Advertisement
English transcript
What happens to babies born behind bars? Around the world, many are left in the care of their
imprisoned mothers. If born in Russia, Germany, Chile, Mexico the newborn will stay with it's
mother for its first few weeks to years of its life. In some countries, incarcerated
mothers are even allowed to leave the prison during weekends to take care of their children
- things like do their laundry, feed, bathe, and help them with their homework. The general
sentiment in these countries is that it is in child’s best interest to remain in close
contact with its mothers during the early stages of life, prisoner or not. But, this
is in stark contrast to the fate of babies born to inmates in the United States, where
most are almost immediately taken from their mothers at birth, either placed in foster
care, with relatives, or put up for adoption. But it hasn’t always been this way. Back
in the early 1900s when women-only prisons were first developed, many prisons included
nurseries and teaching childrearing practices was considered a part of rehabilitation. But
around the 1970s, when the female inmate population began to grow exponentially, prisons found
it financially prohibitive to cover the 24,000 dollars or so a year it takes to rear a child
in prison. Thus, the new norm became to take children away from their mothers. Which can
be a huge problem according to some child development research. Attachment theory posits
that early bonds with our caregivers provide the basis for our adult relationships and
how we interact in our social world. When these parent-child bonds are not created with
incarcerated mothers and their children, it can lead to a child who is more vigilant,
fearful, or has difficulty getting close to others. This is partly why a handful of prisons
(9/10) in the states have begun allowing incarcerated mothers to keep their babies during their
first months of life - one prison in New York even has a comprehensive nursery. And so far,
the results look promising, finding that these children fare better on measures of attachment
compared to at risk children placed in foster care. What’s more, it seems to be good for
the mothers. One inmate mother says, “Nothing has made me want to change before. Kids make
you want to change.” (Mayer) Indeed, results indicated that mothers who rear their children
in prison have lower rates of recidivism and misconduct. From an economics perspective,
this is great for taxpayers - by keeping women from going back to jail, the state saves money.Moreover,
their children may be less likely to cost the state money down the line. Still, some
critics “don’t think any children should be in prison. Period.” And, nurseries could
mean lost revenue for those prisons, some of which are privatized businesses whose models
tend to be aligned with increasing profits and not the welfare of the women, and the
babies born to them: this could be the greatest underlying issue.
For profit prisons are draining the US economy as this episode on Test Tube News explains.
Click here to watch the whole thing. And, as always, thanks for watching Seeker Daily.
Subscribe for more.
imprisoned mothers. If born in Russia, Germany, Chile, Mexico the newborn will stay with it's
mother for its first few weeks to years of its life. In some countries, incarcerated
mothers are even allowed to leave the prison during weekends to take care of their children
- things like do their laundry, feed, bathe, and help them with their homework. The general
sentiment in these countries is that it is in child’s best interest to remain in close
contact with its mothers during the early stages of life, prisoner or not. But, this
is in stark contrast to the fate of babies born to inmates in the United States, where
most are almost immediately taken from their mothers at birth, either placed in foster
care, with relatives, or put up for adoption. But it hasn’t always been this way. Back
in the early 1900s when women-only prisons were first developed, many prisons included
nurseries and teaching childrearing practices was considered a part of rehabilitation. But
around the 1970s, when the female inmate population began to grow exponentially, prisons found
it financially prohibitive to cover the 24,000 dollars or so a year it takes to rear a child
in prison. Thus, the new norm became to take children away from their mothers. Which can
be a huge problem according to some child development research. Attachment theory posits
that early bonds with our caregivers provide the basis for our adult relationships and
how we interact in our social world. When these parent-child bonds are not created with
incarcerated mothers and their children, it can lead to a child who is more vigilant,
fearful, or has difficulty getting close to others. This is partly why a handful of prisons
(9/10) in the states have begun allowing incarcerated mothers to keep their babies during their
first months of life - one prison in New York even has a comprehensive nursery. And so far,
the results look promising, finding that these children fare better on measures of attachment
compared to at risk children placed in foster care. What’s more, it seems to be good for
the mothers. One inmate mother says, “Nothing has made me want to change before. Kids make
you want to change.” (Mayer) Indeed, results indicated that mothers who rear their children
in prison have lower rates of recidivism and misconduct. From an economics perspective,
this is great for taxpayers - by keeping women from going back to jail, the state saves money.Moreover,
their children may be less likely to cost the state money down the line. Still, some
critics “don’t think any children should be in prison. Period.” And, nurseries could
mean lost revenue for those prisons, some of which are privatized businesses whose models
tend to be aligned with increasing profits and not the welfare of the women, and the
babies born to them: this could be the greatest underlying issue.
For profit prisons are draining the US economy as this episode on Test Tube News explains.
Click here to watch the whole thing. And, as always, thanks for watching Seeker Daily.
Subscribe for more.