YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,288 lines · added Nov 15, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

LOGAN URY: So thank you all for coming.
My name is Logan Ury.
I help lead a team at Google called the Irrational Lab.
We're a behavioral economics unit,
and we work closely with Professor Dan
Ariely, who we're very lucky to have with us today.
And Dan Ariely is the James B. Duke Professor of Psychology
and Behavioral Economics at Duke.
He founded the Center for Advanced Hindsight there.
And he's the author of three "New York Times" best sellers,
including "Predictably Irrational,"
"The Upside of Irrationality," and "The Honest Truth About
Dishonesty."
So we're going to do about 35 minutes of questions
between us, and then we'll open it up to the audience.
So save your questions.
And, Dan, I wanted to start off with a really simple question
that somebody in the audience gave me beforehand,
which is, what do women want?
[LAUGHTER]
DAN ARIELY: What do they say they want
or what they really want?
Um.
Any other questions?
LOGAN URY: We can come back to that.
So based on your knowledge of human decision-making--
DAN ARIELY: By the way, I'll say one thing about this.
It seems like a booby trap to get into this,
but I will say there's some really nice results showing
that what women want in terms of men actually
changes through the menstrual cycle.
And there are times in the month that women
crave more men that are metrosexual
and a time of the month when they
crave men that look more manly.
And you can guess when is each of those.
LOGAN URY: People in the audience
are taking notes on that.
That's great.
So based on your knowledge of human decision-making,
how would you design the perfect date, from the initial messages
to the days after the date?
DAN ARIELY: OK, lots of things to say about an optimal date.
So the first question to ask is, what
is the objective of the date?
And is the date a starting point for something else or is
this the end of the experience?
Let's just assume that we're thinking
about a long-term relationship, and we're
just thinking about the first date
as something that could have a potential long life.
One of the things we know is that the ending
matters a great deal.
So we've done lots of experiments on this,
but the nicest experiment is an experiment on colonoscopy.
So imagine you give people a colonoscopy.
And this is not something people particularly enjoy, right?
So that's not the analogy there.
But you have two types of colonoscopy.
Sorry to give you the details.
But colonoscopy, the unpleasant moment
is where you go around the curve.
So imagine you have a colonoscopy.
It takes half an hour.
And then for some people, you just
leave the probe in their anus for just five more minutes,
but you don't make it painful.
So for some people, you have the experience, unpleasant.
And for some people, you have the experience,
and the last five minutes are just not as bad.
Now it's not a good experience.
Nobody says, oh, give me those five minutes.
But it makes the average of everything else go higher.
Which one of those do you think people prefer?
They prefer 30 minutes of an unpleasant experience
or 30 minutes of unpleasant plus 5 minutes of less unpleasant?
They prefer the second one.
Now that's an indication that the end matters a great deal.
And the end matters a great deal in all kinds of things.
Think about dinner.
How do we end a dinner?
We end it with a dessert.
We end it with something extra.
And how would you want to end a vacation?
You want to end it with a high note,
not getting home and washing everything,
and cleaning, or getting stuck in an airport.
So I think I would start by thinking
about the end of the dating experience.
So that would be one thing.
The second thing is that really, sadly,
our imagination is often better than reality.
So think about something, almost everything.
What is better?
The experience itself or how you can imagine it would be?
We have a tendency to fill in the gaps.
And we fill in gaps in over-optimistic terms.
Actually, we see this a lot in online dating.
People read profiles of people in online dating,
and they fill in the gaps.
And they say, wow, this person likes music,
they must love the kind of music I like.
Fantastic.
And then, of course, they meet for coffee
and get disappointed.
So I would say the last moment is incredibly important.
And on top of that, leaving something to the imagination
would be extra, extra useful.
So that's one thing.
The second thing is, how do you get people to have--
so we talked about the end.
You want the end to be meaningful,
and you want to leave something for the imagination for later.
The other thing is the question, how
do you actually make the discussions meaningful?
So we did this in an online dating setup,
and we got people to-- these were MIT students, so it comes
with all the qualifications.
Anybody here went to MIT?
Yeah, so you know.
So you know the material.
But anyway, so these were MIT undergraduates
who were dating on this date site,
and we just captured their text messages to each other.
And how wonderful do you think their discussions were?
How meaningful?
They were terrible.
They were asking things like, what are you majoring in?
And where do you go to school?
And how many siblings?
Now you could say that's what they really want to know.
What really makes a first date interesting
is to go over each other's resume
and exchange those details.
The other possibility is that we actually
don't feel comfortable sharing intimate, useful details
about ourselves.
And what we gravitate toward is the lower common denominator.
So we did another version of this in which we gave people
20 questions.
And we told people, look, you can't ask anything you want.
You have to pick from those 20 questions.
And the other person knew that they could only
pick from those 20 questions.
So if we have a first date, and I start by saying, Logan,
what's your most interesting sexual fantasy?
A little hard to start a discussion
like that because it violates some rules about conversation,
where you expect people to start by saying,
where do you go to school?
But it's really boring, useless stuff
that doesn't promote the relationship in any way.
So we gave people a list of questions,
and we said, these are the only questions you can ask.
And what happened?
Everybody benefited more from those questions.
The people who asked got answers that they cared about.
And the people who answered the question,
it's really much more interesting than saying,
read my resume.
So I think there's another question of,
how do we create a room for a date, that during the date,
we agree in advance not to exchange
meaningless information?
How do you set the tone?
How do you set the rules for that approach?
There's a very nice set of questions in psychology
where they basically came up with a list of 36 questions,
I think, where they said, these 36 questions
help people get to know each other.
The questions themselves are not that crucial.
What is crucial is what they leave out.
So thinking about the date in terms of saying,
how do we make it meaningful?
And then the final thing, I would say,
is that, what are you really trying to get out of a date?
You're trying to get a glimpse of that person.
And some of it comes from direct questioning and answering,
the interview process.
But some of it comes from getting people
to interact in the world.
Imagine you could go on a date with somebody
in an empty room with nothing around.
How much would you learn about that person versus if you
went together to a concert?
And there's lots of other people around,
and vendors, and noise, and things
happen that are unexpected.
How much would you be able to learn in a slightly
non-mediated, non-clear way?
You would actually understand that person
in a much better way.
So thinking also about what's the environment that
could maximize how much you're going to learn
about that person is important.
LOGAN URY: Thank you.
So what about before and after the date?
Is there any research that says people should play hard to get?
That's a question that my friends ask me all the time.
DAN ARIELY: Yes, absolutely.
Playing hard to get is a good recipe.
So you know the term cognitive dissonance, right?
So the original research in cognitive dissonance
looked at the following.
Festinger got people to a room, and he said, please
screw this bolt for an hour.
And people screwed this bolt for an hour.
And then he paid some people $1 for this, very low.
Some people, $20, very high.
And then he basically tried to get them to recommend
this task for other people.
Now if you got $20 for this, what do you say to yourself?
This was an unbelievably boring task.
I got paid a lot.
Perfectly fine.
What do you say if you got paid $1?
You say, I got paid $1.
This was unbelievably boring.
Those things don't fit.
Now can you change the fact that you got paid $1?
No, that's a fact.
So what do you do?
You change your perception of the boringness.
This idea of cognitive dissonance
is it's uncomfortable for us to live
with two ideas that don't fit.
So you say, I got paid $1.
This was boring.
I don't like living with this dissonance.
So let me think about this task as being more interesting.
And now I feel more likely to recommend it to other people.
So think about it in the same way.
You're going on a date, and you work hard for it.
What do you say to yourself?
You say, I'm working very hard for it,
and this person is not worth it.
It doesn't work as well.
So the moment you work harder for somebody, for something,
you can't change that fact.
You change your opinion that this person is actually
worth more.
You have to explain to yourself, why did I try so hard?
Why did I try so hard for such a long time?
And the only solution you have is to say this person
must be amazing.
So you convince yourself that this person is amazing.
So this is kind of a justification
for playing hard to get.
Now there's probably a limit.
But I think that making things too easy are not worthwhile.
There's another more recent research on showing effort.
Do you want to say something about this?
LOGAN URY: Sure.
So Michael Norton, who's a professor at Harvard Business
School, did some research showing
how do people like to see the search results for a travel
website.
So you would think I like to see them as quickly as possible.
But he actually had a condition in which you saw it
instantaneously, you saw it with a progress bar,
or you saw it with a progress bar that said,
we're now searching thousands of websites,
including Orbitz, and United, and American Airlines.
And people actually preferred that third one
because they thought that the, quote, "algorithm"
was working harder for them.
So we like when things are harder but show effort.
DAN ARIELY: So it's not just the hard,
but that we understand the effort that goes into it.
So when you think about relationships,
and you take two people in a relationship, and you ask them,
from the total 100% of the relationship,
how much work do you do, and how much work do you do?
These numbers never sum up to less than 100.
It's always more than 100%.
And why is it?
It's because we see all the details of what we do.
I take the trash.
My goodness, this is a 17-step process,
takes a really long time, really involved.
My wife, she pays the bills.
That has to be very simple.
And the lesson from this is you really
want to be more like Kayak in every aspect of your life.
You want to come home to your significant other,
and you want to say, I'm searching United,
I'm searching.
Here's all the things I've done for our relationship today.
And it's not about lying or exaggerating,
but it's really about making the effort
that you put in clear to the other person as well.
LOGAN URY: It also works for roommates,
I've recently discovered.
Yeah.
So something that I've thought about for a long time
is we're now in this age of Tinder.
And you go on your phone, and there's--
DAN ARIELY: I'm not.
LOGAN URY: --seemingly limitless amount of people.
And you think your soulmate is just one swipe away.
So with what you know about the paradox of choice,
how should we optimize for happiness
in this age of Tinder?
DAN ARIELY: And it's not just the paradox of choice.
So imagine two principles.
The first one is the grass always looks greener.
OK, let's take a step back.
When you get to know somebody better,
what are some of the first things you learn about them?
That they disappoint you in all kinds of ways.
So this is true in visual illusion.
If you take pictures of people, and you blur them out,
and you make them fuzzy, everybody
looks more attractive.
As you get into the little details of life,
you start seeing wrinkles.
And it's true in visual perception,
and it's also true in life.
When you look at people in general terms,
you only see the good things in them.
This, by the way, is not just about romantic attraction.
When companies hire CEOs, and they hire CEOs
from outside the company, they often have high expectations
from them.
But when you look at the results,
the results show that they pay way more to external CEOs
than internal ones, and they perform worse.
But when you look at an external one,
it's very easy to say, oh my goodness,
this person is just great.
Because you don't know the little details.
So if you look at somebody you don't know very well,
all the little annoying habits that they have
are just going to be outside of scope for you,
and you will just imagine that they all work well.
Only when they move in, you get to see those details.
So imagine a world in which, when you look at other people,
they look more green, or they look
more glorious than when you get to know them
in all the details.
And now you're in bed next to somebody,
and you wake up in the morning, and you say,
is this what I want for the rest of my life
when I have other options here?
And this is the Tinder, your phone is here.
And basically, all of those things, all of those options
look so wonderful.
By the way, also, in online dating, or Facebook,
whatever it is, people only present their positive sides.
So you have this biased idea that the outside option,
the set of the outside options, looks so promising.
And now, you wake up next to somebody
or you have a little fight with somebody,
and you think to yourself, in one click,
I could have a date with somebody else.
Now imagine that you have an apartment.
And you have a deal with the landlord
that the lease is day-to-day.
And every morning, you wake up and you say,
do I want to extend this lease or not?
And every day, your landlord will
decide if they want to extend that lease or not.
How much would you invest in the apartment?
Would you paint the walls?
Would you get flowers?
Would you fix the walls?
Would you do all kinds of things?
Of course not.
Because you're always with one foot outside.
And I think that that's really the issue.
It's not just the existence of Tinder, but this idea.
So the analogy is that you wake up
next to your romantic partner every morning, and you say,
should we do it for another day or should we stop now?
The moment you think in the short-term horizon, the odds
that you will invest in a relationship
is much, much lower.
And there's actually a beautiful research
by Dan Gilbert and Ebert.
They got undergrads to take a photography class.
And at the end of the two-week photography class,
they say, hey, you took lots of pictures, pick one,
and we'll send this one picture to England to be developed.
It'll be back here in two weeks.
That's it.
The other group, they said the same thing, but they said,
look, we're going to send it to England for two weeks.
It'll come back.
But during those two weeks, you can change your mind.
In fact, even when the picture comes back,
you can change your mind.
So the picture came back after two weeks.
Of course, they didn't really send it to England,
but they came back.
And then they say, do you change your mind?
Nobody changed their mind.
But how much did people like their pictures?
The people who committed to the pictures loved them.
The people who were still, all the time, saying, yes,
I know I committed to the picture,
but there's all kinds of other pictures,
should I change my mind, and so on, actually liked them less.
So the thing that worries me is that when
we're in a relationship but continuously with one foot out,
and continuously thinking about how the outside world is
more tempting, and more interesting, and so on,
it's actually not a good recipe for investing
in a relationship.
And the relationship gets better when you--
it's not a zero-sum game.
It gets better when you invest in it.
And if you don't think you're there for a long time,
the likelihood of investment is just not that high.
LOGAN URY: So that's a great segue
into something I wanted to talk about,
which is how do you choose who you should settle down with?
And maybe you could apply this to the secretary problem.
DAN ARIELY: So my preference for all of you
is to choose randomly.
It's the best for experimental research.
We haven't been able to do this experiment.
So you know the secretary problem, right?
The secretary problem is a classic problem
in operation research.
And the idea is that living without the secretary is tough.
These were the days when people had secretaries.
But let's say living without an assistant is tough.
Every day, you have lower utility for the day
because you have to do more yourself.
And you interview people.
And you interview people one a day, they just arrive.
You can't interview them all at once.
And if you delay the hiring, you suffer
because you spend time on hiring,
and you don't have a secretary in the middle.
But if you choose very early, somebody who's not great,
you might be missing on somebody great down the line.
And actually, there's an optimal solution for that.
Because what you really want to do is you
want to sample secretaries for a while
until you figure out the distribution
of quality of people out there in the world.
And then the moment you hit somebody
who passed that threshold, you should adopt them
because there's opportunity cost.
And the big insight from that problem is opportunity cost.
So what would you rather do?
Let's say you're a woman, and you're trying to date a man.
And let's say that men are on one scale between 0 and 10.
And one day, you meet somebody who's 8 and 1/2.
Do you say yes?
Or do you say let me search for somebody else?
In the secretary problem, the assumption
is if you throw somebody out, you can never get them back.
And you keep on sampling.
And what we see happening is that people don't take
opportunity cost into account.
So what you need to think about is,
how much do you enjoy life in the search
process versus how much do you enjoy life when you're dating?
Hopefully, the dating one is better than without it.
But assuming this is the case, there's
also a cost for opportunity cost.
Delaying this process by three years also has a cost.
People don't take the cost into account.
So there is an equation of how to figure it out.
I'm not sure people should go exactly with this equation.
But I do think that we need to be a bit more
aware of the opportunity cost and about the almost
on-going misery-- for some people-- of being alone,
and how we take that into account as well.
Plus, I'm speaking for all men, I
think women should just lower their standards a little bit.
LOGAN URY: So speaking of lowering standards,
what's some of the best and worst dating advice
that you've ever heard?
DAN ARIELY: The best and worst dating advice.
LOGAN URY: It could also be for relationships or marriage.
DAN ARIELY: I'm not sure if it's a bit of advice.
OK, here's an advice-- ask your mother
about the person you're dating and your best friends.
You see, when we fall in love with somebody,
we're infatuated.
It's an amazing feeling.
And when we have this amazing feeling,
we feel this euphoria and attraction.
And we think this person is everything about our lives,
and we can't imagine that anything will ever
be different.
The sad real
…

Need subtitles from another video?