Advertisement
English transcript
Believe it or not, brothels were widespread and prostitution largely legal up until the
end of World War II. Some say outlawing these establishments was for the betterment of society,
while others argue that decriminalizing sex work offers a greater degree of protection
and more autonomy for those who work in the trade. So if legal brothels really did safeguard
sex workers, why were they outlawed? The first real brothels that accepted money in exchange
for sex, were established in Greece in the 5th Century BCE but it wasn’t till the the
medieval period that brothels became more widespread and had more formalized rules.
Members of the clergy and married men were not allowed to visit, though this wasn’t
heavily enforced. (Many European governments also stated that brothels had to be licensed
and could only operate in specific regions within a city. In Paris, brothels advertised
where they were by lighting a red lamp outside their doors -- which is how the term ‘red-light
district’ was born. Brothels were often run by madams, usually former prostitutes
who maintained the house, hired and fired sex workers and kept business discreet. Madams
also tried to stay on the good side of the law and the community -- even donating money
to churches and schools. However a lot of that money came from expensive fees charged
to Prostitutes. In exchange they got room, board and a certain degree of safety but it
left them with a meagre income, meaning they were trapped with no way out of the trade.
Legalised brothels operated like this for hundreds of years, right up until World War
II and the driving force behind why they were outlawed was not out of concern for prostitutes
or their safety, like you might have assumed, it was actually a reaction to nazism. In the
early 1900s, Paris had some of the most luxurious brothels in the world, places like le Chabanais
boasted famous clientele like Cary Grant and Humphrey Bogart. During World War II, Nazis
seized control of Parisian brothels for their entertainment -- as such these establishments
enjoyed many luxuries that others did not. When the war was over, the French prostitutes
were seen as Nazi collaborators. Many of them were dragged into the street by angry mobs
who shaved their heads and carved swastikas on their their foreheads. Finally, French
Leader, Charles de Gaulle, supported by former prostitute turned politician, Marthe Richard,
called for the closure of all brothels. Eventually most of Europe and America followed suit.
There are countries like New Zealand where sex work is not a criminal act and Amnesty
International argues that these prostitutes have a better quality of life saying there
is “evidence that the criminalization of adult sex work can lead to increased human
rights violations against sex workers.” So might we see a future where prostitution
is once again, not considered a criminal act? Well, Amnesty is pushing forward a policy
that supports prostitution as a human right, however critics have been quick to point out
that any policy is more likely to favour clients and pimps than the workers themselves, much
like it did in medieval times. In China, men who don’t want to cheat on their wives by
visiting a prostitute are turning to eerily lifelike sex dolls to learn more click here
to watch this episode of This Happened Here. Thanks for watching and please subscribe!
end of World War II. Some say outlawing these establishments was for the betterment of society,
while others argue that decriminalizing sex work offers a greater degree of protection
and more autonomy for those who work in the trade. So if legal brothels really did safeguard
sex workers, why were they outlawed? The first real brothels that accepted money in exchange
for sex, were established in Greece in the 5th Century BCE but it wasn’t till the the
medieval period that brothels became more widespread and had more formalized rules.
Members of the clergy and married men were not allowed to visit, though this wasn’t
heavily enforced. (Many European governments also stated that brothels had to be licensed
and could only operate in specific regions within a city. In Paris, brothels advertised
where they were by lighting a red lamp outside their doors -- which is how the term ‘red-light
district’ was born. Brothels were often run by madams, usually former prostitutes
who maintained the house, hired and fired sex workers and kept business discreet. Madams
also tried to stay on the good side of the law and the community -- even donating money
to churches and schools. However a lot of that money came from expensive fees charged
to Prostitutes. In exchange they got room, board and a certain degree of safety but it
left them with a meagre income, meaning they were trapped with no way out of the trade.
Legalised brothels operated like this for hundreds of years, right up until World War
II and the driving force behind why they were outlawed was not out of concern for prostitutes
or their safety, like you might have assumed, it was actually a reaction to nazism. In the
early 1900s, Paris had some of the most luxurious brothels in the world, places like le Chabanais
boasted famous clientele like Cary Grant and Humphrey Bogart. During World War II, Nazis
seized control of Parisian brothels for their entertainment -- as such these establishments
enjoyed many luxuries that others did not. When the war was over, the French prostitutes
were seen as Nazi collaborators. Many of them were dragged into the street by angry mobs
who shaved their heads and carved swastikas on their their foreheads. Finally, French
Leader, Charles de Gaulle, supported by former prostitute turned politician, Marthe Richard,
called for the closure of all brothels. Eventually most of Europe and America followed suit.
There are countries like New Zealand where sex work is not a criminal act and Amnesty
International argues that these prostitutes have a better quality of life saying there
is “evidence that the criminalization of adult sex work can lead to increased human
rights violations against sex workers.” So might we see a future where prostitution
is once again, not considered a criminal act? Well, Amnesty is pushing forward a policy
that supports prostitution as a human right, however critics have been quick to point out
that any policy is more likely to favour clients and pimps than the workers themselves, much
like it did in medieval times. In China, men who don’t want to cheat on their wives by
visiting a prostitute are turning to eerily lifelike sex dolls to learn more click here
to watch this episode of This Happened Here. Thanks for watching and please subscribe!