YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,240 lines · added Sep 29, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: As you may have noticed, the course has been
proceeding somewhat historically.
First with pre-primate animals, the whole evolution of sex from
things that swam in the ocean, and then we discussed the
primate mating system as you've seen--
in the same sense as on the board.
The first--the pre-primate is a few millions of years--I'm
sorry, tens of millions of years;
primates maybe ten million years or so.
Then last time we started discussing the transition from
ape to human, and evolutionarily modern
humans date to something like 150 thousand years ago.
We're coming up to time and today we're going to discuss
fully anatomically modern humans.
They have the same brain capacity that we do,
etcetera, etcetera.
The earliest groups that we have any kind of decent
demographic data on are hunter gatherers which would include
cavemen and people that are hunter gatherers but do not live
in caves.
Last time we asked why there were so few chimps and so many
humans and today we're going to ask very similar questions
about-- we're going to start with,
we're going to cover a lot more;
we're going to ask very similar questions about hunter
gatherers.
There never was a great density of hunter gatherers.
There is certainly not now and the question is,
why?
If you look where hunter gatherers live now they--
each small group, and the again the small group
is the same size we've been talking about something like 40,
are spread out over a very large area and they use that
area to hunt in and to collect fruits and nuts,
and whatever they can get from the trees.
It looks like a very simple question, why is the density of
hunter gatherers so low?
Why are there so few of them?
For a long time, the answer was:
they didn't have much food.
That they needed all this space to get enough food to survive,
and if they overpopulated that space they couldn't survive.
In sort of modern hubris, we looked back and thought
hunter gatherer is a very inefficient form of food
gathering, not modern, and we're so much
better than them now.
The data is quite clear on some part of those assumptions;
hunter gatherers, at the time when all human
beings were in the stage of hunter gatherers,
before--farming starts about 10,000 years ago.
There's--what is the number here?
There may have been like two million people on the whole
earth.
Remember I said hunter gatherers spread out of Africa,
spread amazingly over the whole earth,
and maybe the total population of humans at that time was
something like two million people.
Now we have over six billion people, that's an increase of
3,000 times in the human population, so clearly there
were fewer hunter gatherers than now.
This is a very--you'll see this in lots of discussions of this
field, but it's a very elementary kind of
consideration.
It talks about the long scale of human demography,
of human population growth, and we came out of being other
species of primate, of hominids and we gradually
grew up to some sort of a limit.
There's the idea that the various productive systems that
we use, like hunter gathering--limit is
some sort of a carrying capacity limit,
and so the idea is that the human population increased until
it reached a limit and then for a very long period of time it
can't get beyond that limit.
Then 10,000 years ago, maybe it's 12,000,
farming is invented and all of a sudden the whole system
changes, there's many more people and we
jump up and then again reach a limit,
and we'll talk about that as some Malthusian limit in this
particular period, later we'll discuss that,
and then around here the industrial revolution happens
and all of a sudden the population increases again.
This is a logarithmic scale so it's not linear.
Each of these jumps is by a factor of several thousand.
That's a very, very schematized version of
human demographic history and we're talking about this period.
What limited hunter gatherers to this level whereas farmers
could go up to this level.
Again, the obvious answer and looking at this kind of rough
data is that it was food.
Whoever then--archeologists, paleontologists go and actually
try to examine this and there turns out to be the data does
not fit that theory terribly well.
What do archeologists do?
They dig up skeletons and they have a good representative set
of skeletons from the last 7,000 years in North and South
America.
One study looked at more than 12,500 skeletons so we're
talking about a good scientific sample.
What did they find out?
These were set into communities, and communities
lasted so much time, so you can date the whole
archeological site to a certain period.
The medical anthropologists got into it and started looking at
the bones and dentition and all this,
and not only did they find the violence we talked about last
time, but these people were also sick.
They had diseases at different times.
You could see bone problems and how well the bones grew and from
the teeth how much calcium they had, and all this.
What does it turn out, that contrary to the idea of
progress that you'd think the later people were more healthy,
in fact, it was earlier people in the--
the earlier individuals that were healthier.
As time goes on, the skeletons get less and less
healthy, that they're getting less food and less good food,
and were more subject to diseases.
It was quite a shocker when this status started coming out.
The researchers attributed this decline in health in large part
to the rise in agriculture.
Two main factors they say, the rise of agriculture and the
rise of urban living, and we'll talk about the urban
story in a moment.
If you again go like we did last time from the archeology to
the anthropology and look at current hunter gatherers,
it's a little bit of a distorted study because nowadays
almost all hunter gatherers have been pushed out of the good
lands that they used to live in, into very marginal lands.
You know this from U.S. History in high school,
how the European farmers pushed the very earlier farmers or
hunter gatherers of the American Indians,
the Native Americans into Arizona, into desert,
into the Badlands in the West, the dry Badlands and to the
West of the U.S., farming peoples push hunter
gatherers into inhospitable land.
There's a story in the Smithsonian Magazine recently
about Pygmies in Africa.
I don't know if you know a little bit about the history of
African demography, which we'll also cover,
but the Bantus have expanded from south--
the bulge of southwest Africa basically all around and have
pushed other people's out and the Pygmies are one of the
groups that have been very severely discriminated against
and really pushed into inhospitable places.
Another example is the Bushmen of Africa who were pushed into
the Kalahari Desert in southern Africa.
Even in the desert these guys eat 85 different species of
plants, and it's almost inconceivable
in their culture, for someone to die of
starvation because plants will bloom some years and not bloom
some years.
They will get a fungus some year, or a virus,
plants--any one species is not generally very reliable.
When you have 85 different species to survive on you're not
going to go without food.
There will always be some group of plants that are going to be
available to you and so you're not going to starve.
Further, the anthropologists lived with these people and they
start writing down what they're doing at every point in time.
Per hour invested, the Bushmen get more food then
the early agriculturalists.
Not modern agriculturalists who can drive a tractor and in an
hour do a lot, but we're comparing
hunter-gatherers to the first stages of agriculture.
The Kalahari--the Bushmen in Kalahari spent 12 to 19 hours a
week collecting food and the rest of the time they used for a
lot more sleep than current farmers,
and a lot more leisure than farming people,
so life is more generous to them.
You have to think now, this is for people pushed into
a desert, a very inhospitable place,
and now if they-- if you can imagine them living
in a lush forest region where they originated,
life must have been much, much easier so the amount of
time exerted to get your basics of food and everything must have
been much-- a lot less.
Not only do they have to work less and they get more food per
hour, but the variety of foods is
very good for you because you need different minerals,
you need different other micronutrients,
you need different vitamins, and as we are bombarded with in
the popular press, a variety of foods is very good
for you.
You don't want to eat just one kind of food,
so they had a very diverse and healthy kind of diet.
Agriculture comes in and indeed it enormously increases the
amount of food per acre when land is limited,
when you have a population density such that land becomes
limiting rather than your time or your need,
when land becomes limiting then agriculture becomes important
because per acre you can get a lot more food than hunter
gathering, but you have to spend lots and
lots of hours to get that land to give you that amount of food.
The question remains 'why are there are--why were there and
still are of course, why are there are so few hunter
gatherers?
Again, a Malthusian type question that,
if we know they lived quite well, we know that later people
going into agriculture lived a lot less well in terms of basics
of life, how come the hunter gatherer
population did not increase up to the same level of misery as
early farmers, which is basically one of the
earliest examples of a Malthusian type question.
Malthus thought those same kind of thoughts but for a much later
population.
Well in truth, we don't really know the answer
to this and it's greatly argued about, but I can tell you some
things that are known.
Current hunter gatherers have a moderate number of children and
many survive.
They do not have an enormous infant mortality,
certainly not compared to later populations which I'll show you
that have a huge infant mortality.
If they are Nomadic, and I'll tell you about an
example of that later, they have to move quite a lot
and that means carrying children around.
I think Bonnie has sort of indicated to you,
even dealing with a lot of children in one place is
difficult, but the difficulty of moving
with very young children, and packing up everything and
moving for a very long time, over a long distance is
difficult and Nomadic peoples very often show very clear signs
of some form of conscious population control.
They know they can't cope with more than "x"
number of children.
We'll get to that all societies have indeed controlled their
population but mechanism they were not totally--
not clear what they think the reason for their doing things
were, but Nomads apparently know what
they're doing.
Hunter gatherers are moderately healthy.
Again, their burden of sickness is not severe,
again compared to later populations;
however parasites are always a problem.
I'll show you again a modern case of parasites.
This is a girl, modern girl,
current girl in Central America, and you may notice the
swollen belly.
You know what's inside there to swell it?
Worms--exactly and when they purge her that was what was
inside that girl, all those worms.
Humans have had this problem since time in memorial.
Hunter gatherers are not immune to this.
Infectious diseases they have less because they're in small
groups, so infectious diseases as you
know need large groups to keep spreading and they're hostile to
their neighbors, just again like chimpanzees so
they don't come in a lot of contact with neighbors,
so diseases don't spread from group to group and each
individual group is not large enough to allow for the
maintenance of a disease.
Each village, if you--anthropologists go and
sit in one village for a long time and they have a high
population growth rate.
Each village seems to be expanding quite noticeably,
and you think, well in each village that we go
study population is increasing, again, it doesn't make sense
why haven't they-- been living that way a hundred
thousand years, why haven't they filled up
their space?
Why is each village surrounded by lots of--basically unused
space?
Even today, a lot of the very tropical lands are not
high--densely populated.
We may have the image that they are but they're not.
New Guinea is not densely populated.
If you call densely populated--the Netherlands is I
think the most densely populated in the world,
Bangladesh, the livable regions of China,
the livable regions of Japan, these are densely populated.
The tropical regions of the world, nothing like that;
New Guinea I said, Borneo very sparsely populated,
the Amazon, Sub-Saharan Africa vast open areas,
so these are not situations of high population density,
yet any village that you sit in is increasing its population.
What's going on?
What are the--what the archeologists find out is that
when they study a site, and I sort of mentioned this
already, what you see is this.
You go to--you start digging a site and you actually dig in
reserve, but you go to the bottom and
you see there was nobody there before certain years,
and then a small population, and what you see,
you can count the amount of food remains,
all kinds of things, the population grows more or
less exponentially.
That means that the same percentage every year.
A half of a percent a year or whatever it is,
and it grows up faster and faster, because there are more
people producing that same percent of population growth.
You get this phase and then all of a sudden you reach the top of
your pile and your village is gone and there's nothing there.
Some sort of a crash happened, where if it's not totally gone
it's really knocked down tremendously,
and then you either wait--look at that site again like the
biblical sites which they dig, and dig, and dig and sometime
later starts up again, or a different site starts up
again and you get the same phenomenon.
Forget this line, this is the idea of -- the
carrying capacity, but you can see nothing fits
the carrying capacity.
It just maybe stays there for a little here, so the idea of
carrying capacity for humans doesn't work very well.
What are the reasons--so--then the explanation for the
population staying more or less constant and not filling up the
space is not that each community doesn't exist,
but communities--here's your space filled with community A,
B, C, D, E and as each community increases some other
community just disappears, goes out of existence.
If you measure over the whole big space you have a floating
game of different communities each growing,
but then disappearing completely, and the population
and the whole space stays more or less the same.
I don't want to push that as it really becomes super duper
constant, but more or less the same--does not fill up.
What are the reasons why a community would grow very
happily, more or less, very vaguely,
exponentially, and then go out of existence?
One is of course climatic disaster.
There could be a freeze; there could be a drought,
these real climatic things, and if you look at the Anasazi
of Arizona that lived near the Colorado River regions,
one of the thoughts--they're one of the communities that fit
this.
They're healthy, you go see their ruins,
and then they just disappeared.
How many of you have been to Anazasi site in Arizona?
Just one student, something you've got to do.
There you're living in a semi--a true desert now and a
semi-desert back then, so climatic things are a
reasonable explanation.
You go into the tropical regions you don't have droughts
that last, you don't have freezes, and yet you see this
same kind of phenomenon.
While undoubtedly climatic things happened occasionally in
the temperate zones, certainly in the northern
zones, most hunter gatherer societies probably that's not
the explanation.
The next thing is diseases of the crops, that some fungus came
by and wiped out your crops.
Well we've just talked about that, that since they're eating
85 different kinds of things in the desert,
there isn't any kind of microorganism that cuts across
species like that, so that explanation doesn't
seem to work.
Diseases of humans, same thing, not diseases of
plants, but diseases of humans,
again, the data just doesn't fit that,
that because of the isolation they don't have a huge problem
with communicable diseases.
That leaves the possibility of violent confrontation from one
community to another.
We've seen in the chimps how the northern group will
completely wipe out the southern group and so forth.
What kind of evidence can one adduce that this might be what's
going on?
If one looks at any modern population and looks at the
survival curve, so this is the number of deaths
per 1,000 per year.
This is India, for instance,
and it's fairly recent--1960s.
Antibiotics are just coming in at this stage,
so very high infant mortality rate,
80 per 1,000--one out of every 12 kids dies almost immediately
and then that high rate continues until about--
comes down to something about six or seven years old so a lot
of your population is just wiped out immediately.
Then you have a pretty low level of death and fairly flat
until it gets to be what's considered old age in different
populations and then the death rate rises.
You have this very standard u-shaped curve,
and here after you have sort of modern medicine--
this is Sweden in the same year as the infant--
primarily the main thing is the infant mortality drops like
crazy and the old age stuff-- everything drops but the main
drop is in infant mortality.
The idea is--what I just want you to get out of this--
we'll see this graph again and again in a couple of times,
is that during the adult years the death rate is very low
compared to either here or here.
Now if you look at what we can gather from archeological data
from hunter gatherer communities, you have a high
death rate of kids.
Not as high as when you get all these communicable diseases in
modern societies, and then you have a flat
period, and then all of a sudden there's this big bump.
What they call an excess mortality in exactly the young
adult years, and then it comes back down
again and you get a more or less normal old age situation.
Well what is it that kills people in their middle years?
Violence.
So this kind of data--again we don't totally--
we don't really know the answer, but this kind of data
leads you to suspect that indeed one of the major reasons,
not the only reason, but a major reason that the
hunter gatherer communities and the early archeological
communities disappear so suddenly is that they are wiped
out by some sort of violence.
We're right back in hunter gatherer times as far as we can
tell to what you've seen before of these mass--
I've showed you last time these mass graves that are
characteristic of this period.
Okay, nevertheless, over the very long scale of
time-- our period of being cavemen and
hunter gatherers lasted hundreds of thousands of years--
but gradually population did slowly increase,
and as population increases, the land available to people
gets less.
We talk, I think next time about Africa,
which has a culture where land is not a scarce commodity and
now it's getting to be scarce, but in their traditions,
land is not the scarce commodity,
but as the population grows the land per person gets less and
then you have to make a more intense utilization of the land
and farming gets invented.
A big discussion whether it actually was the population
pressure that caused farming to be invented or whether that was
just some brilliant stroke by somebody that invented--
that people slowly figured it out.
They actually can trace the origin of agriculture to--
the current data is 11,700 years ago in the Middle East,
in Anatolia, what's now Turkey,
now eastern Turkey, and it expands on the average
from the original sites you can watch it expand and it expands
at one kilometer a year.
That's the average.
Then it eventually takes over the whole world.
The number of people, and when you invent
agriculture, t
…

Need subtitles from another video?