Advertisement
English transcript
On some college campuses, if things were getting hot and heavy between you and your girlfriend,
and you had sex, but she never said yes explicitly, she may have legal grounds for sexual assault.
The idea of what constitutes sexual consent seems to be changing from “no means no”
to “yes means yes,” at least in the eyes of some legislators who have clearly defined
consent for college campuses. In states like New York and California, consent must be explicit.
According to California Bill 967, “Affirmative consent must be ongoing throughout a sexual
activity” and “lack of protest or...silence” does not mean consent. What are your initial
reactions to this? Obviously, the intent of laws like these is to decrease cases of sexual
assault and rape on campus, which is a problem in the US that needs to be addressed - These
laws are meant to act as a deterrent and also disambiguate consent for practical legal purposes
- in essence to make it easier for everyone to figure out if there was any harm done or
intended. But, is this best way to address the problem? In some ways, the assumption
behind these laws is that we are unable to effectively communicate non-verbally - that
we can’t figure out if someone wants to have sex or continue having sex with us unless
they continuously say so - how often, that’s unclear - it may be every 2 minutes, every
4, or every change of position - the law simply states that it must be “ongoing.” But
in many ways, sex IS non-verbal communication. It’s a physical emotional ongoing conversation
between you and one or more parties. Which is why some argue that “Whether anyone could
feel ‘sexy’ under such conditions seems dubious at best.” Still, this was the same
argument we heard with condoms. Yet, today, they are much more normalized, with teenagers
using them at higher rates than older generations. Could this happen with verbal consent as well?
One 18 year old feels, "People might say it's impractical or ridiculous in reality, but
the possible end of doing something that's not something someone wants is a frightening
possibility." If future generations of teenagers are similarly driven by fear it is possible
that saying “yes” will just become a part of what sex IS… Some feel that these laws
are overly paternalistic and intrusive. Others argue that these laws would have little to
no effect on those intent on committing sexual assault. So, it is unclear if explicit affirmative
consent will continue to take hold on other college campuses. But, what will clearly be
an ongoing conversation, is how to negotiate the rights of an individual to privacy with
the rights of all to safety. Education on things like consent and sex is a perpetual
discussion all around the world. To see how the country of Germany is leading the controversial
charge on sex ed by teaching it to students as young as 5 years old, click now! And before
you go, make sure to subscribe. It’s the best way to get our videos to you each day.
Thanks!
and you had sex, but she never said yes explicitly, she may have legal grounds for sexual assault.
The idea of what constitutes sexual consent seems to be changing from “no means no”
to “yes means yes,” at least in the eyes of some legislators who have clearly defined
consent for college campuses. In states like New York and California, consent must be explicit.
According to California Bill 967, “Affirmative consent must be ongoing throughout a sexual
activity” and “lack of protest or...silence” does not mean consent. What are your initial
reactions to this? Obviously, the intent of laws like these is to decrease cases of sexual
assault and rape on campus, which is a problem in the US that needs to be addressed - These
laws are meant to act as a deterrent and also disambiguate consent for practical legal purposes
- in essence to make it easier for everyone to figure out if there was any harm done or
intended. But, is this best way to address the problem? In some ways, the assumption
behind these laws is that we are unable to effectively communicate non-verbally - that
we can’t figure out if someone wants to have sex or continue having sex with us unless
they continuously say so - how often, that’s unclear - it may be every 2 minutes, every
4, or every change of position - the law simply states that it must be “ongoing.” But
in many ways, sex IS non-verbal communication. It’s a physical emotional ongoing conversation
between you and one or more parties. Which is why some argue that “Whether anyone could
feel ‘sexy’ under such conditions seems dubious at best.” Still, this was the same
argument we heard with condoms. Yet, today, they are much more normalized, with teenagers
using them at higher rates than older generations. Could this happen with verbal consent as well?
One 18 year old feels, "People might say it's impractical or ridiculous in reality, but
the possible end of doing something that's not something someone wants is a frightening
possibility." If future generations of teenagers are similarly driven by fear it is possible
that saying “yes” will just become a part of what sex IS… Some feel that these laws
are overly paternalistic and intrusive. Others argue that these laws would have little to
no effect on those intent on committing sexual assault. So, it is unclear if explicit affirmative
consent will continue to take hold on other college campuses. But, what will clearly be
an ongoing conversation, is how to negotiate the rights of an individual to privacy with
the rights of all to safety. Education on things like consent and sex is a perpetual
discussion all around the world. To see how the country of Germany is leading the controversial
charge on sex ed by teaching it to students as young as 5 years old, click now! And before
you go, make sure to subscribe. It’s the best way to get our videos to you each day.
Thanks!