Advertisement
English transcript
If God is the First Cause, the Originator, the Creator, and we are thoughts or extensions
of God, how could a split occur? Because if we...before we become what we think of as
separated beings from God, we had to have been the thought of God, and if our separation
is a tiny, mad idea, doesn't that imply that God is the One that had the tiny, mad idea?
We're complying a book, actually right now, on those frequently asked questions in the
Course. Oh wonderful. And what you just asked is the...without question...the most frequently
asked question. Of course. So congratulations; you have a lot of company. Well one who doesn't
like to be ordinary, I don't know that I like that. Okay, basically, I think, to reframe
the question, it really is if God is perfect, how could there be an imperfect thought? How
could He have an imperfect thought? Or, if God is perfect unity and perfect Oneness and
Wholeness, how could there be thought of separation? And the Course does address that question
in two places. Neither response will really satisfy you intellectually because it doesn't
have an intellectual answer. The first response to it comes at the beginning, somewhere in
the middle of Chapter 4 in the text where Jesus raises the question, "You may wonder
how this could have happened in the past?" And his answer to the question is, "Why would
you wonder about how something happened in the past when you're still choosing to be
separated in the present?" So basically it's a very, very practical answer to the question.
In the clarification of terms, which basically is an appendix to the teacher's manual, he
also raises this question, and he says that the ego may ask many questions that this course
doesn't answer. It may ask, for example, how could the impossible have happened? Or to
what did the impossible occur? And he says basically there, and then a couple of pages
later he addresses it again, and his response to that question is saying that it really
is not a question. It's a statement that's masquerading in question form, and it's a
statement that says that "I believe the separation happened, I believe that I'm really here,
that this is reality, and now I want you to explain to me how it could have happened?"
And once you start to answer that question you're tacitly agreeing with the statement,
because why would you answer a question unless you believed in the basic premise of the question?
In that sense it always struck us as it's similar to the old comedian's question: "When
did you stop beating your wife?" That there's no way you could answer that without incriminating
yourself. True. And so while the answer doesn't...or the question doesn't have a satisfactory,
intellectual answer, the answer is that you should seek the experience of God's Love,
and when you have the experience of God's Love you won't ask the question anymore. Okay
of God, how could a split occur? Because if we...before we become what we think of as
separated beings from God, we had to have been the thought of God, and if our separation
is a tiny, mad idea, doesn't that imply that God is the One that had the tiny, mad idea?
We're complying a book, actually right now, on those frequently asked questions in the
Course. Oh wonderful. And what you just asked is the...without question...the most frequently
asked question. Of course. So congratulations; you have a lot of company. Well one who doesn't
like to be ordinary, I don't know that I like that. Okay, basically, I think, to reframe
the question, it really is if God is perfect, how could there be an imperfect thought? How
could He have an imperfect thought? Or, if God is perfect unity and perfect Oneness and
Wholeness, how could there be thought of separation? And the Course does address that question
in two places. Neither response will really satisfy you intellectually because it doesn't
have an intellectual answer. The first response to it comes at the beginning, somewhere in
the middle of Chapter 4 in the text where Jesus raises the question, "You may wonder
how this could have happened in the past?" And his answer to the question is, "Why would
you wonder about how something happened in the past when you're still choosing to be
separated in the present?" So basically it's a very, very practical answer to the question.
In the clarification of terms, which basically is an appendix to the teacher's manual, he
also raises this question, and he says that the ego may ask many questions that this course
doesn't answer. It may ask, for example, how could the impossible have happened? Or to
what did the impossible occur? And he says basically there, and then a couple of pages
later he addresses it again, and his response to that question is saying that it really
is not a question. It's a statement that's masquerading in question form, and it's a
statement that says that "I believe the separation happened, I believe that I'm really here,
that this is reality, and now I want you to explain to me how it could have happened?"
And once you start to answer that question you're tacitly agreeing with the statement,
because why would you answer a question unless you believed in the basic premise of the question?
In that sense it always struck us as it's similar to the old comedian's question: "When
did you stop beating your wife?" That there's no way you could answer that without incriminating
yourself. True. And so while the answer doesn't...or the question doesn't have a satisfactory,
intellectual answer, the answer is that you should seek the experience of God's Love,
and when you have the experience of God's Love you won't ask the question anymore. Okay