Advertisement
English transcript
Why is anything classified? Because the government deems that certain information threatens national
security so much that its secrecy is more important than the basic democratic right
to have a transparent government. Classification is a process - something exists, a document
or a piece of information, and then becomes classified. But this was not the case for
the prisoners at Guantanamo Bay. Until recently, all of their memories, from the time they've
been under CIA custody, were classified as state secrets of the U.S. government. This
all came to light during the trial of Khalid Sheik Mohammed, architect of the 9/11 attacks.
When the military commission tried Mohammed as well as four of his co-conspirators, they
were told that they couldn’t say what happened to them at Guantanamo bay because their memories
contained secret information about methods the U.S. uses to interrogate prisoners. The
government declared in an order that every single statement from those on trial was “presumptively
classified” -- in other words it’s classified the moment its uttered. And even though the
trial was broadcast via closed circuit TV to select media outlets, it was on 40-second
delay in case the court decided that what was being said could be considered secret.
But now the government is loosening its grip on detainees’ memories. After backlash from
the ACLU and human rights groups, as well as one of the lawyers representing the detainees,
the government has allowed a limited amount of the experiences of these men to be told.
As the lawyer James Connell, put it, “A person's own experiences -- whether the smell
of a rose or the click of a gun near one's head -- are what make them a person, and the
government can never own or control them." And some of the experiences of these prisoners
are particularly gruesome. Reports have surfaced that detail how one prisoner lost his left
eye, others were sexually abused, another was “hung from a pole for two days, naked
and hooded, while interrogators threw ice water on him.” But it wasn’t Connell’s
criticisms that made the government ease its rules. It was a Senate Intelligence Committee
report from last year that detailed several of the military’s “enhanced interrogation
techniques.” It was this report that cut through the government’s original argument
- that the whole operation at Guantanamo was classified, and so any information could jeopardize
it. Now lawyers can submit testimony for declassification, and anything besides locations or people involved,
may possibly be made legal to report. There’s little sympathy for terrorists who committed
atrocities that hurt Americans, but there’s also an imperative to know the torturous things
that they were put through, if only for the sake of that basic democratic right: transparency.
To learn about what the levels of secrecy in the US government are, watch this video
on TestTube News. Thanks for watching, and don’t forget to hit that subscribe button.
security so much that its secrecy is more important than the basic democratic right
to have a transparent government. Classification is a process - something exists, a document
or a piece of information, and then becomes classified. But this was not the case for
the prisoners at Guantanamo Bay. Until recently, all of their memories, from the time they've
been under CIA custody, were classified as state secrets of the U.S. government. This
all came to light during the trial of Khalid Sheik Mohammed, architect of the 9/11 attacks.
When the military commission tried Mohammed as well as four of his co-conspirators, they
were told that they couldn’t say what happened to them at Guantanamo bay because their memories
contained secret information about methods the U.S. uses to interrogate prisoners. The
government declared in an order that every single statement from those on trial was “presumptively
classified” -- in other words it’s classified the moment its uttered. And even though the
trial was broadcast via closed circuit TV to select media outlets, it was on 40-second
delay in case the court decided that what was being said could be considered secret.
But now the government is loosening its grip on detainees’ memories. After backlash from
the ACLU and human rights groups, as well as one of the lawyers representing the detainees,
the government has allowed a limited amount of the experiences of these men to be told.
As the lawyer James Connell, put it, “A person's own experiences -- whether the smell
of a rose or the click of a gun near one's head -- are what make them a person, and the
government can never own or control them." And some of the experiences of these prisoners
are particularly gruesome. Reports have surfaced that detail how one prisoner lost his left
eye, others were sexually abused, another was “hung from a pole for two days, naked
and hooded, while interrogators threw ice water on him.” But it wasn’t Connell’s
criticisms that made the government ease its rules. It was a Senate Intelligence Committee
report from last year that detailed several of the military’s “enhanced interrogation
techniques.” It was this report that cut through the government’s original argument
- that the whole operation at Guantanamo was classified, and so any information could jeopardize
it. Now lawyers can submit testimony for declassification, and anything besides locations or people involved,
may possibly be made legal to report. There’s little sympathy for terrorists who committed
atrocities that hurt Americans, but there’s also an imperative to know the torturous things
that they were put through, if only for the sake of that basic democratic right: transparency.
To learn about what the levels of secrecy in the US government are, watch this video
on TestTube News. Thanks for watching, and don’t forget to hit that subscribe button.