Advertisement
English transcript
MALE SPEAKER: Hello, everyone.
How are we today?
Give me a cheer.
Excellent.
I'm very pleased to welcome Charles Spence to Talks
at Google.
Charles Spence is a professor of experimental psychology
at Oxford University, and a gastrophysicist,
working at the interface between chefs,
food companies, and technology.
I've seen the slides.
They look incredible.
Please join me in welcoming Charles
with a round of applause.
CHARLES SPENCE: OK.
So it's a pleasure to be with you here this lunch time,
and tell you a little bit about the research we
do in Oxford, but also with food companies and chefs
around the world.
It's sort of this interface of psychology, neuroscience,
technology, and fine dining, it has
some of the insights that are emerging from the latest
kind of research at this kind of interface,
are starting to work their way out to home dining,
to a variety of real world situations,
to hopefully allow us all to eat a little more
healthfully in the future.
And it's all kind of premised on this idea of the perfect meal,
the title of the book.
Just feel the weight in your hands and you'll know,
there's quality there.
And the opening quote from the book, from MFK Fisher,
is one that kind of inspires a lot of our thinking.
"That once at least, in the life of every human,
whether he be brute or trembling daffodil,
comes a moment of complete gastronomic satisfaction.
It is, I am sure, as much a matter of spirit as of body.
Everything is right.
Nothing jars.
There's a kind of harmony with every sensation
and emotion melted into one chord of well-being."
If we all think back in our past over the last few years,
we've all had that kind of perfect meal experience.
My colleagues sort of think, well, we
can't study it, because it's kind of different for each
and every one of you.
Maybe for some of you, it's going for your gastro tourism
to some fancy Michelin starred restaurant
on the other side of the world.
For others, it might be nothing more complex
than a picnic on a summer's day in the English countryside.
Different for each and every one of us,
but I think that we can sort of study that perfect meal, what
makes it great, try and extract some generalizations
can be used in everyday life to kind of nudge our meal
experiences in the right direction
to be more stimulating, more engaging, more
memorable, and perhaps more healthy as well.
I'm certainly not the first to think about the perfect meal.
It is a topic that goes back at least a century.
You find some the first sort of mentions from 1894
from French chemist, Berthelot, talking about the perfect meal
and what it would be like sometime around about today.
And for all of the chemists, for the feminist writers,
and also for the sort of serious scientists,
it was this, the meal in a pill.
So he was imagining in 1894, thereabouts, what
it would be like in a century.
And the idea of sitting down to eat
and wasting an hour of your day with a multi-course meal
seems bizarre.
Surely in the future, we'll have a pill, we'll pop it.
And that will sustain us through the day
and we'll need nothing else.
Just take this quote from-- where has he gone?
"Looking Forward: A Dream of the United States
of the Americas in 1999," written in 1899 by Arthur Bird.
"In order to save time, people in 1999,
often dined on a pill, a small pellet which contained
highly nutritious food.
They had little inclination to stretch their legs
under a table for an hour at a time
while masticating on an eight course dinner.
The busy man of 1999 took a soup pill or a concentrated meat
pill for his noon day lunch.
He dispatched these while working at his desk."
So he could be more efficient as a result.
That's what they thought was going to happen in 1999,
but it has not come to pass obviously.
And why not?
Because I think food is so much more than just
about nutrition and sustenance.
There's a whole sort of psychology
behind our experience of food, the way we eat
and what we enjoy eating.
And that is the theme for the book, "The Perfect Meal."
Myself, I worked together with Betina Piqueras-Fiszman,
my co-author, working in a psychology department
at Oxford, trying to understand the factors that
make one meal experience better than another
or that it can ruin a great evening simply
by just getting one sensory cue or trigger wrong.
And this is what we can think of as gastrophysics,
the new sciences of the table, which means since 1984, when
Harold McGee came out with his "On Food and Cooking,"
that was a whole three decades we've had,
a little over, of sort of science in the back of house,
science in the kitchen, science of new techniques of food
preparation, a rotovaps and sous vide and all sorts of stuff,
changing the way that food is prepared,
at least in the hands of some chefs.
We've also had the kind of emergence
of all sorts of new ingredients as well
to deliver textures and spumes and foams
and all kinds of stuff we had never had before.
Three decades, that's taken us a long way,
and it's certainly changed the way
that we eat, at least sometimes, but it's
all science in the kitchen.
Where I think it's changing now, and that's
kind of the idea of gastrophysics,
is it's science moving to the front of house,
to the dining tables, in the restaurants,
because they're easy to study, or can be, through to the home
dining, anywhere where we eat.
It's a science of the diner.
And it's gastrophysics.
So it's gastronomy, we're interested in high end
food in the first instance.
But also physics from psychophysics,
which is the kind of psychology, the measurement
of the human-- what different inputs lead
to different kind of outputs.
Normally it's done with lights and sounds
in front of a computer screen, but we want the gastrophysics
of real food experiences.
Study what matters, what doesn't matter, and how to create
insights that are actionable in the matter where or who
you might be serving food to.
I keep coming back this sort of thing,
that food is so much more than just about food.
So, imagine yourself as the chef,
and you've learned all the techniques.
And until recently you'd kind of think, well,
if I know I source my ingredients locally.
I prepare them beautifully.
Perhaps I give a little attention
to how the food appears on the plate.
If I do all that, it'll be enough.
I can deliver great meal experiences.
But in fact, I think, you need to know
about the mind of the diner as well in order
to change people's behavior for the better
to deliver great meal experiences.
What I'm seeing now, kind of inspired
by the likes of Ferran Adria in Spain and Heston Blumenthal,
just up the road in Bray, is a whole generation of young chefs
who are popping up, starting up, opening gastropubs,
culinary artistry events in the UK
and elsewhere, who for the first time are thinking,
I need to know how to make great tasting food.
But on top of that, I want to know
what's going in the head of my diner or order
to really meet their expectations
or completely confound their expectations.
But I need to know what's in here.
So a couple of examples of why you need to know more than just
about how to prepare food well.
First one is this kind of ugly beast
of the deep, the Patagonian toothfish that has been
on restaurant menus for years.
It just was never very popular.
Would you order it yourself on a menu in a restaurant?
Probably not.
If you saw the picture, definitely not.
But simply a little bit of rebranding
calling this Chilean sea bass, exactly the same fish,
looks still as ugly.
But suddenly sales increased by 1,300% in Australia,
North America, in the UK simply by change of name,
completely changes our food behavior,
what we choose to eat and what we don't.
Sure, great food, but on top of that,
you need to know what to call it.
Another kind of classic example of why the chef, I think,
needs to know about what's going on in the diner's mind.
Here we have a dish, and within the blink of an eye,
your brain has decided what it is.
Your brain is a prediction engine,
trying to figure out where the nutritious
food is in the environment.
So you see that and within 150 milliseconds,
your brain's decided, yeah, that's probably ice cream,
probably cold, probably sweet.
I'll probably like it.
Maybe I'll have a scoop later.
But I'd have to go to the gym.
And probably the flavor is a red fruit,
a raspberry or strawberry, something like that.
All went through your mind without you thinking, just
in the blink of an eye or less.
But the only problem is, that's not
the flavor of this ice cream.
So this is actually a frozen savory ice, popular in the UK
a century ago.
And this comes from the Fat Duck Kitchens.
So it could be a smoked salmon ice cream or a frozen crab
bisque ice cream.
So the chef makes this dish, maybe
is the world's top chef at the time.
He thinks it's seasoned perfectly.
It fits into sort of the theme of historic dining.
He brings it out and gives it to some of his preferred guests
who are regulars at the Fat Duck restaurant.
But when they put it in their mouth and they taste it,
they're going to go, ugh.
I didn't like it.
It's too salty.
But the problem was, the chef thought it was perfect.
He's the world's top chef.
But the diner said, no, it's too salty, pulls a funny face,
does not like at the time and does not
like it when they come back two or three weeks later.
It will remain salty in their experience.
The problem here is a matter of expectations.
Because the diner was thinking it
was going to be a sweet-tasting strawberry or raspberry ice
cream.
In fact, it was savory and salty.
Their expectations were disconfirmed.
They didn't like it.
Whereas if I just tell you before you
put a spoonful of this to your lips,
that this is food 386, a term that means nothing
to any of us, kind of vaguely scientific sounding.
But that title for the dish is enough
that when I give you, here, a spoonful of my new dish,
food 386, suddenly when you taste it,
you'll kind of withhold your expectations
and it will taste seasoned just right, the way the chef
experiences it.
So no matter what you do in the kitchen,
if you don't know the expectations of your diner,
you can't really predict how they're
going to respond or optimize the meal experience.
And if vision is so important, we
might think about the future of food.
Here we've got original sushi on the left, augmented reality
sushi on the right.
This, we were working with Katsu Kojima over in Japan.
There was about 70 vision scientists
thinking about a time, sometime in the future, when maybe we've
fished the seas to extinction of all our favorite sushi fish.
Could we, with our headset, like the one
you see there on the bottom right here.
Maybe you've been watching your movies.
Then you have your dinner and we can give you
the visual impression through the headset, of your best
tasting, now extinct fish on your sushi,
feed you the other one, and maybe
for what you eat, but eye is so important,
you have as good an experience as you
would have done if you could somehow still find
that now extinct fish.
Possibly.
Possibly not.
But again, it's this idea of using technology
and our knowledge of neuroscience
to deliver new, different food experiences.
Sometimes just more stimulating than anything we've had before.
At other times, trying to think about how
to nudge people towards healthier eating behaviors.
OK.
And food, as I say, it's so much more than about food.
It's about the naming and about expectations.
But it's also about mood and those we dine with.
It's kind of social, fundamentally
a social activity.
So I see chefs who think, as they
have done for decades, about palate cleansers.
We're in for a fancy meal.
We should have a palate cleanser to clear up palette
before the first of the chef's real dishes comes out.
And what will that be?
That will be maybe a lime sorbet,
something acidic to cut through something, apparently,
on your tongue.
But I think maybe the tongue is the least interesting bit
of our experience of flavor.
We experience flavors here in the brain.
So if I want to clean your palette, what I really
want to do is clean your mind, a mental palate cleanser
to get you into the right mood.
Because I know if you're in the right mood,
you'll enjoy the food that much more.
And this is the intuitive solution
of the Chef Denis Martin, who has a two Michelin star
restaurant in Vevey in Switzerland
between Charlie Chaplin's final resting house and Nestle
headquarters.
He's got two Michelin stars.
He kind of wants the third one.
Hasn't quite come yet.
Has a single sitting dining experience,
based in a knitting museum, which might
be part of the problem there.
But it's very inventive.
It's smoke and mirrors and all sorts
of great, molecular or modernist culinary practises.
When you go for that single sitting dinner service,
you all arrive, you're there at 7:00.
And you think well, we're all here now and you look around.
And there's nothing on the tables, no knives, no forks,
no glassware, nothing, just this sitting on the middle
of each and every table.
And people would wait and think, well, I'm
sure the first course is going to come out sometime soon.
But it won't.
Nothing will happen until some curious diner picks that thing
up off the table, wondering whether it's
the salt or the pepper shaker with a kind
of peculiar Swiss twist.
When they do that, when they pick that little device up,
look underneath, it's a silly, one euro toy.
It'll make a mooing sound.
The diner will laugh in surprise.
And then within a few moments, every table
in that two Michelin star restaurant
will have their moo cows in the air,
a chorus of mooing cows in a restaurant full of laughing
diners.
The mood has been elevated, enhanced,
and that is the moment when Denis
brings out the first dish, the mental palate cleanser.
Very simple, very easy.
I see other chefs in culinary institutes
trying to think about how to elevate the mood.
Do you put joke cards on the table?
Or do you play some sort of musical video clip
that makes everyone laugh like the laughing policeman
or that video you see it on YouTube of those four
quintuplets of babies.
One starts laughing and that's starts the next one
and that starts the next one.
And they just cannot stop.
You can't watch that video without yourself laughing,
I think.
And that could be a nice mental palate cleanser.
Because food is always so much more than just about the food.
It's all happening up here in your mind, rather than,
I think, on your tongue or in your mouth.
So we're looking how to work sometimes
with some of the top chefs to see how they have delivered
brilliant dining experiences and trying
to turn that into research or science and then kind of export
it out to whoever else.
But very often, we sort of work more these days
with younger chefs, those who have,
for the first time started to think
about the minds of their diners.
And think about some of the simple tricks
that they could utilize to enhance
the quality of their food.
And it's not about using these tricks to serve
bad food that will seem good.
It's about using the best of your culinary skills
together with the best of gastrophysics
to deliver something better yet again.
And here we have the results from a restaurant study
done in Scotland last year.
We have 140 diners in a Scottish hotel in a fancy restaurant.
Half of those diners are served this dish of Scottish fish
for their main course, but they're given a heavy knife
and fork in their hands.
The other half of the diners are eating
the same food on the same day in the same restaurant
have been given the light canteen knife and fork instead.
They're all eating the same food.
We asked them, how much do you like the food?
How artistic does it seemed to be plated to you?
And in this context, how much would you
be willing to pay for that dish in a place like you are today?
And what we find, with the heavy knife and fork in hand,
is people think the food looks more artistic
and they're willing to pay significantly more
for exactly the same output from the kitchen.
A trend towards increased liking didn't quite
reach significance here.
So when I go to those kind of gastropubs
and these young chefs popping up in the Oxfordshire countryside,
near the Oxford department, I see
them so passionate about the food
that they're trying to create.
But sometimes, they think well, we can't afford heavy cutlery.
It's an expensive investment.
But you see results like this and say, no,
the way to the knife and fork should not
matter to a tasting experience, but it does.
And if you go, and you think carefully next time you
go to the Fat Duck Restaurant, and you finally
get the cutlery, on course three, four, or five,
you realize how heavy it is, and realize, intuitively perhaps,
the culinary team have worked that into the experience.
So heavier cup, heavier glass, heavy can,
seems to-- heavier book I think as well,
seems to make the thing even better.
I say, the other chefs, they care so much about the food.
And you go to an Indian restaurant in Oxford
with an up and coming chef and he's passionate about the food.
But he doesn't think about the music.
And you're there in the middle of July,
eating this Indian food, and the restaurant manager got his iPad
on, blaring out Christmas carols or something else that's
completely incongruent with the food, with the time of year,
and it does spoil, to some degree, the experience.
You cannot just concentrate on the food all the time.
Out brain is picking up this stuff
about the lighting, the smells, and music, the chair we're
sitting on, even the table we're sitting at
as well as the waiter, that cutlery,
and integrating it into a final judgment
about how much we like that food and how much we
enjoyed the experience.
I also want stress, while some of the underlying neuroscience
is kind of complicated, some of the insights, I think,
are very actionable and quite simple
for any chef, wherever in the world they might be working.
And here's another sort of simple one
that's come out of our work with the Alicia Foundation, Ferran
Adria's kind of test research kitchens,
just outside Barcelona.
And here we have a dessert that looks again,
suspiciously like a strawberry ice cream.
And in this case it is.
You're safe.
Your eyes did not mislead you.
But in this study, we served exactly the same chef
prepared strawberry dessert, either on a black plate
or a white plate.
About 30 or 40 people eating the desert
from each plate on the same day in the same sort
of a restaurant-like environment.
We asked them how sweet was the ice cream.
How much do you like it?
How fruity, and so on.
And what we find is that one of those plates tastes sweeter.
Same batch of ice cream, but one of those plates
tastes 10% sweeter.
Specifically, those who were eating
from the round, white plate, say this
tastes 10% sweeter, about 15% more flavorful
than exactly the same dish served on a black plate.
If that black plate was angular, it would taste even less.
So round and white seems to be very sweet.
Black and angular is not at all sweet.
And we've done this research with the Alicia Foundation
in Spain.
We've been to the Paul Bocuse Cookery
School, the heart of traditional French cuisine,
sustaining those French values.
They've been sort of interested in this.
Now we know the plate matters, even though we know it
shouldn't.
We want to know how it impacts performance and experience.
And with diners paying in their restaurant in the Paul Bocuse
Chateau just outside Lyon, the same sort of result
holds up again.
Things that shouldn't matter, but they really do.
Food is so much more than just the food.
OK.
Really, that first impression we get of food,
be it the color of the red dessert.
Is it frozen salmon, smoked salmon,
or is it really strawberry, plays a key part
in sitting our expectations.
Then when we come to taste the food,
those expectations anchor our experience.
And maybe very often, we really live
in a world of our expectations.
We occasionally test the world and se
…
How are we today?
Give me a cheer.
Excellent.
I'm very pleased to welcome Charles Spence to Talks
at Google.
Charles Spence is a professor of experimental psychology
at Oxford University, and a gastrophysicist,
working at the interface between chefs,
food companies, and technology.
I've seen the slides.
They look incredible.
Please join me in welcoming Charles
with a round of applause.
CHARLES SPENCE: OK.
So it's a pleasure to be with you here this lunch time,
and tell you a little bit about the research we
do in Oxford, but also with food companies and chefs
around the world.
It's sort of this interface of psychology, neuroscience,
technology, and fine dining, it has
some of the insights that are emerging from the latest
kind of research at this kind of interface,
are starting to work their way out to home dining,
to a variety of real world situations,
to hopefully allow us all to eat a little more
healthfully in the future.
And it's all kind of premised on this idea of the perfect meal,
the title of the book.
Just feel the weight in your hands and you'll know,
there's quality there.
And the opening quote from the book, from MFK Fisher,
is one that kind of inspires a lot of our thinking.
"That once at least, in the life of every human,
whether he be brute or trembling daffodil,
comes a moment of complete gastronomic satisfaction.
It is, I am sure, as much a matter of spirit as of body.
Everything is right.
Nothing jars.
There's a kind of harmony with every sensation
and emotion melted into one chord of well-being."
If we all think back in our past over the last few years,
we've all had that kind of perfect meal experience.
My colleagues sort of think, well, we
can't study it, because it's kind of different for each
and every one of you.
Maybe for some of you, it's going for your gastro tourism
to some fancy Michelin starred restaurant
on the other side of the world.
For others, it might be nothing more complex
than a picnic on a summer's day in the English countryside.
Different for each and every one of us,
but I think that we can sort of study that perfect meal, what
makes it great, try and extract some generalizations
can be used in everyday life to kind of nudge our meal
experiences in the right direction
to be more stimulating, more engaging, more
memorable, and perhaps more healthy as well.
I'm certainly not the first to think about the perfect meal.
It is a topic that goes back at least a century.
You find some the first sort of mentions from 1894
from French chemist, Berthelot, talking about the perfect meal
and what it would be like sometime around about today.
And for all of the chemists, for the feminist writers,
and also for the sort of serious scientists,
it was this, the meal in a pill.
So he was imagining in 1894, thereabouts, what
it would be like in a century.
And the idea of sitting down to eat
and wasting an hour of your day with a multi-course meal
seems bizarre.
Surely in the future, we'll have a pill, we'll pop it.
And that will sustain us through the day
and we'll need nothing else.
Just take this quote from-- where has he gone?
"Looking Forward: A Dream of the United States
of the Americas in 1999," written in 1899 by Arthur Bird.
"In order to save time, people in 1999,
often dined on a pill, a small pellet which contained
highly nutritious food.
They had little inclination to stretch their legs
under a table for an hour at a time
while masticating on an eight course dinner.
The busy man of 1999 took a soup pill or a concentrated meat
pill for his noon day lunch.
He dispatched these while working at his desk."
So he could be more efficient as a result.
That's what they thought was going to happen in 1999,
but it has not come to pass obviously.
And why not?
Because I think food is so much more than just
about nutrition and sustenance.
There's a whole sort of psychology
behind our experience of food, the way we eat
and what we enjoy eating.
And that is the theme for the book, "The Perfect Meal."
Myself, I worked together with Betina Piqueras-Fiszman,
my co-author, working in a psychology department
at Oxford, trying to understand the factors that
make one meal experience better than another
or that it can ruin a great evening simply
by just getting one sensory cue or trigger wrong.
And this is what we can think of as gastrophysics,
the new sciences of the table, which means since 1984, when
Harold McGee came out with his "On Food and Cooking,"
that was a whole three decades we've had,
a little over, of sort of science in the back of house,
science in the kitchen, science of new techniques of food
preparation, a rotovaps and sous vide and all sorts of stuff,
changing the way that food is prepared,
at least in the hands of some chefs.
We've also had the kind of emergence
of all sorts of new ingredients as well
to deliver textures and spumes and foams
and all kinds of stuff we had never had before.
Three decades, that's taken us a long way,
and it's certainly changed the way
that we eat, at least sometimes, but it's
all science in the kitchen.
Where I think it's changing now, and that's
kind of the idea of gastrophysics,
is it's science moving to the front of house,
to the dining tables, in the restaurants,
because they're easy to study, or can be, through to the home
dining, anywhere where we eat.
It's a science of the diner.
And it's gastrophysics.
So it's gastronomy, we're interested in high end
food in the first instance.
But also physics from psychophysics,
which is the kind of psychology, the measurement
of the human-- what different inputs lead
to different kind of outputs.
Normally it's done with lights and sounds
in front of a computer screen, but we want the gastrophysics
of real food experiences.
Study what matters, what doesn't matter, and how to create
insights that are actionable in the matter where or who
you might be serving food to.
I keep coming back this sort of thing,
that food is so much more than just about food.
So, imagine yourself as the chef,
and you've learned all the techniques.
And until recently you'd kind of think, well,
if I know I source my ingredients locally.
I prepare them beautifully.
Perhaps I give a little attention
to how the food appears on the plate.
If I do all that, it'll be enough.
I can deliver great meal experiences.
But in fact, I think, you need to know
about the mind of the diner as well in order
to change people's behavior for the better
to deliver great meal experiences.
What I'm seeing now, kind of inspired
by the likes of Ferran Adria in Spain and Heston Blumenthal,
just up the road in Bray, is a whole generation of young chefs
who are popping up, starting up, opening gastropubs,
culinary artistry events in the UK
and elsewhere, who for the first time are thinking,
I need to know how to make great tasting food.
But on top of that, I want to know
what's going in the head of my diner or order
to really meet their expectations
or completely confound their expectations.
But I need to know what's in here.
So a couple of examples of why you need to know more than just
about how to prepare food well.
First one is this kind of ugly beast
of the deep, the Patagonian toothfish that has been
on restaurant menus for years.
It just was never very popular.
Would you order it yourself on a menu in a restaurant?
Probably not.
If you saw the picture, definitely not.
But simply a little bit of rebranding
calling this Chilean sea bass, exactly the same fish,
looks still as ugly.
But suddenly sales increased by 1,300% in Australia,
North America, in the UK simply by change of name,
completely changes our food behavior,
what we choose to eat and what we don't.
Sure, great food, but on top of that,
you need to know what to call it.
Another kind of classic example of why the chef, I think,
needs to know about what's going on in the diner's mind.
Here we have a dish, and within the blink of an eye,
your brain has decided what it is.
Your brain is a prediction engine,
trying to figure out where the nutritious
food is in the environment.
So you see that and within 150 milliseconds,
your brain's decided, yeah, that's probably ice cream,
probably cold, probably sweet.
I'll probably like it.
Maybe I'll have a scoop later.
But I'd have to go to the gym.
And probably the flavor is a red fruit,
a raspberry or strawberry, something like that.
All went through your mind without you thinking, just
in the blink of an eye or less.
But the only problem is, that's not
the flavor of this ice cream.
So this is actually a frozen savory ice, popular in the UK
a century ago.
And this comes from the Fat Duck Kitchens.
So it could be a smoked salmon ice cream or a frozen crab
bisque ice cream.
So the chef makes this dish, maybe
is the world's top chef at the time.
He thinks it's seasoned perfectly.
It fits into sort of the theme of historic dining.
He brings it out and gives it to some of his preferred guests
who are regulars at the Fat Duck restaurant.
But when they put it in their mouth and they taste it,
they're going to go, ugh.
I didn't like it.
It's too salty.
But the problem was, the chef thought it was perfect.
He's the world's top chef.
But the diner said, no, it's too salty, pulls a funny face,
does not like at the time and does not
like it when they come back two or three weeks later.
It will remain salty in their experience.
The problem here is a matter of expectations.
Because the diner was thinking it
was going to be a sweet-tasting strawberry or raspberry ice
cream.
In fact, it was savory and salty.
Their expectations were disconfirmed.
They didn't like it.
Whereas if I just tell you before you
put a spoonful of this to your lips,
that this is food 386, a term that means nothing
to any of us, kind of vaguely scientific sounding.
But that title for the dish is enough
that when I give you, here, a spoonful of my new dish,
food 386, suddenly when you taste it,
you'll kind of withhold your expectations
and it will taste seasoned just right, the way the chef
experiences it.
So no matter what you do in the kitchen,
if you don't know the expectations of your diner,
you can't really predict how they're
going to respond or optimize the meal experience.
And if vision is so important, we
might think about the future of food.
Here we've got original sushi on the left, augmented reality
sushi on the right.
This, we were working with Katsu Kojima over in Japan.
There was about 70 vision scientists
thinking about a time, sometime in the future, when maybe we've
fished the seas to extinction of all our favorite sushi fish.
Could we, with our headset, like the one
you see there on the bottom right here.
Maybe you've been watching your movies.
Then you have your dinner and we can give you
the visual impression through the headset, of your best
tasting, now extinct fish on your sushi,
feed you the other one, and maybe
for what you eat, but eye is so important,
you have as good an experience as you
would have done if you could somehow still find
that now extinct fish.
Possibly.
Possibly not.
But again, it's this idea of using technology
and our knowledge of neuroscience
to deliver new, different food experiences.
Sometimes just more stimulating than anything we've had before.
At other times, trying to think about how
to nudge people towards healthier eating behaviors.
OK.
And food, as I say, it's so much more than about food.
It's about the naming and about expectations.
But it's also about mood and those we dine with.
It's kind of social, fundamentally
a social activity.
So I see chefs who think, as they
have done for decades, about palate cleansers.
We're in for a fancy meal.
We should have a palate cleanser to clear up palette
before the first of the chef's real dishes comes out.
And what will that be?
That will be maybe a lime sorbet,
something acidic to cut through something, apparently,
on your tongue.
But I think maybe the tongue is the least interesting bit
of our experience of flavor.
We experience flavors here in the brain.
So if I want to clean your palette, what I really
want to do is clean your mind, a mental palate cleanser
to get you into the right mood.
Because I know if you're in the right mood,
you'll enjoy the food that much more.
And this is the intuitive solution
of the Chef Denis Martin, who has a two Michelin star
restaurant in Vevey in Switzerland
between Charlie Chaplin's final resting house and Nestle
headquarters.
He's got two Michelin stars.
He kind of wants the third one.
Hasn't quite come yet.
Has a single sitting dining experience,
based in a knitting museum, which might
be part of the problem there.
But it's very inventive.
It's smoke and mirrors and all sorts
of great, molecular or modernist culinary practises.
When you go for that single sitting dinner service,
you all arrive, you're there at 7:00.
And you think well, we're all here now and you look around.
And there's nothing on the tables, no knives, no forks,
no glassware, nothing, just this sitting on the middle
of each and every table.
And people would wait and think, well, I'm
sure the first course is going to come out sometime soon.
But it won't.
Nothing will happen until some curious diner picks that thing
up off the table, wondering whether it's
the salt or the pepper shaker with a kind
of peculiar Swiss twist.
When they do that, when they pick that little device up,
look underneath, it's a silly, one euro toy.
It'll make a mooing sound.
The diner will laugh in surprise.
And then within a few moments, every table
in that two Michelin star restaurant
will have their moo cows in the air,
a chorus of mooing cows in a restaurant full of laughing
diners.
The mood has been elevated, enhanced,
and that is the moment when Denis
brings out the first dish, the mental palate cleanser.
Very simple, very easy.
I see other chefs in culinary institutes
trying to think about how to elevate the mood.
Do you put joke cards on the table?
Or do you play some sort of musical video clip
that makes everyone laugh like the laughing policeman
or that video you see it on YouTube of those four
quintuplets of babies.
One starts laughing and that's starts the next one
and that starts the next one.
And they just cannot stop.
You can't watch that video without yourself laughing,
I think.
And that could be a nice mental palate cleanser.
Because food is always so much more than just about the food.
It's all happening up here in your mind, rather than,
I think, on your tongue or in your mouth.
So we're looking how to work sometimes
with some of the top chefs to see how they have delivered
brilliant dining experiences and trying
to turn that into research or science and then kind of export
it out to whoever else.
But very often, we sort of work more these days
with younger chefs, those who have,
for the first time started to think
about the minds of their diners.
And think about some of the simple tricks
that they could utilize to enhance
the quality of their food.
And it's not about using these tricks to serve
bad food that will seem good.
It's about using the best of your culinary skills
together with the best of gastrophysics
to deliver something better yet again.
And here we have the results from a restaurant study
done in Scotland last year.
We have 140 diners in a Scottish hotel in a fancy restaurant.
Half of those diners are served this dish of Scottish fish
for their main course, but they're given a heavy knife
and fork in their hands.
The other half of the diners are eating
the same food on the same day in the same restaurant
have been given the light canteen knife and fork instead.
They're all eating the same food.
We asked them, how much do you like the food?
How artistic does it seemed to be plated to you?
And in this context, how much would you
be willing to pay for that dish in a place like you are today?
And what we find, with the heavy knife and fork in hand,
is people think the food looks more artistic
and they're willing to pay significantly more
for exactly the same output from the kitchen.
A trend towards increased liking didn't quite
reach significance here.
So when I go to those kind of gastropubs
and these young chefs popping up in the Oxfordshire countryside,
near the Oxford department, I see
them so passionate about the food
that they're trying to create.
But sometimes, they think well, we can't afford heavy cutlery.
It's an expensive investment.
But you see results like this and say, no,
the way to the knife and fork should not
matter to a tasting experience, but it does.
And if you go, and you think carefully next time you
go to the Fat Duck Restaurant, and you finally
get the cutlery, on course three, four, or five,
you realize how heavy it is, and realize, intuitively perhaps,
the culinary team have worked that into the experience.
So heavier cup, heavier glass, heavy can,
seems to-- heavier book I think as well,
seems to make the thing even better.
I say, the other chefs, they care so much about the food.
And you go to an Indian restaurant in Oxford
with an up and coming chef and he's passionate about the food.
But he doesn't think about the music.
And you're there in the middle of July,
eating this Indian food, and the restaurant manager got his iPad
on, blaring out Christmas carols or something else that's
completely incongruent with the food, with the time of year,
and it does spoil, to some degree, the experience.
You cannot just concentrate on the food all the time.
Out brain is picking up this stuff
about the lighting, the smells, and music, the chair we're
sitting on, even the table we're sitting at
as well as the waiter, that cutlery,
and integrating it into a final judgment
about how much we like that food and how much we
enjoyed the experience.
I also want stress, while some of the underlying neuroscience
is kind of complicated, some of the insights, I think,
are very actionable and quite simple
for any chef, wherever in the world they might be working.
And here's another sort of simple one
that's come out of our work with the Alicia Foundation, Ferran
Adria's kind of test research kitchens,
just outside Barcelona.
And here we have a dessert that looks again,
suspiciously like a strawberry ice cream.
And in this case it is.
You're safe.
Your eyes did not mislead you.
But in this study, we served exactly the same chef
prepared strawberry dessert, either on a black plate
or a white plate.
About 30 or 40 people eating the desert
from each plate on the same day in the same sort
of a restaurant-like environment.
We asked them how sweet was the ice cream.
How much do you like it?
How fruity, and so on.
And what we find is that one of those plates tastes sweeter.
Same batch of ice cream, but one of those plates
tastes 10% sweeter.
Specifically, those who were eating
from the round, white plate, say this
tastes 10% sweeter, about 15% more flavorful
than exactly the same dish served on a black plate.
If that black plate was angular, it would taste even less.
So round and white seems to be very sweet.
Black and angular is not at all sweet.
And we've done this research with the Alicia Foundation
in Spain.
We've been to the Paul Bocuse Cookery
School, the heart of traditional French cuisine,
sustaining those French values.
They've been sort of interested in this.
Now we know the plate matters, even though we know it
shouldn't.
We want to know how it impacts performance and experience.
And with diners paying in their restaurant in the Paul Bocuse
Chateau just outside Lyon, the same sort of result
holds up again.
Things that shouldn't matter, but they really do.
Food is so much more than just the food.
OK.
Really, that first impression we get of food,
be it the color of the red dessert.
Is it frozen salmon, smoked salmon,
or is it really strawberry, plays a key part
in sitting our expectations.
Then when we come to taste the food,
those expectations anchor our experience.
And maybe very often, we really live
in a world of our expectations.
We occasionally test the world and se
…