YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,189 lines · added Nov 17, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

KAREN MAY: It is my absolute pleasure today
to introduce you to Jeffrey Pfeffer.
And Jeff is a professor at Stanford
and an author/co-author of 14 books, another one,
I understand, in the making-- so 14 and 1/2 books.
And so he's got lots and lots of areas of expertise,
and we're here today to talk about his latest
book, "Leadership BS," which is nothing, if not catchy,
as a title.
I am Karen May.
I lead our People Development Team here at Google,
and I know we're joined not only by folks in the room
here today, but also by a number of folks
in other locations via live stream.
So welcome all of you.
And I shared briefly with Jeff a little bit of an
and embarrassing fact, which is I don't read
very many leadership books.
And I tend to read the first chapter
and feel like I kind of got the point
and maybe read like the first paragraph
of the rest of the chapters.
There tends to be a certain sameness.
And so I left about that much time
to read this book, which is no offense.
But what I found when I started reading
is I kind of put my feet up on the couch and leaned back
and slowed down, and I said, oh, this is very interesting.
This is really different, and so I was so pleased
that I had the opportunity to directly ask
you questions because it was a very thought-provoking book.
And I know we can't assume today the you've all
had the chance to read it yet.
I imagine many of you will following our conversation
because you too will be very intrigued.
So I'd like to just start off with the first question, which
as I shared with you, I'm very curious because you've
written at least two books in one, maybe
three with this book.
And two of the themes that you wove together--
one is essentially, excuse my paraphrase here-- you
can correct me you like-- is that the things that we say
we want in our leaders are not necessarily the things that we
get in our leaders, nor are they necessarily the things that
are rewarded in our leaders.
So we have a disconnect.
Similarly, we have a multi-billion dollar leadership
development industry, which claims
to help people develop into that former set of things
that we say we want in our leaders,
and yet it doesn't do a good job of that.
And so you have commentary on both of those states of affairs
in this book.
And I'm curious about why you wrote the book
and why you chose to address both
of those important questions together.
JEFFREY PFEFFER: Wow!
KAREN MAY: No softball questions to get us started.
JEFFREY PFEFFER: So I wrote the book
because I was angry, which turns out
to make writing the book much quicker-- you know, emotion,
motivation-- whatever.
I am increasingly frustrated by a combination of things.
Number one, that people who would
take my Path to Power class at Stanford and say to me,
wow, your class is very different,
which I always take as a compliment
because I take anything as a compliment at this point.
You know, they say your class is very different.
It contradicts what we've learned from other leadership
books or what we've learned in other courses at Stanford.
And that was kind of interesting.
And then I am frustrated by the fact
that it's the dirty little secret.
The Stanford Business School is, of course,
very highly selective.
We have extremely, fabulously fantastic students--
probably now the most selective business
school in the country-- hardest to get into.
And in spite of the fact that we are highly selective
and have these brilliantly stunningly wonderful human
beings who come to us, within the first 24
months of their graduation from Stanford, a reasonably
high-- though since nobody has studied it,
I can't give you exact data, but my anecdotal evidence
from talking to a few former students
is that somewhere between 10% and 20% of our students
will be fired within the first two years.
So that's a high percentage, I mean,
because these are highly selective, highly selected,
fabulously fantastic people.
The idea that one of them would be fired let alone somewhere
between 10% and 20% is I think shocking,
and of course, the reason why they're fired
is because they believe the stuff they've
been told in the other classes.
So I think we as an institution are failing.
I certainly in my past with the Power class, I have as one
of the objectives that you should never have
to leave a job involuntarily.
We are preparing you so that you know
how to survive in the world.
That's the second thing.
But the thing that makes me the angriest, of course,
is the enormous amount of hypocrisy.
I can tolerate people lying, cheating, and stealing,
and doing everything else.
It's part of the world, and some of them are actually,
I guess, now running for president.
But in any event, what I don't take very well to
is the hypocrisy.
The people who stand up at Our View From the Top series
or go and write these books and describe
them and their characteristics as a leader,
which bear almost no resemblance to their behavior
and to what they've done.
But many people in the world believe this.
So you can read Rudy Giuliani's book on leadership.
Or you can read-- I'll get myself into plenty of trouble
because this is broadcast, but his name is in the book,
so I mate as well say it-- Bill George,
who is CEO of Medtronic.
And you know, he wrote "True North."
Just a lovely book written with my dear friend
and former student Pete Sims.
And I actually very innocently served on--
not innocently-- served on the board.
I was on board with somebody who had worked with Bill George
at Medtronic, and when "True North " came out, I said, wow!
It must have been great to work with Bill.
The response was, that's not the Bill George who I experienced.
But this is not to say anything about Bill.
I think is typical.
I make a point in chapter 1 of the book to talk about why it
is difficult for people to tell the truth even if they wanted
to, which by the way, in many instances, they don't.
I think memory selective-- we know from studies of recall
of auto accidents or crimes that even if there's no incentive
for you to misremember, memory is imperfect,
and so we're certainly going to have motivated imperfect memory
around what I did as a leader and wonderful I was and how
everybody loved me even if they don't.
By the way, if you want a little test of this,
ask your friends and colleagues about failed relationships.
You get distorted memory there too,
often in a different direction.
So that's why I wrote the book.
The reason why I wove the two themes together
is because I think they're actually-- I
believe they may be related-- that the reason why
we say we want a set of characteristics,
and we don't get them is in part,
I think, because we have a leadership industry that
is living in some mythical world of the shoulds
and the oughts kind of like Sunday school, which is fine.
I have nothing against religion--
or Saturday school or Friday school
depending upon your particular belief.
I have nothing against religion, but I
think we should not confuse aspirational preaching
or lay preaching with social science.
And to me, I think the two pieces are connected.
But the reason why we have done such a lousy job,
manifestly lousy job, of building,
with the exception of Google and my friends at SAS Institute,
who typically rank about in the top five of
places to work list every year.
But for the most part, workplaces are horrible.
All data suggests it's awful.
Employees are disengaged.
Job satisfaction is horrible.
My favorite statistic, which was picked up
in "The Economist" review of this book
last week was "Parade Magazine" in 2012
said, would you rather have a substantial raise
or be able to fire your boss?
And 35% of the people said, fire my boss.
I think leaders are failing and not having a good experience
either.
So the leadership industry has failed,
and I think the disconnect is one, not the only one,
but it's one manifestation of the failure,
so that's why I rolled the two together.
KAREN MAY: So one of the things that you
outline in a sense is we say we want these things
modesty, honesty, transparency, care for others-- those kinds
of things.
And yet those things aren't rewarded.
But there's a glimmer of hope, if you will,
that when done well and not with leaders who
to 100% in those directions.
But leaders who lead well, there's a possibility that it
actually can be both good for the organization
and the leader's career and self-interest,
but that the leaders career, the employees,
and the organization has three different stakeholder groups,
as you will, often create this triangle of tension with
the leader in the middle, and they will solve first
for their career and often second for the organization
because those two tend to be best aligned,
and it's the employees who suffer as a result.
Is that an accurate--
JEFFREY PFEFFER: I think that's quite fair.
KAREN MAY: So if we've got this stakeholder
triangle and the potential of those actually being aligned
to elicit behavior that works for the leader's
career, the organization, and the employees,
how do we begin to shift from a state
where those are unaligned, which reinforces the disconnect,
to one where they become better aligned?
JEFFREY PFEFFER: That was a question
I was going to ask you.
KAREN MAY: I got it out first.
JEFFREY PFEFFER: Since you're a professional in this field.
Well, you know, I'm not 100% sure
that you actually can align it.
It depends upon again what the literature you want to access
and what scholarship you want to access.
But one of the fundamental principles of sociobiology
is that the interests of the individual and the interests
of the group are frequently at odds with one another
because-- so to take an extreme example,
if someone were to roll a live hand
grenade into this room, what's good
for the group is for somebody to throw their body on it,
but that's not what's good for that individual.
And there are many ways in which what
produces individual fitness and what
produces the best outcomes for the group are not aligned.
You want parents to forgo food so
that their children can live.
Or you wan the individuals-- I guess the best example would
be the Donner Pass.
Hopefully, we'll have snow this winter,
but the Donner Party getting stuck
in the thing and some people, I don't
think they volunteered, but anyway,
being eaten by the rest of the Donner Party
so they could survive the travail.
That would be, again, unaligned interest.
I'm not sure that it is possible to completely align
the interests.
And I'm not sure that many of the qualities that we
say we want or not only that, but we don't apparently want--
but I'm not even sure they're even good for people
or whatever.
So one of my favorites is authenticity,
which we can talk about later.
KAREN MAY: Let's do it now.
That was one of my questions too.
Can I interrupt you?
JEFFREY PFEFFER: Sure.
KAREN MAY: The authenticity-- because one
of things that you said that caught my attention
was that authenticity can actually
be bad for an organization.
We all talk about authenticity.
So say a little bit more about when authenticity
becomes problematic or toxic.
JEFFREY PFEFFER: Well, first of all,
like much of the leadership stuff,
if you search for authenticity on my favorite search
engine, which is in fact Google, you
get a billion definitions or a lot of definitions,
many of which are basically like a list of positive attributes
that don't comport to any kind of definition of authenticity
that I would believe.
But if you look at the more fundamentally
scholarly literature of authenticity,
it talks about being true to yourself.
And I don't believe that leaders need to be true to themselves
at all.
They need to be true to what the human beings around them
need and want.
So one of the examples I use in the book-- I
have a dear friend whose daughter
fell in with a bad crowd.
Her boyfriend gave her drugs.
She had an overdose.
Five months later she was dead.
But, unfortunately, she did not die
that night, which would have been better for everybody.
And as he and his wife watched her die,
and I could describe that if anybody wants,
what that process is like to be brain dead
and have your muscles atrophy, and even though most
of the brain is not functioning, the pain of the muscles
contracting-- so there is this poor, basically
unconscious human being, screaming,
and he was this very senior administrator at a university,
and for the first minute or two, or week, or day, or whatever,
people are sympathetic, and they are always, of course,
concerned for him and about him.
But sooner or later, he has to go back to work,
and his team, as much as they love him
and as wonderful as he is, fundamentally, after a while,
they forget it is about, you know,
you need to serve-- you need to serve the group.
We need your energy.
We need your commitment.
We need your emotional involvement.
We need your leadership in the sense of strategic direction
and all these other things.
And I can assure you that there were many days,
there probably still are many days, when he wakes up,
and the last thing he wants to do
is go to work at some higher education university position
because as he said, you lose a child,
it will stay with you all your life.
It is a sadness which is an ineffable part of his soul.
But on the other hand, that's not what you've been hired for.
And you have to show up and do something different.
And the less extreme example, Gary Loveman,
who just stepped down as CEO of Caesars Entertainment,
first time he came to my class because I wrote a case on him,
he was running 101 degree temperature.
He had the flu.
No sentient human being with 101 degree temperature
wants to do four hours of class with me.
So if he's being true to himself,
I want to be home in bed.
But part of the job of a leader is to convey--
and he would do this when he would show up at his casinos--
more important than my class.
As he said once to my class in a video which I've seen so often
now it's memorized, people need your energy.
They need your physical energy.
They need your intellectual energy.
They need your emotional energy, and they need your energy
even if at that moment in time you've got marital trouble
or your children are acting up, or you don't feel well.
People need your energy, and so the idea
of being authentic to yourself seems a little too
self-centered.
You show up at the leadership role,
you have a responsibility to the people you're being led by.
And so part of the skill of being a leader is the ability,
I think, to act in ways that you're not necessarily
feeling at the time.
I may be tired.
I may be depressed.
I may be distracted.
But in terms of getting the job done,
I have to show up in a fully present, engaged,
energetic way.
Does that make sense?
KAREN MAY: It does.
It does.
So it comes, in a sense, back to the definition of authenticity
and also to one of the points you make about the leadership
training industry is we sort of glamorize
and perhaps exaggerate these traits
so that authenticity means being completely
and utterly vulnerable and open at all times.
JEFFREY PFEFFER: And being true to your wants and needs.
KAREN MAY: Right.
Being true to your own wants and needs
versus a more realistic definition, which
might have to do with evaluating what your team needs from you
or what your organization needs from you,
checking to make sure you're not violating fundamental values,
and defining authenticity on a longer-term scale
than in the moment, how am I doing?
But what's the connection for me there
is when our industry defines things
in an unrealistic way or an idealistic way,
we set a standard that's unrealistically high,
and that then becomes something that people can't achieve,
and that exaggerates perhaps the gap that already exists.
JEFFREY PFEFFER: I think that's right,
and also we presume-- authenticity
is an interesting thing because it presumes
you need to be true to your authentic self,
but which authentic self?
Your authentic self when you were 18 months old?
One of the other stories is my favorite example
is my dear friend Alison Davis-Blake.
I like to say I knew Alison Davis-Blake before she
was hyphenated.
I knew where she Alison Davis and was probably the world
shyest doctoral student that you could ever possibly imagine--
could hardly speak up in class.
If she spoke up, you would not know because you couldn't hear.
And she is today dean of the-- she is just stepping down
as dean of the Ross School at the University of Michigan.
And she's probably going to go on
to be a provost or a university president,
and if you talk to Alison, she will tell you--
she's still-- I don't think she did a personality
transplant or something.
She's still basically an introvert.
But she said to be an introvert, define it, I don't know,
whatever, to be true that.
She said, I figured out after a while
that the behaviors associated with that label,
being introverted, was not very useful for my career.
I was not going to be able to be a dean
or president or an associate dean or probably even
a functioning teacher if I was going to be that shy so nobody
could hear me.
And so I believe, which is one of the themes of the class I
teach, is that human beings-- you
don't have to change who you are,
but you need change your behaviors,
and we can all learn and adopt behaviors that make
us better able to function.
So she's a fabulous public speaker.
She's obviously been extremely successful,
and she will be a provost or a university president
of a major university.
And if you had known her in 1986, if you there
had been a list of 1,000 people who
was going to be a dean or university president,
she would have been last on the list.
And this is partly in her case, saying to herself,
I will re-invent myself.
I will develop skills and resilience and toughness
that I never thought I had.
And that's just perfect.
KAREN MAY: So the self evolves, and we
need to allow space for that.
Many of the examples in your book
focus on CEOs kind of the senior level executive who
might hypothesize are more subject to the tension
in the stakeholder triangle, if you will, than some others.
But I'm curious because you spoke mostly about them.
Do you see the same disconnect kind
of all levels of leaders and managers?
Or does it get worse at top?
JEFFREY PFEFFER: Well, no, actually I
think it's easier at the top because most people at the top
are particularly not at the top because they
are company founders.
But they've worked their way up.
They've overcome anything that worries them
about except their own careers in case
you haven't been reading the newspaper about people who are
pretty much self interested.
Many of the studies that I cite are
studies of people throughout the career course.
The effect of narcissism on career success
has been studied at the level of presidents,
but it's also been studied at the levels of selection
and to the officer ranks in the military.
So I think this holds throughout the career.
And I see you have coming or somebody told me
that you have coming my good friend Adam Galinsky-- "Friend
and Foe."
And that is a different kind of issue
but a another kind of tension because people are both friends
and foes in the same time.
In organizational hierarchies, you
are both peers and competitors.
So you have to collaborate and cooperate at the same time.
That's right.
You have to look out for the organization's interest.
To some extent, you have to look out for your own interests.
My dear friend Joe Podolny, who works
for a company you may have heard of called Apple.
You know, when I wrote the book before this,
"Power," he and I met at Apple-- the food's not as good as here.
But in any event, we had this wonderful discussion
in which he said, you basically are telling people
that they need to take care of themselves.
I said, well Joel, you haven't been at Apple for all that
long.
But 30 or 40 years ago in the Silicon Valley
there became a mantra, and I don't
know if this is true of Google, but I suspect it is,
and the mantra th
…

Need subtitles from another video?