Advertisement
English transcript
RICHARD KARLGAARD: Thanks, I am with "Forbes."
I've been with "Forbes" since the early '90s.
In fact, I joined "Forbes."
Steve Forbes hired me to start a technology magazine,
and one of my go-to people, whenever
I needed understand this new thing called the web,
was a guy who ran R&D at Sun Microsystems named
Eric Schmidt.
So Eric was always-- Eric was always a tremendous friend
and helped me understand what was emerging
in the future of network computing more than just
about anyone.
Now I live in Silicon Valley, as does my co-author Mike Malone.
And one day, we were sitting around noting
how many great startups in Silicon Valley
had been done by pairs, trios, or quartets--
from Hewlett Packard, to Apple, Steve Wozniak and Steve
Jobs, Sergey Brin and Larry Page, the Paypal mafia.
I mean, over and over again, you see the same story
repeating of very small teams-- two, three, four,
five-- starting these tremendous enterprises.
And so we proposed to a publisher
to write a book about that.
The publisher wisely came back and said, well,
that'll just be storytelling.
Can you find some science and data behind this?
And can you apply it to large organizations as well?
So that's what we set out to do.
And Team Genius-- really, we looked at what neuroscience,
anthropology, cognition science, and so on and so forth,
has to say about why it is that some small teams thrive
and others don't.
You've all probably been on teams
where everything looked good on paper.
You had the right set of skills, and something somehow it
didn't gel.
And then you've probably been on teams
where everybody on the team was a pain in the ass
that you were fighting all the time.
It seemed like it was always on the verge of fragmenting,
and somehow the team produced great work.
Now, our theory is that all the great work in the world
is going to be done by small, informal teams going forward.
That is the startup model of small teams.
It's one that is going to apply in large organizations too.
And the reason is that the world to simply moving too fast.
Google has 55,000 employees, but every now and then,
a company will come up like Snapchat with 19 employees,
and seemingly they're able to do things
in an extraordinarily short period of time.
And why is that?
The world is moving too fast.
So the theory that we have in Team Genius
is that inside of large organizations,
if you're really going to get work done,
you have to create an organization
where teams of 2 to 12 people, just like the startup world
does naturally, inside of larger organizations,
teams of 2 to 12 people can spontaneously
arise to meet a challenge or to pursue an opportunity.
Here's the mathematical reason why
small teams work and big teams fall apart very quickly.
That equation, you probably know, is Metcalfe's Law,
but it shows just how fast the number of connections
rise when you add people.
And so if you have two team members,
you have one connection.
If you have 12 team members, you have 66 possible connections.
And the reason that 12 starts breaking down, after 12,
is that the number of connections
go up almost exponentially.
16 team members-- 120 connections.
32-- 496.
So things become unwieldy very quickly.
What breaks in a breakpoint?
Well, communications, accountability, and trust
begin to break down very rapidly when you get over 12.
You start getting the phenomenon of free riders.
That is people-- I'm sure this doesn't happen at Google,
But it happens in every organization
I've been involved with that is large.
If a project looks hot and successful,
people want to join in.
Everybody wants to be part of the success.
Then they may not do the work, but they
want to have it on their resume, and they
want to be able to take credit for it.
Conversely, when things get challenging,
those kind of people will bail, will start pointing fingers
and become politicians.
Exactly the kind of thing that you
don't want in any kind of a team where you have high stakes
and you need to accomplish stuff in a hurry.
Here's what we found out, the research.
And these researchers are cited in the book.
One is a neuroscientist.
One is an anthropologist.
One is a social psychologist.
And that is the optimal size of creative teams.
Remember, I said 2 to 12 is sort of a good range
of creative strike teams.
And amazingly, within that range,
things begin to tighten up.
These three researchers from different fields
have used numbers like 7, 5 to 7, and 4 to 9.
I like 4 to 9.
I call it 7 plus or minus 2.
And the book goes into why teams of that size, whether you're
talking about musical bands, artistic groups, software
projects, marketing launches, PR launches-- whatever
it is, this is an optimal size.
And there are reasons why the brain prefers that size.
In fact, the size of seven as a phone number-- the phone
company didn't come up with the size seven for a phone number
accidentally.
It turns out that that's the median of short term
memory for people.
Software people obviously have super short term memories,
which means that there are a lot of people
walking around that have crappy short term memories.
But seven is the median for the vast majority of people,
and that's why, again, it accords
to the people you can hold in your brain and the ideas
that you can hold in your brain as you're walking around.
Well, Google has 55,000 employees.
Does this still apply?
I'm going to make the argument that it
makes no difference what the size of the organization is.
That it's the task of Google to be able,
to out of 55,000 people, all of whom are super bright.
This friend of mine likes to say to work at Google,
you have to have an IQ that boils water.
But even inside that 55,000 people,
unless you can spontaneously get to these smaller sizes,
projects get bogged down.
The Snapchats of the world with a tiny number of people
can pop up.
And while you're trying to organize teams from on high,
Snapchat has developed tens of millions of users.
That's why doing things on a startup level
becomes so important.
Now, one of things we wanted to do in the book
was take on some of the more controversial areas
and see what research had to say about that.
One of them is diversity, specifically ethnic and gender
diversity.
And the research says that it's a double edged sword,
that there's a much higher beta when you have a diverse team
than when you have a team that is monolithic, that everybody
looks the same, everybody has the same color skin,
everybody has the same gender.
By higher beta, I mean that a truly diverse team
has a higher probability of creating extraordinary success.
And it also has a higher probability of blowing up.
Now, if you're a global company, we are at Forbes.
Google is.
Anybody that touches the internet
is by definition a global company today.
You have to take the risk.
If you're maybe a local construction company,
and you're not touched by the global economy,
perhaps you can have a very monolithic team
and it will work.
But in a global economy, anything
that's creative, the research is very strong about this
that you have to, whether you're doing it
for good reasons of social justice
or whether you want to accomplish
big things in a global economy, you
have to take the risk of being diverse.
The way that you protect the downside-- I
said it has a higher beta.
You have a greater probability of accomplishing great things,
but you also have a greater probability
of having the team blow up.
The way that you prevent the team from blowing up
is with strong leadership and the right framing.
And I'm going to talk a little bit about framing
in the next slide.
So here's the framing quiz.
Which of the following framing strategies-- and remember,
this is back on the topic of diversity.
And you're a leader of a highly diverse team.
You have different ethnicities.
You're balanced in gender.
Which of the following three framing strategies
produces the best results?
And this is according to Harvard researchers Robin Eli and David
Thomas.
OK.
Number one, you have three choices here--
integration and learning perspective,
diversity as a mechanism for helping teams enhance
their capacity for adaptive change, your differences
and experience will help us react quickly
to a rapidly changing marketplace.
Now choice number two, remember you're the leader.
You're trying to frame.
You're trying to get the best out
of everybody in a highly diverse team.
Number two, you frame it as diversity is a better way
to connect with an increasingly diverse marketplace.
Your differences and cultural backgrounds
will help us understand the global marketplace.
That's choice number two.
And now choice number three, discrimination and fairness
perspective.
Diversity as a means to ensuring fair equal treatment of all.
Our differences ensure that there
will be no bias against anyone.
Who thinks the optimal is number one?
If you recall it.
Who thinks the optimal is number two?
And that's diversity because the marketplace is diverse,
therefore we should be diverse.
And who thinks it's number three?
OK.
The winner is the first one.
The integration and learning experience perspective.
And that is using diversity to make everybody smarter
on the team.
Discrimination and fairness perspective-- eh.
Mixed results.
A lot of evidence suggests that for all the inclusion
you might create with that kind of perspective,
it also feels patronizing to many people.
And surprisingly, the loser is the access legitimacy
perspective.
It simply doesn't work, according to these two Harvard
researchers.
Here's a huge one.
If you take away two ideas from the book,
the two ideas that are the major work in the world
is getting done by teams of 2 to 12 people.
And that works fine for startups,
because they are 2 to 12 people.
But if you have 55,000 people, you still
have to create these organizations
where teams of 2 to 12 will spring up
spontaneously to solve a problem or to meet a customer
opportunity.
If the team creation is being ordered from on high,
you simply won't be moving fast enough
to meet the challenges today.
That's idea number one.
The second idea is the power of cognitive diversity.
And that is creating what Tony Fidel, Tony Fidel,
of course, the guy who created Nest Labs, and you guys
bought him in April, 2014.
Tony also is known as one of the founders of the iPod, Apple's
breakout product.
Jonathan Rubinstein, Steve Jobs, Tony Fidel did that.
And Tony, when I interviewed Tony for a previous book--
Google is a very algorithmic company.
And when Tony was designing the smart thermostat,
he explained how it worked, a thermostat that
learns your habits.
And he said, is that an algorithmic problem
or is that a sociology problem?
Is it just simply observing how people behave?
And he said it's both.
He said the problem is the algorithmic people alone
will come up with one solution.
The non-algorithmic people will come up with another solution.
And neither of them are really great solutions
in and of themselves.
So what Tony always tried to do, and I
think what great companies do, Google
does this exceptionally well-- is mash up what
he calls whole brain teams.
And that is within these small teams,
you want to make sure that you have left brain and right brain
thinkers.
You want introverts and extroverts.
There's a great book by a woman named Susan Cain called
"The Power of Quiet."
And it's really the power of introverts in an organization.
Introverts are often very underestimated inside
of an organization because they don't speak up.
Risk IQ.
Everybody talks about risk today and the importance
of being a risk taking organization.
You actually want, in a composition of a team,
you want conformists too.
You want the risk takers to be about 25 to 20%
of the composition of the team.
You want the conformists to be about half,
and you want the rest of the people
to be strictly hard focused operations people.
The reason you want the conformists
is that the risk people will be passionate for sure,
but they will run off the rails if left to their own devices
as many times as not more times than not.
And so the value of conformance, even
at a highly evolutionary company like Google, is very valuable.
You want tenure diversity.
That is to say, you want experienced people
who can see all the traps going forward
on a project, all the political landmines,
all of the things that can trip up a project.
But you also want the fresh eyes,
because the problem is with having
a lot a tenure is the "been there, done that" cynicism
that begins to creep in over time.
Now I briefly want to talk about-- this alludes to a book
that I had last year.
And the two go together.
The book I had last year was called "The Soft Edge."
My proposition here is everything
I've talked about won't happen in a culture
where you don't have trust.
This is one of things that Satya Nadella's discovered
at Microsoft, is that the Ballmer culture was so hard
wired for measurable results.
And the way employees were ranked
within Microsoft, a forced ranking system,
that, in fact, the knives came out,
particularly the top two quintiles.
If you're in the top quintiles at Microsoft,
all the raises and all the bonuses went to the people
in the top quintile.
People in the second quintile got to keep their jobs.
People in the third, fourth, and fifth-- the fifth forget it.
Third and fourth were kind of on the bubble about
whether they'd be able to keep their job.
But all the knives and all the political wars
came out at the borderline between the top quintile
and the second quintile, because all the raises, and all
the accolades, and all the promotions
went to people in the top quintile.
So the trust was shattered.
When I was doing the research on that book
to figure out what it is that creates a healthy culture
inside of a company, I googled health.
And if you google health, this is one of the top three things
that you will get when you google the word health.
It's this thing called the United Nations
Triangle of Health.
This is what the UN gives to doctors
who go into impoverished areas of the world,
Doctors Without Borders, organizations like that.
People who need to see 1,000 patients in a week.
If you're seeing 1,000 patients in a week, all you can do
is triage, and this is the tool to help you triage.
You look at somebody, and in five minutes,
you try to determine whether it's
physically healthy, mentally healthy,
and have social health, which means when they go home,
is there violence in their families or lawlessness
in their village, and so forth.
And the proposition is to be truly healthy
and to have predictably good health going forward,
you have to have good health on all three sides.
Take away any one of these three things,
you jeopardize somebody's health.
You could be a young man with robust physical health
and great mental and emotional clarity,
but if you live in a war torn village,
that's why you need all three sides.
So about 15 months ago, I'm talking to-- now two years ago,
I'm talking to one of my favorite entrepreneurs outside
of the technology industry, but they're actually
a very technology driven company.
Fred Smith, founder and CEO of FedEx, now $50 billion in size.
There once was not a FedEx.
He started it from raw scratch in 1971.
And I asked him what accounts for FedEx
being successful over the long term,
being able to survive recessions,
global turmoil, new competitors coming in,
big technology transitions.
And he made the picture of a triangle,
and he said we are a triangle of forces.
We have to be good at strategy, execution, and culture.
I called execution the hard edge simply because it's measurable.
The soft edge of culture is beginning
to be measurable thanks to Laszlo Bock,
thanks to companies like Google.
But we're way in the early days of that.
And that's why people tend to underinvest in that.
This is my favorite, big data sports.
I have to tell this.
It takes about a minute.
It's how Jennie finch-- this is 10 years ago
in a demonstration during spring training in Major League
Baseball.
The world's best softball pitcher
struck out the two best hitters in baseball
on three successive pitches.
They didn't each.
Neither of them got even a foul ball.
And how did she do that?
Because it's amazing that when you throw a softball 65 miles
an hour-- she can or could-- it gets to the plate in about 4/10
of a second, which is the same time it takes a Major League
Fastball, 95 miles an hour thrown from a longer distance,
to get to the plate too.
So in theory, it looks like it if it
takes the same amount of time and there's
40% more surface space on a softball,
it should be easier to hit.
Why is not easier to hit?
And the answer is It's a big data problem.
Bonds and Pujols could see everything.
A Major League Baseball batter can get the bat
around in about 2/10s of a second, which
means they have 2/10 of a second to determine what the pitch is,
where it's going to go, the speed of the pitch,
and so forth.
They could see it, but they didn't know how to read it.
It was simply a big data problem for them.
You've all heard of Malcolm Gladwell's "10,000 Hours."
They had the 10,000 hours in baseball.
They could read a baseball.
They could read the pattern that the yarn made.
They could read the pitcher's motion.
They didn't know what they were looking at was Jennie Finch,
even though it was right before their eyes.
Everybody talks about corporate culture today.
Very few companies-- Google is one of the few
that really walks the talk.
And the reason it is so very hard for companies--
and it may be even challenging for Google.
You're a publicly traded company.
You have to report to Wall Street
four times a year-- is it there's a built in bias
to fall back on measurable and analytical things.
And particularly because all of you
are so analytically gifted and mathematically gifted,
it's your natural default position anyway.
But I just want to make the case that the cultural values side,
which increasingly is getting measurable,
but it's not that measurable today.
This is not a new debate about the debate
between how much effort do you put into corporate culture.
This is the guy who invented what
was called scientific management named Fredrick Taylor.
He took a stopwatch and a clipboard
to factory floors in the late 1800s.
First person to really take advantage of his findings
was Henry Ford.
The Model T came out in 1908.
But it was 1913 when the first assembly line was built,
and all of a sudden the volume and the affordability
curve of Model T's just got very, very attractive
to the point where Ford, who paid his workers well,
could afford to buy the car that they were making.
That had never been done.
By 1926, they're rolling of the assembly line.
Ford is the dominant motor car company in the world.
Then came the Great Depression.
Ford had labor problems.
People were complaining about the dehumanizing factory floor.
See, Taylor had treated people like machines.
You stood at the assembly line.
You did the same thing over and over and over again
for 10 hours a day, six days a week,
which was a typical work week back then.
And Henry Ford didn't handle the labor strikes very well.
And it really kind of wrecked him.
You see, he couldn't understand, during the Great Depression,
If he was paying people twice the prevailing wage for factory
work, and the people were employed to begin with,
because there was 25% unemployment during the 1930s,
why his workers were turning on him.
He went from being this very creative guy
to this very bitter guy in a very short period of time.
During the 1940s, he did not distinguish himself very well
by being pro-Nazi, and anti-Semitic,
and all kinds of bad things.
He just became a very, very bitter angry guy,
because he couldn't understand, fundamentally,
how he could have created this great product
and these great jobs for people and his workers turned on him.
Well, they turned on him because they were
being treated like machines.
Along comes Alfred Sloan, who was
able to copy the Ford-
…
I've been with "Forbes" since the early '90s.
In fact, I joined "Forbes."
Steve Forbes hired me to start a technology magazine,
and one of my go-to people, whenever
I needed understand this new thing called the web,
was a guy who ran R&D at Sun Microsystems named
Eric Schmidt.
So Eric was always-- Eric was always a tremendous friend
and helped me understand what was emerging
in the future of network computing more than just
about anyone.
Now I live in Silicon Valley, as does my co-author Mike Malone.
And one day, we were sitting around noting
how many great startups in Silicon Valley
had been done by pairs, trios, or quartets--
from Hewlett Packard, to Apple, Steve Wozniak and Steve
Jobs, Sergey Brin and Larry Page, the Paypal mafia.
I mean, over and over again, you see the same story
repeating of very small teams-- two, three, four,
five-- starting these tremendous enterprises.
And so we proposed to a publisher
to write a book about that.
The publisher wisely came back and said, well,
that'll just be storytelling.
Can you find some science and data behind this?
And can you apply it to large organizations as well?
So that's what we set out to do.
And Team Genius-- really, we looked at what neuroscience,
anthropology, cognition science, and so on and so forth,
has to say about why it is that some small teams thrive
and others don't.
You've all probably been on teams
where everything looked good on paper.
You had the right set of skills, and something somehow it
didn't gel.
And then you've probably been on teams
where everybody on the team was a pain in the ass
that you were fighting all the time.
It seemed like it was always on the verge of fragmenting,
and somehow the team produced great work.
Now, our theory is that all the great work in the world
is going to be done by small, informal teams going forward.
That is the startup model of small teams.
It's one that is going to apply in large organizations too.
And the reason is that the world to simply moving too fast.
Google has 55,000 employees, but every now and then,
a company will come up like Snapchat with 19 employees,
and seemingly they're able to do things
in an extraordinarily short period of time.
And why is that?
The world is moving too fast.
So the theory that we have in Team Genius
is that inside of large organizations,
if you're really going to get work done,
you have to create an organization
where teams of 2 to 12 people, just like the startup world
does naturally, inside of larger organizations,
teams of 2 to 12 people can spontaneously
arise to meet a challenge or to pursue an opportunity.
Here's the mathematical reason why
small teams work and big teams fall apart very quickly.
That equation, you probably know, is Metcalfe's Law,
but it shows just how fast the number of connections
rise when you add people.
And so if you have two team members,
you have one connection.
If you have 12 team members, you have 66 possible connections.
And the reason that 12 starts breaking down, after 12,
is that the number of connections
go up almost exponentially.
16 team members-- 120 connections.
32-- 496.
So things become unwieldy very quickly.
What breaks in a breakpoint?
Well, communications, accountability, and trust
begin to break down very rapidly when you get over 12.
You start getting the phenomenon of free riders.
That is people-- I'm sure this doesn't happen at Google,
But it happens in every organization
I've been involved with that is large.
If a project looks hot and successful,
people want to join in.
Everybody wants to be part of the success.
Then they may not do the work, but they
want to have it on their resume, and they
want to be able to take credit for it.
Conversely, when things get challenging,
those kind of people will bail, will start pointing fingers
and become politicians.
Exactly the kind of thing that you
don't want in any kind of a team where you have high stakes
and you need to accomplish stuff in a hurry.
Here's what we found out, the research.
And these researchers are cited in the book.
One is a neuroscientist.
One is an anthropologist.
One is a social psychologist.
And that is the optimal size of creative teams.
Remember, I said 2 to 12 is sort of a good range
of creative strike teams.
And amazingly, within that range,
things begin to tighten up.
These three researchers from different fields
have used numbers like 7, 5 to 7, and 4 to 9.
I like 4 to 9.
I call it 7 plus or minus 2.
And the book goes into why teams of that size, whether you're
talking about musical bands, artistic groups, software
projects, marketing launches, PR launches-- whatever
it is, this is an optimal size.
And there are reasons why the brain prefers that size.
In fact, the size of seven as a phone number-- the phone
company didn't come up with the size seven for a phone number
accidentally.
It turns out that that's the median of short term
memory for people.
Software people obviously have super short term memories,
which means that there are a lot of people
walking around that have crappy short term memories.
But seven is the median for the vast majority of people,
and that's why, again, it accords
to the people you can hold in your brain and the ideas
that you can hold in your brain as you're walking around.
Well, Google has 55,000 employees.
Does this still apply?
I'm going to make the argument that it
makes no difference what the size of the organization is.
That it's the task of Google to be able,
to out of 55,000 people, all of whom are super bright.
This friend of mine likes to say to work at Google,
you have to have an IQ that boils water.
But even inside that 55,000 people,
unless you can spontaneously get to these smaller sizes,
projects get bogged down.
The Snapchats of the world with a tiny number of people
can pop up.
And while you're trying to organize teams from on high,
Snapchat has developed tens of millions of users.
That's why doing things on a startup level
becomes so important.
Now, one of things we wanted to do in the book
was take on some of the more controversial areas
and see what research had to say about that.
One of them is diversity, specifically ethnic and gender
diversity.
And the research says that it's a double edged sword,
that there's a much higher beta when you have a diverse team
than when you have a team that is monolithic, that everybody
looks the same, everybody has the same color skin,
everybody has the same gender.
By higher beta, I mean that a truly diverse team
has a higher probability of creating extraordinary success.
And it also has a higher probability of blowing up.
Now, if you're a global company, we are at Forbes.
Google is.
Anybody that touches the internet
is by definition a global company today.
You have to take the risk.
If you're maybe a local construction company,
and you're not touched by the global economy,
perhaps you can have a very monolithic team
and it will work.
But in a global economy, anything
that's creative, the research is very strong about this
that you have to, whether you're doing it
for good reasons of social justice
or whether you want to accomplish
big things in a global economy, you
have to take the risk of being diverse.
The way that you protect the downside-- I
said it has a higher beta.
You have a greater probability of accomplishing great things,
but you also have a greater probability
of having the team blow up.
The way that you prevent the team from blowing up
is with strong leadership and the right framing.
And I'm going to talk a little bit about framing
in the next slide.
So here's the framing quiz.
Which of the following framing strategies-- and remember,
this is back on the topic of diversity.
And you're a leader of a highly diverse team.
You have different ethnicities.
You're balanced in gender.
Which of the following three framing strategies
produces the best results?
And this is according to Harvard researchers Robin Eli and David
Thomas.
OK.
Number one, you have three choices here--
integration and learning perspective,
diversity as a mechanism for helping teams enhance
their capacity for adaptive change, your differences
and experience will help us react quickly
to a rapidly changing marketplace.
Now choice number two, remember you're the leader.
You're trying to frame.
You're trying to get the best out
of everybody in a highly diverse team.
Number two, you frame it as diversity is a better way
to connect with an increasingly diverse marketplace.
Your differences and cultural backgrounds
will help us understand the global marketplace.
That's choice number two.
And now choice number three, discrimination and fairness
perspective.
Diversity as a means to ensuring fair equal treatment of all.
Our differences ensure that there
will be no bias against anyone.
Who thinks the optimal is number one?
If you recall it.
Who thinks the optimal is number two?
And that's diversity because the marketplace is diverse,
therefore we should be diverse.
And who thinks it's number three?
OK.
The winner is the first one.
The integration and learning experience perspective.
And that is using diversity to make everybody smarter
on the team.
Discrimination and fairness perspective-- eh.
Mixed results.
A lot of evidence suggests that for all the inclusion
you might create with that kind of perspective,
it also feels patronizing to many people.
And surprisingly, the loser is the access legitimacy
perspective.
It simply doesn't work, according to these two Harvard
researchers.
Here's a huge one.
If you take away two ideas from the book,
the two ideas that are the major work in the world
is getting done by teams of 2 to 12 people.
And that works fine for startups,
because they are 2 to 12 people.
But if you have 55,000 people, you still
have to create these organizations
where teams of 2 to 12 will spring up
spontaneously to solve a problem or to meet a customer
opportunity.
If the team creation is being ordered from on high,
you simply won't be moving fast enough
to meet the challenges today.
That's idea number one.
The second idea is the power of cognitive diversity.
And that is creating what Tony Fidel, Tony Fidel,
of course, the guy who created Nest Labs, and you guys
bought him in April, 2014.
Tony also is known as one of the founders of the iPod, Apple's
breakout product.
Jonathan Rubinstein, Steve Jobs, Tony Fidel did that.
And Tony, when I interviewed Tony for a previous book--
Google is a very algorithmic company.
And when Tony was designing the smart thermostat,
he explained how it worked, a thermostat that
learns your habits.
And he said, is that an algorithmic problem
or is that a sociology problem?
Is it just simply observing how people behave?
And he said it's both.
He said the problem is the algorithmic people alone
will come up with one solution.
The non-algorithmic people will come up with another solution.
And neither of them are really great solutions
in and of themselves.
So what Tony always tried to do, and I
think what great companies do, Google
does this exceptionally well-- is mash up what
he calls whole brain teams.
And that is within these small teams,
you want to make sure that you have left brain and right brain
thinkers.
You want introverts and extroverts.
There's a great book by a woman named Susan Cain called
"The Power of Quiet."
And it's really the power of introverts in an organization.
Introverts are often very underestimated inside
of an organization because they don't speak up.
Risk IQ.
Everybody talks about risk today and the importance
of being a risk taking organization.
You actually want, in a composition of a team,
you want conformists too.
You want the risk takers to be about 25 to 20%
of the composition of the team.
You want the conformists to be about half,
and you want the rest of the people
to be strictly hard focused operations people.
The reason you want the conformists
is that the risk people will be passionate for sure,
but they will run off the rails if left to their own devices
as many times as not more times than not.
And so the value of conformance, even
at a highly evolutionary company like Google, is very valuable.
You want tenure diversity.
That is to say, you want experienced people
who can see all the traps going forward
on a project, all the political landmines,
all of the things that can trip up a project.
But you also want the fresh eyes,
because the problem is with having
a lot a tenure is the "been there, done that" cynicism
that begins to creep in over time.
Now I briefly want to talk about-- this alludes to a book
that I had last year.
And the two go together.
The book I had last year was called "The Soft Edge."
My proposition here is everything
I've talked about won't happen in a culture
where you don't have trust.
This is one of things that Satya Nadella's discovered
at Microsoft, is that the Ballmer culture was so hard
wired for measurable results.
And the way employees were ranked
within Microsoft, a forced ranking system,
that, in fact, the knives came out,
particularly the top two quintiles.
If you're in the top quintiles at Microsoft,
all the raises and all the bonuses went to the people
in the top quintile.
People in the second quintile got to keep their jobs.
People in the third, fourth, and fifth-- the fifth forget it.
Third and fourth were kind of on the bubble about
whether they'd be able to keep their job.
But all the knives and all the political wars
came out at the borderline between the top quintile
and the second quintile, because all the raises, and all
the accolades, and all the promotions
went to people in the top quintile.
So the trust was shattered.
When I was doing the research on that book
to figure out what it is that creates a healthy culture
inside of a company, I googled health.
And if you google health, this is one of the top three things
that you will get when you google the word health.
It's this thing called the United Nations
Triangle of Health.
This is what the UN gives to doctors
who go into impoverished areas of the world,
Doctors Without Borders, organizations like that.
People who need to see 1,000 patients in a week.
If you're seeing 1,000 patients in a week, all you can do
is triage, and this is the tool to help you triage.
You look at somebody, and in five minutes,
you try to determine whether it's
physically healthy, mentally healthy,
and have social health, which means when they go home,
is there violence in their families or lawlessness
in their village, and so forth.
And the proposition is to be truly healthy
and to have predictably good health going forward,
you have to have good health on all three sides.
Take away any one of these three things,
you jeopardize somebody's health.
You could be a young man with robust physical health
and great mental and emotional clarity,
but if you live in a war torn village,
that's why you need all three sides.
So about 15 months ago, I'm talking to-- now two years ago,
I'm talking to one of my favorite entrepreneurs outside
of the technology industry, but they're actually
a very technology driven company.
Fred Smith, founder and CEO of FedEx, now $50 billion in size.
There once was not a FedEx.
He started it from raw scratch in 1971.
And I asked him what accounts for FedEx
being successful over the long term,
being able to survive recessions,
global turmoil, new competitors coming in,
big technology transitions.
And he made the picture of a triangle,
and he said we are a triangle of forces.
We have to be good at strategy, execution, and culture.
I called execution the hard edge simply because it's measurable.
The soft edge of culture is beginning
to be measurable thanks to Laszlo Bock,
thanks to companies like Google.
But we're way in the early days of that.
And that's why people tend to underinvest in that.
This is my favorite, big data sports.
I have to tell this.
It takes about a minute.
It's how Jennie finch-- this is 10 years ago
in a demonstration during spring training in Major League
Baseball.
The world's best softball pitcher
struck out the two best hitters in baseball
on three successive pitches.
They didn't each.
Neither of them got even a foul ball.
And how did she do that?
Because it's amazing that when you throw a softball 65 miles
an hour-- she can or could-- it gets to the plate in about 4/10
of a second, which is the same time it takes a Major League
Fastball, 95 miles an hour thrown from a longer distance,
to get to the plate too.
So in theory, it looks like it if it
takes the same amount of time and there's
40% more surface space on a softball,
it should be easier to hit.
Why is not easier to hit?
And the answer is It's a big data problem.
Bonds and Pujols could see everything.
A Major League Baseball batter can get the bat
around in about 2/10s of a second, which
means they have 2/10 of a second to determine what the pitch is,
where it's going to go, the speed of the pitch,
and so forth.
They could see it, but they didn't know how to read it.
It was simply a big data problem for them.
You've all heard of Malcolm Gladwell's "10,000 Hours."
They had the 10,000 hours in baseball.
They could read a baseball.
They could read the pattern that the yarn made.
They could read the pitcher's motion.
They didn't know what they were looking at was Jennie Finch,
even though it was right before their eyes.
Everybody talks about corporate culture today.
Very few companies-- Google is one of the few
that really walks the talk.
And the reason it is so very hard for companies--
and it may be even challenging for Google.
You're a publicly traded company.
You have to report to Wall Street
four times a year-- is it there's a built in bias
to fall back on measurable and analytical things.
And particularly because all of you
are so analytically gifted and mathematically gifted,
it's your natural default position anyway.
But I just want to make the case that the cultural values side,
which increasingly is getting measurable,
but it's not that measurable today.
This is not a new debate about the debate
between how much effort do you put into corporate culture.
This is the guy who invented what
was called scientific management named Fredrick Taylor.
He took a stopwatch and a clipboard
to factory floors in the late 1800s.
First person to really take advantage of his findings
was Henry Ford.
The Model T came out in 1908.
But it was 1913 when the first assembly line was built,
and all of a sudden the volume and the affordability
curve of Model T's just got very, very attractive
to the point where Ford, who paid his workers well,
could afford to buy the car that they were making.
That had never been done.
By 1926, they're rolling of the assembly line.
Ford is the dominant motor car company in the world.
Then came the Great Depression.
Ford had labor problems.
People were complaining about the dehumanizing factory floor.
See, Taylor had treated people like machines.
You stood at the assembly line.
You did the same thing over and over and over again
for 10 hours a day, six days a week,
which was a typical work week back then.
And Henry Ford didn't handle the labor strikes very well.
And it really kind of wrecked him.
You see, he couldn't understand, during the Great Depression,
If he was paying people twice the prevailing wage for factory
work, and the people were employed to begin with,
because there was 25% unemployment during the 1930s,
why his workers were turning on him.
He went from being this very creative guy
to this very bitter guy in a very short period of time.
During the 1940s, he did not distinguish himself very well
by being pro-Nazi, and anti-Semitic,
and all kinds of bad things.
He just became a very, very bitter angry guy,
because he couldn't understand, fundamentally,
how he could have created this great product
and these great jobs for people and his workers turned on him.
Well, they turned on him because they were
being treated like machines.
Along comes Alfred Sloan, who was
able to copy the Ford-
…