YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 33 lines · added Nov 19, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

International benchmarking is difficult, but perhaps one of the areas where this is most
complicated is education. As a widely recognized economic driver and catalyst for national
progress, it is intimately tied with economic and social policy - both of which vary widely
by country. What matters in education differs depending on a country’s culture, values,
and current circumstances. And a country’s curriculum is likely to reflect these, which
is why international education comparisons often fail to accurately reflect knowledge
and learning. In the United States, for example, one of the reasons we see such a strong push
for STEM is because of its importance in fueling the US economy. US top industries include
aerospace, telecommunications, and automobiles, so the country needs highly educated and innovative
workers in these areas like aerospace engineers to move these forward. A country like China,
on the other hand, might be more focused on technical and vocational training to support
its prominent large-scale goods manufacturing. Our education priorities change overtime to
meet new needs as well. If you watched the movie Interstellar, the point is clear - when
food scarcity hit, the entire school curriculum changed to focus on farming and agriculture
instead of say, art and architecture. Though that was just a movie, the same concept applies
today. Context matters. And tests cannot account for this varying contexts across countries.
It’s impossible. In fact, the preeminent PISA test used to make international education
comparisons only tests math reading and science, neglecting other areas like social sciences,
or music. And PISA states very clearly that it “does not test how well a student has
mastered a school’s specific curriculum.” But to further complicate international comparisons,
there’s the issue of the tests being flawed themselves within the areas they are trying
to measure. Exams are incredibly difficult to make because they are meant to be a representation
- or a slice of your knowledge that represents the whole. But you always run the risk of
taking the wrong slice, especially on an international scale where there are no clear universal standards.
But even if there were, the tests still run the risk of being flawed - often in ways that
unfairly favor certain populations over others. Despite this, standardized testing has become
much more prevalent and widely influential. So much so, that among the many criticisms
of leading educational systems, is teaching to the test - an overemphasis on test scores
that reflect how well students memorize information and know the tests rather than a true understanding
of concepts. That aside, some countries have raced to top of these international lists.
Singapore is currently on top and the US, is ranked 29th. For more on where countries
stack up against each other, check out my other episode on Test Tube News by clicking
here. Thanks for watching Seeker Daily. And, subscribe if you haven’t already.

Need subtitles from another video?