YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 240 lines · added Nov 10, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Hi.
I'm David Makinster.
This is an introductory lecture to the Intro
to Philosophy course, the online version.
I've been teaching this course in one form
or another for more than 30 years,
but only online for about 2 and 1/2 years now.
Based on the experience of students in prior semesters,
I thought it would be good to provide
just a few pointers upfront, as I otherwise
don't get to speak to you.
First of all, get the books now.
Don't wait to get the books.
The bookstore only stocks about 70%
of what they anticipate the demand is going to be,
and that's because so many students
do buy their books online.
Get the books as soon as possible.
Now, it's a little more complicated than that.
Please be sure you get the right version of Plato's Republic.
There are innumerable translations
of Plato's Republic.
They're not all equally good.
The crucial thing about the translation I've chosen
is that the translator has created a topical index.
Now, we're not going to read that book cover to cover.
That would take a full semester at least.
But if you want to find the passages that I assign to you,
you're going to need that topical index.
If you get some other translation,
it's just not going to be there and you're
going to have a very difficult time finding what
it is you're supposed to read.
Also, many people who translate Plato's Republic
have a philosophical agenda of one kind or another
so they give a particular slant or they provide
notes that are very much advocating
a particular interpretation.
I've chosen a translation that is simply
very easy to read for a first time reader.
Plato is considered by historians of literature
to be one of the best writers in the Western canon.
His writing is very clear.
That's not true of everyone who translates Plato.
So it's not like all translations are created equal.
They are most assuredly not.
Do get the one I have specified.
Plato's Republic, translated by Lee.
He might be listed as Desmond Lee or as HTP Lee.
But the last name is Lee.
He's very good at being clear and elegant
in his translations, so as a first time reader
you're not intimidated by the prose itself.
We are not going to read Plato's Republic cover to cover.
If we were going to do that, I would actually
use some other translation of Plato.
But for what we're going to do, this
is very, very, very manageable.
Whatever you do, don't get the Jowett translation.
The Kindle version, even if you get it from Penguin,
the Kindle version is the Jowett translation.
The Jowett translation is notorious
for being very difficult to read.
Jowett, much to his credit, was the first person
to try to translate all of Plato into English,
but he did it during Victorian times.
So he translated it into Victorian English.
Students in philosophy very often
refer to it as the King James version of Plato,
because indeed he does consciously
try to imitate the style of the King James Bible.
It just makes it very, very difficult to understand
what's going on in the original.
Also since the time that Jowett did his translation,
there's been an immense amount of scholarship about Plato
and Socrates which does inform Lee's translation
but did not inform Jowett's translation.
So this is just a better version, OK?
Do get this one.
I got a copy to put on reserve at the library at GCC,
just this summer.
From the time I ordered it to the time
it arrived was a week without expedited handling.
The book cost, I believe, $1.99.
So even with shipping, it was well under $10.
So you can get this book.
Do get this version of the book.
Another book that is required is Bertrand Russell's The Problems
of Philosophy.
I mention on the syllabus that book is available in entirety
online for free as a PDF.
If you have Adobe Acrobat Reader, which you can download
for free if you don't have it, you can get that online
and there's no need to actually have
a physical copy of the book unless you really like it.
My wife is very fond of the book.
So maybe you will be, too.
It's pretty straightforward other than that as far
as the books are concerned.
Get them now while they are available.
I ask you, please do read and refer to the syllabus
when you have a question about what we're doing
or why we're doing it.
I've tried to make the syllabus concise and clear.
And many times, when I receive questions
from students during the course of the semester,
those are questions that are answered
very directly by the syllabus.
So do be familiar with the syllabus.
It shows you what we're going to do
and how it all hangs together.
Check your email daily.
I will email you as the need arises,
and I can't necessarily anticipate what
days of the week that will be.
I will check my email daily.
If you are emailing me and you are not
using your academic email, you're
using some other email address, a Gmail address or whatever,
be sure you put your full name into the email.
Otherwise, I cannot figure out who is sending me the email.
I may make announcements.
I may occasionally decide to change some materials,
and I will then send an email and point out
that the change has been made.
But you should routinely-- most of you
are going to be online daily anyway,
for one thing or another.
Just take a minute and check your email
and make sure that there isn't something
from the online course.
Or if there is, that you are aware of it.
When you are sending me your essays,
please do not zip your documents.
If you don't know what a zip file is,
then you're home free and clear.
But please do not zip your documents.
The essays that I assign, the material that you have to do
is fairly short and not terribly ornate.
So it just creates a number of additional steps
to make a zip file out of your document before you attach it.
Also, I have occasionally had difficulty
opening zip files from students.
Let's just sidestep that.
Best way to send me an essay is to simply do
it in whatever word processing product that you like,
whether it's Microsoft Word or whatever.
And once you've finished it and you're done editing it,
just copy the whole thing and paste it
into the body of an email and send me that email.
Then we don't have to worry, will I
be able to open that attachment.
Did you, in fact, give me the right attachment?
Just stick it in the body of the email.
The essays, for this course at least,
are short enough that you should be
able to do that with no problem.
I know that's not true for every class,
but it's the easiest, safest way to do it for this class.
Communicate.
If there's a problem.
If you're having difficulty submitting work
on time, if you're having difficulty understanding what
the assignments are, if you think
you need more feedback about how you're doing in the course,
let me know right away.
Don't put that off.
Because the sooner that we can address it,
the sooner we can get on top of it.
I like to tell students, remember,
online doesn't mean self paced.
Not paste as in, paste together two pieces of paper.
But doesn't mean that you pace it yourself.
There are deadlines.
And you will get behind if you don't
try to meet those deadlines.
I can be flexible if there's good reason why
you need more time, but do talk to me about that.
If you simply think, well, this is online.
I can do it any time.
You're going to end up with a snowball effect
and you're going to say, oh my goodness.
How am I ever going to get all this work done?
The biggest reason why anyone doesn't do well
in this course-- and most students
do just fine in this course.
But the biggest reason why students don't do well
in the course is because they get behind,
and they get so far behind that they can't finish all the work
and then they just give up.
Well, don't let that happen to you.
If you need to talk to me about completing assignments,
please do that right away.
Certainly, I want you to learn this material.
I want you to learn about philosophy.
And so I am entirely willing to work with you
and make such accommodations as might be needed.
In teaching a philosophy course, understand
that what I'm trying to do is to teach you a set of skills.
Philosophy is a process.
When I taught science, I always taught science as a process.
It's an activity, not a set of received answers,
because new investigations could change
what we think those answers ought to be-- in both fields.
It's like art, right?
Art isn't something that you just memorize a bunch of facts
and then you know art.
Art is a process.
You have to do it.
And that's what I'm going to try to teach you.
How to do philosophy.
How do you think philosophically.
How to recognize a philosophical question.
I am not here to teach you the philosophy of David Makinster.
That's not what this course is about.
What I will do is try to give you
a number of tools, a number of important ideas to think about.
Part of my job will be to challenge your ideas.
To get you to think more carefully about them.
To get you to weigh alternatives.
That's all part of the philosophical process.
A good philosophy teacher is a coach, is a facilitator,
is sometimes a gadfly troubling you about things
that you're taking for granted, things
that you should be thinking more carefully about.
Understand that's what I'm doing.
I'm never trying to tell you, this
is what you have to conclude.
But rather, here's what you ought
to think about in drawing your conclusions.
Someone once asked the ancient Greek philosopher Democritus,
why should I learn how to reason?
Democritus said, do you want me to give you a reason?
The fellow said, yes.
And Democritus said, there you go.
So thank you very much for enrolling in the course.
I'm really looking forward to working with you this semester.
And by all means, feel free to ask me
any questions you have at any time.
Thanks.

Need subtitles from another video?