Advertisement
English transcript
MING: Well, good afternoon, my friends.
My name is Ming.
I'm the Jolly Good Fellow of Google for one more
week, because next week I'm retiring from Google.
And this is the very last guest I am hosting at Google,
and very fittingly, it is Professor Bob Thurman.
Bob is a wonderful human being.
Behind his back, we call him Buddha Bob.
He's sort of like-- I think he should
be more like Bob the Buddha, sort of like Bob the Builder,
except with better karma.
Bob the Buddha is considered the leading American expert
on Tibetan Buddhism.
In 1962, Bob became the first American
to wear the robes of a Tibetan Buddhist monk
outside of Halloween.
Eventually, he left his job, and he became a professor
at American University, and right now, he
is a Jey Tsong Khapa professor of Indo-Tibetan Buddhist
studies at Columbia University.
He's also the president of the Tibet House, which
he founded with this guy called Richard Gere, which you may
or may have heard of, and also Philip Glass, which you
may or may not have heard of.
He's also the president of the American
Institute of Buddhist Studies.
He was see considered one of 25 most influential Americans
in the 1997.
And in 1998, he didn't do anything after that.
He has been profiled in "The New York Times," in "People"
magazine, in "Time," he has appeared on CNN, "The News
Hour," Larry King, Oprah.
He is close personal friends with the Dalai Lama.
He knows all the dirt, so ask him later.
He's also the father of Uma Thurman,
so he knows the dirt as well.
Ask him too.
His hobbies are carpentry, landscaping, and saving
the world.
He's here to talk about his latest book,
"Love Your Enemies."
So now that I have this book, all I need is enemies.
My friends, please welcome our dear friend, Bob Thurman.
[APPLAUSE]
ROBERT THURMAN: Thank you so much.
Thank you, Ming.
So sweet.
That was very sweet.
I really enjoy your introducing me more than talking.
I'm sure.
And just I'm doing this, or my wife will be mad at me if I
don't.
So great.
So hi, everybody.
I was asked to talk about ethics,
and I just made a slide.
I do have a lot of PowerPoint, but for some reason,
I didn't feel like doing PowerPoint.
So you probably get PowerPoints all the time
on engineering problems and God knows what down here,
so I didn't think I would do that while I was here.
But then I decided I would make this one slide.
And my talk takes off from a book
that His Holiness the Dalai Lama wrote
called "Beyond Religion-- Ethics for a Whole World."
Have any of you ever seen that book or read it?
Ming has, I'm sure, and a few people have.
And what he does there is because His Holiness has always
been trying to improve understanding
between different kinds of groups of people who identify
themselves as different from each other,
and his main job there, one of his three main jobs in life,
as he puts it, is to improve the mutual understanding
of the world religions, because there's been so much conflict
in history between them.
But one thing that he does when he has meetings, world
religious meetings, he always a little bit
flummoxes the other world religious leaders
by saying that there's another world religion which
is secularism, which are nonbelievers, as he puts it.
And he used to say-- I don't know the statistical basis
of him saying that.
I never did ask him.
He used to say, if there are 4 billion people who believe
in some religion or another, there are at least 1 billion
or 1 and 1/2 billion who don't.
That was a previous earlier count, I guess.
Now we're up to seven.
So I don't know how he does it just now.
And they do have a belief, and they have a belief
of what lies beyond death.
They have a belief, and actually I
think I can prove to anyone who wants to debate it that that is
a faith belief actually, rather than an evidenced belief, which
we can discuss.
And so in that book, which he originally
wanted to title "Secular Ethics," he wanted
to show that there is a reason and a motive for human beings
to be ethical, because it fulfills
the aim of human beings, which finally, of course,
like all animals, the aim of any animal is to avoid pain
and to achieve happiness.
Avoid suffering and achieve happiness.
That's sort of the basic goal of everyone.
Whatever other goals they may set themselves,
no one wants to suffer.
No one wants pain.
Everyone wants pleasure and/or happiness,
depending on how they define them.
And then there's mental levels of pain
and physical levels of pain.
And so he wrote that book, and in the book,
basically, he used sort of anthropological insights,
pretty much, and some biological, a little bit
of biological thinking of secularists
or scientific materialists to prove
that the human being as a mammal, as a being that when
it's young is helpless for many years, at least a decade,
at least till the teenage time, at which point
the human being thinks they're independent.
But the parents don't.
The parents think they need help right up until they're
parents themselves pretty much, and sometimes even after that.
Grandparents get sucked in on babysitting and what have you.
And I can attest to that.
And so because of that, human beings
do depend on the kindness of strangers, not only Mae West,
but everybody.
After all, the mammal conceives a new life,
the more intelligent half of the mammals, that is-- the females.
They allow a total stranger to come
and have a condo in their belly, which is quite a thing.
I think if guys think about it, I think you'd be hesitant.
I would.
I don't know about you, but suddenly, there's something
down there, and it wants a different kind of food,
and it wants this and that, and it kicks after awhile.
And then it's a real pain more than
in the neck to get it outside of yourself.
And so that's all a bunch of altruistic activity
of the females, and the males have to carry along.
They have to end up helping, so mammals' basic nature
is what he's trying to say.
Buddhists don't like the idea of anything
having an absolute nature.
They have a wonderful hermeneutic principle
in Buddhist thought, in Buddhist science, I should say,
because in Buddhism, philosophy and science are not
necessarily separated so dramatically as it has
become in the West nowadays.
But in Buddhist science, there is a rule, a hermeneutic
or a rule of interpretation.
And that is that there is only one kind of teaching that
is considered definitive in meaning,
and that kind is the pure negation of something of self,
the negation of substance, the negation
of any sort of a relative absolute, you could say.
It's almost simplistic and so simple, actually.
The famous concept of emptiness--
we've all heard of it-- selflessness--
these are famous concepts.
And what these mean, they don't mean that things don't exist.
Emptiness is not nothingness.
Completely different word in any of the Buddhist languages.
And what emptiness means is that all relative things are
empty of any non-relative element
or what they would call intrinsic reality,
intrinsic identity, any sort of thing like that,
which is really almost like it's a definition of the words.
It's almost a tautological.
If something's absolute, you can't relate, because absolute
is the opposite of relative.
And so if anybody comes up with some sort of an absolute
and says it relates as some monotheistic teachings do,
as some versions of Buddhism do, then they
are simply misusing language, to use a Wittgensteinian
expression.
And so His Holiness, therefore, is very like a scientist,
and great Buddhist philosophers are
like scientists in that all teachings
about relative reality are relative.
That is to say more or less valid within a context.
There is no absolute truth about relative things,
if you follow me, except that none of them are absolute.
That's the only one.
That's really a logical thing.
But why is that it?
So it seems so simple like why is that a big thing?
The reason it's a big thing is that the human bad habit,
cognitive habit, emotional habit, instinctual habit that
causes all suffering for human beings in Buddha's
psychological and philosophical analysis
is the feeling that we habitually have
that we are absolute.
The person has a feeling, the unenlightened person
has a feeling that the one thing they are sure of-- for example,
Descartes perfectly well illustrates-- stop vibrating--
perfectly illustrated that when he decided
that the one thing he was absolutely sure of
was that he was worrying about what was absolute.
In other words, he was thinking.
That's the famous thing.
He didn't need Buddhism for that.
And everyone subconsciously or subliminally or instinctively
feels something about themself is absolute, and therefore,
when pressed in a corner of a life and death
thing, like my life is the one absolute for me
type of thing people feel that, which, of course,
from Buddha's point of view is erroneous.
His teaching of selflessness means that that's an error.
That doesn't mean that I don't exist.
It means that I am a relational being, not an absolute being.
That means that other beings are equally as real and as
important as I am, and that little shift of not being
the absolute center of it all yourself,
of coming to this viscerally understand
that, first intellectually and philosophically understand
that, and then viscerally understand it--
that's the whole campaign of Buddhist teaching.
Because once you do really understand--
like I had an old Mongolian guru who
had a couple of great sayings-- passed away a long time ago,
but one of his great sayings was,
everyone goes around-- this was three or four
decades before "The Matrix."
He said, everyone goes around secretly thinking, I'm the one.
Therefore, I nearly fainted when they started on
that in "The Matrix," going to see the oracle, who's the one,
you know.
So everybody secretly thinks, I'm the one.
And then the second one is, people are not
wrong to say that they are real.
The problem is people think they're really real.
So all it is.
A lot of people misunderstand Buddhism and think
that the big insight is that you don't exist,
and then you're free, and everything is cool.
And actually, there are certain modern Buddhists
who think that scientific materialism ratifies that
by discovering that you're just a brain
bouncing around inside a skull box
and running around until the brain gets tired,
and you have a stroke or collapse or something,
and then you don't exist anymore.
So in a way, essentially, you don't exist.
You're just a robot that is deluded
into thinking you exist, as long as your heart is pumping,
and your brain is registering and convincing you
that you're there, but you're not really there,
because if you just squash your brain,
you simply cease to exist.
So that's what Buddha was saying in selflessness and emptiness,
and even some translators used to translate emptiness
as nothingness, which is just completely very
bad, because Buddha is very clear that emptiness
as a sort of ultimate cosmological principle
or something like that is a middle way, a central way
between nihilism, nothingness, and absolutism,
making some sort of absolute out of something.
Emptiness is therefore really what it truly is is relativism,
and Buddha really is the discovery of relativity.
And therefore, ethics was a central thing for Buddhism,
because ethics operates on all levels-- physical, not
just physical, not just verbal, but also mental.
Well, Jimmy Carter knew that.
Remember, Jimmy-- most of you are too young.
Somebody remember Jimmy Carter wrote in "Esquire" magazine
how he sinned in his mind.
He lusted after some young thing or something.
And I don't know how Rosalynn took that,
but the Buddhists say you can do that in your mind.
In other words, you can commit a negative ethical act just
with your mind, even if you don't act on it.
And that's one of the reasons Buddhists
are so much into searching inside themselves.
I have to say it with the right emphasis in this room.
So it's a very big deal.
Ethics is a very big deal.
Now the problem-- so then His Holiness does that in his book
by talking about what human life is like and the fact
that we do love-- are happy when we love someone,
not only when we're loved, but also when we do love,
we become very, very happy.
You know, Gene Kelly dancing in the rain, what have you.
And he has two pillars, he said, of his secular ethics.
And one of them is human nature, the nature
of the human as a social animal, which
he takes from a certain side in anthropology,
although he cites many studies.
There are more and more studies that-- actually,
in the famous argument between Ashley Montagu and Konrad
Lorenz historically in the history of anthropology,
there are many more things supporting Ashley Montagu
that humans are really basically gentle.
They're basically kind.
But they can become vicious, worse than any animal,
because the nature of the human being
is so completely programmable, deprogrammable, reprogrammable,
which is why education is so critically important.
Anyway, basically among animals, the human is a more gentle one.
We don't have claws.
We don't have fangs.
We don't have armored skin.
We're soft-skinned and so forth.
And the young take existence inside the bodies
of the female, which is more of a connection
to the next generation than if you just
drop an egg somewhere in the riverbank or by the ocean
and wait for the little turtle to crawl out.
There's a little less parenting involved
when you do it with eggs.
So he uses that.
And then the second one is the relationality of everything
and that everyone is very interrelated
and that people are never happier
than when they do something successfully for someone else,
and they feel really good about that like seeing that person
smile, seeing that child happy.
They really do, and then that leads
to his slogan about compassion that he does,
where he says that if you want someone else to be happy,
be compassionate to them.
And he says if you want to be happy, be
compassionate to someone else, which
is his favorite slogan coming from the tradition
of Shantideva, a great, great Indian philosopher and sage
and yogi call Shantideva, who wrote a great book called
"Way of the Bodhisattva" that I recommend to everyone.
It's one of the great world classics of spirituality,
actually, in which he makes the argument very, very thoroughly
that our nature is such that when
we do something for someone else that succeeds,
it is its own reward.
And they may even make the very clever psychological argument
that when you focus on doing things for others, then
actually, you temporarily forget about what you need yourself.
You tend to.
And then that's a key to happiness,
because the one certain way to be unhappy
is to think, how happy am I?
That's an immediate killer.
The minute you think, how good is it?
What am I getting out of here?
What's going on?
It's like, oh, no, it's not that good.
Whatever marvelous experience it is
when you turn to evaluate it, you're never satisfied.
The Rolling Stones have a song like that, right?
Ain't no satisfaction.
So that's His Holiness's thing on secularism,
which is a beautiful book, and it
has trainings in the back, which is another novel
concept to Western psychologists, which
is that you can train yourself to be
more compassionate and more loving,
that it isn't that a person is just loving.
Of course, there's a set point that Buddhists
would agree from one's upbringing
if one is traumatically brought up,
it's maybe difficult to feel it's natural to be nice
and to be loving if you've been guarding and defending yourself
against abuse as a child.
But basically, whatever level of lovingness one
is or has as a person can be much more highly developed.
And the negative side, the opposite of loving-- hating,
despising, et cetera-- can be diminished by training.
And that's very important.
Should be a part of everyone's education.
It actually is the final purpose of the Search Inside Yourself
strategy, because once you search in there,
you find the negative reflexes and mechanisms that
have caused you trouble in life, or you lost friends
where you annoyed and offended people, where
this and that happened, where you were dissatisfied also
yourself, and then you can deconstruct,
and you can disempower those negative mental habits,
and you can reinforce and empower the positive ones
to a huge degree.
And Buddhists would not agree with those modern psychologists
who keep insisting and write all best-seller books
about how helpless you are, that your unconscious is doing
everything, and you really can't really-- what you
think is a free choice is not.
And Buddhists don't agree.
They do agree that a very unenlightened person is
pretty much robotic in their reactivity and their reaction
patterns, but the whole path of Buddhism
is to become conscious of your unconscious actually
and to reshape it.
It's like the Hercules myth of cleaning the Augean stables
is very perfect for the Buddhist enterprise,
because the human being in Buddha's analysis,
the reason it is such a valuable life form,
and that every one of you has what
they call in Buddhism the precious jewel
of a life endowed with liberty and opportunity.
And the liberty has to do with the fact
that you are free of many kinds of defects.
You're not born in a species that
has no language, that has no culture, that can't share
the mind of others because of having speech
and so forth, literature, in our case,
and memory, and a certain type of self-reflexiveness
is not available to lower animal forms in the human animal form.
And some humans, of course, are less than others.
And so they're not all the same.
So the liberties are like that, and the opportunities
are where you can educate yourself,
because if a human being, if a saint, or a near saint--
actually, in Buddha's view, a complete saint can never
become a murderer, a perfect saint,
but there are degrees of really niceness and sainthood that
could become very evil by different circumstances
and reindoctrination.
And similarly, even the Buddha had one famous disciple,
Angulimala, who was a serial killer
and became a saint, complete saint actually
in his lifetime by changing his behavior
and so forth, and then went to some of the families of some
of the people he had killed.
And he actually was so genuinely--
he offered his life to them anyway,
if that would have helped.
And they actually didn't take his life
when they realized he really had totally changed, actually.
Anyway, that's the Buddha's analysis of the human being.
So I presume, do all of what is the fourfold for the four
noble truths?
Everybody know that in this room?
Anybody doesn't know that, Buddha's sort
of original teaching?
A few people.
Well, I can quickly summarize.
It's important to do, because the people always
think, especially new people, that Buddha's main job was
making a religion.
Now I'm going back from Dalai Lama to Buddha,
because Buddha did the same thing as Dalai Lama did
in the sense that he grounded his version of ethics
in what would be considered scientific reality of that time
and actually may well still be considered scientific reality.
But I'm not going to get into that necessarily,
unless we go into a question period, and you want me to.
So in other words, what His Holiness Dalai Lama is
doing is same thing Buddha did.
His Holiness is doing it in terms
of secular science or materialist science
today, which is the orthodoxy.
It's not the dogmatic orthodoxy among scientists
today, scientific materialism, and in his day,
Buddha did that as well.
Shakyamuni Buddha did that as well,
which is the basis of Buddhist ethics,
and that's what I want to talk about it.
Anyway, the four noble truths, his first Noble Truth
was that the unenlightened person is bound to suffer.
It's not really a religious thing.
It's a scientific and psychological analysis
of the human condition, and and also of animals, actually,
as well, at a worse level than the human.
But what it means is that someone
who has a false sense of what they
…
My name is Ming.
I'm the Jolly Good Fellow of Google for one more
week, because next week I'm retiring from Google.
And this is the very last guest I am hosting at Google,
and very fittingly, it is Professor Bob Thurman.
Bob is a wonderful human being.
Behind his back, we call him Buddha Bob.
He's sort of like-- I think he should
be more like Bob the Buddha, sort of like Bob the Builder,
except with better karma.
Bob the Buddha is considered the leading American expert
on Tibetan Buddhism.
In 1962, Bob became the first American
to wear the robes of a Tibetan Buddhist monk
outside of Halloween.
Eventually, he left his job, and he became a professor
at American University, and right now, he
is a Jey Tsong Khapa professor of Indo-Tibetan Buddhist
studies at Columbia University.
He's also the president of the Tibet House, which
he founded with this guy called Richard Gere, which you may
or may have heard of, and also Philip Glass, which you
may or may not have heard of.
He's also the president of the American
Institute of Buddhist Studies.
He was see considered one of 25 most influential Americans
in the 1997.
And in 1998, he didn't do anything after that.
He has been profiled in "The New York Times," in "People"
magazine, in "Time," he has appeared on CNN, "The News
Hour," Larry King, Oprah.
He is close personal friends with the Dalai Lama.
He knows all the dirt, so ask him later.
He's also the father of Uma Thurman,
so he knows the dirt as well.
Ask him too.
His hobbies are carpentry, landscaping, and saving
the world.
He's here to talk about his latest book,
"Love Your Enemies."
So now that I have this book, all I need is enemies.
My friends, please welcome our dear friend, Bob Thurman.
[APPLAUSE]
ROBERT THURMAN: Thank you so much.
Thank you, Ming.
So sweet.
That was very sweet.
I really enjoy your introducing me more than talking.
I'm sure.
And just I'm doing this, or my wife will be mad at me if I
don't.
So great.
So hi, everybody.
I was asked to talk about ethics,
and I just made a slide.
I do have a lot of PowerPoint, but for some reason,
I didn't feel like doing PowerPoint.
So you probably get PowerPoints all the time
on engineering problems and God knows what down here,
so I didn't think I would do that while I was here.
But then I decided I would make this one slide.
And my talk takes off from a book
that His Holiness the Dalai Lama wrote
called "Beyond Religion-- Ethics for a Whole World."
Have any of you ever seen that book or read it?
Ming has, I'm sure, and a few people have.
And what he does there is because His Holiness has always
been trying to improve understanding
between different kinds of groups of people who identify
themselves as different from each other,
and his main job there, one of his three main jobs in life,
as he puts it, is to improve the mutual understanding
of the world religions, because there's been so much conflict
in history between them.
But one thing that he does when he has meetings, world
religious meetings, he always a little bit
flummoxes the other world religious leaders
by saying that there's another world religion which
is secularism, which are nonbelievers, as he puts it.
And he used to say-- I don't know the statistical basis
of him saying that.
I never did ask him.
He used to say, if there are 4 billion people who believe
in some religion or another, there are at least 1 billion
or 1 and 1/2 billion who don't.
That was a previous earlier count, I guess.
Now we're up to seven.
So I don't know how he does it just now.
And they do have a belief, and they have a belief
of what lies beyond death.
They have a belief, and actually I
think I can prove to anyone who wants to debate it that that is
a faith belief actually, rather than an evidenced belief, which
we can discuss.
And so in that book, which he originally
wanted to title "Secular Ethics," he wanted
to show that there is a reason and a motive for human beings
to be ethical, because it fulfills
the aim of human beings, which finally, of course,
like all animals, the aim of any animal is to avoid pain
and to achieve happiness.
Avoid suffering and achieve happiness.
That's sort of the basic goal of everyone.
Whatever other goals they may set themselves,
no one wants to suffer.
No one wants pain.
Everyone wants pleasure and/or happiness,
depending on how they define them.
And then there's mental levels of pain
and physical levels of pain.
And so he wrote that book, and in the book,
basically, he used sort of anthropological insights,
pretty much, and some biological, a little bit
of biological thinking of secularists
or scientific materialists to prove
that the human being as a mammal, as a being that when
it's young is helpless for many years, at least a decade,
at least till the teenage time, at which point
the human being thinks they're independent.
But the parents don't.
The parents think they need help right up until they're
parents themselves pretty much, and sometimes even after that.
Grandparents get sucked in on babysitting and what have you.
And I can attest to that.
And so because of that, human beings
do depend on the kindness of strangers, not only Mae West,
but everybody.
After all, the mammal conceives a new life,
the more intelligent half of the mammals, that is-- the females.
They allow a total stranger to come
and have a condo in their belly, which is quite a thing.
I think if guys think about it, I think you'd be hesitant.
I would.
I don't know about you, but suddenly, there's something
down there, and it wants a different kind of food,
and it wants this and that, and it kicks after awhile.
And then it's a real pain more than
in the neck to get it outside of yourself.
And so that's all a bunch of altruistic activity
of the females, and the males have to carry along.
They have to end up helping, so mammals' basic nature
is what he's trying to say.
Buddhists don't like the idea of anything
having an absolute nature.
They have a wonderful hermeneutic principle
in Buddhist thought, in Buddhist science, I should say,
because in Buddhism, philosophy and science are not
necessarily separated so dramatically as it has
become in the West nowadays.
But in Buddhist science, there is a rule, a hermeneutic
or a rule of interpretation.
And that is that there is only one kind of teaching that
is considered definitive in meaning,
and that kind is the pure negation of something of self,
the negation of substance, the negation
of any sort of a relative absolute, you could say.
It's almost simplistic and so simple, actually.
The famous concept of emptiness--
we've all heard of it-- selflessness--
these are famous concepts.
And what these mean, they don't mean that things don't exist.
Emptiness is not nothingness.
Completely different word in any of the Buddhist languages.
And what emptiness means is that all relative things are
empty of any non-relative element
or what they would call intrinsic reality,
intrinsic identity, any sort of thing like that,
which is really almost like it's a definition of the words.
It's almost a tautological.
If something's absolute, you can't relate, because absolute
is the opposite of relative.
And so if anybody comes up with some sort of an absolute
and says it relates as some monotheistic teachings do,
as some versions of Buddhism do, then they
are simply misusing language, to use a Wittgensteinian
expression.
And so His Holiness, therefore, is very like a scientist,
and great Buddhist philosophers are
like scientists in that all teachings
about relative reality are relative.
That is to say more or less valid within a context.
There is no absolute truth about relative things,
if you follow me, except that none of them are absolute.
That's the only one.
That's really a logical thing.
But why is that it?
So it seems so simple like why is that a big thing?
The reason it's a big thing is that the human bad habit,
cognitive habit, emotional habit, instinctual habit that
causes all suffering for human beings in Buddha's
psychological and philosophical analysis
is the feeling that we habitually have
that we are absolute.
The person has a feeling, the unenlightened person
has a feeling that the one thing they are sure of-- for example,
Descartes perfectly well illustrates-- stop vibrating--
perfectly illustrated that when he decided
that the one thing he was absolutely sure of
was that he was worrying about what was absolute.
In other words, he was thinking.
That's the famous thing.
He didn't need Buddhism for that.
And everyone subconsciously or subliminally or instinctively
feels something about themself is absolute, and therefore,
when pressed in a corner of a life and death
thing, like my life is the one absolute for me
type of thing people feel that, which, of course,
from Buddha's point of view is erroneous.
His teaching of selflessness means that that's an error.
That doesn't mean that I don't exist.
It means that I am a relational being, not an absolute being.
That means that other beings are equally as real and as
important as I am, and that little shift of not being
the absolute center of it all yourself,
of coming to this viscerally understand
that, first intellectually and philosophically understand
that, and then viscerally understand it--
that's the whole campaign of Buddhist teaching.
Because once you do really understand--
like I had an old Mongolian guru who
had a couple of great sayings-- passed away a long time ago,
but one of his great sayings was,
everyone goes around-- this was three or four
decades before "The Matrix."
He said, everyone goes around secretly thinking, I'm the one.
Therefore, I nearly fainted when they started on
that in "The Matrix," going to see the oracle, who's the one,
you know.
So everybody secretly thinks, I'm the one.
And then the second one is, people are not
wrong to say that they are real.
The problem is people think they're really real.
So all it is.
A lot of people misunderstand Buddhism and think
that the big insight is that you don't exist,
and then you're free, and everything is cool.
And actually, there are certain modern Buddhists
who think that scientific materialism ratifies that
by discovering that you're just a brain
bouncing around inside a skull box
and running around until the brain gets tired,
and you have a stroke or collapse or something,
and then you don't exist anymore.
So in a way, essentially, you don't exist.
You're just a robot that is deluded
into thinking you exist, as long as your heart is pumping,
and your brain is registering and convincing you
that you're there, but you're not really there,
because if you just squash your brain,
you simply cease to exist.
So that's what Buddha was saying in selflessness and emptiness,
and even some translators used to translate emptiness
as nothingness, which is just completely very
bad, because Buddha is very clear that emptiness
as a sort of ultimate cosmological principle
or something like that is a middle way, a central way
between nihilism, nothingness, and absolutism,
making some sort of absolute out of something.
Emptiness is therefore really what it truly is is relativism,
and Buddha really is the discovery of relativity.
And therefore, ethics was a central thing for Buddhism,
because ethics operates on all levels-- physical, not
just physical, not just verbal, but also mental.
Well, Jimmy Carter knew that.
Remember, Jimmy-- most of you are too young.
Somebody remember Jimmy Carter wrote in "Esquire" magazine
how he sinned in his mind.
He lusted after some young thing or something.
And I don't know how Rosalynn took that,
but the Buddhists say you can do that in your mind.
In other words, you can commit a negative ethical act just
with your mind, even if you don't act on it.
And that's one of the reasons Buddhists
are so much into searching inside themselves.
I have to say it with the right emphasis in this room.
So it's a very big deal.
Ethics is a very big deal.
Now the problem-- so then His Holiness does that in his book
by talking about what human life is like and the fact
that we do love-- are happy when we love someone,
not only when we're loved, but also when we do love,
we become very, very happy.
You know, Gene Kelly dancing in the rain, what have you.
And he has two pillars, he said, of his secular ethics.
And one of them is human nature, the nature
of the human as a social animal, which
he takes from a certain side in anthropology,
although he cites many studies.
There are more and more studies that-- actually,
in the famous argument between Ashley Montagu and Konrad
Lorenz historically in the history of anthropology,
there are many more things supporting Ashley Montagu
that humans are really basically gentle.
They're basically kind.
But they can become vicious, worse than any animal,
because the nature of the human being
is so completely programmable, deprogrammable, reprogrammable,
which is why education is so critically important.
Anyway, basically among animals, the human is a more gentle one.
We don't have claws.
We don't have fangs.
We don't have armored skin.
We're soft-skinned and so forth.
And the young take existence inside the bodies
of the female, which is more of a connection
to the next generation than if you just
drop an egg somewhere in the riverbank or by the ocean
and wait for the little turtle to crawl out.
There's a little less parenting involved
when you do it with eggs.
So he uses that.
And then the second one is the relationality of everything
and that everyone is very interrelated
and that people are never happier
than when they do something successfully for someone else,
and they feel really good about that like seeing that person
smile, seeing that child happy.
They really do, and then that leads
to his slogan about compassion that he does,
where he says that if you want someone else to be happy,
be compassionate to them.
And he says if you want to be happy, be
compassionate to someone else, which
is his favorite slogan coming from the tradition
of Shantideva, a great, great Indian philosopher and sage
and yogi call Shantideva, who wrote a great book called
"Way of the Bodhisattva" that I recommend to everyone.
It's one of the great world classics of spirituality,
actually, in which he makes the argument very, very thoroughly
that our nature is such that when
we do something for someone else that succeeds,
it is its own reward.
And they may even make the very clever psychological argument
that when you focus on doing things for others, then
actually, you temporarily forget about what you need yourself.
You tend to.
And then that's a key to happiness,
because the one certain way to be unhappy
is to think, how happy am I?
That's an immediate killer.
The minute you think, how good is it?
What am I getting out of here?
What's going on?
It's like, oh, no, it's not that good.
Whatever marvelous experience it is
when you turn to evaluate it, you're never satisfied.
The Rolling Stones have a song like that, right?
Ain't no satisfaction.
So that's His Holiness's thing on secularism,
which is a beautiful book, and it
has trainings in the back, which is another novel
concept to Western psychologists, which
is that you can train yourself to be
more compassionate and more loving,
that it isn't that a person is just loving.
Of course, there's a set point that Buddhists
would agree from one's upbringing
if one is traumatically brought up,
it's maybe difficult to feel it's natural to be nice
and to be loving if you've been guarding and defending yourself
against abuse as a child.
But basically, whatever level of lovingness one
is or has as a person can be much more highly developed.
And the negative side, the opposite of loving-- hating,
despising, et cetera-- can be diminished by training.
And that's very important.
Should be a part of everyone's education.
It actually is the final purpose of the Search Inside Yourself
strategy, because once you search in there,
you find the negative reflexes and mechanisms that
have caused you trouble in life, or you lost friends
where you annoyed and offended people, where
this and that happened, where you were dissatisfied also
yourself, and then you can deconstruct,
and you can disempower those negative mental habits,
and you can reinforce and empower the positive ones
to a huge degree.
And Buddhists would not agree with those modern psychologists
who keep insisting and write all best-seller books
about how helpless you are, that your unconscious is doing
everything, and you really can't really-- what you
think is a free choice is not.
And Buddhists don't agree.
They do agree that a very unenlightened person is
pretty much robotic in their reactivity and their reaction
patterns, but the whole path of Buddhism
is to become conscious of your unconscious actually
and to reshape it.
It's like the Hercules myth of cleaning the Augean stables
is very perfect for the Buddhist enterprise,
because the human being in Buddha's analysis,
the reason it is such a valuable life form,
and that every one of you has what
they call in Buddhism the precious jewel
of a life endowed with liberty and opportunity.
And the liberty has to do with the fact
that you are free of many kinds of defects.
You're not born in a species that
has no language, that has no culture, that can't share
the mind of others because of having speech
and so forth, literature, in our case,
and memory, and a certain type of self-reflexiveness
is not available to lower animal forms in the human animal form.
And some humans, of course, are less than others.
And so they're not all the same.
So the liberties are like that, and the opportunities
are where you can educate yourself,
because if a human being, if a saint, or a near saint--
actually, in Buddha's view, a complete saint can never
become a murderer, a perfect saint,
but there are degrees of really niceness and sainthood that
could become very evil by different circumstances
and reindoctrination.
And similarly, even the Buddha had one famous disciple,
Angulimala, who was a serial killer
and became a saint, complete saint actually
in his lifetime by changing his behavior
and so forth, and then went to some of the families of some
of the people he had killed.
And he actually was so genuinely--
he offered his life to them anyway,
if that would have helped.
And they actually didn't take his life
when they realized he really had totally changed, actually.
Anyway, that's the Buddha's analysis of the human being.
So I presume, do all of what is the fourfold for the four
noble truths?
Everybody know that in this room?
Anybody doesn't know that, Buddha's sort
of original teaching?
A few people.
Well, I can quickly summarize.
It's important to do, because the people always
think, especially new people, that Buddha's main job was
making a religion.
Now I'm going back from Dalai Lama to Buddha,
because Buddha did the same thing as Dalai Lama did
in the sense that he grounded his version of ethics
in what would be considered scientific reality of that time
and actually may well still be considered scientific reality.
But I'm not going to get into that necessarily,
unless we go into a question period, and you want me to.
So in other words, what His Holiness Dalai Lama is
doing is same thing Buddha did.
His Holiness is doing it in terms
of secular science or materialist science
today, which is the orthodoxy.
It's not the dogmatic orthodoxy among scientists
today, scientific materialism, and in his day,
Buddha did that as well.
Shakyamuni Buddha did that as well,
which is the basis of Buddhist ethics,
and that's what I want to talk about it.
Anyway, the four noble truths, his first Noble Truth
was that the unenlightened person is bound to suffer.
It's not really a religious thing.
It's a scientific and psychological analysis
of the human condition, and and also of animals, actually,
as well, at a worse level than the human.
But what it means is that someone
who has a false sense of what they
…