YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,032 lines · added Sep 1, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

RACHEL AMERA: Hi.
I'm Rachel Amera, and I'm based in the San Francisco office
usually.
I'm part of the gPause Program.
I'm a volunteer to help bring in speakers and coordinate that.
And today I'm really excited to bring in Doctor Leslie Carr.
Doctor Carr is here to talk about why
being present in any relationship
is vital for emotional well-being
and emotional health.
So this is going to be a great talk for all of us.
We all have relationships, I think.
Whether it's at work, whether it's in your personal life,
with your family, relationships are everywhere.
It's really what is the groundwork
for a lot of what we do.
So today, we're going to talk about how
we can improve any of those, which is I think not only
important for work, but in any case
and in any aspect of our lives.
Again, we'll look at things like the interpersonal science
behind that, too.
So that's part of what we want to bring out
in the gPause Program, is what is
going on in the world of learning more
about this from a scientific standpoint,
a neuroscience standpoint.
So Doctor Carr is going to talk about that, too.
And then we're going to all learn
how to be better listeners.
We're going to learn how we can tune in, literally,
to other people so we can feel more
supported by our own presence.
And I think that is a skill that I know I could use and get
more of, and I think all of us would like to learn more of.
Doctor Carr is a licensed clinical psychologist
who works out of San Francisco, and she's
a published author for MindBodyGreen, the newsletter
in "The Huffington Post."
So without further ado, I will introduce Leslie.
Thank you for coming today.
[APPLAUSE]
LESLIE CARR: Thank you so much, Rachel, and thank you
all for being here.
Since we're here today to talk about mindfulness,
I just want to begin by allowing us to take a moment
to just shift gears.
Perhaps we can all just take a minute
to forget about anything that we were doing before we came
into this room, just give ourselves permission to not
think about anything that you're going
to do when you leave here.
Take a minute to just feel your butt in your seats.
Since I'm standing, I'm just going
to take a minute to really feel my feet on the ground.
And perhaps you can just give yourself
a moment to allow your eyes to fall
on anything that is in your natural field of vision.
And just take a moment and look at it.
Take a deep breath.
For those of you who don't know what mindfulness
is-- I know a couple of you raised your hands before saying
that this is unfamiliar territory for you-- when we
talk about mindfulness, this is really
what we're talking about.
We're really just talking about present moment awareness.
It's a certain type of psychological state
that involves thinking less about the past and the future
and more about what's actually happening right in front of us.
Unfortunately, it sounds so simple,
but I think in reality, in the Western world, very few of us
spend much time here.
And what I'm going to be talking to you about today
is how we can use that type of psychological attention
in our relationships to be more present with one another
and to make us better listeners.
And it is absolutely not an exaggeration
to say that using these skills actually
has a measurable impact on our mental health,
and on the mental health of the people
that we are having conversations with,
existing in relationship with, and that kind of stuff.
So without further ado, I want to take a moment just before we
really dig in here to speak for just a minute
about mental health in general.
Because I'm not here today to talk
about mental illness-- if anything,
I'm actually here to talk about mental health,
but these are very interrelated concepts.
And I think it's important to kind of start
by defining our terms a little bit and just making sure
that the train is moving in the right direction.
So maybe I can just start with a question.
Raise your hand if you think of mental illness
as being created by chemical imbalances in the brain,
if you think of it as being a largely genetic
or biochemical experience.
Perhaps you could-- OK.
So that gives me certainly a frame of reference.
I'd say probably 50% of you roughly raised your hands.
And I'm not surprised by that.
If anything, I'm sort of surprised
that more people didn't raise their hands, just because that
is something that-- it's an idea that exists in popular culture
absolutely.
I think that we are really steeped in the idea
that our mental health experiences are created largely
by genes and biochemistry.
And I'm not here to say that that isn't the case.
I'm not here to say that genes don't
matter, that our biochemistry doesn't matter.
But I think that there is this other piece of the puzzle that
doesn't get nearly as much air time, which
is the role that things like our relationships and our life
experiences play in our mental health or mental illness.
We have traumatic experiences, we respond
to those traumatic experiences.
Believe it or not, we have experiences
that are entirely mundane, and we learn from those experiences
and take them forward with us.
So I guess what I want to make clear right now
is just that it's not that genes and biochemistry doesn't
matter, but what I'm going to be talking to you about today
primarily is this other piece, the piece of our relationships
and the experiences that we have.
And just to drive this point home, in case
this is confusing for anybody, something
that I just want to really make clear
is that because of this thing that we call epigenetics,
we have to sort of recognize that even
if we possess the gene for something,
or even if there's a biological proclivity toward something,
our life experiences, whether we're exposed to toxins,
whether we have good relationships in our lives,
these things have the power to quite literally turn genes
on and off and affect their expression.
So I think this is really important stuff
that we're talking about.
There's actually amazing cutting-edge research
going on right now showing that people who are chronically
lonely are more likely to be aggressive,
and it quite literally is turning genes on and off
that are impacting how people are behaving in the world based
on just the experience of being chronically lonely.
So I am going to zip you through about 70 years of research
in my field and tell you a couple of stories
that I think will help to explain the way I
look at some of this stuff.
And perhaps we'll take it from there.
The first story that I want to tell you takes us back to 1945.
We were starting to realize-- at the time,
people were starting to realize--
that we had a really big problem happening
in our orphanage system, because orphans were dying
at a really alarming rate, a rate that greatly outpaced
children in the general population.
And at first, naturally they thought that this
was an immunity issue.
The concern was really just that there
were so many babies and nurses and people in a relatively
contained environment that it was creating a situation where
just germs were really thriving and the kids were getting sick.
The problem was that their reaction to this
was to kind of batten down the hatches
and to do things like touch the children less.
They actually went so far in some orphanages
to put up sheets between the cribs
so that the kids were totally and completely
separated from one another, separated from their caregivers
and that kind of stuff.
And their nurses were told to touch them
as little as possible, to touch them
just enough to change their diapers and hand them a bottle.
And the problem actually got worse.
It became even more extreme.
So 1945 again, a psychoanalyst and physician
named Rene Spitz decided that he wanted to take a look at this.
And he created a bit of a-- we actually wouldn't really
call it an experiment today, but he
wanted to investigate the situation
by comparing the children in these orphanages
to children who were being raised in the prison system
by their mothers because their mothers had been incarcerated.
Because there obviously were a lot
of similarities between these environments,
just a lot of people in a small space, less access to things
like natural air and that kind of stuff.
And in the time that Doctor Spitz was reviewing
this information, 37% of the kids
in the orphanage-- it was an American orphanage that he was
looking at-- 37% of the kids between the ages of zero
and three died, and none of the children in the prison
population died.
And when they looked at the data, what they realized
was that the only difference between these babies
was the fact that the ones who were being raised in prison
were being raised by their mothers,
there were people around, and the ones in the orphanages
were not really having any contact with people at all.
And it's definitely worth noting that not only were the kids
dying, but for the kids who were not dying,
they were really not doing very well.
They were psychiatrically not doing very well.
They had lower IQs than kids in the general population
or the kids in the prison did.
Eventually they were developing physical disabilities,
because they weren't able to get around and crawl.
And one of the reasons why this research was
so groundbreaking at the time that it came out
was because mothers in the 1940s were actually
told that they shouldn't touch their children too much
because it might spoil them.
And this was one of the first things that made people really
question that advice, which brings us
to the next major piece of research that
came on its heels.
It was a psychologist named Harry Harlow
who was working out of the University of Wisconsin
at the time.
And inspired by Spitz's research,
he wanted to conduct some research
with rhesus monkeys in environments
where we could sort of control the environment a little bit
more.
And some of you might be familiar with this,
because this is a little bit sort of psych 101
kind of stuff.
But what he wanted to do, he did a series of studies.
And they began with what has been termed the cloth
mother versus the wire mother.
He created two environments for these monkeys.
He gave them the option of either a wire mother that
provided food but no additional comfort or anything like that,
and then the cloth mother that was made out
of terry cloth that was physically comfortable
but didn't provide any nourishment of any kind.
And his theory-- I guess what he was looking to investigate
is the theory at the time was that children really only
became attached to their parents because that's where they got
food and that kind of stuff.
So his theory was basically that if these monkeys were the way
he thought they would be, that they wouldn't express
much interest in the terry cloth mother,
because it didn't actually provide them
with any nourishment or any food.
Now it's probably not that shocking,
but actually the monkeys ended up spending
like 90% of their days kind of hanging out on this terry cloth
mother, and then just running over to the wire mother
to get food periodically whenever they were hungry.
And perhaps even Harlow himself was not that surprised,
because terry cloth is a lot more comfortable than wire.
So I guess he felt the need to take things a little bit
further.
And he designed another study that
made things just a little bit more extreme
where he would do things like scare the monkeys
and then see what would happen once they had been hanging out
on the cloth mother for awhile and had become ostensibly
sort of attached to it.
What would happen if you took them out into the room,
scared them.
What they do?
And monkeys are often used-- rhesus monkeys particularly--
in psychological research, because they
display some characteristics that are similar to humans.
And the monkeys did something that
is typical of what humans would do,
and they would run back to the cloth mother
because-- it's sort of in the same way
that you would see with children,
that if a kid is scared it would run to its mom.
The rhesus monkeys would do that with the cloth mother.
Now unfortunately, Harry Harlow did not
like rhesus monkeys very much.
He actually went on the record as saying that.
So some of his research starts to get a little bit more
and more disturbing.
And if you're an animal lover like me,
you're not going to want to hear what I have to say next.
But in order to push the limits, what he started to do
was he would take the rhesus monkeys
and put them in isolation chambers for three months, six
months, nine months, a year, sometimes even longer
than that.
And the amounts of time actually really stop mattering,
because the point is that by the time
a rhesus monkey has been put in an isolation
chamber for 12 months, it emerges really not the same.
The monkeys, by the time they were
in these chambers for a year, were behaving really bizarrely.
They would rock themselves back and forth,
stare off into the distance, and that kind of thing.
And if you're wondering why I'm telling you these stories,
it's because I'm trying to drive us towards a point.
And that point is what was happening here?
I don't know if anyone has any theories about why
these babies in their orphanages would be dying,
or why the monkeys, when put in isolation chambers,
would emerge so psychologically distressed.
But what we now know, 70 years later,
is that what the monkeys and the babies were lacking was this.
The photos and the images behind me
are showing what we call in my field attunement.
It's the technical term that we have started to use in my field
for this process, which is a very delicate dance that
happens between babies and their caregivers.
And if you've ever known an infant,
you have probably participated in this yourself.
It turns out that even just these micro-moments that
happen in facial expression and the relationship that develops
between a child and its caregiver
provides an enormous psychological function
in helping us to develop brains that
are capable of things like psychological organization.
Babies between about zero and three months
aren't really capable of this yet.
It's something that's commonly referred
to as the fourth trimester.
But after about three months, once you
get to three months, six months, nine months,
you start to see this dance quite a bit more.
And what you start to see, or what
we have come to realize is true about infants,
is that this is literally how babies
start to realize that they're separate beings psychologically
from their caregivers and from the people around them.
There's this complex dance that happens
in facial expression that plays a really important role in who
we are and who we come to be.
And it's very closely related to this other thing
that we refer to as attachment.
Attachment in psychology and in our well-being
is a really big and vast concept.
This is where a lot of research takes place today.
But as you can see in this sort of graph behind me,
the basic concept behind attachment
is it has to do with what we consider to be sort of signal
response communication.
The idea that a baby has a need, like its diaper
needs to be changed, so it cries,
it signals to its caregiver that it has
a need that needs to be met.
And in an ideal world, the caregiver meets that need.
And over time, a sense of trust and safety
develops not just between that baby and its caregiver,
but between that child and the world itself.
There's this idea that I have a need and that need can be met.
And what we know now, as a result
of Harlow's research and Spitz's research,
is that it's not just food and diaper changes
that babies need, but it's actually this.
It's what we call attunement.
And even though this is vitally important for babies,
it doesn't stop being important for adults.
If you've ever had that experience of just feeling
really connected to somebody, feeling
like you're having a conversation with someone
and they're just really getting you
and you're totally on the same page,
there is a neurotransmitter that is
responsible for making you feel that way,
and it's called oxytocin.
Oxytocin has been called the bonding hormone.
And it's a neuropeptide that flows whenever
we're feeling really close and connected to somebody, if we're
having a really good conversation.
For women, we tend to get extra big bursts of it
when women are having orgasms, or are
in labor, which contributes to that feeling of feeling
super bonded to your baby in that moment after birth.
And what you can sort of see in these images
is people just having happy conversations with each other,
face to face, and having a lot of oxytocin flowing.
And I don't think that it will surprise you
when I say that instead of seeing this
these days, what we often see more of is this.
And I am not anti-technology, believe me.
I am not standing before you as a Luddite.
I love technology.
As a psychotherapist, a lot of the people that I work with I
see via Skype.
I'm active on social media.
I am not an anti-technology person.
But I don't think I'm alone when I
say that as we start to see more and more of this,
that I don't think I'm the only person who
is starting to become a little bit distressed by it
and is maybe starting to perceive some
of the downsides of just how much exposure to technology
we've been engaging in lately.
And I think that this, headlines like this,
are a pretty good example of that.
I think these are the kinds of questions that we're
asking ourselves more and more.
And neurobiologically-speaking, it's
worth noting that part of the reason why technology
is so satisfying to use is because we get
these little dopamine bursts.
From a neurotransmitter perspective,
it's the same thing, it's the same sort
of neurobiological reward that we
get when we're playing the slots or doing cocaine.
It's extremely pleasurable to get a dose of dopamine.
But what we don't get when we're using technology is oxytocin.
We don't have the same bond that we feel with each other
when we're having a face to face conversation, or even
a conversation over the phone when we're using technology.
And one of the dilemmas that we have here,
and this is where I feel like what we're talking about
is really important, is that it's
starting to become more and more extreme.
This article right here, which came out
in April of this year in The New York Times,
talks about some really disturbing research
where they're recognizing that little kids are spending so
much time looking at screens that they
are less able to interpret nonverbal cues.
They're less able to read facial expressions.
Their social skills are quite literally
suffering as a result.
So most of the people in this room
are old enough to probably remember a time when we weren't
using technology so much.
I think even we are experiencing the ramifications of spending
so much time using technology.
I think it's really hard to even imagine
what is happening to kids who are three years old right
now, six years old, 10 years old,
with so much exposure to technology.
So what is the point of all of this?
The point in my mind is really just
that our human relationships really
matter, perhaps more so than a lot of us
really give them credit for.
I'm going to spend the rest of this talk focusing primarily
on listening, talking about what it really
means to be a good listener.
And something that I just want to make
clear is that I think in adult to adult communication,
really listening to each other is
sort of the updated version of those attunement photos
that I was showing to you.
How we listen to each other is how
we make our presence felt by the people
that we're in relationships with.
And I want to just sort of transition and shift gears
here a little bit by reading a quote.
I'll go ahead and read this to you.
This is one of my favorite psychologists,
someone named Carl Rogers.
He has so many beautiful quotes, and this
is one of my favorites.
Sensitive, active listening is exceedingly rare in our lives.
We think we listen, but very rarely
do we listen
…

Need subtitles from another video?