YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,133 lines · added Nov 3, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

MALE SPEAKER: All right.
Thank you for coming, everyone.
We have a special guest today on the day
that his new book is released.
So this is a real treat for us at Google.
Alva Noe is a writer and philosopher,
specializing in human experience and the philosophy of mind.
He holds degrees from Columbia, Oxford, and Harvard,
where he earned his PhD.
He's now a member of philosophy faculty
at the University of California, Berkeley,
as well as Berkeley's Institute for Cognitive and Brain
Sciences and the Center for New Media.
Outside of academia, you can find his writing
on NPR's "13.7, Cosmos and Culture," where
he's written about topics from PTSD
to Wilmer Flores and the New York Mets.
He's the author of four books, "Action in Perception,"
"Out of Our Heads," "Varieties of Presence," and his latest
work, which is the aforementioned book released
today, "Strange Tools."
In this subtle and enthusiastic new book,
he draws on examples from keeping score at a baseball
game, to Nirvana, to avant-garde art exhibitions
to lay out a new way of understanding art-- one that
avoids the reductionist approach of neuroscience and reframes
art as a crucial practice of human life.
For more in that topic and to celebrate
the release of "Strange Tools," please
give a warm welcome to our guest, Alva Noe.
[APPLAUSE]
ALVA NOE: Thank you very much for that warm welcome.
And yes, it's a very exciting day for me.
I've been working on this book for a long time.
And I've given dozens of talks about different aspects
of the book that feed into it.
But I'm never given a talk on the book,
where the books sort of exists already independently of me.
And it's an interesting challenge
to think about, now, what to pull
from it to share with you as sort of an invitation to it.
The book is called "Strange Tools."
It's about art and human nature.
The questions that guide the book from start to finish
are, what is art, why does art matter to us as much as it
does, what does art tell us or what can it tell us about
ourselves.
And I thought I would begin by reading
two pages from Chapter 9, which is called,
"Why Is Art So Boring?"
Did I hear a chuckle?
"Do you remember being bored as a kid?
I recall summer days during vacation that seem,
as I think back on them now, to have been fantastically,
impossibly long, hot, endless, open, without organization,
irritating, the buzz of flies, fighting
with my little brother, nothing to do, parents remote."
"By and large, there's no place for this sort
of radical boredom in the life of an adult. As you get older,
life gets organized around projects, and plans, and needs,
and goals.
And the result of this congealing of activity
is that time speeds up.
Or we simply stop paying attention to the metronome
and are captured by larger patterns
of meaning and organization."
"Our days are over, one might almost
say, before they have begun, for we've already
defined the present moment in relation
to what is yet to happen, in relation to the purpose, point,
or plan.
What did you do yesterday?
Oh, I went to work.
And this is all for the good.
It's a necessity."
"We achieve this.
We do not live in the tick-tock motion of sensations and buzzes
and one thing after another.
It's the mark of our development,
of our integration, to use John Dewey's phrase.
Our lives are not made up of a series of sensations.
They're composed of experiences, experiences
that demand to be named, that dinner in Venice,
going shopping, the softball game last weekend, my visit
here to Google."
And these experiences integrate over time."
"Grown-ups don't get bored.
Grown-ups can't get bored.
For that distinct, emotional state,
vaguely painful, that sense of being
trapped in the unending and meaningless,
that state is available only in the absence of structure, plan,
task, obligation.
The preconditions for boredom are absent in adult life."
"Now, what does this have to do with art?
My conjecture is everything.
The closest I have come as an adult to reliving
the florid, boredom of childhood is when
in the presence of art."
That's another chuckle opportunity.
"Don't get me wrong, I love art.
I work with art.
I study art.
I was raised in a family of artists.
Art matters to me.
And yet, it's hard for me to think of anything
more slit-your-wrists dull than some performances
or more excruciatingly sleep-inducing
than encountering, again, a gallery space
with pictures on the wall, each of which,
to begin with at least, is closed, mute,
indistinguishable, and off-putting."
"It isn't just bad art that is liable in this way
to induce that feeling of anxious capture
by an endless and meaningless present.
I stood in galleries at The Met, or The Frick, or other museums
that I love, and I found myself totally cold in the presence
of work that I know and value.
It's as if someone failed to press the on button.
the work stays off or I do.
And this time spent with art in the standby mode
can be a torture."
"I propose--" it's one of the many proposals
that I make in this book-- "that the boringness of art
is a clue to what art is and why it matters to us.
Any adequate account of what art is and of its place
in our lives must address the striking fact
that art has the power to bore us.
This is a power it maintains when
everything else in our lives mitigates against boredom."
"Art affords us the opportunity to be
bored to tears when almost nothing else in our life does.
And art's potential to be dull does not contradict the fact
that art also moves, and thrills, and transforms,
and excites us.
Indeed, it's the opposite side of the very same coin."
"Just as there is no encounter with love
without the live risk of heartbreak,
so there can be no confrontation with art
that does not open up the possibility of getting lulled,
unconscious, and bored to death.
Art is valuable only in direct proportion
to the degree to which it can or might bore us.
Why should this be?"
That's Chapter 9.
And by the time I've gotten there,
I've sort of set the stage for what an answer to that
would look like.
But for now, I want to kind of let that just hang out there
with us as a kind of prologue.
When I was in graduate school, I studied philosophy.
But from the very start, I was interested
in cognitive science.
And I was especially interested in the study of vision.
And one day, I found myself in conversation
with a man, an older man, an artist,
and he asked me to tell him about vision science.
What do you do in vision science?
And I said, well, the question that we ask in vision science
is, how is it that we manage to experience this three
dimensional world of solid objects and surrounding space,
when what we're given in the retinal image
are really distorted, upside down, twitching, shifting,
gappy pictures?
How do we get from such an impoverished stimulus
to such a rich experience?
How do we experience so much visually
on the basis of so little?
And the artist, a man I admired and knew very well,
he sort of paused a beat, tried to absorb what I just said,
and then he just said, Nonsense!
The question is not, or should not be,
how do we see so much on the basis of so little.
The interesting question is why we see so little when there's
so much around us to perceive.
Well, I came away from that conversation
thinking he just didn't understand the point.
But years went by, and I wrote the books
that were mentioned in the introduction--
"Action in Perception," and "Out of Our Heads,"
and "Varieties of Presence."
And the basic idea of those books--
which I wrote from the context of my own active collaboration
with scientists; I wrote those books very much with one
foot outside of academic philosophy--
the basic idea of those books was
that we shouldn't think of perception, or consciousness,
or experience as something that happens inside us, not
in the brain or anywhere else.
We should think of experience, we
should think of consciousness, as something
that we enact or perform.
And while it depends on what's going on
inside us, and particularly in our brains,
it can't be reduced to what goes on inside us or in our brains.
Perception and consciousness is--
so I argued in these books, convincingly
or not as the case may be-- consciousness is an activity.
It's a dynamic of involvement with, an exchange with,
the world around us.
The body the world the brain the environment other people
make consciousness happen.
Trying to find consciousness in the brain-- which, of course,
nobody's been able to do-- is looking for consciousness
in the wrong place.
It's like looking for the value of the money
in the paper it's printed on, or like looking
for the dance in the dancer's body.
It's just a confusion, so I argued.
And it dawned on me at one point,
as I remembered back to that conversation
I had had in graduate school, that I had developed a view-- I
called it the inactive approach, sometimes
the actionist approach, sometimes the sensory motor
approach to perception consciousness-- that
sort of vindicated what that artist had said to me.
There's really two different ways
of thinking about experience.
You can think of something we achieve
and we can fail to achieve.
Or you can think of experience as something that sort of just
happens, thanks to the way our nervous system is triggered.
And I was planking down for this other view.
So in some sense, I realized looking back on this work
that I'd done, that I was arguing
that the artist was right.
And that was important to me for a number of reasons.
But one of them then dawned on me only even more recently,
which is that it wasn't just that--
and again, you don't have to agree with me about this--
but it wasn't just that I'd come to conclude
that, in some profound sense, the artist had been right,
but it was important to me, I realized,
that the artist was right.
That is, I'd gotten this lesson, I'd gotten this insight,
from an artist and from a perspective that
had been afforded to him in some way through his work
through his in engagement with, through his valuing art.
Now, usually when philosophers, or cognitive scientists,
or psychologists try to write about art,
they think of it as a phenomenon that they're going to explain.
They're going to tell you why it exists
from an evolutionary point of view.
Or they're going to show you how it works neurologically.
But I came away then-- again, thinking back
on this rich experience that I had,
this conversation-- thinking, no, we
shouldn't think of art as a phenomenon to be explained,
but rather art as itself a field of research
or a domain of investigation, a kind of inquiry
in which explanations are sought.
We can think of art itself, the work of dancers and painters,
for example, as forms of research.
So one of the questions I came to think
hard about as I approached writing this book is, well,
what kind of research?
What kind of research is this?
And by the way, long before I wrote "Strange Tools"--
this sort of sounds self-congratulatory,
but it's really part of my journey--
long before I wrote "Strange Tools,"
long before I even really framed for myself the idea of writing
this book, artists were responding positively to these
other books that I'd written, these books that were really
written for people interested in the mind and consciousness,
really for cognitive science broadly construed.
And they were finding some idea that I
was helping them articulate what it was that they
were investigating in my work.
Anyway, that's kind of an aside.
I don't really know how to finish that thought.
But the point is I've come to this point-- and in a way,
this is perhaps the most salient,
most prominent thesis in this book "Strange Tools"--
one of the main themes of the book is the idea that art
as a research practice, specifically,
it is a philosophical practice.
I might just as well have said that philosophy is an aesthetic
or artistic practice.
And one of the things I do in the book
is I try to explain that, or unpack that, or give
that meaning, especially give that meaning
when terms like philosophy of themselves
is difficult to define and explain and maybe just as
problematic as notions like art itself.
And the final position that I arrive at,
and which I explain in the body of the book,
and which I'll try to explain to some degree with you right now
is that, actually, the sort of official view at the end
is not that art and philosophy are the same,
but that each of them is a species of a common genus.
And that common genus I call reorganizational practice.
And just in a line, the thing about reorganizational
practices is that they exhibit us to ourselves
and, in doing so, invariably give us the resources,
whether we like it or not, to change ourselves.
Let me make a first pass at some of those ideas-- a very
informal first pass.
I gave a talk at Google a number of years ago,
when "Out of Our Heads" came out.
And I gave a version of this example
then, too, because it's a rich example that I come back to
again and again.
Imagine you're at a gallery.
And there, you encounter paintings, let's say.
And imagine that they're in a style which
is completely strange to you.
Maybe they're by a painter you've never heard of or never
seen, or they're part of a movement
that you're unfamiliar with.
It's a very familiar, very normal experience
that you kind of walk in.
Maybe you're with a friend.
You're talking.
The pictures don't grab your attention.
They all kind of look the same.
They certainly don't fascinate you.
And left to your own devices, you might very likely just
continue on to the next room looking for something
more attention-getting.
But I'm interested in what happens
when you don't do that-- when you don't keep on going,
when you don't simply just pass by,
but when you stop and take another look and look again.
Suppose that the friend you're with
is a huge fan of this artist.
And she calls your attention to features of the work
that you hadn't noticed-- maybe patterns in the composition
or in the color scheme or relationship
between the different pictures.
Or maybe she points out something
about the order in which the pictures were made,
or something about the historical context in which
they were made, or the kind of work that was going on
at the time they were made and what this
would have meant to people who saw it then,
whatever it might be.
Sometimes, if you're lucky, something remarkable happens.
Whereas, all the pieces basically
look the same at first, now they start
to pop out at you as individuals.
And whereas before, they seemed flat and uninteresting,
now you start to, as it were, see depth in them,
or see into them, see structure, see meaning, and indeed find
them to be fascinating.
Whereas, before they were dull, now all of a sudden,
they are attention-getting.
So I'm very interested in that transition.
I mean, I think we have all had that experience.
If you've ever spent any time with art,
you've had that experience.
Or with a record album, I can remember
the first time I listened to Led Zeppelin's
"Houses of the Holy."
I couldn't understand what people liked about it.
Just one song sounded like the next.
I came to love the album.
And I came to perceive the structure
and subtle differences between the songs.
So how do we understand this transformation?
It's a transformation, which I think of as one
from not seeing to seeing.
Or as Nicole [? Pizzel, ?] who's here in the audience,
put it to me from seeing to seeing differently.
You might say, well, it's a change in you.
After all, the works haven't changed.
We're not talking about kinetic art or digital art that
might actually be changing.
I'm just imagining paintings in the wall.
So the paintings haven't changed.
If there's a change, there's a change in you.
But I think it's important to realize that it's not
merely a change in what you think or believe,
because whatever the change is, I would argue.
It's a change that enables you to see what was there all along
but they couldn't see before.
It's a change that enables you to bring with what is there
into focus, to bring it into focus
for your conscious experience.
Now, one way I could summarize what
I'm trying to do in this book is to understand
that transformation.
I call it reorganization.
How is it that in that situation through active
looking, through thinking, through talking,
and through interrogating the things before you that we come
to experience them differently?
How is it that we reorganize ourselves in that way?
Notice that what I described as such,
doesn't really have anything special to do with art.
It's a general feature of our perceptual lives
that through learning and knowledge and talking
and interaction we achieve access
to what there is around us in our perceptual lives.
Think of how you learn a language,
and then you can read.
You couldn't be offended by the racist graffiti
if you couldn't read the language it was in.
Suddenly, you can read it, and boom, you can be hit by it.
So we can bring the world into focus through learning.
And it happened really quickly.
So in some sense, this gallery example
I've given you isn't an art-specific example.
But there is something about it which
I think is maybe a clue to what makes art special or at least
one of art's special gifts.
And that is that a visit to the gallery of this kind
is one in which you get the opportunity to catch yourself
in the act of doing just that.
It's not just that you undergo a transformation,
but you realize that you're undergoing the transformation
and it's made available to you.
Now for me, that is a paradigmatically philosophical
kind of moment, where you in a way stop business as usual
but get to reflect on what you're doing.
It's one of the things that philosophy
aims at-- that kind of self-disclosure or unveiling
of oneself to oneself.
And moreover, in this example, it
does it in the setting of the exercise of our abilities
to look and think and see, that is,
in the setting of our real lives,
in the setting up our lived experience.
So the ways in which we reorganize
and the ways in which we transform ourselves
have to do with perception and consciousness.
So if this is right, then there's
a sense in which what this encounter with art is affording
us is not just an episode in consciousness
but a kind of revelation or an insight into what consciousness
is.
So I take this to be a very rich example.
And I could spend the whole talk just talking
about this example.
And I won't, but I'll just mention as a footnote,
it's interesting to think about, to compare this
to a platonic or Socratic dialogue.
The kind of transformation that happens in this visit
to the gallery for me is very much like what
happens between Socrates and his interlocutors
and their dialogues.
But there is one last note I'll mention before I go on,
more substantively.
And that is, I think this example also gives us
a hint as to what goes on when we think
about the boringness of art.
Welcome.
Because what's striking about-- what
was required to set the stage for you
to see what you couldn't see or to see what you saw
but differently, what was required
was a kind of a disruption, a moment of not being
able to see it, a confrontation with stuff
that all looked the same.
And in our natural, habitual, organized living,
the natural thing to do when everything looks the same,
is uninteresting, is to keep on going.
But what the work ritually-- sort
of the art situation invited you to do
was to disrupt those habits, to put the email away,
to stop the conversation-- rather,
the conversation that's unrelated to what's
going on around you, and look to the work.
And so I think, we begin to see a way in which the work creates
a setting in which boredom is a stage through which you
have to go to make discovery.
So that's a first pass.
I now want to approach these issues, these very same issues,
but in a slightly different manner.
And just in case any of you are pressed for time,
I'm thinking that I'll probably go about 20 more minutes.
And then there'll be time for discuss
…

Need subtitles from another video?