YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,325 lines · added Nov 14, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: I see this is largely,
but of course not exclusively a female class,
and I know that's because of the reputation of the class as
being very tough on men.
What have we learned about men so far?
They're violent, they contribute only a speck of
protoplasm to the next generation, they help hardly at
all in child rearing.
In the Tuesday reading you found that they're even afraid
of their wives, and on Thursday how many of you
did the reading about the Na?
What do they believe about man's role in reproduction?
Student: Gardening.
Prof: Just do gardening, they just water it.
That the baby comes totally from the woman's substance and
men just have to water it occasionally.
As you know water is water, is water so it doesn't matter
which man waters it, and they have a very
promiscuous sexuality.
Feeling very sorry for the males, and I don't want them to
go through too much of an ego crush,
I have to tell you that some cultures indeed give credit to
males in all of this.
In particular, the Barre tribe of Venezuela,
who are one of the isolated tribes in the Venezuelan Amazon,
and they believe that a woman's body is just a vessel and that
men do all the work of reproduction.
The only limitation--the very first act of sex must be between
husband and wife.
They have marriages but the first copulation has to between
husband and wife because that plants the seed,
and it's very important that the seed belong to the husband.
Once he has planted the seed the growing fetus is not done
with male need, so the fetus obviously has to
be nourished, it's keeping to grow has to get
the nourishment.
It doesn't get the nourishment from the mother,
it gets it from semen.
The fetus needs a constant contribution of semen all along
to make it grow.
The Barre claim that this is very hard work for men to
support a pregnancy.
They have to have sex all the time to do this and the women
are worried about wearing out their poor husbands.
Now this is not just this cultural-- just dreaming stuff
up, this has real empirical basis and the Barre say,
'look it's obvious, women grow fat during the
pregnancy, while men they grow thin from
all their work,' so they have good reasons for believing what
they do.
What's the solution?
Well they ask other men to help.
The husband--they don't want to wear out their husband,
he's got to do a lot of stuff.
They ask other men to help, and it's strange,
even though it is such hard work, the men seem quite willing
to pitch in and help.
It's very nice, it's very heartwarming that men
can, at least temporarily, stop all this male/male
competition and help another guy when his wife needs a little
nourishment.
When we get to discussing the reproductive biology that
relates to abortion much later in the course,
you will find that actually Western scientific knowledge
does not go much beyond what the Barre understood until about
1840 and well into the nineteenth century.
That's--until then what--how a fetus was formed,
what the male contribution was, what the female contribution
was, was a big hot argument.
Some thought it was all woman, some thought it was all male,
and they just had no idea.
Human fertilization was not discovered until 1840 in the
West.
We were having the same argument that the Barre do.
Furthermore--anybody know approximately how long it takes
if a human couple wants to get pregnant how long it takes on
average?
It's more like five months.
You'll hear--again when we discuss abortion you'll hear the
reasons for that.
Actually, in that five months, the husband gets the first
copulation, but thereafter a lot of guys
have to help, so by the time five months
rolls around, the average for getting
impregnated, an awful lot of guys have had
their seed in there.
Again, in actuality, paternity is totally uncertain.
That is it comes right back to the chimp story that the
community hangs together, one reason because no one knows
anything about paternity.
Okay, last time I was describing how all cultures have
mechanisms so that families in fact only have about half as
many children of which they're biologically capable.
Remember we did this calculation and we found this 69
number and so forth.
I was in the middle of a story and actually it's in your
reading.
It's reading for last Tuesday about the Mae Enga of New
Guinea.
They believe, the males and females both
believe, that the sexual fluids and odors and emanations from
women are dangerous and even lethal to men.
Hence, the men are terrified of having sex with the women.
Now you read this in your reading and you may again throw
it off as just one of these cultural practices of primitive
people, and that's not the way you
should approach this class.
You should--on the other hand ask how does such a practice
arise?
What are its roots?
How does it help their culture to survive?
The theory being that most of the things that people are doing
have some role in helping them in a difficult world.
As you know, in chimps as in most human
societies, they're exogamous,
that instead of the male going out to mating,
the males stay together in one community,
and the females go out to mating.
The same is true with the Mae Enga, and females transfer
groups.
Also we know that, as in chimps,
in New Guinea each of these tribes is always at constant
warfare with their neighbors.
They are truly enemies.
When women are exchanged between neighboring communities
they don't travel very far; they'll get killed if they
travel very far, so the only people they know
are the neighboring communities and someone from this community
will marry-- will get a woman from a fairly
neighboring community which means getting a wife from their
enemy.
That's again very similar to the chimp setup.
The Mae Enga are very much aware of this,
as you've read, 'we marry the people we fight,'
and there's a lot of distrust and fear of the enemy wives.
Because of that, the husband does not sleep in
the hut with his wife and children but sleeps in the men's
hut.
It's a male bonding sort of thing rather than a male/female
bonding sort of thing.
Apparently culture has used this distrust of the wife,
this fear of the wife, as a mechanism for restricting
sexual activity.
Of course, the Mae Enga like every other human has
tremendously strong sexual drives but they're living on
very fragile ecological land and they can't overpopulate it,
so they have to have some mechanism of tamping down
reproduction.
This is one of the mechanisms; the men don't even sleep in the
same house with women.
It's a rare event when the women--when they visit the
women, a rare and dangerous event and that keeps the
birthrate down.
Now in the reading, there's a third point that's
very easy to miss because it's just one little phrase and it
talks about how dangerous sex is.
You remember who it says is particularly vulnerable?
The young males are partic--she remembers that.
The young males are particularly vulnerable to these
dangers and so their health will be undermined,
not only by frequent intercourse with women,
but even by frequent contact with women.
Of course the older men are rather immune;
as you grow older you gather immunity to this.
Now we know younger males are driven very much sexually,
older males it cools down somewhat,
and so here's this cultural belief counteracting biology.
It's the inverse of what you would expect.
You would expect the younger men to have a lot of sex and the
older men to sort of tail off on it, but what does it insure?
It insures the control by the older, dominant,
mature men.
Again, it goes right back, it's the Mae Enga;
it can be perceived as the Mae Enga version of dominance
hierarchy in the chimpanzees.
Well there's an extended description of this in the
reading which is wonderful, which I hope you've already
done.
The--so far I've been describing how culture,
communities push fertility up, because,
if you don't get on average eight or so children from each
woman, the culture disappears,
but they also have to push it down because if reproduction
goes too wild the children just die.
I showed you data about inter birth interval can't get too
short or the children just die.
Individuals--that's all from the community perspective so
far--but individuals, and individual families,
they have to adjust these rules.
There's these cultural rules which are usually very strongly
enforced, but individual families
have--each has a different situation and they have to
adjust the rules somehow to cope with their individual situation.
Of course this leads to conflict between what an
individual or an individual family wants and what the
culture says you must do.
One of these examples, I mentioned last time,
is post-partum abstinence, that in many parts for instance
of Africa, after a child is born there
will be three years in which a woman is not supposed to engage
is sex.
Obviously, primarily a mechanism for spacing births,
so that the children stay alive and the woman doesn't get killed
from too much strain on her resources.
Now if you think about that a little bit,
you have a young woman, young husband,
marriage is fairly young generally,
the husband will be a good bit older but still young and he's
facing-- the wife has a kid,
he has a kid, and the wife is face--
the husband now facing three years without any sex.
What is he going to do?
He's going to want to take a second wife or maybe visit a lot
of prostitutes and spend money.
That's something that often the wife--the first wife or second,
or third, or wherever she is in the chain, will not want.
Sometimes she does want that and we'll talk about polygamy
later and why women very often choose to be in polygamous
relationships, but very often she won't want
him to take another wife unless he's got a lot of money he just
won't be able to help more than one wife.
What does she do?
She has to figure out of way of resuming sexual intercourse but
not get pregnant.
What does she use?
Contraception; so surprisingly in Africa,
one of the major reasons for the people accepting
contraception is not a desire to reduce fertility as in most all
the rest of the world, but a desire to resume sexual
relationships without getting pregnant.
She has to do this not only to protect herself because she
knows that if she has children too often she wears out her
body, and there's a reading on
exactly what certain groups in Africa--
one group in Africa considers this wearing out of the body.
Also, if she gets pregnant right away the community knows
that she and her husband have violated the taboo,
and there's very strong social proscriptions against--
proscriptions against violating the taboos,
so contraception which you take privately is sort of the perfect
solution for women wanting to return to sexuality but not to
get pregnant.
Another aspect which we already--I just mentioned of
control of fertility is what I call gerontocracy,
ruled by old folk.
The old folk can monopolize--the older men,
can monopolize the sexual activities of younger women,
and because they're not as vigorous shall we say that
reduces-- is one mechanism for reducing
fertility.
One of the ways which came up in one of the sections is the
idea of bride price.
Dowry is more commonly known is where the wife's family pays the
husband, the husband or the husband's family when the wife
gets married.
The reverse of that is called bride price and it's much more
common then dowry in Africa.
In this case, the man or the man's family,
or the man's side must pay the father of the wife for
the--before he gets the woman.
It's sometimes in the West considered buying the woman but
it really is not a buying situation.
These bride prices can be very high and a young man usually
does not have the money to buy a bride.
Who controls the money of the village?
Who controls the resources?
Why the older men who are the village elders and control
everything.
They dole out very sparingly the bride price to allow men to
get married.
This is like among the Maasai of Kenya, very tall people with
a lot of popular press about that.
And because the young men are not getting married and there's
roughly-- equal numbers of males and
females, that leaves a lot of excess
young girls, fertile young girls,
and who gets them?
The older men go polygamous and they can have several wives,
but remember for every man who has more than one wife that
means there's another man that has no wife whatsoever.
When you read the ethnography of this,
the anthropologists who go in, it's very clear that the young
men are held in a state of sexual frustration and the young
men have ways that they talk to each other,
and they are just on the verge of rebellion.
The strategy of the older guys is to keep these young men just
below that-- keep as much sex for themselves
but keep the young men from getting together and rebelling.
They co-opt what we now were--they co-opt the young guys
when the older more dominant of the younger guys,
when things start to get out of hand a little bit,
we now have bride price, and you can go and get married
and that co-opts him and takes him out of the cabal that might
start a small revolution.
This is all going on subtly, often hidden within these
communities.
These are large--affects this whole polygamist situation.
In much of West Africa almost half of all wives are in
polygamous marriages and that means about half of the men have
no wives whatsoever.
And in the 1920s--so a lot of what I'm describing is
traditional culture and we all know that the whole--
everywhere in the world is changing very rapidly,
but you can't understand where they're going unless you know
where they're coming from.
In the 1920s, 40% of the men got to be 40
years old without having been able to marry,
so that's almost half your population without
"legitimate sexual outlet" until they're 40
years old.
Today, even today, and this is from a few years
ago, the median age of marriage is
still almost 30 and great pressure and power from the
older guys is necessary to maintain a situation like that.
They also leave sort of a pressure valve on this whole
situation that they don't totally suppress the sexual
activity of young men.
They turn a blind eye to a fair amount of prostitution;
that's reasonably accepted, and to "discrete access to
the younger wives of older brothers or even of their
fathers."
Again there's the dominant males who are sort of officially
in charge, but there's a lot of extra stuff going on.
Again, it's the great ape kind of pattern.
Even today, this story of the dominant older males getting the
most sex has by no means disappeared.
Now it gets a little more unpleasant because this control
of population by pre- is very often post-pregnancy.
We've described so far all kinds of pre-pregnancy
mechanisms reducing sex, etc., but women still get
pregnant and very often they or their families decide that they
can't have these children.
A lot of this is post-pregnancy population control and even--and
post-natal also.
Abortion and infanticide are common among--or have been
recently--among almost all human groups.
Different communities and different individual families
have a different amount of resources and they must match,
in some way, match their fertility to the
resources that are available.
This is a very discussed and studied topic in population
circles, so a few years back Karen
Mason, who was president of the Population Association of
America gave a wonderful quote about how people adjust their
family size.
"Parents kill their infants,
abandon them, neglect them in the hopes that
they will die, give them into the care of wet
nurses where they usually die, sell them, give them up for
adoption, marry them off at a young age,
loan them to other families for fostering,
send them into service, or into other households,
send them to the military, the merchant marine,
prostitution, or send them overseas as
migrants."
All of these are very standard mechanisms for individual
families controlling the number of children that they have to
rear.
In Western culture it's certainly not unknown,
the founding myth of Jewish people?
Moses.
What happened to Moses?
He's a baby; he's thrown in the basket,
floated down the Nile.
You go to China, a very standard way of getting
rid of children-- everywhere--every culture that
has a river, babies are put in baskets and
floated down the river as a way of getting rid of them.
Of course the Bible story that the Pharaoh's daughter finds
this baby floating down the river and you can believe that
or not, but obviously,
that sort of behavior of putting a newborn infant in a
basket and floating him down the river was apparently extremely
common at that time, so the story wouldn't have been
surprising.
Student: There is one minor difference.
Moses mother didn't want to kill him, on the contrary,
she wanted him to survive.
Prof: That's the story.
Student: Yeah, because the Pharaoh would have
had him killed otherwise--as all the Jewish boys were killed.
Prof: Yeah, if you read the
original--you're completely correct, if you read the
original story it reads as if 1.
She wanted to keep him alive and Pharaoh was going to kill
them all, and 2.
that she saw the princess sort of on the other side of the
river and thought that the princess would see it,
so you can interpret the story as you want,
but it's a very standard multi--many, many cultures,
cross-cultural mechanism of infanticide and there it
appears.
What is the founding myth of the Roman people?
Students: Romulus and Remus.
Prof: Romulus and Remus; what's the story of Romulus and
Remus?
Student: Raised by a wolf.
Prof: Raised by a wolf, so Romulus and Remus
twins--we'll talk about twins in a moment, left out on a
hillside; standard form everywhere in the
world of abandonment, you know some animal will eat
it, but in this case the wolves didn't eat the babies,
they suckled them and they came up to found the Roman Empire.
Sure, so it's quite interesting how many of the founding myths
have this abandonment story in them.
With respect to twins, for instance,
the Uwa tribe who were very traditional,
isolated people in Columbia and South America,
when they have twins they abandon them in the forest or
toss them into the rivers, and their cultural belief is
that they bring bad luck.
Of course in this situation where a mother is undernourished
she probably is going to have difficulty bringing up one
child, and two is just kind of
impossible.
If she believes, or the culture has sort of over
history figured out that the children are going to die,
one or both of them, then the amount of resources
put into trying to raise a child who you know is going to die
anyway is just not acceptable.
Of course none of this is a conscious calculation.
If you ask the people why they're doing it,
they always give some kind of religious or mystical,
or magical kind of interpretation to this behavior,
but we can see it as one of the mechanisms for having families
limit their fertility to what they think they can cope with.
In addition to controlling the rate of reproduction,
the control of population continues after birth.
We haven't talked about abortion, but during pregnancy
via abortion, we'll get to that later.
Societies are also really very careful about controlling the
number of child bearers and they--
in England, for instance, and we'll talk a little more
about this at a later time, people couldn't marry.
The peasant on somebody's estate could not get permission
to marry unless he had enough property to support a wife and
children.
Very often this meant that he couldn't marry until his father
died.
The father was living in the house and he just had to wait
until the father dies and then he was owner of this property,
then he could take a wife.
Well the father dies when the guy is maybe 40 or late 30s,
and so that cuts down his reproductive potential a lot,
and of course the wife that he marries has not been married up
until then, so her reproductive potential
has also been knocked down.
In many ways, since the fertilit
…

Need subtitles from another video?