Advertisement
English transcript
US soldiers have been allegedly told to turn a blind eye to child molestation in Afghanistan.
A US Marine’s father says his son revealed to him that, “At night we can hear them
screaming, but we’re not allowed to do anything about it.” According to reports, soldiers
were disgusted at the sight of men lying with young boys and a sex slave chained to a bed.
Instead of responding, however, soldiers were allegedly told to respect cultural differences
- in this case, the seemingly common practice of bacha bazi or “boy play,” in which
older men force young boys into sexual servitude. In spite of this command, however, some US
soldiers have intervened - but do they have a responsibility or even the right to address
this issue?
One major reason why this is so controversial, is because in this case, the alleged perpetrators
of child abuse are US allies: Afghan forces. And, as recently as March 2015, President
Obama maintained that "the United States will continue to train, advise and assist Afghan
security forces." This is patently different from other cases, in which soldiers witness
atrocities in passing from afar. Some would argue that by aiding Afghan forces, the US
is complicit in the abuse.
In fact, after a Marine was shot down by an enslaved boy, the Marine’s father blamed
the US for his death. The father argued the young boy did not see a difference between
his son, who was repulsed by the sexual molestation, and his abusers. They are one and the same.
Another criticism is the seeming hypocrisy behind the US’s actions. One former Special
Forces Captain remarks, “The reason we were here is because we heard the terrible things
the Taliban were doing to people...But we were putting people into power who would do
things that were worse than the Taliban did...”
Still, in some people’s eyes, this issue is divorced from the war - seen as a domestic
matter that should be left to the jurisdiction of the governing state. Those who strictly
adhere to the international principle of non-intervention might argue that we are forbidden from intervening.
Even intervention for humanitarian causes is debated. In Afghanistan, soldiers engaging
in sexual relations with boys is not uncommon; for many, it is a symbol of status. One Afghan
commander explains that, "I had a boy because every commander had one..." However, many
argue that, child molestation should not fall under protection of cultural values - that
it is instead, a universal human rights violation.
Following this international outcry, the Afghan President responded by vowing to take aggressive
action against the abuses. The United States, for its part, has denied allegations of instructing
soldiers to ignore the abuse, despite the numerous reports. Because admitting fault
could lend credence to the argument that “Under conditions of democracy, to be frank and honest
about the purpose and nature of imperialism would be counterproductive to these aims.”
and so The United States must do so under the guise of “... protecting the causes
of freedom, democracy, and justice worldwide.”
The United States’ stance of not negotiating with terrorist is another highly contentious
international policy. Click here to watch our video on the pros and cons of negotiating with terrorists. Thanks for watching
Seeker Daily, and please make sure to subscribe.
A US Marine’s father says his son revealed to him that, “At night we can hear them
screaming, but we’re not allowed to do anything about it.” According to reports, soldiers
were disgusted at the sight of men lying with young boys and a sex slave chained to a bed.
Instead of responding, however, soldiers were allegedly told to respect cultural differences
- in this case, the seemingly common practice of bacha bazi or “boy play,” in which
older men force young boys into sexual servitude. In spite of this command, however, some US
soldiers have intervened - but do they have a responsibility or even the right to address
this issue?
One major reason why this is so controversial, is because in this case, the alleged perpetrators
of child abuse are US allies: Afghan forces. And, as recently as March 2015, President
Obama maintained that "the United States will continue to train, advise and assist Afghan
security forces." This is patently different from other cases, in which soldiers witness
atrocities in passing from afar. Some would argue that by aiding Afghan forces, the US
is complicit in the abuse.
In fact, after a Marine was shot down by an enslaved boy, the Marine’s father blamed
the US for his death. The father argued the young boy did not see a difference between
his son, who was repulsed by the sexual molestation, and his abusers. They are one and the same.
Another criticism is the seeming hypocrisy behind the US’s actions. One former Special
Forces Captain remarks, “The reason we were here is because we heard the terrible things
the Taliban were doing to people...But we were putting people into power who would do
things that were worse than the Taliban did...”
Still, in some people’s eyes, this issue is divorced from the war - seen as a domestic
matter that should be left to the jurisdiction of the governing state. Those who strictly
adhere to the international principle of non-intervention might argue that we are forbidden from intervening.
Even intervention for humanitarian causes is debated. In Afghanistan, soldiers engaging
in sexual relations with boys is not uncommon; for many, it is a symbol of status. One Afghan
commander explains that, "I had a boy because every commander had one..." However, many
argue that, child molestation should not fall under protection of cultural values - that
it is instead, a universal human rights violation.
Following this international outcry, the Afghan President responded by vowing to take aggressive
action against the abuses. The United States, for its part, has denied allegations of instructing
soldiers to ignore the abuse, despite the numerous reports. Because admitting fault
could lend credence to the argument that “Under conditions of democracy, to be frank and honest
about the purpose and nature of imperialism would be counterproductive to these aims.”
and so The United States must do so under the guise of “... protecting the causes
of freedom, democracy, and justice worldwide.”
The United States’ stance of not negotiating with terrorist is another highly contentious
international policy. Click here to watch our video on the pros and cons of negotiating with terrorists. Thanks for watching
Seeker Daily, and please make sure to subscribe.