Advertisement
English transcript
Text on screen: Vera Institute of Justice
Vera Voices Podcast Series
Neil A. Weiner, Research Speaker Series, presents: David W. Garland, Arthur T. Vanderbilt,
Professor of Law, Professor of Sociology
David W. Garland: My name is David Garland, and I'm going to talk about my new book,
which is a book called Peculiar Institution: America's Death Penalty in an Age of Abolition.
The "peculiar institution" idea actually has three connotations; three meanings.
The first one is most obvious one. To an outside reader, that's to say that America's death penalty now looks peculiar.
It looks like an anomaly. All the other Western nations have abolished the death penalty.
The last one in Europe was in 1981 when France gave up the guillotine.
And yet America continues to have it. That's become abnormal or peculiar; how do we explain that?
The second peculiar characteristic of the American death penalty is the odd (some would say irrational)
way in which the system's actually administered and enacted.
So, we have the death penalty. Thirty-five states have the death penalty.
But most of them don't use it to any extent. About 12 of them in the last 45 years have three or fewer executions.
Even those of them who do impose death sentences impose death sentences on very few people eligible
and very few aggravated murderers actually end up with that sentence.
And then there's a peculiarity of the death sentence murderers.
About two-thirds of them will have their sentence overturned on appeal or habeas review.
And those tiny number of the large population of eligible murderers who are eventually put to death will,
on average, wait for 14 years before being executed.
Now, the peculiarity there is, if you expect capital punishment to deter individuals, it's unlikely to do so.
It's so uncertain and so rare.
If you intend it simply to deliver punishments, well, it doesn't deliver them very swiftly or very reliably.
If you expect to somehow compensate or gratify or bring closure to victims of murders' families, then it does the opposite.
Basically, the victims' families look on while the murderer gets sentenced to death.
Momentary sense of justice being done.
And then for the next two, sometimes three, decades, contests the verdict; contests the sentence.
And often becomes a kind of hero of the death penalty opposition community.
And so, it's very far from justice that seems to be being done.
So, all of that makes it seem peculiar.
The last sense of peculiar institution is the one that Americans might understand best,
and it's a reference to the peculiar institution of racialized chattel slavery.
Because there's definitely a sense that people have that somehow or other,
the continuation of the death penalty, and the use of the death penalty,
which is primarily being executed in the southern states,
is disproportionately imposed on the black perpetrators of murder against white victims.
And is, by and large, the product of impassioned community sentiments expressed through popular juries.
All of that makes people think that lynching and racial violence and Jim Crow and slavery
is the kind of heritage that has given rise to the American present.
These are the questions that the book tries to address.
So, the question of whether the death penalty works is an interesting and an important one.
A sociologist would say any institution that's continually re-energized and re-enlivened
by a political power being channeled into it, or by resources being used for it, must be serving some function.
It doesn't just continue because of inertia.
It's continually renewed and continually energized, and we see that in the political process here.
So, it seems to be serving some function.
On the other hand, these functions are not, I think, the standard criminal justice ones.
I mentioned already the idea that the death penalty deters potential murderers seems unlikely.
It's so uncertain and so rarely used.
The idea that it delivers retribution or justice, again, is uncertain and delayed, and justice delayed is justice denied.
The idea that it incapacitates murderers, certainly that's true, but life imprisonment without parole,
which is now available in every one of the death penalty states, can also incapacitate murderers more or less effectively.
So, these ways of the death penalty working seem implausible to me.
On the other hand, the death penalty does other kind of work.
It works to energize political majorities.
It works to provide a kind of sign; a politician who supports the death penalty
is tough on crime or responsive to majority preference.
It works to provide the media and the culture industry with a kind of added drama and suspense and morality play
that criminal events and criminal trials typically don't have in the this country.
The fact that there could be a death penalty imposed is really very useful for everybody concerned.
It kind of; it adds a kind of intensity and suspense and drama to an otherwise routine sentencing event.
So, for a variety of reasons, in addition, juries and prosecutors and even police
like to have the death penalty in their repertoire to kind of mark the seriousness of the offense.
And maybe if you're a prosecutor, to win plea bargains. And even to win cases.
So, for a variety of actors, there are uses to which the death penalty can be put.
But that's not for a moment to say that for the society as a whole, the death penalty serves any useful function.
If we got to a situation where a majority of states in this country did not use the death penalty;
did not have the death penalty, and the tendency was for them to abolish, and that the Supreme Court
was looking at a fact, which is that the death penalty, as executed, has become a southern, regional phenomenon,
with real problems of fairness and discrimination attached, and maybe even problems of innocence,
with people being put to death who aren't guilty,
I could, under these circumstances, see the Supreme Court of the USA saying the death penalty law
is cruel and unusual and unconstitutional and abolishing it for that reason.
But I think we have to get to a trend toward majority state abolition
before the Supreme Court felt comfortable doing so.
Vera Institute of Justice, Vera Voices Podcast Series
Neil A. Weiner, Research Speaker Series, presents: David W. Garland, Arthur T. Vanderbilt,
Professor of Law, Professor of Sociology
www.vera.org, Research Department, www.vera.org/research
Vera Voices Podcast Series
Neil A. Weiner, Research Speaker Series, presents: David W. Garland, Arthur T. Vanderbilt,
Professor of Law, Professor of Sociology
David W. Garland: My name is David Garland, and I'm going to talk about my new book,
which is a book called Peculiar Institution: America's Death Penalty in an Age of Abolition.
The "peculiar institution" idea actually has three connotations; three meanings.
The first one is most obvious one. To an outside reader, that's to say that America's death penalty now looks peculiar.
It looks like an anomaly. All the other Western nations have abolished the death penalty.
The last one in Europe was in 1981 when France gave up the guillotine.
And yet America continues to have it. That's become abnormal or peculiar; how do we explain that?
The second peculiar characteristic of the American death penalty is the odd (some would say irrational)
way in which the system's actually administered and enacted.
So, we have the death penalty. Thirty-five states have the death penalty.
But most of them don't use it to any extent. About 12 of them in the last 45 years have three or fewer executions.
Even those of them who do impose death sentences impose death sentences on very few people eligible
and very few aggravated murderers actually end up with that sentence.
And then there's a peculiarity of the death sentence murderers.
About two-thirds of them will have their sentence overturned on appeal or habeas review.
And those tiny number of the large population of eligible murderers who are eventually put to death will,
on average, wait for 14 years before being executed.
Now, the peculiarity there is, if you expect capital punishment to deter individuals, it's unlikely to do so.
It's so uncertain and so rare.
If you intend it simply to deliver punishments, well, it doesn't deliver them very swiftly or very reliably.
If you expect to somehow compensate or gratify or bring closure to victims of murders' families, then it does the opposite.
Basically, the victims' families look on while the murderer gets sentenced to death.
Momentary sense of justice being done.
And then for the next two, sometimes three, decades, contests the verdict; contests the sentence.
And often becomes a kind of hero of the death penalty opposition community.
And so, it's very far from justice that seems to be being done.
So, all of that makes it seem peculiar.
The last sense of peculiar institution is the one that Americans might understand best,
and it's a reference to the peculiar institution of racialized chattel slavery.
Because there's definitely a sense that people have that somehow or other,
the continuation of the death penalty, and the use of the death penalty,
which is primarily being executed in the southern states,
is disproportionately imposed on the black perpetrators of murder against white victims.
And is, by and large, the product of impassioned community sentiments expressed through popular juries.
All of that makes people think that lynching and racial violence and Jim Crow and slavery
is the kind of heritage that has given rise to the American present.
These are the questions that the book tries to address.
So, the question of whether the death penalty works is an interesting and an important one.
A sociologist would say any institution that's continually re-energized and re-enlivened
by a political power being channeled into it, or by resources being used for it, must be serving some function.
It doesn't just continue because of inertia.
It's continually renewed and continually energized, and we see that in the political process here.
So, it seems to be serving some function.
On the other hand, these functions are not, I think, the standard criminal justice ones.
I mentioned already the idea that the death penalty deters potential murderers seems unlikely.
It's so uncertain and so rarely used.
The idea that it delivers retribution or justice, again, is uncertain and delayed, and justice delayed is justice denied.
The idea that it incapacitates murderers, certainly that's true, but life imprisonment without parole,
which is now available in every one of the death penalty states, can also incapacitate murderers more or less effectively.
So, these ways of the death penalty working seem implausible to me.
On the other hand, the death penalty does other kind of work.
It works to energize political majorities.
It works to provide a kind of sign; a politician who supports the death penalty
is tough on crime or responsive to majority preference.
It works to provide the media and the culture industry with a kind of added drama and suspense and morality play
that criminal events and criminal trials typically don't have in the this country.
The fact that there could be a death penalty imposed is really very useful for everybody concerned.
It kind of; it adds a kind of intensity and suspense and drama to an otherwise routine sentencing event.
So, for a variety of reasons, in addition, juries and prosecutors and even police
like to have the death penalty in their repertoire to kind of mark the seriousness of the offense.
And maybe if you're a prosecutor, to win plea bargains. And even to win cases.
So, for a variety of actors, there are uses to which the death penalty can be put.
But that's not for a moment to say that for the society as a whole, the death penalty serves any useful function.
If we got to a situation where a majority of states in this country did not use the death penalty;
did not have the death penalty, and the tendency was for them to abolish, and that the Supreme Court
was looking at a fact, which is that the death penalty, as executed, has become a southern, regional phenomenon,
with real problems of fairness and discrimination attached, and maybe even problems of innocence,
with people being put to death who aren't guilty,
I could, under these circumstances, see the Supreme Court of the USA saying the death penalty law
is cruel and unusual and unconstitutional and abolishing it for that reason.
But I think we have to get to a trend toward majority state abolition
before the Supreme Court felt comfortable doing so.
Vera Institute of Justice, Vera Voices Podcast Series
Neil A. Weiner, Research Speaker Series, presents: David W. Garland, Arthur T. Vanderbilt,
Professor of Law, Professor of Sociology
www.vera.org, Research Department, www.vera.org/research