YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 1,208 lines · added Nov 19, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: Did I tell you the story when one of my friends was
offered--to buy from me?
I was in upper Egypt and I was traveling with a young lady,
and a third woman, a little bit older,
sort of was traveling alone; it's not terribly comfortable.
She asked to join us I and said 'that's fine,' so the three of
us were sitting there near Aswan,
and there were two men sitting sort of across the room.
One of them dressed in clearly Arab garb,
and one dressed in a rather modern suit,
and at some point the guy in the suit came over,
introduced himself very politely, and he was a
Palestinian and the other man was a Saudi Arabian sheik,
and they had noticed that I had two wives and so the sheik had
wanted to know-- would like to purchase the
second--the older one, the second wife from me.
Since it was the somewhat older one, he thought I wouldn't mind
very much.
It was a wonderful scene because, as you know,
Palestinians are very sophisticated;
they've been living with Jews, who are basically Europeans,
for a very long time so they're just like anybody else.
The Saudi Arabian sheik was obviously living,
not in the modern world and this poor Palestinian had to
intermediate, so he was very scared how I
would respond.
Would I make a scene, would I slug him,
would I try to get him arrested, or any of this sort of
stuff?
Of course it was immediately obvious to me what was going on
and to my two lady friends and so we played it very cool and
we, you know--please sit down,
let's discuss this, how old is the sheik,
how many wives does he already have,
how many has he divorced, does he have any concubines in
addition to his wives, how much money do you have,
etc., etc.
We had a very, very nice polite thing and you
could just see the intermediary his face just relaxed because he
was expecting something terrible.
Everybody played along and it went off very well,
and in the middle of this the sheik calls the intermediary
over back to him, and they talk something and out
comes a velvet purse given to the Palestinian and he gives it
to me as a sign of good faith on the part of the Arabian,
he wanted me to have this.
What is it?
A set of Muslim prayer beads, beautiful cat's-eye stones,
many--not just a chain but beautiful, beautiful handiwork
and probably very valuable.
I was looking for--to bring to class--actually last time and I
can't find it right now.
Everything worked out, the women paid very great
attention to what was going on, and we said politely at the end
that we would consider and give them an answer tomorrow.
In the end she didn't want to be bought, even though she's
obviously going to have some good chunk of change out of it,
or at least I was.
Two things will have to be delayed because Eliezeri is not
here and we have to add something to Noah's
presentation.
Let's skip that.
Last time we were discussing Europe and we were coming into
the-- we started to discuss the
Middle Ages and we start with Europe because we have the best
data.
We have very, very good data about lots and
lots of things from Europe.
It's not so good from the rest of the world.
From about--for about 500 years, from 1200 to 1700 the
data, poor as the data is, shows that population really
didn't rise terribly much.
They were in some sort of stasis.
The reasons for this we had discussed a little bit.
We talked about the plague, and the plague lasted like 500
years-- this is--remember the plague
hit Europe in 1347 so this table where they have good data starts
200 years later.
The plague has been around for 200 years and still there's a
number of cases; that's not individuals but
different cities and places in which there was an outbreak and
we just don't have good records of how many people died,
but 1550,1600, 1650, see the plague is dying
out slowly and there's many, many theories whether people
got resistance to it, or the rats that carried it,
died or were out-competed by another species of rats.
Not known, but the plague did eventually die out.
From 1347 to 1849, is 500 years where the plague
keeps recurring.
That was clearly one of the reasons why population couldn't
grow.
Then there was violence, there was constant small level
violence, and then when the Protestant
Reformation happened, the religious wars broke out
and according to one of the standard textbooks of European
history they ran from 1531 up to 1657,
so another 130 years of slaughter and they rolled around
different places in Europe.
By the time they were done the most contested--
southern Europe stayed Catholic, and very northern
Europe became Protestant but the middle of Europe was strongly
contested-- and so something like a third
to a half of everybody got killed in this time because of
the religious wars.
This is the period that Malthus is describing and we'll come
back to Malthus--that Malthus knew about.
This is the history that he understood and we'll come back
to what his theories were, but the historians now agree
pretty much that productivity of the land,
especially agriculture, because that was the main
occupation, was rising very slowly during
this period, but population is also rising
very slowly during this period, so pretty much the gains in
agricultural productivity were balanced by the gains in
population and the average standard of living did not
improve and we'll talk a good bit more about that.
Now why--so the question I mean is pretty obvious why they were
not able to improve agricultural productivity,
why they were not able to significantly improve any other
kind of manufacturing productivity,
why they were not able to do anything to fight these
diseases.
It comes down to, that not only was there no
scientific knowledge as we currently understand the word
scientific, there really wasn't any
particular interest in-- intellectually in the real
world.
Everything was focused on religion and the other world,
so there was not a lot of intellectual energy expended in
trying to understand what was going on around your feet so to
speak.
Because they had all kinds of problems that we take for
granted, all kinds of ways of dealing
with the real world just were not even--
were not really thought about in any serious way.
Sanitation, up until the eighteenth century,
up until the 1800s actually, the sanitation in Europe was
just absolutely atrocious.
There was no system for disposing of human waste.
Nobody bothered to pay attention to what to do with
human waste.
Feces were basically everywhere.
Wherever you went there was someone else's feces.
In the eighteenth century the city streets everywhere had
ditches down the middle of the street and that's where the
feces got dumped.
There were buckets inside the house and some servant,
or the housewife would take the bucket and dump it into these
ditches.
They were also used as latrines, people would just go
out there and if they didn't have a bucket in the house,
or if they didn't have a house, go in and do it in the latrine.
Again, in each case--I was in Belize City in Latin--
in Central America as you know, not that many years ago in the
middle of the street there's one big latrine,
and the stink was just incredible.
Now you didn't actually have to--were not required to
actually take your bucket of feces and dump them in the
street, you could throw them out your
window.
But eventually people did start thinking about that,
and the issue was not to dump it on someone's head.
In Edinburgh, Scotland they rang bells at
10:00 p.m.
at night when they figured people should be off the street
and that was the specified time for dumping excrement out your
window.
Some of the older of you that were properly brought up--
the young men were maybe told that you should walk on the
street side when you're escorting a young lady.
Do you know what that's for?
When stuff gets dumped out the window it's to prevent splash
from cars, it's way earlier then cars,
it was to-- so that when someone dumped
stuff out the window it would-- the lady would be under some
kind of awnings there.
It wasn't only the common people, the poor,
the uneducated that were living in such filth,
it went right up to the royalty and we have records of this.
In 1665, there was a great plague in London,
one of those that I've showed you there and that's the one
that-- written about by Robinson
Crusoe author, Daniel Dafoe.
The King, Charles II, and his court took his refuge
in Oxford University.
Now Yale is modeled after--a lot of Yale is modeled after
Oxford, so you have a good image of what it looks like.
The plague was over, it took about a year,
the plague was over, they went back to London and
just left whatever they left in Oxford,
and the cleaning people came in and what did they find?
Excrement everywhere, they described it excrement in
every corner, in chimneys,
in studies, in coal houses, in cellars, just all over the
place.
Now some of this information comes from the diary of Samuel
Pepys.
How many of you are aware of this?
Some of you again if you've taken history or literature,
he was the famous diarist from that.
He was England's first Secretary of the Admiralty,
a Member of Parliament, President of The Royal
Scientific Society, so he was not your ordinary
average guy.
He was educated, had money and in the upper
classes, but he writes that -- when he
had to defecate in the middle of the night--
he didn't bother to go to the privy,
he just deposited his feces in the fireplace.
You can see that it was a smelly place to live in.
Now along with no concern or no thought about where you deposit
your excrement, the idea of keeping drinking
water separate from this excrement was not in anybody's
mind.
That very often if there were public holes or someplace where
the public could go to do their thing,
then maybe right next to it was a drinking fountain.
In terms of the waste in the streets, it wasn't just feces
but everything else was just dumped into the streets.
England especially had lots of animals, Europe had animals,
unlike China, and when animals died--just
left in the middle of the street to rot.
Butchers that pulled out the entrails,
the guts of the animals and inedible parts,
dump it in the street and so the streets are just full of not
only human excrement but the waste of all the animals,
and of course the flies and insects lay their eggs in it and
grow, and it's very unsanitary.
Dead people were not handled any better than this.
As more people died, the urban cemeteries got filled
up.
There was not so much space and so they stopped burying the poor
people in-- properly in cemeteries but just
what they call 'poor holes,' just large pits in which piles
of bodies were just laid out side by side,
row by row, and row on top of row and they were not closed
until they were full.
You had these pits of rotting bodies just festering there in
the middle of all the cities that had enough people to bury.
Of course the stench was just overwhelming and the rich people
were not buried in these pits but if they were--
they could be buried in cemeteries,
but if they were really important they bought space in
the church crypt or they contributed money and got space
in the church crypt.
Many of you have undoubtedly gone to churches and in the
basement they've got these crypts of dead people and guess
what?
They were rotting and stank, so the churches stank.
One quote is that 'they stank out parson and
congregation'--that people just couldn't stand to be there.
In 1742, Dr. Johnson, who you know wrote The Life of
Boswell--excuse me, Boswell's Life of
Johnson, so he's quoting Johnson.
Described London as a city, "Which abounds with such
heaps of filth as a savage would look on with amazement."
The death rate--cities were so unhealthy from all this filth
that the death rates were enormously high and cities did
not keep themselves going.
If left to itself a city's population would just disappear
and some estimates are that about every generation,
about a third of the inhabitants of a city would die.
I mean everybody died, but the population left--
the city just left to itself would go down by a third in
every generation, and the only reason that cities
were able to prosper was that in the countryside where things
were healthier just because of space,
there wasn't the demography, there wasn't the crowding of
people that constantly the excess births,
the excess population from the countryside would keep migrating
into the cities because they had primogeniture in England,
for instance.
Only the oldest son could inherit the land,
so younger sons had to migrate into the cities or into the army
and that's what kept the cities going.
There's a constant stream of people coming in from the
countryside.
Now it's not only London and the great cities,
and it's not only that part of Europe,
but we have descriptions of some of the other cities,
and one of them is currently politically very relevant.
It is Jerusalem and now all the great Western religions claim
that Jerusalem is central to their religion and they compete
viciously; they fight viciously over
Jerusalem.
They all claim that they've been interested forever in this,
but in fact, … until Napoleon's
expedition to Egypt in the Middle East,
it was totally ignored as a physical thing from the crusades
to Napoleon it was totally ignored.
In 1840 it was a tiny town of 15,000 people;
7,000 Jews; 5,000 Muslims;
3,000 Christians from the records that we have.
In a place like that, presumably the seed of the
Western religions, the feces were 50 feet deep and
had been collecting since the destruction of the second temple
by the Romans.
Before the Romans destroyed Jerusalem there was some sort of
sanitation going on, but between then and 1840 the
feces just kept going up.
Of course in this filth everybody was sick.
Basically everyone had malaria, and malaria was endemic there.
When cholera came through, which it came periodically,
75% of the people would die of it and one quote describing
this, "The sanitary condition of
the city of God insure that any pilgrim who sought to spend his
last days on earth there could look forward to fulfilling that
ideal with great dispatch."
Personal cleanliness: this was also unknown.
We have one professor of medieval history who gives a
great lecture and if he ever gives it as a public lecture
that I've seen him give.
If he ever gives it again absolutely go.
It's called '1,000 Years Without a Bath,' so this is in
Europe, the Romans were very careful
about personal cleanliness and they built these great big
baths.
… Have you visited the baths of Caracalla in Rome;
a couple of you have.
How about Bath--the city in England named after its baths
and so forth?
All these are Roman creations, so the Romans very careful,
as much as they could in a place like that with personal
hygiene.
But after the fall of Rome the morality changes,
the church takes over, and the church wants people to
concentrate on their souls not on their bodies,
and washing was considered too much of a sign of preoccupation
with the body, and especially for women.
It's not good for women to pay too much attention to their
bodies.
Europeans at that time, boasted and you've probably
heard this that they only wash three times in their lives.
How many of you have ever heard that?
Once when they're born, once when they get married,
and once when they die they get washed,
and the rest of that--not only didn't they wash they thought
that water that you washed with carried disease,
contagion, various theories and that if you washed you would
probably get sick from the washing.
The solution was not cleanliness--the solution to the
bad conditions-- but perfume,
and perfume comes up in this era because people stank so much
that, if they had the money,
they would buy perfume.
Anybody know why--yes?
Student: Was the water likely to make you sick because
it was so dirty?
Prof: Good question, was the water likely to make
them sick?
If they drank the water, yes.
If they washed in the water, no.
There's very little in temperate zone water that's
going to get through your skin.
In tropical zones there can be parasites in there and they can
be dangerous, but in Europe I'm not sort of
aware of anything that washing in the water will get you sick.
Student: On the hand if you wash yourself and it stays
on your skin and then you eat or something could you then get
sick?
Prof: Yes, if you wash yourself,
it stays on your skin and then you eat with your unwashed
hands-- well probably what was on there
before you washed is going to be worse.
In general, I think nobody washed unless something comes
off--the burden of whatever's on the skin gets less.
All of these things are what we modern people think about,
but obviously, back then, just these kind of
very simple straightforward questions were not really
considered.
People back then, George Washington,
King George wore wigs--anybody know why?
Some of you probably know why they wear wigs--underneath the
wig was-- Student: Head lice.
Prof: Lots of lice, shaved heads,
they had lice.
Lice was endemic, they couldn't get rid of it,
so they shaved their heads.
I think we just saw that on television with the John Adams
story.
Every so often--did any of you see that TV show?
HBO--anyway he takes off his wig and there he is bald,
that was to prevent lice.
One of the reasons--one of the major reasons for this lack of
population growth for hundreds of years in Europe,
just no idea about sanitation, hygiene,
any of this kind of stuff.
Another aspect which you'll be reading about is infanticide.
Infanticide was a very large factor in European demography
and the rest of the world, as you will read about,
but in Europe it was very important.
There was always a level of infanticide and--
of various sorts but in the eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries it apparently exploded--
the number of kids that were done away with.
In Milan, from 1840s to 1860s, one third of all children born
to married parents-- we're not talking about
unmarried situations-- were left at foundling homes
and in foundling homes the death rate was near 100%.
More than half of all the children born to working class
parents were left in foundling homes,
and almost all the illegitimate children were abandoned and the
death rates-- it was a form of infanticide,
you just gave them to a foundling home,
they were taken, basically, no care of,
they died.
It was out of sight.
Again, not just the ordinary ignorant person but you all know
Jean-Jacques Rousseau?
The famous French philosophe who wrote a
lot that encouraged the American Revolution.
This is a quote from him, "My third child was thus
deposited in a foundling home just like the first two,
and I did the same with the two following.
I had five in all.
The arrangement seemed to me so good,
so sensible, so appropriate that,
if I did not boast of it publicly,
it was solely out of regard for their mother."
There was no--here they're abandoning these children to
almost certain death and it--there was just no moral
compunction about it whatsoever.
Aside from absolute abandonment to foundling homes or …
just leaving them in the streets--
you'll read about American and England where the kids were just
often left in the streets.
Another mechanism was sending out children to nurse with wet
nurses and the death rate of wet nurse children was enormously
high.
So, if parents tried to rear their children,
the death rate was about one in six at this time.
In eighteenth century France between a half and two-thirds of
infants that were sent out to nurse died.
Even at a higher death rate were the so called baby farms,
in the nineteenth century Europe there were--
it's like we call them puppy mills now,
they were baby farms, and they took in vast numbers
of children presumably to wet nurse,
but almost none of them survived.
As I showed you from these and all kinds of reasons,
about a third of children died in infancy.
The idea of being a parent and the family idea of childrearing
was completely different then we now understand.
The standard thing was a chil
…

Need subtitles from another video?