Advertisement
English transcript
[MUSIC PLAYING]
KEVIN VLK: Hello, everyone.
Welcome to Talks at Google.
I'm Kevin Vlk.
And today I'm very excited to have JR here.
So let's welcome him.
[APPLAUSE]
JR: Thanks, Kevin.
Thank you, everybody.
KEVIN VLK: So you have your directorial debut
of your new film short film, "Ellis."
Can you talk to us about what the film is about?
JR: Yes.
It's a short film about this quite amazing place
on Ellis Island where 12 million immigrants came
through to America on the east coast.
And half of the island has actually never been seen.
And it's abandoned since more than 80 years now,
since they closed out.
And when I discovered that place,
I just wanted to paste some image, which
is most of what I do.
I take photos that I repaste on walls.
But in this case, it was photos from the time, archived,
that I find of immigrants arriving there.
And then I wanted to film this place
because I knew that it would decay and decay.
And maybe one day, no one would ever see it again
because it would disappear.
And already since we've filmed-- and you
can see the trailer online, actually-- a lot of those rooms
have fell down so are not visible anymore.
So it's the story of an immigrant that
got stuck there, like a lot of people at the time who would
make it there but would never make it
to the other side of the water, which is crazy,
After, like, two, three months of travels,
they would get to the island right in front of their goal.
And yet, they had to go back.
And Eric Roth wrote it brilliantly.
And we made a [INAUDIBLE] two day story.
And when we started working on that a year and something ago,
we didn't know that it would connect to the largest crisis
right now since the Second World War.
So it's a special time to release such a piece.
KEVIN VLK: Yeah.
And it stars Robert De Niro.
And it was written by Eric Roth.
And so how did you bring them and why
did you decide to bring them to the project?
JR: That was the only actor that I could find.
[LAUGHTER]
JR: The only one.
JR: And they send me their curriculum vitae.
And I said, all right.
You know, Robert De Niro never done any short film before,
which is true, actually.
He never made any shorts.
So I went, OK.
I'm going to give you your first debut.
No, but to be serious, he was a great help in the project.
And when I mentioned that I was working on Ellis Island,
he said, oh, great.
But then I was like, maybe I would love that, somehow, you
jump in for a minute.
And if, by chance, I have a camera filming,
you know, then you might star in my film.
He laughed about it.
And he said, look, if you write it properly
and you get a writer for that-- and that's
how we got in touch with Eric Roth-- who [INAUDIBLE].
So he right away jumped in the project and started writing.
And then by the time we were ready, it was winter.
And we were like, that's actually
the perfect time to film it.
What we didn't know is that there would be a crazy storm
and that'd make it so much magical.
Because we couldn't bring any equipment there.
We had no rights to change the light whatsoever.
And as much as it's decaying, it's also a protected monument.
So they were really careful about any stuff bringing there.
So we got lucky with the light, also.
KEVIN VLK: And when writing this--
with having Eric write this and the story,
was it based on any particular story?
Or was it just kind of done through all the research?
JR: So Eric Roth did an incredible job going
through a lot of research.
And we also went through contemporary research
of people who just got here.
And we've been emailing back and forth about stories
that we hear in the media that we hear from people we knew.
And I guess all of it made this film possible.
KEVIN VLK: And this was commissioned
by the Ellis Island Hospital.
And so is it somewhat of a permanent expression.
JR: The pasting, yes.
They kind of commissioned it at some point, saying, OK.
We'll keep it there forever, until the building fell.
And people can actually go and visit.
You have to log in for the hard-hat tour.
And you put a hard hat and two guys go with you.
And you can actually visit that space.
But the film, we completely self-financed it,
completely independently.
But it was the first time they actually authorized anybody
to film there.
So I hope this stays also as a documentation of how
the space is and was for some of the places that
are disappearing.
KEVIN VLK: And this is your first time as a director.
So what was that like going from-- because you've
written books and you've done films before.
But you'd never directed one.
So how is that, going from behind a still camera
and to a live action camera?
JR: I mean, I was not afraid of the camera,
especially that there was no one in the buildings
for most of the time.
But directing my first actor was definitely a challenge.
And when it's Robert De Niro, it also
makes it a little bit more difficult.
But he's been an incredible inspiration and help
on this project, and guiding me, also,
on how much we would need to put in the film.
And he'd help, also, on the script.
So I was well-guided, let's say.
But it was definitely a moment of learning.
And it still is.
That's why I love collaborating with artists and people that
know much more in their field than I
do so that in the process, I get to learn, also,
about all these things.
And this was definitely an incredible experience.
KEVIN VLK: And your career really
was started on the streets of Paris.
And you kind of took this whole idea
of taking almost the graffiti and street art
into a whole different realm and a whole different world.
So what inspired you to do that?
And what are some of the boundaries
that you face in terms of-- because a lot of it's illegal.
So did any of that really scare you?
Or was it just you felt like this message needed to be told?
JR: Yeah, I mean, pasting photos in the street
doesn't sound like a crime when you say it like that.
In some countries, it isn't.
In some others now, I'm welcome in the biggest museum.
And at the same time, in other places, it's still a crime.
But that's always been the case since I
started when I was 17, 18.
It's just that now you have this whole movement of street art.
And it's a little bit less seen as vandalism
than it used to be.
For me, it's always been trying to enter
another world and many worlds that we don't know about.
So I always wait for someone to tell me, no,
that art doesn't belong here.
We don't want that.
And I started traveling because of my art in tons of places.
And I would go in places that I've heard only
through the media, that I've never
been to like Liberia or Sierra Leone or Kenya, Brazil.
And I would, of course, ask the community,
because I didn't have any authorization if I could work
there, expecting someone to tell me for a good reason
or not that it was not possible.
And I never encountered that.
People were like, no, let us help you.
Where do you want to paste?
How should we do it?
Maybe we should do it this way because it
makes more sense for us.
And slowly, I would see how the communities were actually
engaged themselves in.
And that was really the beginning of a change for me
of realizing how much a community was involved.
And so how much more could I get them involved?
So I started a project where I actually wouldn't travel there.
But I would ask them to take the photo.
And I would send it to them.
So suddenly, in a year, we would do thousands of cities
but not about what I believe should be right,
about what the people in their own community
believe is important to them.
And so while this project is running,
I've started working on other projects.
And in this case, I knew that there was something--
that immigration has always been a subject.
It was 100 years ago, and it will be in 100 years.
And we all come from somewhere.
I just thought that trying to see and understand
better our past was a good way to understand
what's going on right now and maybe face our future.
And Ellis Island, here in America,
it rings a bell to how America got built.
But in Europe, some people know about it.
Some don't.
It's more this idea of a gate, you know?
And I went in Sicily, Lampedusa, where a lot of migrants
arrive in.
And you find a lot of similarities
except that this was a place that was not made to be a gate
but that became by itself.
And so it's just interesting to put parallels, especially
with what's going on right now.
KEVIN VLK: Yeah.
You said something that was really interesting,
said about sending them the pictures
and having them send it back and stuff.
So since you started in the mid-2000s,
and now we're in 2015, where technology is completely
evolved, how has that changed how
you do stuff or what kind of projects that you do?
JR: I think I would not do any of what
I do if low-cost flight would have come in,
if digital camera had appeared.
When I started, there was none of that.
But my work evolved widely around the world because
of that, because of technology, because
of the easier way to exchange with everybody,
the social media.
All that stuff really is a big part of my work.
It's not just a place where I just
repost what I do in the street.
It's really something that I gather people,
I connect with people, I find ways to shoot,
to involve, or discover about communities.
So it's really a big part of my process.
And in this film, for example-- it's
not just a film that I'm willing to just show here and there.
It's a film that I want people to organize screenings
instead of just putting it online and trying to get
as much views as possible.
I want, actually, people to get into their community.
And it means anybody through their friends, their family.
We're going to send the film for free to anybody who wants it.
And then they can screen it and make a little decision after.
I think social medias and technology have connected us
all but at the same time disconnected us
all from each other.
All I'm trying to do is use that technology
to reconnect us in physical place.
And for that, it means also disrupting a bit the way
social media, like short films and artworks like that
are normally shown.
KEVIN VLK: It's interesting because it
seems like you are embracing and engaging with people and stuff.
Has it become more difficult to do some of these projects
now, knowing that there is social media
and everyone has a camera in their pocket, where someone
could just be like I'm taking a selfie with JR,
on site while you're trying to do this stuff overnight?
JR: When we paste, it's fine.
Actually, the funniest thing is when we do big pasting,
it's so big that people actually come and be like,
uh, do you guys need a hand?
That's more what happened.
They're like, you guys look like you're not organized at all.
And then people jump in and help.
And we most of the time set up a project where we get a place
and then people start gathering.
And then once they realize-- we just did that this weekend.
We were shooting a piece in New York.
And people in line that waited forever, they're like, yo,
instead of waiting can I just help?
This looks like a bit of a mess, the organization here, there.
And we're like, sure.
And then that's how we get together people.
And then people come with ideas.
We love this making it in the way
and involving people in the process.
KEVIN VLK: You have a three-book series,
which is "28 Millimeter" series-- "Women Are Heroes,"
"Face2Face," and "Portrait of a Generation."
So with the 2007 one, where you have huge portraits of Israelis
and Palestinians, you went around eight different cities
and printed them up on the security fence and the walls
and stuff.
So how did you get that done in that region?
JR: Definitely illegally.
But same thing, I really thought it would not
be-- people remember the wall.
But actually, what impressed me the most
is that it was faces of Israeli and Palestinians
doing the same job.
So two taxi drivers, one's Israeli, one Palestinian.
And we actually pasted them in four Palestinian cities
and four Israeli cities on people's houses.
So it means that it's actually people
who gave their wall to have two faces
that, of course, when we pasted them, created a lot of debate
and who are those people?
And when they realized there was one from each side,
there was always a long silence because nobody
could recognize who is who.
But then after, what people don't understand
is that those photos stayed, and until today.
We're almost 10 years later.
They're still there, for a lot of them.
And those people had to explain that project every day.
I was gone the next week.
But people there had to explain why those photos were
on their wall.
That's what I found extraordinary,
when from here sometimes we feel that there is so much hate
between both sides.
And that project was just a living proof,
that actually people first accepted on both sides
to have the photo of the others on their wall,
but also they actually carried it all those years.
So it could have gone completely wrong, that project.
And I was prepared for that, too.
But I'm actually amazed that it not only one
went really well when we were there,
but also that it kept on going and created so much more impact
after over the years because of those images
that I would have never believed.
There was even a guy that does a lot of tourism that
organized the first Israel-Palestine tour so
that people can go and see by themselves.
They say, go and judge by yourself.
Go and meet both sides.
Don't only go through the political tour that I organize.
But go and visit and make your own opinion.
And they used my images for that.
And I was fine with it because for me,
that people go and judge by themselves
is what we need instead of just taking the information we're
grabbing from here and there.
So that's the first reason why I went there
the first time because I just wanted
to actually see by myself.
And as a foreigner, we actually have the chance
to be able to go on both sides, which they can't do.
KEVIN VLK: We'll be taking some audience questions
here if you guys want to start lining up at the mic.
So in 2008, you did this beautiful series,
"Women Are Heroes," which is part of the "28 Millimeter"
series.
So what inspired you to create this thing that just celebrates
women and just did a beautiful job with portraying them?
JR: I guess when I just did the Middle East,
I wanted to go in other places where there
is no museum, where there is no street art
or anything like that.
And when I traveled to Africa the first time,
I realized that men were really the ones controlling
the street.
And because I work with no tradition except the tradition
from the people, I knew that those men in the street
would be the ones that I'd have to negotiate with.
And I would see that the women were
the pillar of their community and their society.
So I found a way, by photographing women,
to then involve men to paste the photos because there would
be the gates to those walls.
And so that's how the project started and slowly taking
over different communities around the world
and find the same process in all of those places.
KEVIN VLK: Interesting.
And is there a location or a country or a place
where you have not gone to or you have not a piece of work
in?
And is there a place that you want to go but you can't?
JR: I mean, there's many place I haven't been.
But my work has been through the "Inside Out."
They have been in more than-- I don't know how many--
140 countries and tens of thousands of cities.
But you know, I travel really-- like,
if you see on my Instagram, it's kind
of like on the daily basis of where I am.
And that's why I say, hey, we're doing a screening tonight
or a wall here.
And really, most of the time we say the morning for the night.
And sometimes I travel to a place that-- next week,
I'm going to Japan.
And I'm going to places I've never been to.
And I hope-- I'm always curious to visit new places.
So I guess I have time for that.
KEVIN VLK: What was your favorite place to shoot so far?
JR: That's a hard one because there's a lot of places I love.
Working in Brazil was amazing, and that's why in that favela,
we're still working in that same community seven years later.
So in some places, I love, actually, the continuation
of working in the same-- like in the projects of Paris,
in the suburbs, where I started.
10 years later, we're still doing projects there.
And I love that because then you see the impact of the work
and what it means.
You see the same people growing.
I mean, that's what I love because the pastings are
ephemeral.
But we often underestimate the power of the image.
And the image can become timeless.
KEVIN VLK: And you mentioned this-- in 2011,
you won the TED Prize.
And then with that money, you started
the "Inside Out Project."
So can you tell us about that?
JR: Yeah, I mean, the TED speech was for me
a hard exercise in the way that you have to combine
all your ideas in 20 minutes.
But it was an easy thing because I
had only people in suits in front of me and shirts.
Where when I had to explain my work in Liberia,
I had people with machetes.
So it was much easier to explain on the west coast.
But I was really impressed at how the speech then
went and went viral.
And then people got to understand the connection
between one work to another.
And that actually was a big step for me
because I was often in the shadow of the work.
And for once, I just wanted to explain the different links
between them.
And I guess I would re-do it one day.
KEVIN VLK: Audience questions?
AUDIENCE: I was just wondering if you could explain
your process of when you narrow down
the images for your pastes?
What are you looking for when you choose that image?
And then, just on average, how many
do you go through to get to that image you're looking for,
those images?
Thanks.
JR: You mean for Ellis Island, for example?
AUDIENCE: For Ellis Island or just in general.
I guess the Ellis Island's a little bit more different
because you're going through archived works
versus current images.
JR: Yeah.
Well, you know, I don't shoot that much.
I paste much more than I take photos.
So when I take a portrait of someone,
it doesn't take me long, just a couple of minutes.
And I know right away when there is an expression-- you see it
in the photo, when there is just this expression
that, OK, that's an honest one.
There's pure energy in there.
So generally, when I see I have that, I
just-- I feel almost bad taking photos of people.
So then when I know I have it, I have it
because in a lot of the countries that we're going,
people couldn't believe that I was coming back to paste them.
And even if I was explaining them and showing them
books of my previous project, still,
when we were coming back, they were, like, oh, I never
thought that you would come back, where for me that's
the whole base of the work.
And then on Ellis Island, there hadn't
been that many photos taken at the time.
So I went through the archive, and there's still a couple
hundred photos, and selected the ones that I cannot reflect
myself in or the story of my family of the stories of what I
was seeing right now in the media.
And I guess you compare both images with today's, and you
still feel the same energy in them.
KEVIN VLK: An interesting thing, just to follow up on that,
was you had to use archival photos in Ellis Island.
So that was interesting.
So how'd you get access to all that?
And also, just kind of going off that, too,
when you're working with these people trying
to get this-- you talk about you want that genuine, you
want that real expression.
How do you get that when you're working with these people?
JR: So on Ellis Island, I just went through the archives.
And they have a great-- actually,
it's in the public domain.
So anybody can use those photos.
When I take the photo myself, I-- I don't know.
That's a good question.
KEVIN VLK: [INAUDIBLE].
JR: You know, once I remember I was in South Sudan.
And I really thought that I could never
get those photos because the women I
was about the pho
…
KEVIN VLK: Hello, everyone.
Welcome to Talks at Google.
I'm Kevin Vlk.
And today I'm very excited to have JR here.
So let's welcome him.
[APPLAUSE]
JR: Thanks, Kevin.
Thank you, everybody.
KEVIN VLK: So you have your directorial debut
of your new film short film, "Ellis."
Can you talk to us about what the film is about?
JR: Yes.
It's a short film about this quite amazing place
on Ellis Island where 12 million immigrants came
through to America on the east coast.
And half of the island has actually never been seen.
And it's abandoned since more than 80 years now,
since they closed out.
And when I discovered that place,
I just wanted to paste some image, which
is most of what I do.
I take photos that I repaste on walls.
But in this case, it was photos from the time, archived,
that I find of immigrants arriving there.
And then I wanted to film this place
because I knew that it would decay and decay.
And maybe one day, no one would ever see it again
because it would disappear.
And already since we've filmed-- and you
can see the trailer online, actually-- a lot of those rooms
have fell down so are not visible anymore.
So it's the story of an immigrant that
got stuck there, like a lot of people at the time who would
make it there but would never make it
to the other side of the water, which is crazy,
After, like, two, three months of travels,
they would get to the island right in front of their goal.
And yet, they had to go back.
And Eric Roth wrote it brilliantly.
And we made a [INAUDIBLE] two day story.
And when we started working on that a year and something ago,
we didn't know that it would connect to the largest crisis
right now since the Second World War.
So it's a special time to release such a piece.
KEVIN VLK: Yeah.
And it stars Robert De Niro.
And it was written by Eric Roth.
And so how did you bring them and why
did you decide to bring them to the project?
JR: That was the only actor that I could find.
[LAUGHTER]
JR: The only one.
JR: And they send me their curriculum vitae.
And I said, all right.
You know, Robert De Niro never done any short film before,
which is true, actually.
He never made any shorts.
So I went, OK.
I'm going to give you your first debut.
No, but to be serious, he was a great help in the project.
And when I mentioned that I was working on Ellis Island,
he said, oh, great.
But then I was like, maybe I would love that, somehow, you
jump in for a minute.
And if, by chance, I have a camera filming,
you know, then you might star in my film.
He laughed about it.
And he said, look, if you write it properly
and you get a writer for that-- and that's
how we got in touch with Eric Roth-- who [INAUDIBLE].
So he right away jumped in the project and started writing.
And then by the time we were ready, it was winter.
And we were like, that's actually
the perfect time to film it.
What we didn't know is that there would be a crazy storm
and that'd make it so much magical.
Because we couldn't bring any equipment there.
We had no rights to change the light whatsoever.
And as much as it's decaying, it's also a protected monument.
So they were really careful about any stuff bringing there.
So we got lucky with the light, also.
KEVIN VLK: And when writing this--
with having Eric write this and the story,
was it based on any particular story?
Or was it just kind of done through all the research?
JR: So Eric Roth did an incredible job going
through a lot of research.
And we also went through contemporary research
of people who just got here.
And we've been emailing back and forth about stories
that we hear in the media that we hear from people we knew.
And I guess all of it made this film possible.
KEVIN VLK: And this was commissioned
by the Ellis Island Hospital.
And so is it somewhat of a permanent expression.
JR: The pasting, yes.
They kind of commissioned it at some point, saying, OK.
We'll keep it there forever, until the building fell.
And people can actually go and visit.
You have to log in for the hard-hat tour.
And you put a hard hat and two guys go with you.
And you can actually visit that space.
But the film, we completely self-financed it,
completely independently.
But it was the first time they actually authorized anybody
to film there.
So I hope this stays also as a documentation of how
the space is and was for some of the places that
are disappearing.
KEVIN VLK: And this is your first time as a director.
So what was that like going from-- because you've
written books and you've done films before.
But you'd never directed one.
So how is that, going from behind a still camera
and to a live action camera?
JR: I mean, I was not afraid of the camera,
especially that there was no one in the buildings
for most of the time.
But directing my first actor was definitely a challenge.
And when it's Robert De Niro, it also
makes it a little bit more difficult.
But he's been an incredible inspiration and help
on this project, and guiding me, also,
on how much we would need to put in the film.
And he'd help, also, on the script.
So I was well-guided, let's say.
But it was definitely a moment of learning.
And it still is.
That's why I love collaborating with artists and people that
know much more in their field than I
do so that in the process, I get to learn, also,
about all these things.
And this was definitely an incredible experience.
KEVIN VLK: And your career really
was started on the streets of Paris.
And you kind of took this whole idea
of taking almost the graffiti and street art
into a whole different realm and a whole different world.
So what inspired you to do that?
And what are some of the boundaries
that you face in terms of-- because a lot of it's illegal.
So did any of that really scare you?
Or was it just you felt like this message needed to be told?
JR: Yeah, I mean, pasting photos in the street
doesn't sound like a crime when you say it like that.
In some countries, it isn't.
In some others now, I'm welcome in the biggest museum.
And at the same time, in other places, it's still a crime.
But that's always been the case since I
started when I was 17, 18.
It's just that now you have this whole movement of street art.
And it's a little bit less seen as vandalism
than it used to be.
For me, it's always been trying to enter
another world and many worlds that we don't know about.
So I always wait for someone to tell me, no,
that art doesn't belong here.
We don't want that.
And I started traveling because of my art in tons of places.
And I would go in places that I've heard only
through the media, that I've never
been to like Liberia or Sierra Leone or Kenya, Brazil.
And I would, of course, ask the community,
because I didn't have any authorization if I could work
there, expecting someone to tell me for a good reason
or not that it was not possible.
And I never encountered that.
People were like, no, let us help you.
Where do you want to paste?
How should we do it?
Maybe we should do it this way because it
makes more sense for us.
And slowly, I would see how the communities were actually
engaged themselves in.
And that was really the beginning of a change for me
of realizing how much a community was involved.
And so how much more could I get them involved?
So I started a project where I actually wouldn't travel there.
But I would ask them to take the photo.
And I would send it to them.
So suddenly, in a year, we would do thousands of cities
but not about what I believe should be right,
about what the people in their own community
believe is important to them.
And so while this project is running,
I've started working on other projects.
And in this case, I knew that there was something--
that immigration has always been a subject.
It was 100 years ago, and it will be in 100 years.
And we all come from somewhere.
I just thought that trying to see and understand
better our past was a good way to understand
what's going on right now and maybe face our future.
And Ellis Island, here in America,
it rings a bell to how America got built.
But in Europe, some people know about it.
Some don't.
It's more this idea of a gate, you know?
And I went in Sicily, Lampedusa, where a lot of migrants
arrive in.
And you find a lot of similarities
except that this was a place that was not made to be a gate
but that became by itself.
And so it's just interesting to put parallels, especially
with what's going on right now.
KEVIN VLK: Yeah.
You said something that was really interesting,
said about sending them the pictures
and having them send it back and stuff.
So since you started in the mid-2000s,
and now we're in 2015, where technology is completely
evolved, how has that changed how
you do stuff or what kind of projects that you do?
JR: I think I would not do any of what
I do if low-cost flight would have come in,
if digital camera had appeared.
When I started, there was none of that.
But my work evolved widely around the world because
of that, because of technology, because
of the easier way to exchange with everybody,
the social media.
All that stuff really is a big part of my work.
It's not just a place where I just
repost what I do in the street.
It's really something that I gather people,
I connect with people, I find ways to shoot,
to involve, or discover about communities.
So it's really a big part of my process.
And in this film, for example-- it's
not just a film that I'm willing to just show here and there.
It's a film that I want people to organize screenings
instead of just putting it online and trying to get
as much views as possible.
I want, actually, people to get into their community.
And it means anybody through their friends, their family.
We're going to send the film for free to anybody who wants it.
And then they can screen it and make a little decision after.
I think social medias and technology have connected us
all but at the same time disconnected us
all from each other.
All I'm trying to do is use that technology
to reconnect us in physical place.
And for that, it means also disrupting a bit the way
social media, like short films and artworks like that
are normally shown.
KEVIN VLK: It's interesting because it
seems like you are embracing and engaging with people and stuff.
Has it become more difficult to do some of these projects
now, knowing that there is social media
and everyone has a camera in their pocket, where someone
could just be like I'm taking a selfie with JR,
on site while you're trying to do this stuff overnight?
JR: When we paste, it's fine.
Actually, the funniest thing is when we do big pasting,
it's so big that people actually come and be like,
uh, do you guys need a hand?
That's more what happened.
They're like, you guys look like you're not organized at all.
And then people jump in and help.
And we most of the time set up a project where we get a place
and then people start gathering.
And then once they realize-- we just did that this weekend.
We were shooting a piece in New York.
And people in line that waited forever, they're like, yo,
instead of waiting can I just help?
This looks like a bit of a mess, the organization here, there.
And we're like, sure.
And then that's how we get together people.
And then people come with ideas.
We love this making it in the way
and involving people in the process.
KEVIN VLK: You have a three-book series,
which is "28 Millimeter" series-- "Women Are Heroes,"
"Face2Face," and "Portrait of a Generation."
So with the 2007 one, where you have huge portraits of Israelis
and Palestinians, you went around eight different cities
and printed them up on the security fence and the walls
and stuff.
So how did you get that done in that region?
JR: Definitely illegally.
But same thing, I really thought it would not
be-- people remember the wall.
But actually, what impressed me the most
is that it was faces of Israeli and Palestinians
doing the same job.
So two taxi drivers, one's Israeli, one Palestinian.
And we actually pasted them in four Palestinian cities
and four Israeli cities on people's houses.
So it means that it's actually people
who gave their wall to have two faces
that, of course, when we pasted them, created a lot of debate
and who are those people?
And when they realized there was one from each side,
there was always a long silence because nobody
could recognize who is who.
But then after, what people don't understand
is that those photos stayed, and until today.
We're almost 10 years later.
They're still there, for a lot of them.
And those people had to explain that project every day.
I was gone the next week.
But people there had to explain why those photos were
on their wall.
That's what I found extraordinary,
when from here sometimes we feel that there is so much hate
between both sides.
And that project was just a living proof,
that actually people first accepted on both sides
to have the photo of the others on their wall,
but also they actually carried it all those years.
So it could have gone completely wrong, that project.
And I was prepared for that, too.
But I'm actually amazed that it not only one
went really well when we were there,
but also that it kept on going and created so much more impact
after over the years because of those images
that I would have never believed.
There was even a guy that does a lot of tourism that
organized the first Israel-Palestine tour so
that people can go and see by themselves.
They say, go and judge by yourself.
Go and meet both sides.
Don't only go through the political tour that I organize.
But go and visit and make your own opinion.
And they used my images for that.
And I was fine with it because for me,
that people go and judge by themselves
is what we need instead of just taking the information we're
grabbing from here and there.
So that's the first reason why I went there
the first time because I just wanted
to actually see by myself.
And as a foreigner, we actually have the chance
to be able to go on both sides, which they can't do.
KEVIN VLK: We'll be taking some audience questions
here if you guys want to start lining up at the mic.
So in 2008, you did this beautiful series,
"Women Are Heroes," which is part of the "28 Millimeter"
series.
So what inspired you to create this thing that just celebrates
women and just did a beautiful job with portraying them?
JR: I guess when I just did the Middle East,
I wanted to go in other places where there
is no museum, where there is no street art
or anything like that.
And when I traveled to Africa the first time,
I realized that men were really the ones controlling
the street.
And because I work with no tradition except the tradition
from the people, I knew that those men in the street
would be the ones that I'd have to negotiate with.
And I would see that the women were
the pillar of their community and their society.
So I found a way, by photographing women,
to then involve men to paste the photos because there would
be the gates to those walls.
And so that's how the project started and slowly taking
over different communities around the world
and find the same process in all of those places.
KEVIN VLK: Interesting.
And is there a location or a country or a place
where you have not gone to or you have not a piece of work
in?
And is there a place that you want to go but you can't?
JR: I mean, there's many place I haven't been.
But my work has been through the "Inside Out."
They have been in more than-- I don't know how many--
140 countries and tens of thousands of cities.
But you know, I travel really-- like,
if you see on my Instagram, it's kind
of like on the daily basis of where I am.
And that's why I say, hey, we're doing a screening tonight
or a wall here.
And really, most of the time we say the morning for the night.
And sometimes I travel to a place that-- next week,
I'm going to Japan.
And I'm going to places I've never been to.
And I hope-- I'm always curious to visit new places.
So I guess I have time for that.
KEVIN VLK: What was your favorite place to shoot so far?
JR: That's a hard one because there's a lot of places I love.
Working in Brazil was amazing, and that's why in that favela,
we're still working in that same community seven years later.
So in some places, I love, actually, the continuation
of working in the same-- like in the projects of Paris,
in the suburbs, where I started.
10 years later, we're still doing projects there.
And I love that because then you see the impact of the work
and what it means.
You see the same people growing.
I mean, that's what I love because the pastings are
ephemeral.
But we often underestimate the power of the image.
And the image can become timeless.
KEVIN VLK: And you mentioned this-- in 2011,
you won the TED Prize.
And then with that money, you started
the "Inside Out Project."
So can you tell us about that?
JR: Yeah, I mean, the TED speech was for me
a hard exercise in the way that you have to combine
all your ideas in 20 minutes.
But it was an easy thing because I
had only people in suits in front of me and shirts.
Where when I had to explain my work in Liberia,
I had people with machetes.
So it was much easier to explain on the west coast.
But I was really impressed at how the speech then
went and went viral.
And then people got to understand the connection
between one work to another.
And that actually was a big step for me
because I was often in the shadow of the work.
And for once, I just wanted to explain the different links
between them.
And I guess I would re-do it one day.
KEVIN VLK: Audience questions?
AUDIENCE: I was just wondering if you could explain
your process of when you narrow down
the images for your pastes?
What are you looking for when you choose that image?
And then, just on average, how many
do you go through to get to that image you're looking for,
those images?
Thanks.
JR: You mean for Ellis Island, for example?
AUDIENCE: For Ellis Island or just in general.
I guess the Ellis Island's a little bit more different
because you're going through archived works
versus current images.
JR: Yeah.
Well, you know, I don't shoot that much.
I paste much more than I take photos.
So when I take a portrait of someone,
it doesn't take me long, just a couple of minutes.
And I know right away when there is an expression-- you see it
in the photo, when there is just this expression
that, OK, that's an honest one.
There's pure energy in there.
So generally, when I see I have that, I
just-- I feel almost bad taking photos of people.
So then when I know I have it, I have it
because in a lot of the countries that we're going,
people couldn't believe that I was coming back to paste them.
And even if I was explaining them and showing them
books of my previous project, still,
when we were coming back, they were, like, oh, I never
thought that you would come back, where for me that's
the whole base of the work.
And then on Ellis Island, there hadn't
been that many photos taken at the time.
So I went through the archive, and there's still a couple
hundred photos, and selected the ones that I cannot reflect
myself in or the story of my family of the stories of what I
was seeing right now in the media.
And I guess you compare both images with today's, and you
still feel the same energy in them.
KEVIN VLK: An interesting thing, just to follow up on that,
was you had to use archival photos in Ellis Island.
So that was interesting.
So how'd you get access to all that?
And also, just kind of going off that, too,
when you're working with these people trying
to get this-- you talk about you want that genuine, you
want that real expression.
How do you get that when you're working with these people?
JR: So on Ellis Island, I just went through the archives.
And they have a great-- actually,
it's in the public domain.
So anybody can use those photos.
When I take the photo myself, I-- I don't know.
That's a good question.
KEVIN VLK: [INAUDIBLE].
JR: You know, once I remember I was in South Sudan.
And I really thought that I could never
get those photos because the women I
was about the pho
…