Advertisement
English transcript
What happens to your body when you die? When Jesse Shipley died in a car accident in 2005,
his body was autopsied after which his family buried his body and held a funeral. Pretty
typical. But, some time after, when Jesse’s former classmates were touring a morgue on
a field trip, they saw “Jesse Shipley” labeled on a jar that was preserving Jesse’s
brain in chemicals. The kicker is that his family neither authorized
the display of his brain nor was notified that Jesse’s brain was missing from his
body when they buried him. Disturbed to learn this, his family sued the state of New York.
And while they initially won the case, the ruling was recently overturned in appeals
court - deeming that so long as body parts are NOT removed illegally during an autopsy,
the state has discretion over them and is not required to notify the families. Basically,
any organs can be removed and your family would never even know. Which can be a huge
problem for those who are ideologically opposed to organ removal. Under New York’s law,
they would have little to no legal recourse. If no one claims your body and you don’t
have a will, your body will typically be disposed of by the state - in which case, you don’t
really have a say in the matter. If you indicate in your will or have a “next of kin” who
can speak for you, the state will generally grant your wishes for body disposition. But,
like Jessie’s case illustrates, your body is still considered to be a body even when
parts are removed, so technically organs can be removed and no laws will be broken. It
seems that parts are not really considered a part of you - in Canada, an Ontario court
ruled that tissue removed from patients is the property of the institution that removed
it and not of the patients. Your body parts are not really your own. And it’s all really
complicated because, legally, your body as a whole belongs to no one. If you’re as
intrigued as I am, please let us know what you think in the comments. I would love to
hear your thoughts and keep the conversation going. And as always, thanks for watching
Seeker Daily. Please subscribe.
his body was autopsied after which his family buried his body and held a funeral. Pretty
typical. But, some time after, when Jesse’s former classmates were touring a morgue on
a field trip, they saw “Jesse Shipley” labeled on a jar that was preserving Jesse’s
brain in chemicals. The kicker is that his family neither authorized
the display of his brain nor was notified that Jesse’s brain was missing from his
body when they buried him. Disturbed to learn this, his family sued the state of New York.
And while they initially won the case, the ruling was recently overturned in appeals
court - deeming that so long as body parts are NOT removed illegally during an autopsy,
the state has discretion over them and is not required to notify the families. Basically,
any organs can be removed and your family would never even know. Which can be a huge
problem for those who are ideologically opposed to organ removal. Under New York’s law,
they would have little to no legal recourse. If no one claims your body and you don’t
have a will, your body will typically be disposed of by the state - in which case, you don’t
really have a say in the matter. If you indicate in your will or have a “next of kin” who
can speak for you, the state will generally grant your wishes for body disposition. But,
like Jessie’s case illustrates, your body is still considered to be a body even when
parts are removed, so technically organs can be removed and no laws will be broken. It
seems that parts are not really considered a part of you - in Canada, an Ontario court
ruled that tissue removed from patients is the property of the institution that removed
it and not of the patients. Your body parts are not really your own. And it’s all really
complicated because, legally, your body as a whole belongs to no one. If you’re as
intrigued as I am, please let us know what you think in the comments. I would love to
hear your thoughts and keep the conversation going. And as always, thanks for watching
Seeker Daily. Please subscribe.