YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 40 lines · added Nov 19, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

In 2013, Kayla Mueller, an American aid worker was taken captive while leaving a hospital
in Syria and allegedly sold off to an Isis militant who repeatedly beat, raped and eventually
killed her, acts that have obviously been condemned by the American people. But, some
have also criticized The United States government for its response to the situation - arguing
that once made aware of her capture, the government sat on this information for seven weeks and
this inaction decreased her chances of survival - in many ways reflecting the United States
long standing policy of not negotiating with terrorists. A policy that has recently come
under fire with the unfortunately similar fates of other Americans like journalists
James Foley and Steven Sotloff. So, does this approach make sense? Should the US negotiate
with terrorists?
First, the idea of not negotiating as government policy, seems to have originated in the 1980s,
with former President Ronald Reagan stance during his presidential campaign, wherein
he pronounced that "We will not negotiate with terrorists." But, in practice, Reagan
and every president since, has negotiated with terrorists in one way or another.
However, this stance cannot be dismissed as mere political rhetoric. The policy has had
very real consequences and applications - as is the case with legislation that forbade
ordinary citizens from negotiating ransoms for their family members’ release. Though
the Obama administration has recently relaxed this law, the National Security Council has
argued that "...the U.S. does not grant concessions to hostage takers. Doing so would only put
more Americans at risk of being taken captive." Indeed, when some point to European countries
like France and Italy who have rescued hostages by paying ransoms, others are quick to fight
back, arguing that it’s the fact that these hostages home countries pay ransoms that motivate
the capture in the first place. And they make a good case, especially if we assume that
these captures are motivated largely by financial incentives.
But what if they’re not? In 2014, ISIS made hundreds of millions of dollars more from
extortion and taxing the people of Iraq than from ransom payments. The money from these
ransoms, is really just a drop in a bucket. So it’s possible that these hostage situations
are motivated not by money, but by a desire to intimidate, to display power, and gain
legitimacy. The act of negotiation itself can confer similar licit status to the negotiating
party and signal that this legitimate entity views the terrorist organization as a serious
threat. TestTube News did a whole episode on just that.
But, motivations aside, one must consider the potential benefits of negotiation. The
obvious one, here, is that it may save innocent people’s lives. But another reason to engage,
is to gather information about the enemy. In Kayla’s case, for example, negotiating
could have meant learning more about ISIS, it’s members, operations, locations, drivers,
and other data that could have helped rescue her and prevent future kidnappings, as well
as defeat terrorist organizations.
Looking at the root of the problem, what drives terrorists to kidnap civilians in the first
place? To explore terrorists’ motives, check out this episode by TestTubeNews. As always,
thanks for watching, and subscribe to Seeker Daily.

Need subtitles from another video?