Advertisement
English transcript
Columbus Day has become one of the more controversial national holidays in the United States, and
as a Canadian, this has always struck me as strange. To me it’s always been a celebration
of American nationalism, but many protest the holiday, calling it a celebration of the
destruction of Native American life and the murder of millions of indigenous people. So
why does America still celebrate Columbus Day?
Columbus Day, for those of you living outside the U.S., is an American national holiday
commemorating Christopher Columbus landing in the New World on October 12, 1492. Though
it was a bit of an accident. The Italian-born explorer set sail two months earlier on the
dime of the Spanish monarchy to find a western sea route to China, India, and the rumoured
gold and spice islands of Asia. Instead he landed in the Bahamas, becoming the first
European to visit the Americas since the Vikings set up colonies in Greenland and Newfoundland
in the 10th century.
Over the course of four journeys across the Atlantic, Columbus never set foot in modern-day
United States. Nevertheless, he’s become a figure of American nationalistic pride.
Case in point, the nation’s capital is the District of Columbia.
The first Columbus Day celebration was on the 300th anniversary in 1792. A century later
on the 400th anniversary, President Benjamin Harrison issued a proclamation encouraging
Americans to mark the date with patriotic celebrations. In 1937, President Franklin
D. Roosevelt made Columbus Day a national holiday. A law passed in 1968 which sought
to give Americans long holiday weekends lead to the creation of Columbus Day, which was
fixed as the second Monday in October in 1971.
The opposition to the holiday we’re seeing is actually older than the holiday itself
going back at least to the 19th century.
Italian immigrants arrived in America in large numbers in the late nineteenth century, and
they quickly adopted Columbus as a shield against discrimination. America as it was
existed because an Italian explorer landed there, so the other immigrant populations,
namely those from nordic and northern European countries, couldn’t possibly bar Italian
immigrants from enjoying their new American national identity, right?
Well, Americans were still not keen on their new Italian countrymen and pushed back against
Columbus Day celebrations, looking instead to a more ethnically comfortable figurehead.
They found one in Leif Erikson, the Viking explorer already lauded by Norwegian immigrants
who gave some American populations a means to target the Italian Catholic populations.
By the end of the nineteenth century, patriotism was taking the place of anti-Catholic sentiments,
and Columbus became an ethnically and religiously-neutral figurehead used to celebrate American identity
in all it’s forms.
But the more modern issues stem from the fact that celebrating Columbus confirms a Eurocentric
worldview embodied by a man who brought disease to an indigenous population before treating
them brutally for years. He has even become a sort of punching bag people use when pointing
out the flaws of the nation he founded. Once neutral, Columbus has reemerged as a dead
white male who embodies the “limits and costs of American opportunity.”
So this holiday is steeped in controversy, but the ongoing controversy over Columbus
Day in a multicultural democracy might be the most American thing about the holiday.
Columbus isn’t the only historical figure whose past is being questioned. The newest
Catholic Saint, Junipero Serra, is being scrutinized for his brutal colonization practices in California
in the 1700s. To learn more check out our video (pause). Thanks for watching, and be
sure to subscribe.
as a Canadian, this has always struck me as strange. To me it’s always been a celebration
of American nationalism, but many protest the holiday, calling it a celebration of the
destruction of Native American life and the murder of millions of indigenous people. So
why does America still celebrate Columbus Day?
Columbus Day, for those of you living outside the U.S., is an American national holiday
commemorating Christopher Columbus landing in the New World on October 12, 1492. Though
it was a bit of an accident. The Italian-born explorer set sail two months earlier on the
dime of the Spanish monarchy to find a western sea route to China, India, and the rumoured
gold and spice islands of Asia. Instead he landed in the Bahamas, becoming the first
European to visit the Americas since the Vikings set up colonies in Greenland and Newfoundland
in the 10th century.
Over the course of four journeys across the Atlantic, Columbus never set foot in modern-day
United States. Nevertheless, he’s become a figure of American nationalistic pride.
Case in point, the nation’s capital is the District of Columbia.
The first Columbus Day celebration was on the 300th anniversary in 1792. A century later
on the 400th anniversary, President Benjamin Harrison issued a proclamation encouraging
Americans to mark the date with patriotic celebrations. In 1937, President Franklin
D. Roosevelt made Columbus Day a national holiday. A law passed in 1968 which sought
to give Americans long holiday weekends lead to the creation of Columbus Day, which was
fixed as the second Monday in October in 1971.
The opposition to the holiday we’re seeing is actually older than the holiday itself
going back at least to the 19th century.
Italian immigrants arrived in America in large numbers in the late nineteenth century, and
they quickly adopted Columbus as a shield against discrimination. America as it was
existed because an Italian explorer landed there, so the other immigrant populations,
namely those from nordic and northern European countries, couldn’t possibly bar Italian
immigrants from enjoying their new American national identity, right?
Well, Americans were still not keen on their new Italian countrymen and pushed back against
Columbus Day celebrations, looking instead to a more ethnically comfortable figurehead.
They found one in Leif Erikson, the Viking explorer already lauded by Norwegian immigrants
who gave some American populations a means to target the Italian Catholic populations.
By the end of the nineteenth century, patriotism was taking the place of anti-Catholic sentiments,
and Columbus became an ethnically and religiously-neutral figurehead used to celebrate American identity
in all it’s forms.
But the more modern issues stem from the fact that celebrating Columbus confirms a Eurocentric
worldview embodied by a man who brought disease to an indigenous population before treating
them brutally for years. He has even become a sort of punching bag people use when pointing
out the flaws of the nation he founded. Once neutral, Columbus has reemerged as a dead
white male who embodies the “limits and costs of American opportunity.”
So this holiday is steeped in controversy, but the ongoing controversy over Columbus
Day in a multicultural democracy might be the most American thing about the holiday.
Columbus isn’t the only historical figure whose past is being questioned. The newest
Catholic Saint, Junipero Serra, is being scrutinized for his brutal colonization practices in California
in the 1700s. To learn more check out our video (pause). Thanks for watching, and be
sure to subscribe.