Advertisement
English (United Kingdom) transcript
Announcer [Doorkeeper?]: My Lords, Ladies and gentlemen, rise for the Lord Speaker
Lord Speaker [Baroness Hayman]: Itís, as you know, a first for us to welcome UK Youth
Parliament members into the Chamber. Itís a first for you to be debating inside Parliament.
Lord Speaker: The first one is going to be proposed by James Greenhalgh.
James, are you there?
Male youth 1 [James Greenhalgh?]: Thank you very much. [Transcriberís note: background applause].
My fellow MYPs, Members of the Youth Parliament, we propose that the campaign
to abolish university tuition fees should be adopted as one of the three main National
UK Youth Parliament campaigns.
Female youth 1: How can the Government possibly expect to get over 50% of 18-30 year-olds
into further education when theyíre going to be drowning in debt afterwards?
Male youth 2: I just want to say that I think we need to remind ourselves that university
education is not a right, it is a privilege, and when I - I do intend to go to university
and and when I do go to university, at the same time, as - as much as I would love to
go for free, at the same time I want a good university education, with good lecturers,
with good resources and good facilities, and I simply don't understand how we are going
to be able to pay for that without raising taxes, which are too high in this country
to begin with. Scotland may have done it, but they've done it using English taxpayersí
money through the Barnett Formula [Transcriberís note: Background sound - oooogh]. Iím sorry,
my fellow MYPs but it's true.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Male youth 1 [2nd appearance]: We have applied for information, from [sic] the Freedom of
Information Act, and that enabled us to find out how much it would cost to make university
free for all young people. The figure was approximately three and a half billion pounds
per year. Yes, three and a half billion pounds per year is a lot of money, but if you consider
that the Education budget is around 80 billion pounds, and the whole budget that we spend
in the UK every year is around 600 billion pounds, I think it is a very, very small cost,
considering the benefits that we could get as a nation.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Campaigning for a fair and accurate representation of young people in the media [Transcriberís
Female youth 2: Almost all of the publicity that the media gives to young people is negative.
Surprisingly, these aren't my words these are the words of the former Political Editor
of the Mirror Group, David Seymour.
Male youth 3: From The Cornishmaní in West Cornwall, it says Brainwashed teenage yobs
should not have a view on society, because they're not taxpayers. I know we're not
taxpayers, but we are the consumers of tomorrow, as Rebeccaís just said. We need to have a
view on society.
Male youth 4: The media is using us like a sling-shot. We are not sling-shots, we are
young people, young people of the future.
Male youth 5: The media is an industry. We cannot tell them what to do, we cannot tell
them how to write their papers, all we can do is make good stories, make sure whatever
we can do to get them publicised.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Lowering the voting age to 16 [Transcriberís note: Title of Motion shown on screen as Male
youth 6 starts to speak]
Male youth 6: Denying 16- and 17-year olds [the right] to express their political views
through the ballot box gives the impression of young people to the rest of the community
and society that young peopleís views are not valued.
Female youth 3: At the moment, 16-year-olds can join the Army, they can be subjected to
horrific images of violence, they can perpetrate violence and they can do all these things,
but they are not capable of picking up a pen and voting for who they want.
Male youth 7: What difference does a further two years make? It's nothing. If you don't
like who you're fighting in the war, don't join the Army. If if - you don't like
what the Government are doing with your family, don't start one [Transcriberís note: background
laughter]. It doesn't life doesn't - necessarily start at 16. Two years does not make a difference.
Female youth 4: We need to empower the young people, to prove that they can vote, and then
maybe once we've proved that we can vote for ourselves, weíll be given the opportunity
to do so.
[Transcriber's note: background applause]
[Text appears on the screen, but is very difficult to read. Appears to include the words Free public
transport.for people under 18í]
Female youth 5: Transport is an issue that affects everyone. Everyone needs to get places.
It especially affects those who, like me, live in rural places. Poor transport services
and expensive fares makes getting to places difficult and this should be addressed by
the UK Youth Parliament as one of the three campaign proposals, as - as it has been for
the last 2 to 3 years, but we still have a long way to go.
Female youth 6: Introduction of the concessions card for Pensioners and Registered Disableds
from the 1st of April [Transcriberís note: 1st April 2008]. If the Government can recognise
that they struggle to pay transport costs, then why canít they recognise that young
people also struggle to pay transport costs?
Male youth 8: £2.60 really isnít going to hurt your balance much, and that's why, to
be honest, I really donít think that we should vote for this campaign as one of our top priorities,
as there are 5 other campaigns on here that are may be of more importance and there
may be of more equivalence to this one.
Male youth 9: the introduction of the Oyster Card
I know, has benefited the thousands of young people, both in my
constituency and constituencies throughout London.
of Motion shown on screen as Female youth 7 starts to speak]
Female youth 7: Well, this campaign is about equality, fairness and transparency for young
people of the UK. We aim to tackle the many inconsistencies and hypocrisies that are seen
throughout society in regard to the age at which we are considered to be adults.
Female youth 8: Today, I donít know about you, but I feel that weíre being forced to
grow up too quickly. I think we should just focus on being the age we are today and not
tomorrow, as life really is too short. [Transcriberís note: Background murmuring of agreement]
Female youth 9: 17, I don't understand why the Government says that you can't buy
your drink in a pub until you're 18, but you can be with a parent
or guardian in a pub at 16, or even younger. That doesn't make sense in my world, I'm afraid.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
[ Text of fifth motion and the environment hard to read - appears on the screen
note: Title of Motion very difficult to read - shown on screen as Male youth 10 starts to speak?
Male youth 10: but I have a belief that, as a people, we can save lives and create
a better future. Let us come together and devise a mechanism, a way of recycling ambassadors
in every school, every home, every college, every university. Let us put the environment
at the heart of the home and the home at the heart of the environment. Our responsibility
is to positively impact the present and the future of this country, and it all begins
now, with you voting for this campaign. This is an issue a lot of people are running away
from, but real champions are running to. The big question I ask you now is: are you in?
Male youth 11: they use more environmentally-friendly energy sources. I think we have to devote
more time to finding viable solutions to climate change. If we do nothing, we are destroying our future.
Female youth 10: I'm not sure that I see this as a UKYP
campaign. Weíve already got eco-schools operating
on a national basis. Perhaps they could work better, and perhaps we could support them
to do better, but Iím not sure that we need to come in and create something new.
Male youth 12: Thereís a great catastrophe waiting for us around the corner. It is us
who are going to suffer, more than most of the adults who usually sit in these seats.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Lord Speaker: I think itís absolutely brilliant that we ended with the youngest person in
the room, but now, you want to get on with the decision-making.
Andy Handlett [Chief Executive, UK Youth Parliament]: My first note of thanks goes to the House
of Lords and the Lord Speaker for inviting us here [in the Palace? Hard to hear].
Lord Speaker: So I'm going to read out, with the votes, the three that you have chosen
to be your campaign issues for this year. At Number 3, with 252 votes, ëThe abolition
of university tuition feesí [Transcriber's note: background applause]. At Number 2, with
425 votes these are weighted votes, thatís why you did your 3, 2, 1 National public transport concession cards for young people
[Transcriber's note: background applause].
But I've got to tell you, for Number 1, you're all in
[Transcriberís note: background laughter]: Your future, your world, your [hard to hear this word]
[Transcriberís note: Prolonged background applause]. And that was 490 votes.
So, you've put your votes there; you're now going to have to put your energy there,
and I'm sure, from today, that you will. Listen,
have a safe journey home. Thank you so, so much for how youíve behaved today and for
making this an absolutely brilliant event. Take care. Thank you.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
[Transcriberís note: End of video]
Lord Speaker [Baroness Hayman]: Itís, as you know, a first for us to welcome UK Youth
Parliament members into the Chamber. Itís a first for you to be debating inside Parliament.
Lord Speaker: The first one is going to be proposed by James Greenhalgh.
James, are you there?
Male youth 1 [James Greenhalgh?]: Thank you very much. [Transcriberís note: background applause].
My fellow MYPs, Members of the Youth Parliament, we propose that the campaign
to abolish university tuition fees should be adopted as one of the three main National
UK Youth Parliament campaigns.
Female youth 1: How can the Government possibly expect to get over 50% of 18-30 year-olds
into further education when theyíre going to be drowning in debt afterwards?
Male youth 2: I just want to say that I think we need to remind ourselves that university
education is not a right, it is a privilege, and when I - I do intend to go to university
and and when I do go to university, at the same time, as - as much as I would love to
go for free, at the same time I want a good university education, with good lecturers,
with good resources and good facilities, and I simply don't understand how we are going
to be able to pay for that without raising taxes, which are too high in this country
to begin with. Scotland may have done it, but they've done it using English taxpayersí
money through the Barnett Formula [Transcriberís note: Background sound - oooogh]. Iím sorry,
my fellow MYPs but it's true.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Male youth 1 [2nd appearance]: We have applied for information, from [sic] the Freedom of
Information Act, and that enabled us to find out how much it would cost to make university
free for all young people. The figure was approximately three and a half billion pounds
per year. Yes, three and a half billion pounds per year is a lot of money, but if you consider
that the Education budget is around 80 billion pounds, and the whole budget that we spend
in the UK every year is around 600 billion pounds, I think it is a very, very small cost,
considering the benefits that we could get as a nation.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Campaigning for a fair and accurate representation of young people in the media [Transcriberís
Female youth 2: Almost all of the publicity that the media gives to young people is negative.
Surprisingly, these aren't my words these are the words of the former Political Editor
of the Mirror Group, David Seymour.
Male youth 3: From The Cornishmaní in West Cornwall, it says Brainwashed teenage yobs
should not have a view on society, because they're not taxpayers. I know we're not
taxpayers, but we are the consumers of tomorrow, as Rebeccaís just said. We need to have a
view on society.
Male youth 4: The media is using us like a sling-shot. We are not sling-shots, we are
young people, young people of the future.
Male youth 5: The media is an industry. We cannot tell them what to do, we cannot tell
them how to write their papers, all we can do is make good stories, make sure whatever
we can do to get them publicised.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Lowering the voting age to 16 [Transcriberís note: Title of Motion shown on screen as Male
youth 6 starts to speak]
Male youth 6: Denying 16- and 17-year olds [the right] to express their political views
through the ballot box gives the impression of young people to the rest of the community
and society that young peopleís views are not valued.
Female youth 3: At the moment, 16-year-olds can join the Army, they can be subjected to
horrific images of violence, they can perpetrate violence and they can do all these things,
but they are not capable of picking up a pen and voting for who they want.
Male youth 7: What difference does a further two years make? It's nothing. If you don't
like who you're fighting in the war, don't join the Army. If if - you don't like
what the Government are doing with your family, don't start one [Transcriberís note: background
laughter]. It doesn't life doesn't - necessarily start at 16. Two years does not make a difference.
Female youth 4: We need to empower the young people, to prove that they can vote, and then
maybe once we've proved that we can vote for ourselves, weíll be given the opportunity
to do so.
[Transcriber's note: background applause]
[Text appears on the screen, but is very difficult to read. Appears to include the words Free public
transport.for people under 18í]
Female youth 5: Transport is an issue that affects everyone. Everyone needs to get places.
It especially affects those who, like me, live in rural places. Poor transport services
and expensive fares makes getting to places difficult and this should be addressed by
the UK Youth Parliament as one of the three campaign proposals, as - as it has been for
the last 2 to 3 years, but we still have a long way to go.
Female youth 6: Introduction of the concessions card for Pensioners and Registered Disableds
from the 1st of April [Transcriberís note: 1st April 2008]. If the Government can recognise
that they struggle to pay transport costs, then why canít they recognise that young
people also struggle to pay transport costs?
Male youth 8: £2.60 really isnít going to hurt your balance much, and that's why, to
be honest, I really donít think that we should vote for this campaign as one of our top priorities,
as there are 5 other campaigns on here that are may be of more importance and there
may be of more equivalence to this one.
Male youth 9: the introduction of the Oyster Card
I know, has benefited the thousands of young people, both in my
constituency and constituencies throughout London.
of Motion shown on screen as Female youth 7 starts to speak]
Female youth 7: Well, this campaign is about equality, fairness and transparency for young
people of the UK. We aim to tackle the many inconsistencies and hypocrisies that are seen
throughout society in regard to the age at which we are considered to be adults.
Female youth 8: Today, I donít know about you, but I feel that weíre being forced to
grow up too quickly. I think we should just focus on being the age we are today and not
tomorrow, as life really is too short. [Transcriberís note: Background murmuring of agreement]
Female youth 9: 17, I don't understand why the Government says that you can't buy
your drink in a pub until you're 18, but you can be with a parent
or guardian in a pub at 16, or even younger. That doesn't make sense in my world, I'm afraid.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
[ Text of fifth motion and the environment hard to read - appears on the screen
note: Title of Motion very difficult to read - shown on screen as Male youth 10 starts to speak?
Male youth 10: but I have a belief that, as a people, we can save lives and create
a better future. Let us come together and devise a mechanism, a way of recycling ambassadors
in every school, every home, every college, every university. Let us put the environment
at the heart of the home and the home at the heart of the environment. Our responsibility
is to positively impact the present and the future of this country, and it all begins
now, with you voting for this campaign. This is an issue a lot of people are running away
from, but real champions are running to. The big question I ask you now is: are you in?
Male youth 11: they use more environmentally-friendly energy sources. I think we have to devote
more time to finding viable solutions to climate change. If we do nothing, we are destroying our future.
Female youth 10: I'm not sure that I see this as a UKYP
campaign. Weíve already got eco-schools operating
on a national basis. Perhaps they could work better, and perhaps we could support them
to do better, but Iím not sure that we need to come in and create something new.
Male youth 12: Thereís a great catastrophe waiting for us around the corner. It is us
who are going to suffer, more than most of the adults who usually sit in these seats.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
Lord Speaker: I think itís absolutely brilliant that we ended with the youngest person in
the room, but now, you want to get on with the decision-making.
Andy Handlett [Chief Executive, UK Youth Parliament]: My first note of thanks goes to the House
of Lords and the Lord Speaker for inviting us here [in the Palace? Hard to hear].
Lord Speaker: So I'm going to read out, with the votes, the three that you have chosen
to be your campaign issues for this year. At Number 3, with 252 votes, ëThe abolition
of university tuition feesí [Transcriber's note: background applause]. At Number 2, with
425 votes these are weighted votes, thatís why you did your 3, 2, 1 National public transport concession cards for young people
[Transcriber's note: background applause].
But I've got to tell you, for Number 1, you're all in
[Transcriberís note: background laughter]: Your future, your world, your [hard to hear this word]
[Transcriberís note: Prolonged background applause]. And that was 490 votes.
So, you've put your votes there; you're now going to have to put your energy there,
and I'm sure, from today, that you will. Listen,
have a safe journey home. Thank you so, so much for how youíve behaved today and for
making this an absolutely brilliant event. Take care. Thank you.
[Transcriberís note: background applause]
[Transcriberís note: End of video]