Advertisement
English transcript
Welcome back to ChessOpenings.com. Today I want to look at an interesting
position which arises after the moves pawn to e4, pawn to e5, Knight f3 and
Knight to c6. And it's from this position that today I'd like us to look at
some minute differences between the Ruy Lopez, which would be to move
Bishop to b5, and the Italian game, which would be to move Bishop to c4.
Now both moves look equally good in this position, so it might be
surprising to find out modern grand masters, the top players in the world,
largely prefer the Ruy Lopez. In fact, they're about 10 times more likely
to play Bishop b5 from this position, rather than Bishop c4. And so by
drawing your attention to some of the minute differences between these two
systems, I hope to enrich your understanding of both the Ruy Lopez and the
Italian game. Let's take a look.
Here we have the key position where White is able to choose between
deploying the Bishop on b5, and deploying the Bishop on c4. And it appears
that both moves have their advantages. On c4, the Bishop has the most scope
and also maybe targets this f7 point - which could become key later in the
tactical phase, whereas with Bishop b5, White starts some additional
pressure on this e5 pawn. Both moves also prepare White to castle quickly,
but as we'll see in just a moment, there are a lot of other fascinating
things going on in this position.
Now in this position both sides face a similar situation in the center,
since the center is symmetrical. Pawn on e4 and pawn on e5. But White's
counting on two important little trumps here. First of all, he still
retains the right to move; and this means that his operations will come on
just a little bit more quickly, but secondly, and just as importantly,
White has managed to force Black to play Knight to c6 in this position. And
it's due to this tiniest of details that White gets an idea. His idea is to
play pawn to c3 and pawn to d4, attacking the e5 pawn and building up a
bigger share of the center, and he's exploiting the fact that Black has
blocked his own C pawn, and cannot play the same build up plan in the
center.
So, to make this plan work, White has to be sure that he doesn't fall under
the same problem covering his own E pawn. For example, in light of the
discussion we just had, you might suppose that White should just play pawn
to c3 in this position. But in fact this move has two major drawbacks.
First of all, the move is so slow that Black can just play d5 himself, and
he can achieve an equal game right off the bat, since he immediately
achieves this all important thrust with the D pawn, and he doesn't have to
worry about losing time with the Queen, after say, pawn takes pawn and
Queen takes pawn, since the Knight is currently deprived of the c3 square.
This is one reason that c3 is not a great idea in this position.
A second antidote, which is also very successful, and which is a little bit
more instructive in this position, is Knight to f6. And this is normally
what White needs to fear. Black also can attack the E pawn and here it's
kind of difficult to find a good way to defend this pawn without
surrendering the plan of d2 to d4. For example, if White plays the move
pawn to d3, well of course this pawn is no longer eligible to come to d4
for quite some time. The same is true if White plays the awkward move,
Bishop to d3, when of course again, the pawn is weirdly situated here.
Another move which White might try is Queen to c2, but in this case, I
think that White is just losing time. Black's move, Knight to f6, will be
immensely more useful than White's move, Queen to c2, since we're not
really interested in developing the Queen so early, and probably just the
move d5 leads to a perfectly adequate game for Black. So, it's due to all
these things, in fact, that White normally goes ahead and enters
complications, with the move pawn to d4, as anything else gives Black a
very satisfactory game. But here too, it's been well known for a while that
after Knight takes pawn on e4, Black still achieves a satisfactory game.
Since, for example, after the move pawn takes pawn on e5, Black is still
able to bring this pawn up to d5, and Black has already achieved a rather
comfortable game.
So even though White in this position has successfully found the right idea
of playing c2 to c3, and d2 to d4, he still needs to take appropriate
details into account, and he needs to devise a strategy, and make
arrangements for how he's going to deal with Black getting ready to attack
White's pawn on e4. Whatever White does next, he needs to keep this factor
in mind while he continues to play for the correct plan.
With the move Bishop to c4, in addition to the other attractive points,
putting the Bishop on a nice square, and observing f7 and also preparing to
castle King side, in addition to these points, White is also ready to play
pawn to d3 at a moment's notice if he needs to defend the e4 pawn. And in
this case now, he already has the Bishop outside of the pawn chain, and
later he is going to make efforts to bring further defense to the e4 pawn,
probably by castling, playing moves like rook e1, and then the Knight to
b to d2. And then later he'll play for c3 and d4, and this is one of the
points of Bishop c4, is that it helps to facilitate White's playing d2 to
d3, in order to defend the e4 pawn.
In fact, the best players in the world have tended to handle the Italian
game using this sort of slow build up idea. For example, after Knight f6,
players on the White side have come to prefer the very quiet move, simple
pawn to d3. And now White will play in a very gradual style, similar to the
Ruy Lopez. In fact, let's just imagine that White gets a bunch of moves
here, in order to show some of the key ideas. White would ordinarily
continue with c2 to c3, castles King side, Bishop b3, and then moves, let's
say rook e1, Knight b to d2. Notice how we're defending this pawn adequately,
and we're also using a very typical maneuver of the Knight to f1 and to g3.
Then usually around here does White finally make a choice about when and
whether to play pawn to d4.
This is a very typical plan. For example, let's just give Black some moves
now, and show how this potentially pans out. After Knight f6, many games
have continued - d3, Bishop e7, castles King side, castles King side, and
Bishop e3. Now, I want to point out that the idea of this move, Bishop b3,
is to save this Bishop from an eventual stab by the Knight at a5.
At the moment, Black is not quite yet ready to play Knight a5, because he
has to watch this pawn on e5. So, first he plays d6, but now White is just
in time with the move c3, ready to give this Bishop an attractive square on
c2. In fact, Black still continues with the move Knight to a5, Bishop c2
and c5. This is the key idea, bringing that C pawn into the game and
helping control the center. Rook e1, the Knight comes back to the more
sensible c6 square, and now Knight b to d2. Then play tends to go rook e8, h3,
Bishop to f8, Knight f1. Very standard setup for White, in fact, we see
this exact same sort of setup for White many, many times in the Ruy Lopez.
To show a comparison, let's look at one of the most traditional lines in
the Ruy Lopez, and show just how similar play is from White's point of
view. Instead of this move, Bishop c4, the Ruy Lopez of course continues
Bishop b5, and now play often continues for the main lines, a6, Bishop a4,
Knight f6, castling King side, Bishop e7, rook e1, b5, Bishop to b3, d6.
Once again, he's defending this pawn, so we now know what we have to do. We
have to make sure that we've made arrangements for this Bishop to reach c2.
So White plays c3, and that's also in accordance with his plan, and now
castles King side, h3 is the known move here, Knight a5, Bishop c2, c5 very
similar play even by Black. And now White plays d4 and in the Chigorin
Variation, which this is, from the Ruy Lopez, Black normally plays Queen
c7, Knight b to d2, and we're setting up for very, very similar play.
So this is very similar, no matter whether we play the Ruy Lopez or the
Italian game, it looks like these positions are more or less very
equivalent. White is doing very similar things, and Black is doing very
similar things, so it's up to us to try to figure out what is it about this
position which we're looking at now, that White players find so much more
attractive than the Italian game version, which we just saw a moment ago.
What is the difference in this position? Why is it that world champions and
grand masters have been willing to play the Ruy Lopez version of these
positions, whereas mostly players at the club level are willing to play the
Italian game.
Let's back up just a moment to this position right before d2 to d4 and I
want you to notice something very subtle; that in this position, White is
able to play the move pawn to d4 all in one go. And by that I mean in the
Italian game, he typically had wasted a tempo playing d2 to d3 very early
on in the game, so that when this pawn came to d4, it was only with a loss
of tempo. For example, normally that would mean that Black's Knight would
already have had time to retreat successfully to the c6 square, and this
little difference is one of the major reasons why White has a little bit
less of an advantage in the Ruy Lopez than in the Italian game.
Let's take a look at that a little bit more closely. Let's slowly review
the Italian version again. White played Bishop c4, Knight f6, and now pawn
to d3, little difference, Bishop to e7, castles King side, castles King
side. We showed the move Bishop to b3, pawn to d6, c3, Knight to a5, Bishop
to c2 and pawn to c5. And now, White typically continued rook to e1 and
Knight to c6; notice that this is a big difference, that Black's Knight has
already come back to this c6 square.
And now Knight to b to d2, and we have rook e8, h3, all very same for White,
but there are some big differences with Black setup. But the main
difference which I want us to focus on for today, after Bishop f8, Knight
f1, h6 and now, for example, pawn to d4, the big difference that I want us
to focus on is that White has lost a tempo with this maneuver. d3, very
early, d3 occurred on move 4, and on move 13 we're moving that pawn a
second time, whereas in the Ruy Lopez, we did not have to do that.
There are some other differences, but the major way that Black has profited
from this tempo is that his Knight is already on a much better location,
and often this gives Black an option, for example, to trade material on d
four and achieve a pretty natural game here.
There are actually a few differences we can discuss between these very
similar versions of the same position. However, I just want to focus right
now on how exactly White lost a tempo in the Italian game. To see this more
clearly, let's start looking again at the move Bishop b5, which was the Ruy
Lopez.
Now, one of the little secrets in the Ruy Lopez, is that White has in fact
devised a solution to the defense of his e4 pawn. Remember that early on in
this video we spent a long time discussing the fact that White needs to
make some preparations to defend the e4 pawn. It turns out that in the Ruy
Lopez, White has an option to temporarily ignore the threat to e4.
For example, after the move Knight f6, or after the move a6, which is a
little bit more common, Bishop a4 and now Knight f6, instead of playing d2
to d3 as White played in the Italian game, White actually has the move
castling King side in this position. And in both cases, if Black does in
fact take on e4, and I want to point out really quick that quite often
Black does not take on e4 and instead he plays Bishop e7, and now White
uses his rook to defend the e4 pawn and the problem is solved; but if Black
takes on e4, White has access to the move pawn to d6. A lot of theory has
been written about these positions, but it's well known that White has
excellent chances of an advantage in this kind of position.
So, why can't White use the same exact idea in the Italian game? Well, it
turns out that after Bishop to c4, after Knight f6, the move castling King
side is just a very weak move. Since after Knight takes e4, the big problem
is that Black is going to be able to play d5, next move with tempo. And he
will do this no matter whether White plays rook e1 or if he plays pawn to
d4. Now Black would simply play pawn to d5 with tempo against the Bishop on
c4. It's because of this tiny little factor that the Bishop placement on d4
actually turns out to be a slight disadvantage for White.
If the Bishop is on b5, he never has to fear this kind of possibility, and
would simply play something like Knight takes e5. But on c4, Black's threat
on e4, to take on e4 with a Knight is slightly stronger because he can
always follow up with d5 with tempo. It's this little detail that means
that White needs to go out of his way to defend the pawn on e4, usually
with the move pawn to d3.
And so as we've seen before in the Ruy Lopez, after Bishop to e5, a6,
Bishop a4, Knight f6, castles, indeed Black most often does not take on e4,
and instead simply plays Bishop e7, and this gives White the opportunity to
play rook e1. Problem solved.
As we've seen, White is now in an excellent position to play his plan, c2
to c3, and pawn to d4, and by using the rook to defend the e4 pawn, he's
avoided the time-wasting move of d2 to d3. And now that you've seen all
this, you now understand one of the key strategic benefits of the Ruy Lopez
over the Italian game.
In the Ruy Lopez, White is able to deal with the threat to e4 more
effectively, set for a single tempo he can afford not to defend the e4
pawn. And it's this little difference which makes White's attempts to gain
the advantage in the Ruy Lopez more persuasive than his attempts to gain an
advantage in the Italian game.
I hope you've enjoyed this little journey into heart of the Ruy Lopez and
the Italian game. Whether you ultimately decide to look at some of the
fascinating details of the Ruy Lopez, or to simply play the Italian game
for its clear strategic ideas, I hope that by understanding these small
details you will have a better appreciation for the openings and have more
success in playing them. Thank you for watching, and I hope to see you
soon.
position which arises after the moves pawn to e4, pawn to e5, Knight f3 and
Knight to c6. And it's from this position that today I'd like us to look at
some minute differences between the Ruy Lopez, which would be to move
Bishop to b5, and the Italian game, which would be to move Bishop to c4.
Now both moves look equally good in this position, so it might be
surprising to find out modern grand masters, the top players in the world,
largely prefer the Ruy Lopez. In fact, they're about 10 times more likely
to play Bishop b5 from this position, rather than Bishop c4. And so by
drawing your attention to some of the minute differences between these two
systems, I hope to enrich your understanding of both the Ruy Lopez and the
Italian game. Let's take a look.
Here we have the key position where White is able to choose between
deploying the Bishop on b5, and deploying the Bishop on c4. And it appears
that both moves have their advantages. On c4, the Bishop has the most scope
and also maybe targets this f7 point - which could become key later in the
tactical phase, whereas with Bishop b5, White starts some additional
pressure on this e5 pawn. Both moves also prepare White to castle quickly,
but as we'll see in just a moment, there are a lot of other fascinating
things going on in this position.
Now in this position both sides face a similar situation in the center,
since the center is symmetrical. Pawn on e4 and pawn on e5. But White's
counting on two important little trumps here. First of all, he still
retains the right to move; and this means that his operations will come on
just a little bit more quickly, but secondly, and just as importantly,
White has managed to force Black to play Knight to c6 in this position. And
it's due to this tiniest of details that White gets an idea. His idea is to
play pawn to c3 and pawn to d4, attacking the e5 pawn and building up a
bigger share of the center, and he's exploiting the fact that Black has
blocked his own C pawn, and cannot play the same build up plan in the
center.
So, to make this plan work, White has to be sure that he doesn't fall under
the same problem covering his own E pawn. For example, in light of the
discussion we just had, you might suppose that White should just play pawn
to c3 in this position. But in fact this move has two major drawbacks.
First of all, the move is so slow that Black can just play d5 himself, and
he can achieve an equal game right off the bat, since he immediately
achieves this all important thrust with the D pawn, and he doesn't have to
worry about losing time with the Queen, after say, pawn takes pawn and
Queen takes pawn, since the Knight is currently deprived of the c3 square.
This is one reason that c3 is not a great idea in this position.
A second antidote, which is also very successful, and which is a little bit
more instructive in this position, is Knight to f6. And this is normally
what White needs to fear. Black also can attack the E pawn and here it's
kind of difficult to find a good way to defend this pawn without
surrendering the plan of d2 to d4. For example, if White plays the move
pawn to d3, well of course this pawn is no longer eligible to come to d4
for quite some time. The same is true if White plays the awkward move,
Bishop to d3, when of course again, the pawn is weirdly situated here.
Another move which White might try is Queen to c2, but in this case, I
think that White is just losing time. Black's move, Knight to f6, will be
immensely more useful than White's move, Queen to c2, since we're not
really interested in developing the Queen so early, and probably just the
move d5 leads to a perfectly adequate game for Black. So, it's due to all
these things, in fact, that White normally goes ahead and enters
complications, with the move pawn to d4, as anything else gives Black a
very satisfactory game. But here too, it's been well known for a while that
after Knight takes pawn on e4, Black still achieves a satisfactory game.
Since, for example, after the move pawn takes pawn on e5, Black is still
able to bring this pawn up to d5, and Black has already achieved a rather
comfortable game.
So even though White in this position has successfully found the right idea
of playing c2 to c3, and d2 to d4, he still needs to take appropriate
details into account, and he needs to devise a strategy, and make
arrangements for how he's going to deal with Black getting ready to attack
White's pawn on e4. Whatever White does next, he needs to keep this factor
in mind while he continues to play for the correct plan.
With the move Bishop to c4, in addition to the other attractive points,
putting the Bishop on a nice square, and observing f7 and also preparing to
castle King side, in addition to these points, White is also ready to play
pawn to d3 at a moment's notice if he needs to defend the e4 pawn. And in
this case now, he already has the Bishop outside of the pawn chain, and
later he is going to make efforts to bring further defense to the e4 pawn,
probably by castling, playing moves like rook e1, and then the Knight to
b to d2. And then later he'll play for c3 and d4, and this is one of the
points of Bishop c4, is that it helps to facilitate White's playing d2 to
d3, in order to defend the e4 pawn.
In fact, the best players in the world have tended to handle the Italian
game using this sort of slow build up idea. For example, after Knight f6,
players on the White side have come to prefer the very quiet move, simple
pawn to d3. And now White will play in a very gradual style, similar to the
Ruy Lopez. In fact, let's just imagine that White gets a bunch of moves
here, in order to show some of the key ideas. White would ordinarily
continue with c2 to c3, castles King side, Bishop b3, and then moves, let's
say rook e1, Knight b to d2. Notice how we're defending this pawn adequately,
and we're also using a very typical maneuver of the Knight to f1 and to g3.
Then usually around here does White finally make a choice about when and
whether to play pawn to d4.
This is a very typical plan. For example, let's just give Black some moves
now, and show how this potentially pans out. After Knight f6, many games
have continued - d3, Bishop e7, castles King side, castles King side, and
Bishop e3. Now, I want to point out that the idea of this move, Bishop b3,
is to save this Bishop from an eventual stab by the Knight at a5.
At the moment, Black is not quite yet ready to play Knight a5, because he
has to watch this pawn on e5. So, first he plays d6, but now White is just
in time with the move c3, ready to give this Bishop an attractive square on
c2. In fact, Black still continues with the move Knight to a5, Bishop c2
and c5. This is the key idea, bringing that C pawn into the game and
helping control the center. Rook e1, the Knight comes back to the more
sensible c6 square, and now Knight b to d2. Then play tends to go rook e8, h3,
Bishop to f8, Knight f1. Very standard setup for White, in fact, we see
this exact same sort of setup for White many, many times in the Ruy Lopez.
To show a comparison, let's look at one of the most traditional lines in
the Ruy Lopez, and show just how similar play is from White's point of
view. Instead of this move, Bishop c4, the Ruy Lopez of course continues
Bishop b5, and now play often continues for the main lines, a6, Bishop a4,
Knight f6, castling King side, Bishop e7, rook e1, b5, Bishop to b3, d6.
Once again, he's defending this pawn, so we now know what we have to do. We
have to make sure that we've made arrangements for this Bishop to reach c2.
So White plays c3, and that's also in accordance with his plan, and now
castles King side, h3 is the known move here, Knight a5, Bishop c2, c5 very
similar play even by Black. And now White plays d4 and in the Chigorin
Variation, which this is, from the Ruy Lopez, Black normally plays Queen
c7, Knight b to d2, and we're setting up for very, very similar play.
So this is very similar, no matter whether we play the Ruy Lopez or the
Italian game, it looks like these positions are more or less very
equivalent. White is doing very similar things, and Black is doing very
similar things, so it's up to us to try to figure out what is it about this
position which we're looking at now, that White players find so much more
attractive than the Italian game version, which we just saw a moment ago.
What is the difference in this position? Why is it that world champions and
grand masters have been willing to play the Ruy Lopez version of these
positions, whereas mostly players at the club level are willing to play the
Italian game.
Let's back up just a moment to this position right before d2 to d4 and I
want you to notice something very subtle; that in this position, White is
able to play the move pawn to d4 all in one go. And by that I mean in the
Italian game, he typically had wasted a tempo playing d2 to d3 very early
on in the game, so that when this pawn came to d4, it was only with a loss
of tempo. For example, normally that would mean that Black's Knight would
already have had time to retreat successfully to the c6 square, and this
little difference is one of the major reasons why White has a little bit
less of an advantage in the Ruy Lopez than in the Italian game.
Let's take a look at that a little bit more closely. Let's slowly review
the Italian version again. White played Bishop c4, Knight f6, and now pawn
to d3, little difference, Bishop to e7, castles King side, castles King
side. We showed the move Bishop to b3, pawn to d6, c3, Knight to a5, Bishop
to c2 and pawn to c5. And now, White typically continued rook to e1 and
Knight to c6; notice that this is a big difference, that Black's Knight has
already come back to this c6 square.
And now Knight to b to d2, and we have rook e8, h3, all very same for White,
but there are some big differences with Black setup. But the main
difference which I want us to focus on for today, after Bishop f8, Knight
f1, h6 and now, for example, pawn to d4, the big difference that I want us
to focus on is that White has lost a tempo with this maneuver. d3, very
early, d3 occurred on move 4, and on move 13 we're moving that pawn a
second time, whereas in the Ruy Lopez, we did not have to do that.
There are some other differences, but the major way that Black has profited
from this tempo is that his Knight is already on a much better location,
and often this gives Black an option, for example, to trade material on d
four and achieve a pretty natural game here.
There are actually a few differences we can discuss between these very
similar versions of the same position. However, I just want to focus right
now on how exactly White lost a tempo in the Italian game. To see this more
clearly, let's start looking again at the move Bishop b5, which was the Ruy
Lopez.
Now, one of the little secrets in the Ruy Lopez, is that White has in fact
devised a solution to the defense of his e4 pawn. Remember that early on in
this video we spent a long time discussing the fact that White needs to
make some preparations to defend the e4 pawn. It turns out that in the Ruy
Lopez, White has an option to temporarily ignore the threat to e4.
For example, after the move Knight f6, or after the move a6, which is a
little bit more common, Bishop a4 and now Knight f6, instead of playing d2
to d3 as White played in the Italian game, White actually has the move
castling King side in this position. And in both cases, if Black does in
fact take on e4, and I want to point out really quick that quite often
Black does not take on e4 and instead he plays Bishop e7, and now White
uses his rook to defend the e4 pawn and the problem is solved; but if Black
takes on e4, White has access to the move pawn to d6. A lot of theory has
been written about these positions, but it's well known that White has
excellent chances of an advantage in this kind of position.
So, why can't White use the same exact idea in the Italian game? Well, it
turns out that after Bishop to c4, after Knight f6, the move castling King
side is just a very weak move. Since after Knight takes e4, the big problem
is that Black is going to be able to play d5, next move with tempo. And he
will do this no matter whether White plays rook e1 or if he plays pawn to
d4. Now Black would simply play pawn to d5 with tempo against the Bishop on
c4. It's because of this tiny little factor that the Bishop placement on d4
actually turns out to be a slight disadvantage for White.
If the Bishop is on b5, he never has to fear this kind of possibility, and
would simply play something like Knight takes e5. But on c4, Black's threat
on e4, to take on e4 with a Knight is slightly stronger because he can
always follow up with d5 with tempo. It's this little detail that means
that White needs to go out of his way to defend the pawn on e4, usually
with the move pawn to d3.
And so as we've seen before in the Ruy Lopez, after Bishop to e5, a6,
Bishop a4, Knight f6, castles, indeed Black most often does not take on e4,
and instead simply plays Bishop e7, and this gives White the opportunity to
play rook e1. Problem solved.
As we've seen, White is now in an excellent position to play his plan, c2
to c3, and pawn to d4, and by using the rook to defend the e4 pawn, he's
avoided the time-wasting move of d2 to d3. And now that you've seen all
this, you now understand one of the key strategic benefits of the Ruy Lopez
over the Italian game.
In the Ruy Lopez, White is able to deal with the threat to e4 more
effectively, set for a single tempo he can afford not to defend the e4
pawn. And it's this little difference which makes White's attempts to gain
the advantage in the Ruy Lopez more persuasive than his attempts to gain an
advantage in the Italian game.
I hope you've enjoyed this little journey into heart of the Ruy Lopez and
the Italian game. Whether you ultimately decide to look at some of the
fascinating details of the Ruy Lopez, or to simply play the Italian game
for its clear strategic ideas, I hope that by understanding these small
details you will have a better appreciation for the openings and have more
success in playing them. Thank you for watching, and I hope to see you
soon.