Advertisement
English transcript
MALE SPEAKER: Good afternoon, and welcome to Talks at Google.
Today we're joined by Arlene Blum, celebrated aplinist
and biophysical chemist.
As a mountaineer, she led the first all-female ascent
of Annapurna, one of the 14 8,000-meter peaks.
On Denali, she co-led the first women's team climb.
She was the first American woman to attempt Mount Everest
and completed the great Himalayan Traverse
across Bhutan, Nepal, and India.
As a scientist, she's worked as a tireless advocate
for consumer safety.
Her research has focused on the use of toxic chemicals
in everyday products.
This work has led to bans on carcinogenic flame retardants
in children's sleepwear and household furniture.
Currently, she serves as Executive Director of the Green
Science Policy Institute and is a visiting scholar
at UC Berkeley's Department of Chemistry.
Today, she will share stories of climbing and policy
from her memoir, "Breaking Trail: A Climbing Life."
Please join me in welcoming Arlene Blum.
[APPLAUSE]
Well, it's really great to be here sharing
adventures in both science and mountain climbing.
Because I suspect many of you have your own adventures
in things relating to science, and it probably
feels like mountain climbing.
Some of you might be looking at me
and thinking that I seem like a regular person,
and how did I start doing all those crazy things.
So I will start back where it all started.
That's my freshman chemistry lab at Reed College.
And my chemistry professor was a young woman.
She was 23.
She had a Ph.D. From MIT and thought chemistry
was the neatest subject on the planet.
There were four girls in my class,
and we all got doctorates in chemistry,
which says something about the importance of role models.
Also, my chemistry lab partner was a very handsome young man
from Portland who was a mountain climber.
And late one starry night, he said,
do you want to go climb Mount Hood?
And he was very handsome, so I said sure.
And we drove up to Timberline Lodge,
and he put a big pack on my back.
I was from Chicago.
I'd never done anything very physical in my life.
I started gasping.
He later said he didn't think I'd make it out
of the parking lot.
But he was very handsome.
I was very determined.
And we got up on the snow.
It was the most beautiful place I'd been.
I fell in love with him and with mountain climbing,
and started a life of mountains and molecules--
or we said peaks, public policy, and public health.
So I continue doing expeditions.
Back in those days, the world's highest mountains
had not been climbed much by women.
And indeed, when I applied to go on an expedition
to Denali, the highest mountain in North America,
I was told that women didn't have
the physical strength or emotional stability
to climb mountains like Denali.
So this is the first all women's expedition on top of Denali,
which I took the picture, so I'm not in it.
And so I continued doing mountains and molecules.
And then things really changed on this beautiful mountain
in India.
Now, doesn't this look like an easy, beautiful mountain?
Wouldn't you all like to be there?
It's nearly 24,000 feet, but it's gentle snow slopes.
And we're climbing this mountain,
and got up to near the top.
It was our summit day.
And I'm kind of a slow climber, so the others
got to the top first.
And when I got to the top, someone
said, what happened to Bruce, who had gotten there first?
And Bruce had walked along here to what was here,
which was snow, but was actually a cornice where
the snow is over a rock face.
And the cornice broke, and he fell to his death.
And Bruce was the country's leading young rock climber.
He had pioneered the hardest routes in Yosemite
without using pitons.
And it was just unbelievable that he
died on this easy but high mountain in India.
So when that happened, I got very depressed.
At the time, I was a postdoc at Stanford
studying how proteins fold.
And that seemed really irrelevant.
And I wanted to do something for the environment
in Bruce's memory.
And so I went to a professor of mine
at Berkeley, [INAUDIBLE] Committee, Bruce Aimes,
and said, is there anything I can do to help the environment?
And he said, well, why don't you look at the flame retardants
in children's sleepwear?
He said, right now, pretty much all the kids in America
are wearing pajamas that are 10% by weight a flame retardant
called brominated tris.
And I think it might get from the pajamas into the children,
and it's a cancer-causing chemical, I think.
And so that seemed a little weird to me, flame retardants.
But I was depressed, so I thought I want to do something.
So I found a little girl who had never
worn tris-treated pajamas.
And we put her in the pajamas and collected her urine.
And the first morning she wore them,
she had tris products in her urine.
And she wore them for three days.
The level of tris in her urine went up,
and she stopped wearing them, and it went down.
So it meant the tris was getting into the little girl.
And then we ran a screening test to see if tris was a mutagen.
Did it change DNA?
And it was one of the strongest mutagens ever studied.
So this was a huge worry.
And we thought, oh my goodness.
We need to tell the parents of America
that most of the kids in the country
are wearing pajamas that are 10% by weight
this harmful chemical.
So about that time, I got invited to go to this mountain.
Do you know what mountain this is?
Anybody know?
Mount Everest.
It's the highest mountain in the world.
And at that point, no American woman
had ever even had a chance to try to climb Mount Everest.
So I was like, wow, this is such an opportunity.
And I didn't know what to do.
Should I stay and write the paper
about the tris-treated pajamas, or should I
go try to climb Mount Everest?
So I can't help but ask.
How many of you would have stayed and written
the paper about the tris-treated pajamas?
Most of you.
How many of you would have gone to Mount Everest?
Even more.
Well, I did both.
So I did go to Mount Everest.
And when I was climbing in the Khumbu Icefall,
every night, I'd write the paper.
And then up in the great Western Cwm,
we'd put stringing ladders, and making
our way amongst the crevasses, and we'd
get up steep ice faces.
And every night, I'd keep working on the paper
until I reached my high point.
Here I am at about 24 5 on Everest.
And my summit flag, The Mutants, has a Petri dish.
Without tris, there are only two colonies,
because it's a mutagen. And this one you can see.
It's blowing in the wind.
That's the tris Petri dish with many bacterial colonies.
So this was October of 1976.
And we did reach the summit.
We were the second American expedition.
Now people reach the summit all the time.
But the first American expedition was '63,
and we were the second one in '76,
so it was much less [INAUDIBLE].
And we had the whole mountain to ourselves.
Only one expedition on Mount Everest, which is a little bit
different nowadays.
So I finished the paper.
I sent it by mail runner to Kathmandu.
And it was published in Science Magazine a couple months later.
And if you read the subtitle of the paper,
the main flame retardant in children's pajamas is a mutagen
and should not be used.
Now, that's a little bit of an unusual title for a paper.
If any of you-- I'm sure you have--
if you read scientific papers, they
tend to have the same recommendation
at the end, almost invariably.
And what's that recommendation at the end
of all scientific papers?
What is the next step?
More studies.
And it's always more studies.
And it tends not to be something like a chemical should not
be used in kids' pajamas.
And at the Green Science Policy Institute,
our goal is to really help inspire, encourage scientists
to take their research and tell people what needs to be done.
Because scientists are the ones who really know.
They understand the science, and then they
understand what needs to be done.
And we believe that scientists have a responsibility
to share their science in a way that affects change,
particularly if they're working on harmful chemicals.
And it works.
Scientists are very respected.
When they speak up, things happen.
This was January of 1977 where we
called for tris not being used in kid's pajamas.
And April 1977, tris was banned from kid's pajamas,
just like it should be.
And that was a really good thing,
because whole generations of kids only wore it.
It was only used for a couple of years,
which is a very good thing.
So however, when a chemical is banned,
there's a big tendency to replace it
with another chemical that's very similar, because industry
likes to keep processes as similar as possible.
It makes sense.
It was funny.
I remember about six months after the tris ban,
I thought, I wonder what they're using now,
if they're still using tris.
So I remember I rode I rode my bicycle to Penny's, downtown
Berkeley, and I bought 20 pairs of pajamas
in all different sizes.
And the sales lady just gushed at me,
oh, you have such a nice, big family.
And I sort of felt like a super spy with all my pajamas.
And I thought, well, these might make nice shower presents
for my friends.
So I just took a little fabric out
of the inseam of each pajama.
But I actually didn't need to bother, since none of them
would I have wanted to give for presents.
And then I analyzed what was in them.
And not surprisingly, about a third of them
had brominated interest, because it takes time
for the market to turn over.
But then nearly 2/3 of them had a new chemical
which turned out to be chlorinated tris, almost
identical.
And so we went, oh my god.
So we ran more immunogenicity tests,
and chlorinated tris was also a mutagen. It changed DNA.
And we wrote another paper in Science,
and chlorinated tris was removed from pajamas.
However, what we didn't know then
is it continued to be used, for example, in furniture.
And in 2005, when a very bad flame retardant
was banned from use in our furniture,
it was replaced with chlorinated tris,
which was then banned in 2012.
But if any of you have a couch that
was purchased between 2006 and 2012--
anyone have a couch purchased during that time?
Anyway, there's about a 3/4 chance that your couch-- 5%
of the weight of the foam will be chlorinated tris.
So if you have 20 pounds of foam in your couch,
you have about a pound of this chemical in your couch.
Not the best.
But we didn't know it back then.
And back then, I thought it was really time
to give women a chance to climb one of the world's highest
mountains.
So in the '70s, all the world's 8,000-meter peaks--
there are 14 of them.
The highest mountains in the world had been climbed by men,
and no woman had climbed that high.
And I thought, women should have a chance.
We had done pretty well on Everest.
So I got a permit for Annapurna on my way back from Everest,
and I thought, it's the first of the 8,000-meter peaks ever
climbed, among the lowest.
It must be one of the safest and easiest.
But as it turned out, there wasn't so much
research in those days.
So guess which is the most dangerous of all
the 8,000-meter peaks?
Annapurna.
And which has the highest fatality rate
and is considered, perhaps, the most difficult to climb?
Anyway, we didn't know that.
But we found out.
So this is our team.
We had 10 climbers, a couple filmmakers, a base camp
manager.
We're all still friends.
There are copies here afterwards-- I'm
happy to sign copies of "Annapurna" or "Breaking
Trail" for people.
And "Annapurna" has just been reprinted, September 15.
Sierra Club Books had been out of business,
and the book had been out of press for a few years,
so it's just back in press.
And we're all going to be getting
together for an Annapurna book party next month.
And I have to say, when we get together,
it feels like we're back on the glacier
just like it did a long time ago.
So climbing Annapurna was incredibly beautiful.
I'll just share a few of the pictures.
The beauty is extraordinary, but the climbing was really tough.
And there were huge storms.
The reason it's such a dangerous mountain
is very high precipitation.
And these huge snowfalls led to huge avalanches.
So it was a very dangerous place.
Ever since I became a mom, I haven't wanted to go there.
But wonderful climbing.
And we did reach the summit.
We were the first women, the first Americans.
We reached the summit with two Sherpa climbers.
We unfurled our flags, held together with a Save
the Whales pin, and we felt content then
we had achieved our goal.
But we tragically lost two of our team
on a second summit attempt.
So climbing Annapurna is a very, very dangerous thing.
I wrote this book, "Annapurna: A Woman's Place,"
which now, as I said, it's just been reissued this week.
And then I wrote another book, "Breaking Trail,"
trying to understand how my childhood and my life
had led to both my scientific research and my mountain
climbing.
And when I finished "Breaking Trail," it was in 2006.
I had spent 20 years writing "Breaking Trail."
I twas like a personal therapy project.
It was a lot of work trying to understand my family.
And I had just finished the book.
My daughter was starting college.
I thought I'd really would like to go back to doing science.
But I actually stopped being a scientist in 1980
to walk across the whole Himalayan mountain range.
I have a job at UC Berkeley.
I said, I want to take a year off
to walk across the Himalayas.
And they were like, well, you have to decide.
Do you want your chemistry job or the Himalayas?
So I chose the Himalayas in 1980.
And many things intervened.
It was 2006, 26 years later.
And the last sentence of "Breaking Trail"
is the future is like an unbroken snow slope.
I hope I can find a way to break trail to a better world.
But I actually really didn't know what I was going to do,
because we hadn't done science for 26 years.
I thought, well, maybe I can get a job washing
test tubes in a lab.
I thought I must be completely out of date.
But that was nine years ago.
And the last nine years, I have felt every day
like I was climbing Annapurna.
I've been on my life's greatest adventure.
And it's been really similar, because we're
working with a great team of scientists and businesspeople
all over the world.
A bunch of people in Google are on the same team.
Really working together for healthier and safer products.
And it's a real challenge, but a real opportunity.
So I felt incredibly lucky that I could not
do science for 26 years and then come back and be able to really
try to climb this mountain.
And the reason that we're all climbing this mountain
is there is a big problem.
And that is-- I sometimes ask this question.
I bet you'll know the answer.
But what do you think-- do you think
if you have chemicals in your shampoo
or your toothpaste or your chair,
anyone think the government is making sure they're
safe for their your health?
You all know not.
But most people do think that.
I used to think that.
And the government actually can't, because they
don't have the authority.
There's only one law about chemicals
before they go out in the world.
Once they're out in the world, you
have a Clean Air Act, a Clean Water Act,
but you can't really bring them back in.
So the only law before they go out in the world
is called the Toxic Substances Control Act.
It passed in 1976.
62,000 chemicals were grandfathered, like you're OK.
And even a chemical like asbestos that kills 10,000
people a year cannot be controlled by the EPA.
And you might say asbestos, there are asbestos lawsuits.
Asbestos is illegal.
Well, asbestos is not illegal.
There are lawsuits.
And there's a rare form of cancer
called mesothelioma that's only associated
with asbestos exposure.
So if you're an asbestos worker or the spouse of an asbestos
worker and you get mesothelioma, you
can sue the asbestos industry that that's
the reason for your disease.
And you'll probably win the case, but you also will die.
Everybody that gets mesothelioma dies.
And that's not a good way to regulate chemicals.
And that's how we regulate asbestos, through lawsuits.
By then, it's really late.
So the 62,000 chemicals nobody can do anything
about-- there have been 20,000 new industrial chemicals.
No data is required.
Most of them have no health data.
2/3 have no data at all.
The EPA has six weeks to try to show harm with no data.
And if they do show harm, the company
has several years to try to prove their chemical is OK,
and they can sell it during those several years
to raise the money for the testing.
And once they're out there selling it,
it's really hard to stop it.
So basically-- and indeed, I'm going
to speak at the EPA tomorrow.
In fact, if anyone wants to hear my talk,
you can tell them 10 o'clock tomorrow,
I'll be speaking by the post office at the main EPA
building.
So if you ASK the EPA, they say we can't even ban asbestos.
They say that.
It's really a problem.
Another problem-- and in fact, this
leads to what two brilliant pediatricians, Herb Needleman
and Phil Landrigan, said-- that we are de facto conducting
a human toxicological trial.
Our children and our children's children
are the experimental subjects.
So if these chemicals aren't tested in any other way,
they're tested on us.
And that's not a good thing to do.
And they do contribute to increased rates
of cancer, infertility, neurological impairments.
So another problem is what we call
the regrettable substitution problem.
If after a lot of work, a chemical is regulated,
the substitute is often the chemical cousin.
For example, over here, we have-- if you know chemistry,
we've got decabromo, 10 bromines, diphenly,
two phenyl rings.
Decabrominated diphenyl ether, that's
an ether bond with the oxygen in the middle.
And it's persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic.
And about 15% of the weight to the plastic in an average TV
is decabromodiphenyl ether.
It's used in fabric back coatings, many uses.
Due to its severe persistence, bioaccumulation and toxicity,
the deca ether has been phased out.
But what's the substitute?
Decabrominated diphenyl ethane.
So there's an ethane bond instead of an ether.
It's also persistent, bioaccumulative,
and appears to be toxic.
So as the deca ether sales go down,
the deca ethane sales go up.
Is that a good deal?
Not much improvement.
So it's a discouraging situation.
However-- everyone is looking depressed but me, right?
Because I think there are things that can be done.
And to solve this problem, we decided
to bring together scientists who cared passionately about this
to really focus on what could be done.
And so we have had a series of retreats
where we invite five scientists from industry,
five from academia, five from NGOs, and five from government.
So it's about 20 scientists, maybe 25.
And at the first retreat, we said, are there
certain chemicals, certain chemical families,
that we know are harmful that can be avoided?
A simpler way of thinking of this.
When you think of that 80,000 chemicals,
it sounds kind of daunting.
All you can do is put your head down and get poison.
Because who can deal with 80,000 chemicals?
So we came up with six classes.
And this is a solution that really invites action.
And so briefly, the classes are highly fluorinated chemicals.
These are stain and water repellents, like Scotchguard.
Let me just ask-- how many of you knew or know--
and by the way, there's a handout
at the back when you leave that lists all the classes and more
information about them.
But let me see.
How many of you know that Scotchguard is
a problem in these chemicals?
OK.
One person who works in this area.
But when people know, they can make better choices.
The next class is the chlorinated antimicrobials,
like triclosan and triclocarban approach ban liquids soaps.
Who knew about them?
A couple people.
Then we have the flame retardants.
Who's heard about the flame retardants?
OK.
You've all heard about the flame retardants.
We have bisphenols.
Remember those bisphenol A water bottles?
Phthalates, organic solvents, certain metals.
And you look at this list-- this is
most of the harmful chemicals
…
Today we're joined by Arlene Blum, celebrated aplinist
and biophysical chemist.
As a mountaineer, she led the first all-female ascent
of Annapurna, one of the 14 8,000-meter peaks.
On Denali, she co-led the first women's team climb.
She was the first American woman to attempt Mount Everest
and completed the great Himalayan Traverse
across Bhutan, Nepal, and India.
As a scientist, she's worked as a tireless advocate
for consumer safety.
Her research has focused on the use of toxic chemicals
in everyday products.
This work has led to bans on carcinogenic flame retardants
in children's sleepwear and household furniture.
Currently, she serves as Executive Director of the Green
Science Policy Institute and is a visiting scholar
at UC Berkeley's Department of Chemistry.
Today, she will share stories of climbing and policy
from her memoir, "Breaking Trail: A Climbing Life."
Please join me in welcoming Arlene Blum.
[APPLAUSE]
Well, it's really great to be here sharing
adventures in both science and mountain climbing.
Because I suspect many of you have your own adventures
in things relating to science, and it probably
feels like mountain climbing.
Some of you might be looking at me
and thinking that I seem like a regular person,
and how did I start doing all those crazy things.
So I will start back where it all started.
That's my freshman chemistry lab at Reed College.
And my chemistry professor was a young woman.
She was 23.
She had a Ph.D. From MIT and thought chemistry
was the neatest subject on the planet.
There were four girls in my class,
and we all got doctorates in chemistry,
which says something about the importance of role models.
Also, my chemistry lab partner was a very handsome young man
from Portland who was a mountain climber.
And late one starry night, he said,
do you want to go climb Mount Hood?
And he was very handsome, so I said sure.
And we drove up to Timberline Lodge,
and he put a big pack on my back.
I was from Chicago.
I'd never done anything very physical in my life.
I started gasping.
He later said he didn't think I'd make it out
of the parking lot.
But he was very handsome.
I was very determined.
And we got up on the snow.
It was the most beautiful place I'd been.
I fell in love with him and with mountain climbing,
and started a life of mountains and molecules--
or we said peaks, public policy, and public health.
So I continue doing expeditions.
Back in those days, the world's highest mountains
had not been climbed much by women.
And indeed, when I applied to go on an expedition
to Denali, the highest mountain in North America,
I was told that women didn't have
the physical strength or emotional stability
to climb mountains like Denali.
So this is the first all women's expedition on top of Denali,
which I took the picture, so I'm not in it.
And so I continued doing mountains and molecules.
And then things really changed on this beautiful mountain
in India.
Now, doesn't this look like an easy, beautiful mountain?
Wouldn't you all like to be there?
It's nearly 24,000 feet, but it's gentle snow slopes.
And we're climbing this mountain,
and got up to near the top.
It was our summit day.
And I'm kind of a slow climber, so the others
got to the top first.
And when I got to the top, someone
said, what happened to Bruce, who had gotten there first?
And Bruce had walked along here to what was here,
which was snow, but was actually a cornice where
the snow is over a rock face.
And the cornice broke, and he fell to his death.
And Bruce was the country's leading young rock climber.
He had pioneered the hardest routes in Yosemite
without using pitons.
And it was just unbelievable that he
died on this easy but high mountain in India.
So when that happened, I got very depressed.
At the time, I was a postdoc at Stanford
studying how proteins fold.
And that seemed really irrelevant.
And I wanted to do something for the environment
in Bruce's memory.
And so I went to a professor of mine
at Berkeley, [INAUDIBLE] Committee, Bruce Aimes,
and said, is there anything I can do to help the environment?
And he said, well, why don't you look at the flame retardants
in children's sleepwear?
He said, right now, pretty much all the kids in America
are wearing pajamas that are 10% by weight a flame retardant
called brominated tris.
And I think it might get from the pajamas into the children,
and it's a cancer-causing chemical, I think.
And so that seemed a little weird to me, flame retardants.
But I was depressed, so I thought I want to do something.
So I found a little girl who had never
worn tris-treated pajamas.
And we put her in the pajamas and collected her urine.
And the first morning she wore them,
she had tris products in her urine.
And she wore them for three days.
The level of tris in her urine went up,
and she stopped wearing them, and it went down.
So it meant the tris was getting into the little girl.
And then we ran a screening test to see if tris was a mutagen.
Did it change DNA?
And it was one of the strongest mutagens ever studied.
So this was a huge worry.
And we thought, oh my goodness.
We need to tell the parents of America
that most of the kids in the country
are wearing pajamas that are 10% by weight
this harmful chemical.
So about that time, I got invited to go to this mountain.
Do you know what mountain this is?
Anybody know?
Mount Everest.
It's the highest mountain in the world.
And at that point, no American woman
had ever even had a chance to try to climb Mount Everest.
So I was like, wow, this is such an opportunity.
And I didn't know what to do.
Should I stay and write the paper
about the tris-treated pajamas, or should I
go try to climb Mount Everest?
So I can't help but ask.
How many of you would have stayed and written
the paper about the tris-treated pajamas?
Most of you.
How many of you would have gone to Mount Everest?
Even more.
Well, I did both.
So I did go to Mount Everest.
And when I was climbing in the Khumbu Icefall,
every night, I'd write the paper.
And then up in the great Western Cwm,
we'd put stringing ladders, and making
our way amongst the crevasses, and we'd
get up steep ice faces.
And every night, I'd keep working on the paper
until I reached my high point.
Here I am at about 24 5 on Everest.
And my summit flag, The Mutants, has a Petri dish.
Without tris, there are only two colonies,
because it's a mutagen. And this one you can see.
It's blowing in the wind.
That's the tris Petri dish with many bacterial colonies.
So this was October of 1976.
And we did reach the summit.
We were the second American expedition.
Now people reach the summit all the time.
But the first American expedition was '63,
and we were the second one in '76,
so it was much less [INAUDIBLE].
And we had the whole mountain to ourselves.
Only one expedition on Mount Everest, which is a little bit
different nowadays.
So I finished the paper.
I sent it by mail runner to Kathmandu.
And it was published in Science Magazine a couple months later.
And if you read the subtitle of the paper,
the main flame retardant in children's pajamas is a mutagen
and should not be used.
Now, that's a little bit of an unusual title for a paper.
If any of you-- I'm sure you have--
if you read scientific papers, they
tend to have the same recommendation
at the end, almost invariably.
And what's that recommendation at the end
of all scientific papers?
What is the next step?
More studies.
And it's always more studies.
And it tends not to be something like a chemical should not
be used in kids' pajamas.
And at the Green Science Policy Institute,
our goal is to really help inspire, encourage scientists
to take their research and tell people what needs to be done.
Because scientists are the ones who really know.
They understand the science, and then they
understand what needs to be done.
And we believe that scientists have a responsibility
to share their science in a way that affects change,
particularly if they're working on harmful chemicals.
And it works.
Scientists are very respected.
When they speak up, things happen.
This was January of 1977 where we
called for tris not being used in kid's pajamas.
And April 1977, tris was banned from kid's pajamas,
just like it should be.
And that was a really good thing,
because whole generations of kids only wore it.
It was only used for a couple of years,
which is a very good thing.
So however, when a chemical is banned,
there's a big tendency to replace it
with another chemical that's very similar, because industry
likes to keep processes as similar as possible.
It makes sense.
It was funny.
I remember about six months after the tris ban,
I thought, I wonder what they're using now,
if they're still using tris.
So I remember I rode I rode my bicycle to Penny's, downtown
Berkeley, and I bought 20 pairs of pajamas
in all different sizes.
And the sales lady just gushed at me,
oh, you have such a nice, big family.
And I sort of felt like a super spy with all my pajamas.
And I thought, well, these might make nice shower presents
for my friends.
So I just took a little fabric out
of the inseam of each pajama.
But I actually didn't need to bother, since none of them
would I have wanted to give for presents.
And then I analyzed what was in them.
And not surprisingly, about a third of them
had brominated interest, because it takes time
for the market to turn over.
But then nearly 2/3 of them had a new chemical
which turned out to be chlorinated tris, almost
identical.
And so we went, oh my god.
So we ran more immunogenicity tests,
and chlorinated tris was also a mutagen. It changed DNA.
And we wrote another paper in Science,
and chlorinated tris was removed from pajamas.
However, what we didn't know then
is it continued to be used, for example, in furniture.
And in 2005, when a very bad flame retardant
was banned from use in our furniture,
it was replaced with chlorinated tris,
which was then banned in 2012.
But if any of you have a couch that
was purchased between 2006 and 2012--
anyone have a couch purchased during that time?
Anyway, there's about a 3/4 chance that your couch-- 5%
of the weight of the foam will be chlorinated tris.
So if you have 20 pounds of foam in your couch,
you have about a pound of this chemical in your couch.
Not the best.
But we didn't know it back then.
And back then, I thought it was really time
to give women a chance to climb one of the world's highest
mountains.
So in the '70s, all the world's 8,000-meter peaks--
there are 14 of them.
The highest mountains in the world had been climbed by men,
and no woman had climbed that high.
And I thought, women should have a chance.
We had done pretty well on Everest.
So I got a permit for Annapurna on my way back from Everest,
and I thought, it's the first of the 8,000-meter peaks ever
climbed, among the lowest.
It must be one of the safest and easiest.
But as it turned out, there wasn't so much
research in those days.
So guess which is the most dangerous of all
the 8,000-meter peaks?
Annapurna.
And which has the highest fatality rate
and is considered, perhaps, the most difficult to climb?
Anyway, we didn't know that.
But we found out.
So this is our team.
We had 10 climbers, a couple filmmakers, a base camp
manager.
We're all still friends.
There are copies here afterwards-- I'm
happy to sign copies of "Annapurna" or "Breaking
Trail" for people.
And "Annapurna" has just been reprinted, September 15.
Sierra Club Books had been out of business,
and the book had been out of press for a few years,
so it's just back in press.
And we're all going to be getting
together for an Annapurna book party next month.
And I have to say, when we get together,
it feels like we're back on the glacier
just like it did a long time ago.
So climbing Annapurna was incredibly beautiful.
I'll just share a few of the pictures.
The beauty is extraordinary, but the climbing was really tough.
And there were huge storms.
The reason it's such a dangerous mountain
is very high precipitation.
And these huge snowfalls led to huge avalanches.
So it was a very dangerous place.
Ever since I became a mom, I haven't wanted to go there.
But wonderful climbing.
And we did reach the summit.
We were the first women, the first Americans.
We reached the summit with two Sherpa climbers.
We unfurled our flags, held together with a Save
the Whales pin, and we felt content then
we had achieved our goal.
But we tragically lost two of our team
on a second summit attempt.
So climbing Annapurna is a very, very dangerous thing.
I wrote this book, "Annapurna: A Woman's Place,"
which now, as I said, it's just been reissued this week.
And then I wrote another book, "Breaking Trail,"
trying to understand how my childhood and my life
had led to both my scientific research and my mountain
climbing.
And when I finished "Breaking Trail," it was in 2006.
I had spent 20 years writing "Breaking Trail."
I twas like a personal therapy project.
It was a lot of work trying to understand my family.
And I had just finished the book.
My daughter was starting college.
I thought I'd really would like to go back to doing science.
But I actually stopped being a scientist in 1980
to walk across the whole Himalayan mountain range.
I have a job at UC Berkeley.
I said, I want to take a year off
to walk across the Himalayas.
And they were like, well, you have to decide.
Do you want your chemistry job or the Himalayas?
So I chose the Himalayas in 1980.
And many things intervened.
It was 2006, 26 years later.
And the last sentence of "Breaking Trail"
is the future is like an unbroken snow slope.
I hope I can find a way to break trail to a better world.
But I actually really didn't know what I was going to do,
because we hadn't done science for 26 years.
I thought, well, maybe I can get a job washing
test tubes in a lab.
I thought I must be completely out of date.
But that was nine years ago.
And the last nine years, I have felt every day
like I was climbing Annapurna.
I've been on my life's greatest adventure.
And it's been really similar, because we're
working with a great team of scientists and businesspeople
all over the world.
A bunch of people in Google are on the same team.
Really working together for healthier and safer products.
And it's a real challenge, but a real opportunity.
So I felt incredibly lucky that I could not
do science for 26 years and then come back and be able to really
try to climb this mountain.
And the reason that we're all climbing this mountain
is there is a big problem.
And that is-- I sometimes ask this question.
I bet you'll know the answer.
But what do you think-- do you think
if you have chemicals in your shampoo
or your toothpaste or your chair,
anyone think the government is making sure they're
safe for their your health?
You all know not.
But most people do think that.
I used to think that.
And the government actually can't, because they
don't have the authority.
There's only one law about chemicals
before they go out in the world.
Once they're out in the world, you
have a Clean Air Act, a Clean Water Act,
but you can't really bring them back in.
So the only law before they go out in the world
is called the Toxic Substances Control Act.
It passed in 1976.
62,000 chemicals were grandfathered, like you're OK.
And even a chemical like asbestos that kills 10,000
people a year cannot be controlled by the EPA.
And you might say asbestos, there are asbestos lawsuits.
Asbestos is illegal.
Well, asbestos is not illegal.
There are lawsuits.
And there's a rare form of cancer
called mesothelioma that's only associated
with asbestos exposure.
So if you're an asbestos worker or the spouse of an asbestos
worker and you get mesothelioma, you
can sue the asbestos industry that that's
the reason for your disease.
And you'll probably win the case, but you also will die.
Everybody that gets mesothelioma dies.
And that's not a good way to regulate chemicals.
And that's how we regulate asbestos, through lawsuits.
By then, it's really late.
So the 62,000 chemicals nobody can do anything
about-- there have been 20,000 new industrial chemicals.
No data is required.
Most of them have no health data.
2/3 have no data at all.
The EPA has six weeks to try to show harm with no data.
And if they do show harm, the company
has several years to try to prove their chemical is OK,
and they can sell it during those several years
to raise the money for the testing.
And once they're out there selling it,
it's really hard to stop it.
So basically-- and indeed, I'm going
to speak at the EPA tomorrow.
In fact, if anyone wants to hear my talk,
you can tell them 10 o'clock tomorrow,
I'll be speaking by the post office at the main EPA
building.
So if you ASK the EPA, they say we can't even ban asbestos.
They say that.
It's really a problem.
Another problem-- and in fact, this
leads to what two brilliant pediatricians, Herb Needleman
and Phil Landrigan, said-- that we are de facto conducting
a human toxicological trial.
Our children and our children's children
are the experimental subjects.
So if these chemicals aren't tested in any other way,
they're tested on us.
And that's not a good thing to do.
And they do contribute to increased rates
of cancer, infertility, neurological impairments.
So another problem is what we call
the regrettable substitution problem.
If after a lot of work, a chemical is regulated,
the substitute is often the chemical cousin.
For example, over here, we have-- if you know chemistry,
we've got decabromo, 10 bromines, diphenly,
two phenyl rings.
Decabrominated diphenyl ether, that's
an ether bond with the oxygen in the middle.
And it's persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic.
And about 15% of the weight to the plastic in an average TV
is decabromodiphenyl ether.
It's used in fabric back coatings, many uses.
Due to its severe persistence, bioaccumulation and toxicity,
the deca ether has been phased out.
But what's the substitute?
Decabrominated diphenyl ethane.
So there's an ethane bond instead of an ether.
It's also persistent, bioaccumulative,
and appears to be toxic.
So as the deca ether sales go down,
the deca ethane sales go up.
Is that a good deal?
Not much improvement.
So it's a discouraging situation.
However-- everyone is looking depressed but me, right?
Because I think there are things that can be done.
And to solve this problem, we decided
to bring together scientists who cared passionately about this
to really focus on what could be done.
And so we have had a series of retreats
where we invite five scientists from industry,
five from academia, five from NGOs, and five from government.
So it's about 20 scientists, maybe 25.
And at the first retreat, we said, are there
certain chemicals, certain chemical families,
that we know are harmful that can be avoided?
A simpler way of thinking of this.
When you think of that 80,000 chemicals,
it sounds kind of daunting.
All you can do is put your head down and get poison.
Because who can deal with 80,000 chemicals?
So we came up with six classes.
And this is a solution that really invites action.
And so briefly, the classes are highly fluorinated chemicals.
These are stain and water repellents, like Scotchguard.
Let me just ask-- how many of you knew or know--
and by the way, there's a handout
at the back when you leave that lists all the classes and more
information about them.
But let me see.
How many of you know that Scotchguard is
a problem in these chemicals?
OK.
One person who works in this area.
But when people know, they can make better choices.
The next class is the chlorinated antimicrobials,
like triclosan and triclocarban approach ban liquids soaps.
Who knew about them?
A couple people.
Then we have the flame retardants.
Who's heard about the flame retardants?
OK.
You've all heard about the flame retardants.
We have bisphenols.
Remember those bisphenol A water bottles?
Phthalates, organic solvents, certain metals.
And you look at this list-- this is
most of the harmful chemicals
…