YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,317 lines · added Nov 18, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: Last time we started talking about tropical
places where high productivity agriculture is generally just
not possible.
Hence, without productive agriculture you can't support
dense populations.
Those cultures grew up in time--in places where plenty of
land, land was not filled up, it was people that were scarce.
While individual women of course still had to control
their fertility so that the children--
the infants that they had didn't die and there's many,
many things that they do for that.
The community cultural controls on fertility are generally
absent because from the community point of view you
always wants to be, at that time,
larger and among other reasons to protect your community from
the ravages of hostile neighbors because almost all of these
communities are-- just read any history of any
part of the world constant, constant warfare,
as we've discussed a lot.
Of many places in the world, which one could describe,
traditional Africa provides some of the best examples of how
these cultures operate.
Again, I want to emphasize that this a tradition--
a picture of a traditional time and things are changing now
extremely rapidly everywhere in the world,
including of course Africa.
As I showed you last time, Africa really is different than
the rest of the world.
I showed statistics comparing Morocco on the north coast of
Africa, included in the Mediterranean cultural zone.
You cross the Sahara, you're in Niger,
or you're in Mali, and totally different
situation.
The number of children is much high--
people have is much higher, I showed you that,
the number of children that they want is much higher,
infant mortality has come down in both places,
in Morocco the fertility responds to it,
in Niger the fertility does not respond to it.
While we're going--so we're going to discuss this region and
using a lot of generalizations which will not fit any
particular culture.
If you add up all the birthrate statistics, Sub-Saharan African
has about twice the birth rate of North Africa.
Again, it's all Suni Muslim we're talking about,
so religion is not the difference, but the something
else about the southern culture which we've been talking about.
It probably starts with the agriculture and then goes into
other fields.
Of all the things that are changing in Africa,
fertility--the attitudes toward fertility--
again I'm always using fertility as the number of
children a woman actually has and not her ability to have
children.
The attitudes towards fertility are sort of the most resistant
to change.
These societies have what you might call a culture of
reproduction in which the central idea is that of lineage,
a family and its line of male ancestors.
The prime duty in these cultures is to keep the lineage
going.
Of course you've all read stuff about China, China is
not--traditional China is not particularly different than
this.
The important thing is to provide descendants for the
ancestors.
Not only is your own future--if you don't have the son as your
own future as a shade, as sort of a spirit that hovers
around, is dependent on continuation of
the line.
The whole history of ancestors, stretching back,
is dependent on your having descendants.
The future line which is perceived as sort of almost in
existence, of potential existence,
the whole line from the distant past going through you to the
distant future is all dependent on you having descendants,
male descendants in the line.
The central purpose, the central goal,
the central job of existence is to continue this line of
fertility.
Now the traditional religion is based on this lineage idea.
Because it's your own--the gods are in a sense your own
ancestors, people that you knew,
people that you talk too, they stay more close to you
after they die.
Unlike Western gods where you pray but it's never clear
whether your prayers are being answered or not,
in an ancestor worship situation, the answer is right
there, and you can talk back and forth
with them.
They're not distant, eerie, supernatural kind of
characters but rather like a grandfather who just stays near
us after his death.
This kind of description comes from the ethnographers,
the anthropologists that go and talk to the people in these
traditional cultures.
The lineage head, who is almost always the old--
often the oldest male member of the lineage,
he often can communicate directly with these ancestors or
there may be a soothsayer in the community and then the head man
will commission the soothsayer to ask the ancestors some
particular question.
The ancestors are quite available to discuss the most
ordinary and mundane issues of life or they can discuss very
weighty affairs.
This doesn't require waiting for some big holiday or some
huge amount of time, it can be--the whole thing can
be transacted in 15 minutes or maybe a half an hour.
Sometimes they're contacted, they provide their answers,
and you've got the answer that you need.
One of the interesting, with respect to this course,
one of the interesting things that goes on is that family
planning is being introduced into Africa,
has been now for quite a while, and it's becoming available.
The people are thinking it over; it's a hot topic.
They're discussing it, they're trying to figure out
whether it's good for them or not,
whether it's permissible for them or not,
what's going to happen if you use it,
what's going to happen if you don't use it.
It's a very hot topic and of course they want the wisdom of
the ancestors on this.
In the middle of this, one set of demographers went
into-- in Ghana there's a group of
Nankana-- the name of the people there,
and they went into their villages and they wanted to see
how this worked out.
If this discussion with the ancestors, as they call the
traditional religion, would be hostile to the
introduction of family planning because elsewhere in the world
of course the more conservative the more--
it doesn't depend on the individual religion,
a particular religion as I have said and will say again,
but it does depend on the religiosity of the person.
The more religious a person is, in almost any tradition,
the more hostile they will be to change,
and in particular to the adoption of new reproductive
practices like family planning.
They're interested in this issue how this would work out in
traditional villages in Africa.
He asked the village head man--one of the
anthropologists--to inquire of the spirits how many children
should a family have; a simple question.
Here's what the spirit said, "Listen to what I have to
say, children are the lineage, if there are no children the
lineage will end.
We ancestors want many children; the women should give birth to
many children."
That was a pretty clear answer; there was no futzing around
with that one.
But being Western skeptics, they didn't really believe that
the ancestor was saying that, so he was saying,
well the headman put into the mouths of the spirits whatever
the headman believed, and that was not--made the
anthropologists quite satisfied with this.
He was a good scientist and he did the control experiment,
he asked the headman, the same headman who had just
reported the conservative views of the ancestors.
Well what do you think, he got a completely different
answer.
"Women need to have just enough children.
Currently it is very difficult to fend for the children.
There's no food to feed them.
If they are in school it is difficult to pay their school
fees and to buy them school uniforms.
Taking them to the hospital when they are sick demands a lot
of money.
That is why we need to give birth to few children."
Well that's a little different take, and so then the
demographer's brain starts rolling and says;
now I got the scene, now I got it right.
The ancestors are giving the traditional point of view,
well that's true, that was what the older
generation believed, but the headmen are part of the
current generation and they're going to take current views into
consideration and take a more moderate view.
They interviewed the next--they went to the next village and
interviewed the next lineage head and that hypothesis didn't
stand up.
Speaking for himself, the headman said,
"I would like them to have many children because a large
following it makes one a chief.
There is power in numbers."
This is the idea that if you have only a few people in your
village you're not very powerful,
your neighbors can ignore you, they can take advantage of you,
but if you have a big set of descendants and a big family and
extended family, a big village then you're a
powerful chief and he wanted children so that he would be
powerful.
But then this same guy was asked to see what the ancestors
have to say about it, and the ancestors said,
"Everybody should have a small number of children,
but they should not refuse to have children altogether."
Since the ancestors are close at hand,
it's perfectly reasonable that they're aware of current trends,
and one of the ancestors said, "It is now difficult to
get an education as well as to do farming.
If a problem crops up and the child is sick then money is
everything.
You have to buy medicine," meaning modern medicine,
"And even if you go to the herbalist,"
traditional medicine, "You need to take a
fowl," a chicken or something,
"along to pay for the treatment.
It's no longer the same as in the olden days when everybody
did farming."
That's the ancestor speaking, very well aware of current
trends and problems.
After they interviewed a whole lot of these Nankana villages in
Ghana they summarized the research,
and the result was no pattern of responses at all.
Sometime the headman and his ancestors they agreed;
sometimes they disagreed; sometimes it was the ancestor
taking the conservative line; sometimes it was the headman
taking the conservative line.
It was indeed like a discussion between a man and say his
grandfather that was going on and they will have different
points of view and individuals will be different.
This contact with the ancestors seems quite natural.
You read this story--you hear this story as 'oh my God,' but
it's perfectly natural to the people.
These people in northern Ghana they have no word for
supernatural.
It just doesn't exist.
They don't have any--they don't have scientific explanations for
anything, so all explanations are sort of
somewhere floating around, some are empirical and
observational, and some of them are
supernatural, and so there's no boundary
between these kinds of explanations for things,
and so they don't have such a word and they don't distinguish
these kinds of discussions with the ancestors from real things,
real dreams or daydreams or anything else.
It's all a very fluid kind of thing.
To people living in that kind of a culture the Western idea of
an unwavering set of rules, cast in stone in some book
thousands of years ago, like the Bible,
like the Koran, would seem ludicrous to
Nankana.
To them, our system of a book that says everything you need to
know is as crazy as our view of them talking to the ancestors.
You should then compare this kind of individualistic,
flexible style of religion to the mass monotheistic religions
that we have in the northern temperate zones,
at least the Western northern temperate zones.
These religions are all part of a big political structure which
requires uniformity of the subjects of some king,
or some emperor, and submission to that person.
Of course, as you probably all know,
the word Islam itself means 'submission' and the ideal in
monotheistic religions is often--
notice the uniformity.
This is women at prayer and notice the--
as you see--when you see a bigger picture of this there's
just a sea of women at some big event all dressed identically,
all looking identical.
When I was in Morocco I got a little instruction book that is
given to children about how to pray,
and every detail is specified down to when you bow down during
prayer the position of the toes is specified--
are they curled under, are they spread out,
you have to know that.
Conformity is a very important part of mass religion.
Of course in the west how is conformity enforced in
Christianity?
You burn the heretics, a long history of burning and
killing by the dominant church, wherever it is,
you just slaughter the people that--
even on very tiny theological differences if they don't
believe exactly as the authorities think they should
believe, off with their head,
so it's a very different kind of pattern of cultural
understanding of religion and ancestors and the world.
Given this intensity of devotion to the lineage,
the main virtue in Africa then is fertility.
The main sin is to be barren, is not have children.
An inability to have children, barrenness, is not just a
passive thing that happens to you but it's punishment for
something bad that you have done.
There's very little distinction between infertility,
the woman just can't get pregnant, and of course they
don't accept the idea that it might be the man's fault,
but the woman doesn't get pregnant,
she's infertile, she has miscarriages,
goes partway through the pregnancy,
or infant deaths.
The important thing is to have descendants who can carry on the
line and however-- whatever the mechanism is by
which a man or woman, or the family,
is incapable of having descendants,
that's the worst sin and it's your fault.
It's not a passive thing that happens to you.
Barren women can be divorced, they can be shunned,
and sometimes they need to--they're not even allowed to
live in the center of the village because--
of course they have no scientific explanation for
barrenness, but maybe it's catching in some
sense, either by evil spirits which
are keeping the woman from getting pregnant and you don't
want the evil spirits to attack you,
or some other reason they can often be required to live on the
edge of the village.
Given this emphasis on, one way or another,
getting pregnant, monogamy is not strictly
enforced; it's not the kind of obsession
that it is in the West.
Here's a wonderful story--recent 2000,
this is The People Newspaper from Nairobi,
Kenya.
"A group of women stormed the Kenya police station to
demand that officers either make love to them or close illegal
drinking dens.
They said the drinking made their husbands impotent.
The women said the population of the district was falling off
as a result of the poor sexual performance of the men.
The women," it was Kanda actually,
north of Nairobi, "brought the businesses in
town to a halt with their daylong protest against
excessive drinking by their men folk.
'Our men have turned to vegetables;
they leave home early and come back intoxicated.
There is no one to meet the sexual needs of the
wives.'" Guess which group it was where
these women came from?
It was 24 Catholic Church groups in Kenya.
They came together and demanded that the officer in charge of
the police station order his men to make love to these women.
The newspaper discretely does not say how the police responded
to this demand.
Now--so the women must be fertile and the men must be
believed to be potent or fertile, of course it's harder
to tell whether the man is or isn't.
The men of course, in a sense, want to keep the
fertility of the women for themselves but it's more
important to have children no matter who is the biological
father.
Not only in the family but once a child is born,
perhaps under obviously uncertain circumstances,
the village will accept--the community accepts the children.
They need people; they want strength in numbers,
and so promiscuity is not frowned on particularly by the
community.
Everybody knows it goes on and just keeps quiet.
I was reading this week and last a history of a Lesotho.
How many--Lesotho is a small country--you've been there?
No, okay.
A small enclave totally surrounded by South Africa.
This was a history before the Europeans came about the 1700s.
There was a king then and the king,
it was a very small group at that time,
not much more than a village, and when the third son--
this is sort of a quote, "When the third son of the
king died he left a widow who was still of childbearing age
but had no surviving children.
By custom the widow should have gone to live with her husband's
younger brother so that she could continue the seed of her
dead husband."
Exactly as we see in the Old Testament that we talked about
last time.
The widow didn't agree and she went off and actually got
pregnant by sort of a no good who wasn't even of that tribe.
Now this is a real no-no and--but nevertheless the child,
since that woman was legally part of a certain lineage,
that child by someone who wasn't even a member of the
tribe and against the convention was still accepted as a member
of the king's lineage there.
It turns that the child of this--illegitimate in a sense--
child became the greatest king that Lesotho has ever known,
a very important guy named Moshoeshoe.
Moshoeshoe himself, the grandson of the time I'm
talking about, he was reputed to have 140 to
200 wives.
You read the history, they of course--
they have whatever written records they have and the first
one says well-- when he was young he has 35
wives, then he has 80 wives, and every time this is reported
as he gets older, and probably accumulates more
wives, the number goes up.
The last report was 200 wives.
Of course we don't know anything about the accuracy of
this.
But it was said most of his latter wives were regarded as
distinctly inferior.
Moshoeshoe would summon whomever he wished to spend the
night with him, and he undoubtedly sired a vast
progeny.
He also offered these lesser wives to visitors for the night
by way of hospitality, but according to custom,
any children these visitors produced were regarded as
Moshoeshoe's own children.
Again, in the West, chastity, monogamy is valued,
who the father is.
In under-populated cultures, in cultures that have responded
to under population it's the children that are wanted,
and the mechanism of biologically fathering a child
is much less important.
I experienced this myself quite surprisingly.
I think I mentioned I had been in Borneo living with some
headhunters for a while, and I got along pretty well
with the young guys.
Sort of the guys stay together and so after I was there a
little bit they offered me their sisters and said,
'you shouldn't be sleeping alone,' and for discretion,
I won't tell you what happened.
Even nowadays many African scholars maintain that African
societies don't even really distinguish between legitimate
and illegitimate births.
15% to 25% of women in various west and east African countries,
including Kenya for instance, report premarital births,
so they may or may not marry the guy that's there before
marriage.
As all these estimates of behavior that is now becoming
with the Christianization and the Islamization becoming
somewhat questionable, if the official statistics are
15% to 25% for sure it's a lot larger than that.
Of course the husband again isn't really wildly happy about
all this playing around and--but what's most important to him is
his status.
Again, the biological parentage of the child is less important.
He knows whatever child his wife has will be officially his,
but he doesn't want to get to be known as impotent.
His potency is what matters to him.
As long as the woman--and this happens a lot because very often
the man is quite significantly older than the wife,
especially younger--as he gets older and accumulates more
wives, then younger wives,
and so his potency may really be flagging quite a bit,
so it's a real concern.
As long as--if the wife--as long as the wife is discreet and
doesn't make a public display that this kid is really someone
else's then not a big problem.
The legal father accepts the child;
the community accepts the child.
Anthropologists of course thought this was very
interesting and they-- one wonderful--Susan Watkins
from The University of Pennsylvania,
a sociologist, works in Kenya in the Luo,
with the Luo on the west of Kenya;
Luo peopl
…

Need subtitles from another video?