YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 722 lines · added Nov 18, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: So welcome.
This is a course on Foundations of Modern Social Thought.
It has a sociology number, a political science number,
and a humanities number.
And my name is Iván Szelényi.
I'm a professor of sociology, a professor of political
science, and it is my honor that I can
introduce you to some of the Founding Fathers--
I'm afraid they are all fathers right,
no mothers among them; I will tell you why not--of
modern social thought.
It's basically theories, starting from the sixteenth
century and ending up in the early twentieth century.
The first author on our list, Thomas Hobbes,
did a lot of work on optics and has been in a violent
controversy with Descartes.
So those of you who are in natural sciences are probably
familiar with Descartes and his pioneering work on optics.
John Locke, for those of you who aspire to become a doctor,
was actually studying medicine and performed a surgery on a
very well-known English politician.
A quite successful surgery, though even today doctors quite
don't know whether this politician survived because of
good luck or because of the surgery.
Anyway, the point I'm trying to make,
in the early sixteenth, seventeenth,
eighteenth centuries, sciences and social sciences
are not separated from each other yet.
Jean Jacques Rousseau, a real pain in the neck but an
extremely smart guy, he also wrote an important book
which dealt with sciences and social studies.
It's really by the kind of late eighteenth century that people
are beginning to identify as studying society or human
behavior.
But even then, until the very last author--
what we have here, Emile Durkheim--people
identified themselves with a number of approaches,
disciplinary approaches.
There were social scientists, all right, or philosophers,
all right.
The difference between philosophy and social science is
a very vague one.
So they're beginning to distinguish themselves
increasingly from sciences, but they are still
multidisciplinary.
Who is Karl Marx, you know?
He is a philosopher.
He's an economist.
He is a political scientist.
Sociologists name him as one of the Founding Fathers of
sociology.
Max Weber, he identified himself as a legal theorist.
He was studying economic history.
I think primarily he identified himself, early in life,
as an economist, as an economic historian;
later in life he began to call himself a sociologist.
So the point is, this is a very
interdisciplinary course.
So one advantage of you to take this course is that you will be
getting knowledge, which leads you--which would
benefit you, if you are studying sciences.
If you want to become a psychologist,
if you become an economist or a political scientist or an
anthropologist or a philosopher, this list of names will appear
on your reading list.
Okay, so that's I think--I will go--I have many,
many slides to show you, and I will try to bring them
alive to you a little.
So I don't want to waste too much of my time here,
to rush through all this.
But let me still speak to some of the details,
what I'm sure many of you are particularly interested.
First, about the readings.
And my first advice is: don't let yourself to be scared
by me.
All right?
All the readings are on the internet.
You don't have to buy any books, you don't have to go to
the library, you just go to the internet and
you on load the readings and you can print the readings out.
That's when you get scared because some of the readings are
too long, and some of the readings you
start reading and you feel you don't understand a word of it.
Well, your experience is not very different from mine when I
was reading these texts for the first time.
So my advice is don't get scared.
Right?
I don't expect you to do much more reading for this course in
a week than let's say five or six hours.
This will not be enough for you, in first reading,
to get the readings on your command.
Reading characters like Hobbes, or reading even characters like
Nietzsche, is hard stuff to do.
My advice is that you kind of quickly skim-read for the
lecture; do some reading for the
lecture, so you can come in with a sense of the text.
And I will give you the most important citations and an
interpretation, and then I'll give you a
searchlight.
You can go back to the text, and you know what you are
looking for, and get ready for the discussion section.
At the discussion section, I will keep my mouth shut,
and I want you to talk.
I will ask questions, and we will have a lively
discussion.
Right?
So by that time you will have to have more of a sense.
But I will use a lot of PowerPoints, and the PowerPoints
will be put on the internet and will help you to go through the
text.
So my first point is: don't get scared with the
readings.
Please don't drop this course because you said there are too
many, too difficult readings.
This is not meant to be an easy course, but I will make it easy
for you.
Easy and fun!
You can't believe how Thomas Hobbes can be fun,
but give me just one week and you will see how fun he is.
All right?
Now the other concern by people who shop: assignments.
Well there are quite a few assignments to this course.
But I am one of those people who are scared of exams.
I was almost 70 when I got my driver's license because I did
not want to fail my driver's test.
So I understand anxieties about tests.
So therefore I have been working hard,
over my life, to make assignments serious--
make sure that you put serious work into the course,
you master the material--and at the same time the level of
anxiety is reduced near zero.
How do I do that? Easy.
There will be three tests.
All the three tests will be administered on the internet.
You sit in your room, you sit in a library,
you go to a coffee shop, you go to Starbucks,
and you login, 8:00 p.m., at a given day,
and then you will get questions from which you have to answer
some of them.
Right?
I also will give you a set of questions one week before the
test.
So you will not be surprised what kind of questions you will
be asked.
I will reduce that list, and even from this--
let's say I will give you a list of about eight to ten
questions, reduce it to three,
and then you will have to answer two.
Okay?
But there will be no anxiety; you know exactly what's going
on.
You will have one hour to answer it.
I don't mind if you prepare and you cut and paste and you put it
on the internet; that's okay.
It's open book, you can use books.
What I want you to do, not to use books;
I want to use your brain, for a change.
Okay, so that's the three tests.
And then there will be one paper for the end of the course.
The paper is not a big deal.
I just want to try to bring the course together,
different elements of the course together.
The three tests are about three blocks of the courses.
The paper is supposed to link at least two blocks of these
courses.
All right?
And again, you will be able to talk to me, and your teaching
fellows, about the paper topic.
And let me then introduce--ask our teaching assistants,
teaching fellows, to introduce themselves.
Could you do so?
Student: I'm Elizabeth Breese, and I'm a third year in
the sociology department.
Student: I'm Joseph Klett, also a third year in the
sociology department.
Prof: Well we have a third one, who didn't show.
And I will take also two discussion sections myself.
I will take Monday and Wednesday, a discussion section,
7:00 p.m.
So sort of make sure that people don't overlap with other
obligations.
Even athletes can take it because practices are usually
over, and dinner is over, right?
So after dinner you can come to a nice after-dinner conversation
with me.
And I will be grading the assignments of students who take
my discussion sections.
You can also be sure that we will make all efforts that
everybody will be able to get into a discussion section.
So right now the crowd is bigger than the number of
teaching fellows and myself.
We have so far on the internet listed only five discussion
sections, but if you want to take the
course, and you do not fit into any of
the discussion sections, you will be talking to me,
and I will be figuring out that you will get your discussion
section.
Not a single person should drop out of this course because there
is no discussion section that student will take.
You have my word for it. Okay?
I think that's probably all housekeeping.
Any question about this?
If yes, please loud.
Well it looks like it's clear, right?
Both clear and attractive.
As just one very last sentence, I don't want this to be a
"Mickey Mouse" course.
I want this to be serious.
Right?
I want you to be challenged, I want you to think,
I want you to read, and I want you to remember what
you learned in this course.
Right?
But I want to decrease the level of anxiety and make the
workload reasonable.
And if you come to lectures, you come to discussion
sections, it will be okay.
You will not be overloaded by work, and you will not be filled
with anxiety.
Now, let me try to rush quickly through all of these authors and
give you at least a couple of words about everyone so you get
a sense what will happen in this course.
All right?
And I have how many--27 minutes to do that.
So this is Thomas Hobbes, born in 1588.
Well, Hobbes had a bit of a troubled childhood--a difficult
father who was a clergyman, got into a fight with another
clergyman and had to disappear.
He had a fight actually in a cemetery, which in the sixteenth
century was no-no, especially for a clergyman.
Anyway, he grew up with uncles.
Nevertheless, he got to the University of
Oxford, did pretty good,
and became a tutor of William Cavendish,
and then traveled with him to Europe,
France, and Italy, and he met Galileo and was
greatly influenced by Galileo.
At that time in English universities,
they were mainly teaching Aristotle,
and well Hobbes became very disenchanted with Aristotle,
the dogmatism of Aristotle's philosophy,
and he was enthralled by the emergence of new positive
science, what Galileo represented.
Then he came back in England, and there were very turbulent
politics; I will talk about this greater
in the course.
And he was among those, as a conservative guy--if you
are Republican you will love it--he sided with the king
against the parliament.
And since he did that in 1640, he better skipped and went to
France, into exile, and then returned in '51 to
England.
Because he was a troublemaker, he was not only in conflict
with the Republicans, he was also in conflict with
the Royalists.
He died in 1679.
Now his first work was a translation of Thucydides.
He liked Thucydides because he thought Thucydides showed why
democracy doesn't work.
Right?
He's an absolutist, Hobbes: a conservative,
absolutist.
And then he wrote an interesting trilogy,
and this again shows the unity of sciences and social sciences.
The first volume deals with the human body, with biology.
The second works on the individual; it is really
psychology.
And the last one works on society and politics.
And he thinks the way how to understand human existence is
start with bodily functions, and move from bodily functions
to politics and philosophy.
And then his major work is Leviathan.
This is the work probably most of you've heard the title of.
And this was actually at a time when Charles I was already
executed, and he actually was considering
there should be a possibility to transfer loyalty to a new
ruler-- what the Royalists,
fellow Royalists, all in exile in Paris,
didn't like.
So now he had to escape Paris, to escape the anger of the
Royalists.
This is the First Edition of the Leviathan,
one of the most influential books in politics ever written.
Well not a very attractive book.
The main theme is that in the state of nature--
naturally by human nature, people are quite evil,
and therefore order has to be imposed over people above each
other; otherwise there would be a
war--we would be in a state of war of everyone against
everyone.
This is the major citation from Leviathan;
that's what everybody knows.
Right?
Okay, John Locke is the next, born half a century later--also
a British scientist.
He came from a minor gentry family.
He also studied at Oxford--philosophy and,
as I said, medicine was also his second major.
Early on, he was very much attracted to Hobbes,
but then he met a major British politician, Shaftesbury.
He performed a liver operation on him, assumedly saving his
life.
And then he changed course from a conservative and became sort
of a Republican; or by American political
standards he shifted from the Republican Party to the
Democratic Party, that's what he did.
Right?
Well, in fact, he was even involved in '82 in
a plot to overthrow Absolutism, and he had to escape to the
Netherlands-- returned in '89 to London,
and died a few years later.
Well his conservative work was in '64--
his address at the college in which he actually offered a
Hobbesian thesis: Kings are gods and the
people are beasts. But then he changed completely.
He already writes an important paper on toleration.
Liberals are still reading it.
And especially he writes the Two Treatises,
which is a major foundation work for modern democratic
theory-- a major foundation work for the
American Constitution as well.
This is the First Edition of it.
So what are the main points?
He said, well, men are born free and equal,
and in the state of nature they are good.
There is a need for a superior, but a superior can also be
accepted by the consent of everybody who is subjected to
authority.
And he is the first political theorist who advocates the
separation of powers and has a major impact,
together with Jean Jacques Rousseau, on the foundation of
the American Constitution-- this is where the American
Constitution comes from.
Now we move from England to France,
to Montesquieu, who was born in the late
seventeenth century and lived in the kind of already swinging
eighteenth century.
The eighteenth century was essentially, at least in France,
fun to live in.
Well it was a lot of turbulence, but interpersonal
relationships were quite interesting, you'd say.
It reminds me of the 1960s, hobbies and hippies and
whatever.
Right?
So before the French Revolution you had the 1960s kind of stuff.
Well there was not marijuana, but there was a lot of various
kinds of sex which made the eighteenth century quite fun.
And the life of Montesquieu made it quite fun.
Well he was born in the right place, near Bordeaux,
where the good wine is grown, bread.
His name was actually Charles-Louis de Secondat,
and he became Montesquieu when his uncle died and he inherited
the title of Baron de Montesquieu from him.
He studied Law.
He's a major legal theorist.
Anyone of you who is heading to law school will have to take
this course because the theory of law starts with Montesquieu.
Anyway, he studied at the University of Bordeaux.
In '28 he did the right thing.
You know, to be a parliamentarian in Bordeaux was
boring and rather he did, he went into commerce.
He became a wine merchant and a mercenary and an adventurer--
spent two years traveling all over in Europe and having lots
of fun, leaving his wife behind to run
the business.
Not very nice of him.
So the wife was sending the money to--
money orders or the equivalence of it--
wherever he was having fun, in Italy or England or the
Netherlands, where there was fun.
Then when he returned, he began to do writing,
particularly his major book, that we will talk about.
And he died in '55.
About the work, there are two major works:
the Persian Letters, which is a fun work,
an ironic view of French and Persian--
of the life of Paris in the eyes of two Persian visitors--
a kind of ironic view of the absurdities of French life.
And then, in '48, he writes finally his major
book, The Spirits of Laws,
which--it's an extremely important book and you will
read-- this is the First Edition of
it--you will read from it.
What are the major contributions?
Well, as I mentioned already, Locke noticed the need for the
separation of powers.
But Locke separated only three branches of government:
the executive, the legislative,
and one he called the federative.
Montesquieu formulated the way, how it is in the American
Constitution; namely he separates the
legislative, the executive and the judicial branch.
And we will talk a great deal about this--why it is so
important to separate the juridical branch from the
legislative and the executive.
And then he also did something very pioneering--extremely
naïve but very pioneering--he looked at
ecosystem.
Right?
He's sort of the first environmentalist;
not quite.
Even Khaldun did much before him.
But for modern, more contemporary theorists,
it's really Montesquieu who tries to explain the nature of
laws with climatic conditions-- looks at the interaction
between nature and society.
And it took us basically three hundred years to realize how
important this interaction is.
Right?
So he's really doing some absolutely path-breaking work.
Now this is Jean Jacques Rousseau.
I mean, I have many favorites among these people.
Jean Jacques Rousseau is one of them,
not--because I agree with everything what he said,
but he says it so provocatively and in such a fun way that I
just cannot resist to enjoy it all the time.
He was born already in the eighteenth century and died just
before the French Revolution, though he played a big role
paving the road to the French Revolution.
About his life: he was born in Geneva so he's
Swiss, whatever it means.
His father was a watchmaker.
And, like Hobbes, had a turbulent childhood.
The father probably had some debts, so he had to jump the
boat and went to Istanbul and left his son behind.
Who then in '28 moved to Annecy, France and met a
wonderful lady, Mrs. Warens,
who took in young boys.
He was just about sixteen at that time.
She was about ten or twelve years his senior and--well I
will talk about this more; I will give you all this gossip
in this course.
Well it fascinated a lot of people, later on,
this interesting relationship between Jean Jacques and
Mrs. Warens.
Stendhal candal!
Anybody remember the name of the French novelist,
Rouge et Noir, Red and Black?
Well this is all telling the story of Jean Jacques Rousseau
and Mrs. Warens.
Well the affair lasted for a long time.
Then he moved in '42, in Paris, and he became a
superstar.
You know, wherever he was he had to be a superstar,
and he was a superstar in everything.
There is just no match.
Probably Leonardo da Vinci is somebody who can be compared
with Rousseau in his--as a Renaissance man.
You know, he knew everything, and he did everything
perfectly.
Perfectly...I mean, all problematic.
Now in '62, he publishes two of his major books,
and I will talk about them a little later.
The big scandal is they have to escape France because he would
be in big trouble with the church in particular.
But in Switzerland he doesn't get along very well either.
So then he goes to England--returns later to France
under an assumed name, and died in '78.
Okay, about Rousseau's work.
I skip the first one, which I said is still dealing
with sciences and social sciences.
The disciplines are not separated from each other.
But let me also mention that in '52 he writes an opera!
And he writes a wonderful opera, Le Devin du
Village.
I have a CD of the opera and if I would know how to play music,
I would show you some of his music.
It's great music.
Mozart was so excited that he actually wrote an opera
following Rousseau's opera.
He was in a big--I will talk about this later;
I am a bit obsessed with music.
Anyway, he was in a big conflict with the greatest
French composer ever, Rameau;
I'm sure many of you know the work of Rameau,
a great eighteenth century musician.
Well Rousseau was not quite as great a composer as Rameau but
had a debate with him, and his music was to be an
alternative to Rameau.
Rameau wanted to write French music, and Rousseau was
committed to Italian music: melody, belle canto.
Right?
That's what he loved.
And that's what Mozart in most of his operas loved.
That's why Mozart loved Rousseau,
…

Need subtitles from another video?