Advertisement
English transcript
This morning we are going to talk about forgiveness and I'll divide my comments into two parts.
The first will deal with what "The Song of Prayer" pamphlet calls forgiveness-to-destroy,
in other words what forgiveness is not. And then in the next video we'll talk about forgiveness
is. Even though the term "forgiveness-to-destroy" does not appear in the Course itself, it is
talked about in both the text and the workbook, or described. But it's in "The Song of Prayer"
pamphlet that the term is actually used and, in fact, it's the title of a section. Forgiveness-to-destroy
is the ego's version of forgiveness which is all about making the error of separation
real. So that when we forgive someone from the ego's point of view, what we are really
doing is accentuating and reinforcing the fact that I and the other person are different
and separate from each other. So that it could take the form, as you often find in traditional
Christianity, you are a miserable sinner but in the goodness of my heart and the sanctity
of my being, I forgive you. I'm different from you. I am holier than you, but I have
the power to forgive you. And, of course, in the Catholic Church this took the form
of the sacrament of penance or confession where one went to a priest who had the power
to forgive, but there was a clear delineation of roles. There was the priest who was God's
or Jesus' chosen messenger or stand-in and then there was the poor penitent who had sinned.
All that this does, once again, is reinforce the ego's fundamental thought that we are
separate and different from each other. This is not true forgiveness because it does not
undo the error. As I was just saying, it simply makes it even more real and because of that,
it reinforces guilt. So that the person who says he or she is forgiving is actually reenacting
the original error of making separation and differences real. Since that's what the ego
labels sin, which ironically is not supposed to be forgiven, it makes the thought of sin
real and the forgiver, which automatically leads to guilt. Guilt then must be repressed
and then projected which means that in the guise of forgiveness, you are really simply
attacking still further. And this is what the Course refers to or describes as the guilt/attack
cycle...that the guiltier I feel, the greater is my need to project it out in the maladaptive
or magical way of getting rid of it, thereby making you guilty which constitutes the attack
which reinforces my own guilt, and we go around and around a very vicious circle. But that's
what forgiveness-to-destroy is all about. To say it another way, what forgiveness-to-destroy
does is establish sin is real and then pretend to forgive it. How could you first forgive
something that you've established as real and has happened. This is the kind of forgiveness
that the ego sanctions. It's what the world has always blessed. It's what, for example,
the Anti-Defamation League used to say of the holocaust: we will forgive but never forget.
In other words, that you the bad guys, the Nazis, and all the people who seemed to support
them did something unconscionably terrible and we will forgive it, but we will never
forget what you did. I remember growing up with that having been raised in a Jewish household.
This was the rallying cry of all Jews. This is not true forgiveness. Again, all that it
does is reinforce guilt; and when there is guilt, the guilt will always be projected
and you will do unto others what you believe had been done unto you. This is true on a
large-scale level as well as on an individual level. So forgiveness-to-destroy fits in perfectly
with the ego's thought system. There's a line in the text that says "defenses do what they
would defend." A defense that is supposed to protect us, in this case from guilt, simply
reinforces it and so, once again, we all go around both individually and collectively
as racial, political, national, religious groups go around and around the same vicious
circle of making the ego's thought system real and then attempting to escape from the
horrible consequences of it, which means our own punishment, by finding somebody else whom
we could label as the sinner. And if we are trying to do this within a religious or spiritual
context, it would appear as if we are the good guys and they are the bad guys. And this,
of course, will never work except from the ego's point of view.
The first will deal with what "The Song of Prayer" pamphlet calls forgiveness-to-destroy,
in other words what forgiveness is not. And then in the next video we'll talk about forgiveness
is. Even though the term "forgiveness-to-destroy" does not appear in the Course itself, it is
talked about in both the text and the workbook, or described. But it's in "The Song of Prayer"
pamphlet that the term is actually used and, in fact, it's the title of a section. Forgiveness-to-destroy
is the ego's version of forgiveness which is all about making the error of separation
real. So that when we forgive someone from the ego's point of view, what we are really
doing is accentuating and reinforcing the fact that I and the other person are different
and separate from each other. So that it could take the form, as you often find in traditional
Christianity, you are a miserable sinner but in the goodness of my heart and the sanctity
of my being, I forgive you. I'm different from you. I am holier than you, but I have
the power to forgive you. And, of course, in the Catholic Church this took the form
of the sacrament of penance or confession where one went to a priest who had the power
to forgive, but there was a clear delineation of roles. There was the priest who was God's
or Jesus' chosen messenger or stand-in and then there was the poor penitent who had sinned.
All that this does, once again, is reinforce the ego's fundamental thought that we are
separate and different from each other. This is not true forgiveness because it does not
undo the error. As I was just saying, it simply makes it even more real and because of that,
it reinforces guilt. So that the person who says he or she is forgiving is actually reenacting
the original error of making separation and differences real. Since that's what the ego
labels sin, which ironically is not supposed to be forgiven, it makes the thought of sin
real and the forgiver, which automatically leads to guilt. Guilt then must be repressed
and then projected which means that in the guise of forgiveness, you are really simply
attacking still further. And this is what the Course refers to or describes as the guilt/attack
cycle...that the guiltier I feel, the greater is my need to project it out in the maladaptive
or magical way of getting rid of it, thereby making you guilty which constitutes the attack
which reinforces my own guilt, and we go around and around a very vicious circle. But that's
what forgiveness-to-destroy is all about. To say it another way, what forgiveness-to-destroy
does is establish sin is real and then pretend to forgive it. How could you first forgive
something that you've established as real and has happened. This is the kind of forgiveness
that the ego sanctions. It's what the world has always blessed. It's what, for example,
the Anti-Defamation League used to say of the holocaust: we will forgive but never forget.
In other words, that you the bad guys, the Nazis, and all the people who seemed to support
them did something unconscionably terrible and we will forgive it, but we will never
forget what you did. I remember growing up with that having been raised in a Jewish household.
This was the rallying cry of all Jews. This is not true forgiveness. Again, all that it
does is reinforce guilt; and when there is guilt, the guilt will always be projected
and you will do unto others what you believe had been done unto you. This is true on a
large-scale level as well as on an individual level. So forgiveness-to-destroy fits in perfectly
with the ego's thought system. There's a line in the text that says "defenses do what they
would defend." A defense that is supposed to protect us, in this case from guilt, simply
reinforces it and so, once again, we all go around both individually and collectively
as racial, political, national, religious groups go around and around the same vicious
circle of making the ego's thought system real and then attempting to escape from the
horrible consequences of it, which means our own punishment, by finding somebody else whom
we could label as the sinner. And if we are trying to do this within a religious or spiritual
context, it would appear as if we are the good guys and they are the bad guys. And this,
of course, will never work except from the ego's point of view.