YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,170 lines · added Nov 2, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

MALE SPEAKER: And good morning.
Welcome to Talks at Google in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Today it's my great privilege and pleasure
to introduce Sherry Turkle.
Dr. Turkle is Professor of the Social Studies of Science
and Technology at MIT.
She's a sociologist and clinical psychologist,
a leading media scholar who spent the last three
decades studying our relationship
with the digital culture we've created.
Her classic studies in the field are "The Second Self,"
"Life on the Screen," and "Alone Together."
She joins us today to discuss her latest
book, "Reclaiming Conversation-- The Power of Talk
in a Digital Age."
Emphasis here on the power.
I found this book an eloquent, profound, and often moving
examination of the consequences of our addiction
to our devices for ourselves and our families,
and how conversation, which we may dimly
recall as an interaction between two
or more humans, in which no devices are involved, can help.
Please join me in welcoming Sherry Turkle.
[APPLAUSE]
SHERRY TURKLE: Well, that was a lovely introduction.
And what was loveliest about it is
that I think it touches on the fact
that this really is a book of my heart.
The other books I've written-- and I'm
dedicated to all of them-- all books are like your children--
basically came out of my doing-- sponsored
by the NSF or other funders-- 10, 15 years
of work-- 5, 10, 15 years of work,
and then reporting out on what I had found.
And this book began in a somewhat different way.
At the end of "Alone Together," which
was a book about a kind of new social situation
that people found themselves in-- we'd all be here,
so we were together in a social situation of some sort.
But we often found ourselves feeling
that we could find a sort of place
alone in our heads in a new kind of way
because we could go to our phones
and be in a different kind of space.
Or flip it.
We would be alone in our apartment
or in a park or wherever, but we would feel ourselves
more together with the world, with our communities--
a new kind of global together that
was absolutely unprecedented.
So the topic of that book really was
what was the psychology, what were
the new political dynamics, what was
the feeling of that new state.
At the end of that book, as I listened to the transcripts
and gone over the hundreds and hundreds of transcripts,
particularly from young people but not just from young people,
one phrase kept coming up-- something
that I really hadn't had a chance to explore
in that book, which was, I'd rather text than talk.
As part of the situation of people who now have the devices
that enable this alone-together state, these new, always-on,
always-on-you technologies that enable this new thing I was
studying--
And I'm a psychologist, and I'm psychodynamically trained,
which means that I'm interested in interpersonal dynamics,
the importance of early childhood,
the importance of communication and connection
in early childhood, the importance of empathy
and its development in early childhood.
And I thought to myself, OK, let's take seriously--
instead of taking this as a litany or a catchphrase,
let's really take seriously-- if people tell me
they'd rather text than talk-- if they're really doing that,
let me explore this like an ethnographer.
Let me follow this story in business, in romance,
in the raising of children, and how people are getting along
in their communities and with their colleagues,
with their lovers, with their families,
with their friends-- let me follow this story
and what will that mean in all of these areas of life.
And so that's how I'm trained.
I'm trained to be an ethnographer.
And essentially, that's what "Reclaiming Conversation" is.
It's a look at, for me, a much broader sweep of data,
because I did go into law firms and doctors' offices--
the kinds of doctors' offices where, literally,
doctors are looking at screens instead of talking to patients
because they're forced to, to law firms where people felt it
was more important to stay at their screens than go to lunch
with their colleagues.
Big mistake if you're a lawyer and want to get promoted.
Big mistake in terms of the culture of those firms,
but yet, that's how they felt about it.
Software companies, where people had
the right kind of cafeterias and micro-kitchens
to sit down and have a conversation,
except the highest value of the company
was that they'd be always on the messaging system
in order to show their devotion.
So I went to all kinds of places,
as I say, a much broader sweep of the world,
and I studied this issue of conversation.
So what did I find?
Well, maybe it makes sense to say
what I found by starting with a story, which is not
a feel-good story for me.
At the end of-- the book was published
and I was just waiting for it to come out.
Before it comes out, a "New York Times" reporter calls me.
My publisher hadn't wanted me talking
much before the book comes out.
It's such an event.
And "The New York Times" reporter calls me,
and he wants me to-- now I'm finally
allowed to talk about the book-- he
wants me to comment on a story he's
writing about Hello Barbie.
So Hello Barbie is a robot doll that comes out of the box
and says, "Hello, I'm Barbie.
I think I love you.
I have a sister.
I don't like her so much.
I think I'm jealous of her.
I hear you have a sister.
Are you jealous of your sister?
Let's talk?"
In other words, it comes out of the box
with a pretend-empathy narrative and starts
to try to engage you in conversation
about this pretend-empathy narrative,
with the idea that that will be--
this just pretend best-friend thing that
will be conversation.
So my position on this-- everything
I know about kids growing up and from studying
sociable robotics and how kids respond to it--
is that you can get a kid to talk to a robot that
offers pretend empathy.
But you can't get a child to learn and experience empathy
from a robot that has none to give,
because this robot hasn't known a life,
it doesn't have a sister, it doesn't know what jealousy is.
In other words, this conversation
is not going to do the job that conversation needs to do.
So it turns out-- after studying law offices and business
offices and families-- now there is
another part of the story, in fact, too, which, in fact,
I do end the book on the issue of robotics.
But Hello Barbie wasn't on the market.
I would have ended the book with Hello Barbie if it had been.
It turns out that sociable robotics is also
part of this story of a crisis of conversation, because we're
offering ourselves and our children objects that
are a faux conversation.
So just to give you some sense of all the ways
we can't learn empathy now in our culture,
and yet, there's an empathy crisis.
And I'm going to argue-- just to give the argument that
I'm going to make today and that I make in "Reclaiming
Conversation"-- that to this empathy crisis,
conversation is the remedy.
And, to make a bad pun, I call it the talking cure.
And that, in fact, is where the book
began-- with a 40% drop in all markers for empathy
among college students.
It was a meta-analysis that looked at many surveys--
many studies-- over the past 20 years.
There's this 40% drop among college students
in many markers for empathy-- most of it
in the past 10 years.
And in our conversation-- because I'm
going to talk about half my time--
it's telling that the very brilliant woman who
was the head of this study, after learning this,
decided to write empathy apps for the iPhone.
So the whole question of-- let us
grant that part of the way we got ourselves into some trouble
with empathy, which is born from looking at someone in the eye,
not breaking that contact, hearing what they have to say,
they're hearing back what you have to say,
taking some time-- let us grant that interrupting that,
by going like this, is part of the problem.
To what degree do we want to solve it with this technology
that we have always on hand?
How much are we going to look to technology
to solve the problem that, perhaps, technology
got us into?
It obviously is very seductive to do that.
But is that a good idea?
So I found out that I began to get more evidence
about the empathy crisis when I was called in
to consult in middle schools for much younger
students than college students.
And in one school in particular-- in the book,
I call it the Holbrook School-- the teachers were saying
that the students, about 12-year-old students,
were behaving like eight-year-old students.
They were showing a kind of cruelty
to their fellow students-- not on the Internet,
not in cyberbullying situations.
But really, the teachers were saying
they didn't seem to understand how other students were feeling
when other students were talking to them.
They essentially were describing a crisis of empathy.
And they didn't seem to get it when
their teachers spoke to them.
They said 12-year-old students behaved
like eight-year-old students.
So it was a very dramatic study for me--
all these places where I was finding teachers and educators
of-- did a large study of teachers
and all kinds of educators in that age
range, who were all talking about kind of the same thing.
But then there were a group of studies
that were truly optimistic and that I want to share with you.
In only five days without phones in a summer camp that's
device-free, young people get those empathy
markers to come right back up.
In other words, we are built to have an empathic response
to each other.
Now how do they get those empathy markers
to come back up?
They talk to each other.
They talk to each other without turning away from each other
to look for a device.
So getting back to the Barbie, and getting back to the fact
that most kids have phones when they're five or six or seven,
why would we give kids-- just at the time
when they're developing that empathic response,
why would we want to give children
an object that will block the development of empathy?
And phones do block the development of empathy,
not because we meant them to.
It's not because we said, oh, we're
going to just invent something that's really going
to get in the way of empathy.
It's just because, when you go like that to a person,
you're putting them on pause and you're
saying that you can't attend to what
they're thinking or feeling.
Now the more developed and older the person is,
the less-- let's say-- damage it's going to do.
But a series of studies show that if you are sitting
at a table and you put a phone, a silent phone,
on the table between you, first of all,
the conversation will go to trivial matters.
The topic of the conversation will change.
It will not be about important things.
And secondly, you will feel less empathic connection
with the person you're talking to.
And then they re-did this study in a natural setting,
where they put the phone, not between two people having
lunch, but in the periphery of the landscape-- like if you
put the phone almost where I couldn't see it
at the edge of the stage, and had me talking
to somebody at lunch, but the phone's
almost like at the next table.
And they got the same results-- conversation
on things less important, and less sense of commitment
and connection, less empathic sense with the person
you're talking with.
Essentially, it makes every kind of sense
that if people think they're going to be interrupted,
their attitude toward a conversation changes.
It's really as simple as that.
And college students know that.
They know that they don't pay attention to each other
when they have their phones.
And they talked to me about something
they called the rule of threes, as a lot of my own research
took place on college campuses.
So one young man says to me, introducing the Rule of Three--
because at the beginning, I had been
thinking of doing a study on the nature of texting,
on the diction of texting, really
getting deeply into the linguistics of texting.
And he said, don't do that.
It's not our texting, he says, that's getting us into trouble.
It's what our texting is doing to our in-person conversations.
And that really was my lodestar for this study.
It's not our texting that's getting us into trouble,
he said, it's what our texting is doing
to our in-person conversations.
And I said, well, tell me more.
And to illustrate this, I get the story
about the Rule of Three.
And here's the Rule of Three.
When you're at dinner-- let's say
it's six-- three people have to have their heads up
before you give yourself permission
to put your head down to text, because everybody
has their phone and everybody's going to be texting at dinner.
So the Rule of Three is a kind of new politeness
about when you can let your attention go down.
So what is the result of the Rule of Three?
It's exactly the result of all those studies
that took place with the silent phone on the table,
that that changed the nature of discussion
and gave people less than empathic connection
with each other.
Things are kept light and on subjects
where you don't mind being interrupted,
and people feel less of an empathic connection
with each other.
And it's not just among college students.
I should mention a recent Pew study showed that 89% of adults
say that, in their last social interaction,
they took out a phone.
And 82% say that it diminished the conversation.
Now that study goes on to be very realistic and very
positive and very upbeat about all the great things people did
when they took out their phone.
They looked up a movie, they looked up a cinematographer,
they checked a thing in their neighborhood.
The phone is completely integrated in their life.
But, bottom line, 89% interrupted
a social interaction; 82% say it lessened the conversation.
Rule of Three.
And then there's the Rule of Seven.
The Rule of Seven is what a college junior
described as this.
It takes seven minutes to know where a conversation is going
to go, just like it probably takes seven minutes
to know whether you're going to pay close attention to this.
You have to get used to somebody's body in the room,
the way somebody speaks, the kind of cadence,
how they express themselves.
But certainly in a conversation, where
you're adjusting to each other, there are fits
and there are starts and there are lulls,
it takes seven minutes to see whether this
is going to be worth her time, she explains to me.
And then she says, I often don't put in my seven minutes,
because I just would rather go to the phone
and get the reliability of that steady feed.
It's easier to just send a text during those seven minutes.
It's easier to get something sure and certain,
and it's more efficient.
And a lot of people I interviewed
said that-- they don't put in that kind of time
or wait for that kind of lull, or allow themselves
a moment of boredom in conversations today.
Before that happens, they go to a phone.
So you can see a kind of perfect storm building up here.
All roads led me to a crisis in a certain kind of conversation.
It's not like we're not talking.
I'm talking about the kind of conversation that's
spontaneous, open ended, where there are tangents,
where you allow yourself lulls, where
you don't interrupt each other, where there's eye
contact-- the kind of thing where empathy is born,
where creativity is most likely to happen.
And a crisis in empathy is happening,
and I'm arguing that conversation is the talking
cure.
Conversation-- that kind of conversation--
is the most human and humanizing thing that we know how to do,
that doesn't take away in the slightest
from the fun and the intellectual qualities
and the sexiness and the eroticism
and the joy of texting, and e-mail, and messaging,
and everything, just everything.
It just means that conversation has some particularities,
even in our neurophysiology, that
makes it the ideal thing for teaching empathy
and for getting certain kinds of results
in creativity, collaboration, and developing the human.
It's the training ground for empathy.
And I'm not saying to put away your phones
for a certain amount of time because it's polite,
or because I want you to learn some kind of art
of conversation, to be kind of fancy talkers.
I'm really saying that this flight from conversation,
the fact that we don't want to sit around
the boring bits-- as one woman said to me,
I don't like the boring bits-- is actually
interfering with something we need to do
for each other as human beings.
There are great ironies, as I said.
Even though the psychologists are
agreeing on this crisis in empathy,
there's this big movement to create these empathy apps--
getting ourselves into trouble and wanting technology
to cure it, just as people are intolerant of being alone
and want technology to cure that.
Many of you may have heard of a study that's
become widely cited, in which a group of college
students-- this was part of a group of 21 studies--
but one study at the University of Virginia,
a group of college students were told that they would be asked
to sit alone from six to 15 minutes
and were they OK with that.
Sure.
No devices, no books.
Sure.
Did they think they might want to give themselves
electroshocks during that period.
No, not really.
No.
They were asked to test the shocking out.
They tested it.
No, really not.
And then they were just asked to sit alone without a device.
After six minutes, the students were shocking themselves.
[CHUCKLING]
So being alone was so intolerable
that they would rather give themselves electroshocks
than sit quietly with their own thoughts.
Being alone is a problem that we want technology to solve.
And I bring this up because there is actually
an important connection that I want to leave you with.
If you leave with one thing, it's
like-- this is the thing to leave
with-- this important connection between conversation
and solitude, because I think this is where
my work is often misunderstood.
They'll say, well, sure, Sherry Turkle
says the problem is we're looking at our devices
when we're together.
OK, grant her that.
That's not so cool.
But what about if I look at my device when I'm alone?
Who's that bothering?
That's not a problem for anybody.
You need to have a capacity for solitude
in order to have a capacity for sociality.
The link between conversation and solitude is tremendous.
We cannot solve our flight from conversation,
our crisis of empathy, without dealing with our incapacity
for solitude, with our flight from solitude.
That it's only when you can gather yourself, be content
with yourself, and, because of that, talk to another person
and really see who they are as a person,
and hear them for who they are because you're
OK with yourself, can you begin to have a conversation.
The way psychologists have put this
so beautifully is that, if you don't teach your children to be
alone, they'll only know how to be lonely-- that solitude
and sociality go together.
And that's why you can't just say, oh, well,
the devices-- I'll worry about the devices
when I'm with other people.
But whatever I do by myself, my intolerance for having a moment
alone, that's nothing.
We have to be more intentional in our use of devices
for ourselves, not just because we're breaking up conversations
with other people.
So what I'm basically saying is that we're
at a kind of Rachel Carson moment--
distracted at our dinner tables and living rooms,
at business meetings and in classrooms.
I see traces of the new Silent Spring--
that's the term that Carson coined--
when we were ready to see that with technological change
had come an assault on our environment.
And now we've arrived at another moment of recognition.
When I wrote "Alone Together," people
thought it was a good book, but people wanted to fight with me.
It was like, OK, this is a really good book.
Let's fight about this.
And now I really feel that we've arrived
at a moment of recognition when people
feel that something is amiss.
Something is amiss.
We have a great technology, but something is amiss.
We need to get it more aligned with the lives
we want to leave.
This time, technology is implicated
in an assault on empa
…

Need subtitles from another video?