YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 35 lines · added Nov 20, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Slum tourism, the act of visiting the often crowded, unsanitary, dangerous places and
the people who inhabit them, is rapidly growing worldwide. A 15 year old crouching down as
she washes dishes in a slum in India says, “I feel awkward that you are seeing me like
this. It’s not exploitation, but it makes me uncomfortable because you are very rich
and we are very poor.” While she believes it is not exploitation; some argue that it
is unequivocally so. Yet others, argue slum tourism is beneficial to the impoverished
communities. So which is it? What does slum touring actually look like and how is it impacting
communities? Slum tourism inherently creates a dynamic of an observer and an observed - a
sort of disconnect that is nothing new - this type of tourism was present in the 19th century
in London and New York to satisfy the local elite’s desire to see “how the other half
lives.” What has changed, however, is the gross commercialization and unprecedented
access to such places. Often foreigners come from other countries and pay $50 or so to
a tour guide company who then provides accompanied walking tours of the homes, shops, and the
daily lives of slum dwellers. Tourists today are from farther away and their experience
is greatly shaped by the specific tour group they have hired and their particular agenda.
Some types of slum touring, where residents are viewed like animals in a zoo, are in stark
contrast to what others describe as a cultural exchange that can serve as a catalyst for
progress. It is not uncommon to see children running up to tourists and engaging them in
conversation, facilitating connection. One seemingly practical slum dweller in Kenya
who recognizes tourists have choices, says “We’d rather prefer that the muzungu [white
people] come to see us because they [might] come and fund a school here.” Obviously,
the hope here is that these experiences will inspire the wealthy to give back. And many,
do. But even those who don’t, may still be contributing. Economically speaking, the
very act of taking the tour can flow money into the community. How much all depends on
the touring company. Some, give 50 to 80 percent of ticket proceeds to the inhabitants, while
others may not give back at all - another reason why it’s so difficult to ascertain
the impact of slum touring. Economics aside, some slum tourism subjects believe there is
greater cost. As one Kenyan resident puts it, “Slum tourism is a one-way street: They
get photos; we lose a piece of our dignity.” Regardless of where you land on the spectrum,
most agree that it is difficult to effect change without awareness. Perhaps the middle
ground lies in contextualizing tours and ensuring inhabitants have a voice both in the message
being conveyed and the distribution of funds. One photographer shared his striking images
of a boy who works on a literal mountain of garbage in Cambodia with our other channel
Seeker Stories. To see and learn more about his incredible photos, click the annotation
now! And if you haven’t already, please make sure to subscribe. Thanks for watching!

Need subtitles from another video?