I'm going to try to explain how information continues
to grow at the high level of complexity that you and I live.
So the first thing that I need to answer
to be able to explain that is, what are
the types of information that we produce in society
and that we use in society?
And to do that, I'm going to tell you a story.
So I'm originally from Chile, and I've been living in the US
for 11 years now.
And if anybody here probably has moved out
of their home country, where you find yourself is that when
you're procrastinating online, often, you're
going to go and visit a newspaper from the country
that you were born.
There's not many interesting news there.
It's kind of like local news.
And once, there was this news, "Chilean Bought the World's
Most Expensive Car."
And obviously, my first reaction was like, what a douche.
Why do you need to buy a car that's so expensive?
But then eventually, I started thinking about,
what car was it, and how much was it worth?
And the car was a Bugatti Veyron.
So I searched online.
And a Bugatti Veyron costs $2 and 1/2 million,
and that's $1,300 a kilo.
So obviously, you think that, well,
why is this guy thinking about how much does
a kilo of a car worth?
This is not rice or beans or things that you buy per kilo.
But thinking of a kilo of a Bugatti
is interesting because it's going
to teach us an important lesson about the nature of information
in the economy.
So imagine that you have just won
this vehicle on the lottery, and you're driving it
through the city, very excited because this is a brand new car
and you're all pumped up.
And then boom!
You crash it against the wall.
Now, how much is that kilo of Bugatti worth?
Obviously, you don't need a PhD in economics
to know that a kilo of a Bugatti now
is worth way less than before.
The value evaporated when you crashed that car
against that wall.
And what this is telling you as well that the value of that car
was not related to the atoms, but was related
to the way in which those atoms were ordered or arranged,
and that is information.
So the Bugatti was made of information
even though it was not a message.
It was an object.
So let's try to understand a little bit more
about the types of information that we have
in society and the economy.
And the second example that I'm going to use
is I'm going to ask you guys to compare apples and apples.
And on the left, you have the Apples that here in Google
detest.
And on the right, you have the ones
that you buy in the supermarket that you eat.
And the question I'm going to ask
you is, what is the fundamental difference between these two
types of products?
Obviously, they both contain information and physical order.
And some people might say price, some people
might say complexity.
But I can basically argue that the apple
on the right, the one that you eat,
has molecular mechanisms inside its cells
that are unparalleled by anything that has been built
by an engineer in the world.
So the true difference is not in their price,
it's not in their complexity.
It's not in the fact that one of them has information
and the other one doesn't because both have information.
The true difference is that the first apple existed first
in the world and then in your heads,
and the second Apple existed first
in someone's head and then in the world.
The first apple existed before there was a name for apples,
a price for apples, and a market for apples.
So what this telling us is that the second Apple is special
because it is a crystal of imagination.
And that's an observation that is very important
because we live in a world that is tangible,
but that tangibility is actually made of fiction.
All of the objects that we have-- the clothes that we
wear, the shoes, the computers that we use,
the cars that we drive, the buildings that we live in--
were all imagined before they were built.
And by noticing that the products that we
make in our economy are crystals of imagination,
we can interpret important economic processes.
So we can reinterpret the economy based on the idea
that products are made of crystallized imagination.
So as an example, let's take some data
from the Observatory of Economic Complexity, which
is a data visualization engine that I created with my team
at MIT.
And here are the products that Chile exports to South Korea.
And you see there are two things.
On aggregate, you see that Chile exports $4.6 billion.
But in this more desirable view, you
see what Chile exports to South Korea.
And you see that Chile exports to South Korea mostly atoms--
refined copper, copper ores, and pig meat, grapes, and so forth.
Now, what does Chile buy from South Korea?
What Chile buys from South Korea are cars, machines,
and delivery trucks.
In total, they're buying only $2.5 million.
So what that means is that Chile has a positive trade
surplus with Korea because they're exporting 4.6 billion
and buying 2.5 But they have a negative imagination surplus.
They have a negative imagination balance
because Chile is exporting atoms and Korea,
what it's sending back is the way in which
those atoms are arranged.
And what this is starting to tell
us is that eventually, economies are computers, and are
computers with different capacities.
And as we will see by the end of this talk,
the different computational capacity of different economies
can help us even explain the level of income
that each economy is able to achieve.
In this case, it should be obvious
that the economy of South Korea is
a more sophisticated computer than that of Chile,
is able to generate more sophisticated forms
of physical order.
Another thing that, for example, thinking
about the world in terms of crystallized imagination
helps us reinterpret is the dynamics
of natural resource exploitation that
are prevalent in many developing countries.
I come from Chile.
And as you've seen, Chile basically sells rocks.
Why the heck we sell so many rocks?
Every year, Chile exports roughly $50 billion
worth of rocks.
Why is the world willing to pay so much money for those rocks?
Those green rocks are rocks of copper,
and people are willing to pay for copper.
Well, because copper, once you melt it and make it
into a spaghetti, you can actually
conduct electricity quite as well-- not as good as gold,
but much cheaper than gold.
So some people say, well, Chile is being exploited
because people are taking these rocks out of Chile that
are very valuable.
And then basically, what is Chile getting out
of this other than some miners that
live in some towns that are pretty desolate and $50
million?
And the thing is, well, you have to think about,
where is that value actually coming from?
Is the value on the atoms?
Is the value on the rocks?
Or was the value endowed to the rocks by some sort
of computational process?
So we are buying these rocks now.
And we were not buying these rocks for a lot of money
300 years ago because roughly 150 years ago, there
was a guy called Michael Faraday that figured out
that if you jiggle a magnet inside a coil,
you can produce electricity.
That knowledge eventually is the one
that allows us to live in this electrified world
that we live in nowadays that allows us to produce
a large amount of information because we have transformed
that energy that helps us produce information
in the form of electricity.
But it's also that piece of knowledge and that piece of
know how that endowed those rocks with all
of that economic value.
So in some sense, we can say that Chile is not
being exploited because people are taking rocks out of Chile.
Chile is actually exploiting knowledge
and know how that was produced elsewhere.
So the question then is, well, why
do we crystallize imagination?
One thing that you might have not noticed
is that we make products that are tangible
but that started as fiction, and we're the only species
to do so.
There's no other species that makes
products that are tangible and that started as imagination.
And if you see pictures of elephants making drawings
on the internet, they basically get whipped the heck out
of in very questionable practices
to make sure that they make the same drawing over and over.
So it's not like the elephant has this
…
and I'm a Professor at the MIT Media
Lab, where I run a group called Macro Connections.
And today I'm here promoting this little baby.
It took me 2 and 1/2 years to give birth to it,
and it's called "Why Information Grows."
The story of the book actually is quite simple.
The idea is that the universe is made of three things-- energy,
matter, and information.
But information is the one that makes the universe interesting.
Information is the one that gives the universe
its structure, its beauty, and its complexity.
But for the most part, we have struggled
to understand where information comes from.
So what I'm going to do in the next 40 minutes
is explain to you what information is,
where it comes from, and how it manages to grow.
And to understand the origins of information,
we have to understand how information
is related to matter because, as Landauer
repeated an infinite number of times, information is physical.
It's always embodied on physical states, physical particles.
In some way, despite the physicality of information,
it is one of the latest things that we
have been able to understand from a physical perspective.
Some of the first people to start thinking about this
were people in the 19th century like Ludwig Boltzmann.
Now, Boltzmann was a famous statistical physicist, but also
a relatively sad man.
He ended his own life in 1906.
And he ended own life after having
gone through a scientific career that
was full of very fruitful results,
but also results that were sometimes
rejected by his colleagues.
Boltzmann had, for instance, advocated
for the idea of atoms, and many of his colleagues
believed that atoms were nothing more than a convenient analogy
and they should not be incorporated
into scientific theories because they were not
directly observable.
Boltzmann also was inspired by some people
that had produced great scientific results a little bit
before him.
Two of where Charles Darwin and Alfred Wallace.
And Boltzmann had seen in Darwin's and Wallace's theory
of evolution through natural selection,
an explanation of the biological origins of order.
And what he wanted to do in his life
was actually develop an explanation
of the physical origins of order.
So he tried to understand systems that were
composed of many particles.
And what he realized is that those systems eventually do not
go towards order, but go towards disorder.
That was something that also troubled him.
Because the thing is that the universe
has a tendency to average itself out.
This is known as the second law of thermodynamics.
So think about a very simple example.
I am now speaking in this room.
And as I speak in this room, I'm technically
writing on pressure waves on air.
But those pressure ways on the air are very short lived.
These pressure waves move around the room.
Basically, the particles that have differences in pressure
average out and that sound disappears,
and that information is not embodied in the air anymore.
And the same is true for a lot of physical systems.
So you take a cup of coffee and you put milk in the beginning,
you have all of these beautiful swirls that
are full of correlations and very interesting informations
and fractural structures that after a while
is just a hazy cloud in which everything is kind of mixed.
And the universe has this tendency of mixing things
in ways that are not mixable.
The thing that you cannot unmix is temperature,
and that's what Boltzmann discovered.
So the question of where order comes from
was a question that actually eluded not only Boltzmann,
but many great scientists that came after him
and tried to continue to develop the statistical physics
that Boltzmann had started.
This included Maxwell, Einstein, and Gibbs.
And the true breakthrough happened
in the first half of the 20th century
when the Russian born and Belgian
raised statistical physicist Ilya Prigogine started
to look at systems that were a bit different
than the ones that had been looked at by Boltzmann.
Prigogine realized that Boltzmann was right,
that physical systems that are composed of many particles
when left to their own devices would go to an equilibrium
state in which basically, all particles more or less
are moving willy nilly.
And even though they encode technically
a lot of information in their quantum states
or in the positions and velocities that they have,
they do not encode much order.
And Prigogine also wanted to explain
the origins of physical order, but he
realized that in order to do so, you
had to look at a little bit of a different system.
The systems that Boltzmann, Einstein, Maxwell, and Gibbs
had looked at were systems that were in equilibrium--
basically, when looking at the state of the coffee
and the milk after the milk had been in the coffee
for a long time and everything had mixed up.
Prigogine realized that what he had to look at
were systems that were out of equilibrium.
And what he realized is that the systems that
were out of equilibrium satisfied a different objective
function.
The systems that are in equilibrium maximize entropy.
The systems that are out of equilibrium, Prigogine
showed in a very particular example,
they minimize the rate of entropy production.
What does that mean?
Well, the systems are producing entropy,
but are producing as little entropy as possible.
And when the systems self organize
to produce as little entropy as possible
is where order emerges.
So the classic example of this is the bathtub whirlpool.
How many of you have used a bathtub in your lives?
I assume most of you have used a bathtub.
And you have made this observation
that when you take the plunger out
of the bathtub and the water starts racing down
the drain, at some point, there is
a little whirlpool that forms.
That whirlpool is actually a very simple form
of physical order that is emerging
in the steady state of a dynamical system that
is out of equilibrium.
Why?
Because in this whirlpool, if you think about it,
if you know the velocity of a particle,
you very much know the velocity of the particles
that are neighboring that.
They tend to be very similar.
But since these particles are correlated
and they're moving with velocities
that are similar to that of their neighbors,
they're not dissipating too much energy
because they don't have too much friction,
or interactions that are not happening
at speeds that are highly dissimilar between these two
particles.
So they're minimizing the rate at which they dissipate energy.
And in that state in which they minimize
the rate at which they dissipate energy,
order starts to emerge for free.
But the big lesson here is actually
that in order to generate physical order and information,
there is an energy cost.
You cannot produce order without spending energy.
And that's a fundamental thermodynamic relationship.
You cannot record a video on your phone when your battery is
gone.
The thing is the origins of physical order
were explained by Prigogine by looking out
of equilibrium systems does not help us explain
more complex forms of physical order,
like the ones, for instance, that we observe in our cities
or in our homes, or in the economy at large.
For that maybe we're going to need
to have a few other additional principles that
help us understand how order continues
to grow to the extent in which it's able to produce
the type of complexity that we observe
in nature and in society.
So the second ingredient for the physical origins of order
was one what was hinted at by Erwin Schrodinger in his 1944
book, "What is Life."
So Schrodinger in his book "What is Life" already acknowledges
and recognizes that life is a machine
that is going against the second law of thermodynamics.
It's minimizing entropy internally
and obviously, we are producing heat
at our seams to make sure that the entropy in the universe
at large continues to increase.
But locally, we eat food and we use
that energy to produce order.
But the thing is if we always have
to be producing order by consuming
energy, the amount of order that we would be
able to produce is very little.
So we have to have a way of saving that order, marking sure
that order endures, perseveres.
So what Schrodinger said in some sense,
one of the tricks that life had figured out to help order grow
and to help information grow was to store that information
in aperiodic crystals.
Think of proteins.
Think of DNA.
Think of RNA.
All of these molecules are actually quite stable.
DNA is very stable.
You can store it at room temperature
for a very long time.
And it's able to preserve information,
and it's able to in some way obviate
the second law of thermodynamics, at least
temporarily.
And because solids make order endure,
once you're able to store information in solids,
you don't need to be creating it all the time.
You can start recombining it and you can help order grow.
So that's the second trick.
The second trick is that you need to preserve information.
And for that, you need solids.
But there's one more trick that nature has in its
[INAUDIBLE] that helps order grow
in pockets of the universe.
This one is the capacity of matter to compute.
People tend to think of computation as something
that we invented recently.
But actually, computation started with the big bang.
Every time two physical particles interact,
they're actually exchanging information,
and that's an act of computation.
They're processing information.
And computation is actually a prerequisite of life.
So just to give you an idea of how fundamental computation is,
I'm going to use as an example a tree because people don't tend
to think of trees as computers.
But trees are computers.
They don't have consciousness like you and I,
and they cannot run MATLAB or R or Python like the digital
computers that we have built, but they can run actually
programs that maybe are even more sophisticated than those.
A tree knows how to grow its leaves
in a certain direction and its roots in a direction
of the world that it needs.
A tree knows how to turn genes on and off to fight off pests.
A tree also knows how to perform photosynthesis.
A tree knows when to shed its leaves
and when to grow them again.
These are all acts of computation
that a tree is performing because in some sense,
the tree is a computer that is building itself
from the intimacy of the cells to the totality of its larger
structure.
So for information to grow in the universe
and to exist despite the second law of thermodynamics,
the universe has three fundamental tricks.
The first one is that you need to spend some energy.
You cannot get information in an equilibrium system.
It has to get out of equilibrium system because information,
order are not free.
The second thing is that you need
to have ways of saving that information.
You need to have some sort of solid.
And here, be very in some sense general in the use of the word
"solids."
When you have spins in a hard drive,
you can also think that in some sense,
as long as those spins are stable in that hard drive,
that's a solid, too.
It doesn't have to be something like a totem in which we're
passing on cultural information by carving it on wood.
It can be actually a very general thing about something
that is not a fluid, that has a state of stasis that is
stable to thermal fluctuations.
That's what I mean by a solid here.
And finally, by using solids, energy,
matter develops the capacity to compute,
which is the capacity to recompile information.
So what we will see now is that this capacity to compute
is actually the key to make possible the growth
of information in the universe.
But it also has made the growth of information
in the universe very difficult.
So what I'm going to do next is I'm
going to take these three fundamental mechanism
and I'm going to look now at society and the economy.
And I'm going to try to explain how information continues
to grow at the high level of complexity that you and I live.
So the first thing that I need to answer
to be able to explain that is, what are
the types of information that we produce in society
and that we use in society?
And to do that, I'm going to tell you a story.
So I'm originally from Chile, and I've been living in the US
for 11 years now.
And if anybody here probably has moved out
of their home country, where you find yourself is that when
you're procrastinating online, often, you're
going to go and visit a newspaper from the country
that you were born.
There's not many interesting news there.
It's kind of like local news.
And once, there was this news, "Chilean Bought the World's
Most Expensive Car."
And obviously, my first reaction was like, what a douche.
Why do you need to buy a car that's so expensive?
But then eventually, I started thinking about,
what car was it, and how much was it worth?
And the car was a Bugatti Veyron.
So I searched online.
And a Bugatti Veyron costs $2 and 1/2 million,
and that's $1,300 a kilo.
So obviously, you think that, well,
why is this guy thinking about how much does
a kilo of a car worth?
This is not rice or beans or things that you buy per kilo.
But thinking of a kilo of a Bugatti
is interesting because it's going
to teach us an important lesson about the nature of information
in the economy.
So imagine that you have just won
this vehicle on the lottery, and you're driving it
through the city, very excited because this is a brand new car
and you're all pumped up.
And then boom!
You crash it against the wall.
Now, how much is that kilo of Bugatti worth?
Obviously, you don't need a PhD in economics
to know that a kilo of a Bugatti now
is worth way less than before.
The value evaporated when you crashed that car
against that wall.
And what this is telling you as well that the value of that car
was not related to the atoms, but was related
to the way in which those atoms were ordered or arranged,
and that is information.
So the Bugatti was made of information
even though it was not a message.
It was an object.
So let's try to understand a little bit more
about the types of information that we have
in society and the economy.
And the second example that I'm going to use
is I'm going to ask you guys to compare apples and apples.
And on the left, you have the Apples that here in Google
detest.
And on the right, you have the ones
that you buy in the supermarket that you eat.
And the question I'm going to ask
you is, what is the fundamental difference between these two
types of products?
Obviously, they both contain information and physical order.
And some people might say price, some people
might say complexity.
But I can basically argue that the apple
on the right, the one that you eat,
has molecular mechanisms inside its cells
that are unparalleled by anything that has been built
by an engineer in the world.
So the true difference is not in their price,
it's not in their complexity.
It's not in the fact that one of them has information
and the other one doesn't because both have information.
The true difference is that the first apple existed first
in the world and then in your heads,
and the second Apple existed first
in someone's head and then in the world.
The first apple existed before there was a name for apples,
a price for apples, and a market for apples.
So what this telling us is that the second Apple is special
because it is a crystal of imagination.
And that's an observation that is very important
because we live in a world that is tangible,
but that tangibility is actually made of fiction.
All of the objects that we have-- the clothes that we
wear, the shoes, the computers that we use,
the cars that we drive, the buildings that we live in--
were all imagined before they were built.
And by noticing that the products that we
make in our economy are crystals of imagination,
we can interpret important economic processes.
So we can reinterpret the economy based on the idea
that products are made of crystallized imagination.
So as an example, let's take some data
from the Observatory of Economic Complexity, which
is a data visualization engine that I created with my team
at MIT.
And here are the products that Chile exports to South Korea.
And you see there are two things.
On aggregate, you see that Chile exports $4.6 billion.
But in this more desirable view, you
see what Chile exports to South Korea.
And you see that Chile exports to South Korea mostly atoms--
refined copper, copper ores, and pig meat, grapes, and so forth.
Now, what does Chile buy from South Korea?
What Chile buys from South Korea are cars, machines,
and delivery trucks.
In total, they're buying only $2.5 million.
So what that means is that Chile has a positive trade
surplus with Korea because they're exporting 4.6 billion
and buying 2.5 But they have a negative imagination surplus.
They have a negative imagination balance
because Chile is exporting atoms and Korea,
what it's sending back is the way in which
those atoms are arranged.
And what this is starting to tell
us is that eventually, economies are computers, and are
computers with different capacities.
And as we will see by the end of this talk,
the different computational capacity of different economies
can help us even explain the level of income
that each economy is able to achieve.
In this case, it should be obvious
that the economy of South Korea is
a more sophisticated computer than that of Chile,
is able to generate more sophisticated forms
of physical order.
Another thing that, for example, thinking
about the world in terms of crystallized imagination
helps us reinterpret is the dynamics
of natural resource exploitation that
are prevalent in many developing countries.
I come from Chile.
And as you've seen, Chile basically sells rocks.
Why the heck we sell so many rocks?
Every year, Chile exports roughly $50 billion
worth of rocks.
Why is the world willing to pay so much money for those rocks?
Those green rocks are rocks of copper,
and people are willing to pay for copper.
Well, because copper, once you melt it and make it
into a spaghetti, you can actually
conduct electricity quite as well-- not as good as gold,
but much cheaper than gold.
So some people say, well, Chile is being exploited
because people are taking these rocks out of Chile that
are very valuable.
And then basically, what is Chile getting out
of this other than some miners that
live in some towns that are pretty desolate and $50
million?
And the thing is, well, you have to think about,
where is that value actually coming from?
Is the value on the atoms?
Is the value on the rocks?
Or was the value endowed to the rocks by some sort
of computational process?
So we are buying these rocks now.
And we were not buying these rocks for a lot of money
300 years ago because roughly 150 years ago, there
was a guy called Michael Faraday that figured out
that if you jiggle a magnet inside a coil,
you can produce electricity.
That knowledge eventually is the one
that allows us to live in this electrified world
that we live in nowadays that allows us to produce
a large amount of information because we have transformed
that energy that helps us produce information
in the form of electricity.
But it's also that piece of knowledge and that piece of
know how that endowed those rocks with all
of that economic value.
So in some sense, we can say that Chile is not
being exploited because people are taking rocks out of Chile.
Chile is actually exploiting knowledge
and know how that was produced elsewhere.
So the question then is, well, why
do we crystallize imagination?
One thing that you might have not noticed
is that we make products that are tangible
but that started as fiction, and we're the only species
to do so.
There's no other species that makes
products that are tangible and that started as imagination.
And if you see pictures of elephants making drawings
on the internet, they basically get whipped the heck out
of in very questionable practices
to make sure that they make the same drawing over and over.
So it's not like the elephant has this
…