Advertisement
English transcript
Most actors aren’t real doctors, they just play one on TV. So should you listen to their
medical advice or get a second opinion?
What up my peeps, Julian here for DNews. We love famous people, even when we hate them.
We love looking at them, gossiping about them, and listening to their advice. Usually that
advice is harmless. Maybe they’re giving you tips on how to succeed, or for a killer
kale salad or something. But when that advice affects public health, should you listen?
Well, as with most things in life, that’s a gray area. It can go either way. Like in
the case of Angelina Jolie. In 2013 the actress announced she had had a double mastectomy
in a preventative measure against breast cancer. Genetic testing revealed she had a mutation
of the BRCA1 gene that, according to Jolie, gave her an 87% chance of developing the disease.
Some critics panned her decision, either for being too extreme or lamenting that she would
alter her figure. I would like to remind those people that it is in fact her figure and she
can do whatever she likes with it.
And it looks like Jolie’s decision has had a positive impact on public awareness about
breast cancer. Serendipitously the Medical University of Graz in Austria had just surveyed
1000 women about breast cancer treatment options right before Jolie’s announcement. Once
the news broke, they decided to survey 1000 women again to see if their knowledge on the
topic had changed. And indeed it had. The first survey showed 88.9% of women knew mastectomies
were an option. That number got a little bump, up to 92.6% on the second survey. But the
real change was seen in awareness of treatment options. The first poll showed 57.6% of women
knew they could have reconstructive surgery using their own fatty tissue instead of synthetic
breast implants. That number jumped to 68.9% in the second poll. And at first only 40.5%
knew reconstruction could be done at the same time as the mastectomy. That number shot up
19% to 59.5% in the second survey. A separate 2014 study in the UK found that demand for
genetic testing for breast cancer risk almost doubled after Jolie’s announcement.
The fact that it was Angelina Jolie probably helped in another way. As it turns out, people
are quite attached to their body parts, and having them surgically removed can be a traumatizing
thing. But if Angelina Jolie, a woman of famous beauty, valued her health more and had the
operation, maybe it’s not so scary after all.
Celebrity advice isn’t always so helpful though. I knew as soon as I brought this topic
up, many of you were screaming the name “Jenny McCarthy.” I could hear you through your
computer screen. For those that don’t know, Jenny McCarthy is a model and actress who
has become the de facto face of the anti-vaccination movement. Her son was diagnosed with autism
shortly after receiving vaccinations, she correlated the two, and has been on a crusade
to keep parents from vaccinating their children since.
The thing is, it’s pretty definitive that vaccines and autism are unrelated. Thimerosal,
the mercury containing compound that anti-vaxxers demonize hasn’t been used in childhood vaccines
since 2001, yet autism rates continue to climb. But you know what vaccines do cause? A severe
deficiency in measles and mumps. And you know what measles and mumps do? They kill children,
that’s what.
It looks like the celebrity backed anti-vax movement has had an impact though. One study
found that when a family has a child on the autism spectrum, they vaccinate their subsequent
children by age two 73% of the time. Families with no autistic children vaccinated by that
age 84% of the time. The gap had narrowed by age 5, but following the vaccine schedule
is vital to preventing outbreaks. In the end, this particular celebrity and her message
are hurting public health.
Of course these are just two examples. This list of celebrity backed campaigns that affect
public health are endless. Celebrities endorse pet causes that are all over the map, from
gun control to parkinson's research to HIV prevention to cancer awareness. But even if
they support a good cause, the information they dole out isn’t always accurate. Still,
according to a 2011 University of Michigan survey, 24% of people place some value on
a celebrity’s opinion. So, what’s the answer to our first question? Should you trust
an unqualified but convincing stranger that you feel you know and trust? To be brutally
honest, no. I know that you have the internet. You can always dig deeper on a topic and have
no excuse to be ignorant. Always search for new information, avoid the human tendency
for confirmation bias, seek out expert opinions, and be willing to accept that what you thought
was unshakably right was wrong. It’s not easy, but for your health and the public’s
health, it’s the smart thing to do.
Public health misconceptions and crazy diet fads often go together and both of them drive
me insane. Worse, it looks like health food can make you fat because the world is a tragically
ironic place. Matt Lieberman explains here.
Do you take advice from celebrities or not? How’s that working out for you? Let us know
in the comments, subscribe for more, and I will see you next time on DNews.
medical advice or get a second opinion?
What up my peeps, Julian here for DNews. We love famous people, even when we hate them.
We love looking at them, gossiping about them, and listening to their advice. Usually that
advice is harmless. Maybe they’re giving you tips on how to succeed, or for a killer
kale salad or something. But when that advice affects public health, should you listen?
Well, as with most things in life, that’s a gray area. It can go either way. Like in
the case of Angelina Jolie. In 2013 the actress announced she had had a double mastectomy
in a preventative measure against breast cancer. Genetic testing revealed she had a mutation
of the BRCA1 gene that, according to Jolie, gave her an 87% chance of developing the disease.
Some critics panned her decision, either for being too extreme or lamenting that she would
alter her figure. I would like to remind those people that it is in fact her figure and she
can do whatever she likes with it.
And it looks like Jolie’s decision has had a positive impact on public awareness about
breast cancer. Serendipitously the Medical University of Graz in Austria had just surveyed
1000 women about breast cancer treatment options right before Jolie’s announcement. Once
the news broke, they decided to survey 1000 women again to see if their knowledge on the
topic had changed. And indeed it had. The first survey showed 88.9% of women knew mastectomies
were an option. That number got a little bump, up to 92.6% on the second survey. But the
real change was seen in awareness of treatment options. The first poll showed 57.6% of women
knew they could have reconstructive surgery using their own fatty tissue instead of synthetic
breast implants. That number jumped to 68.9% in the second poll. And at first only 40.5%
knew reconstruction could be done at the same time as the mastectomy. That number shot up
19% to 59.5% in the second survey. A separate 2014 study in the UK found that demand for
genetic testing for breast cancer risk almost doubled after Jolie’s announcement.
The fact that it was Angelina Jolie probably helped in another way. As it turns out, people
are quite attached to their body parts, and having them surgically removed can be a traumatizing
thing. But if Angelina Jolie, a woman of famous beauty, valued her health more and had the
operation, maybe it’s not so scary after all.
Celebrity advice isn’t always so helpful though. I knew as soon as I brought this topic
up, many of you were screaming the name “Jenny McCarthy.” I could hear you through your
computer screen. For those that don’t know, Jenny McCarthy is a model and actress who
has become the de facto face of the anti-vaccination movement. Her son was diagnosed with autism
shortly after receiving vaccinations, she correlated the two, and has been on a crusade
to keep parents from vaccinating their children since.
The thing is, it’s pretty definitive that vaccines and autism are unrelated. Thimerosal,
the mercury containing compound that anti-vaxxers demonize hasn’t been used in childhood vaccines
since 2001, yet autism rates continue to climb. But you know what vaccines do cause? A severe
deficiency in measles and mumps. And you know what measles and mumps do? They kill children,
that’s what.
It looks like the celebrity backed anti-vax movement has had an impact though. One study
found that when a family has a child on the autism spectrum, they vaccinate their subsequent
children by age two 73% of the time. Families with no autistic children vaccinated by that
age 84% of the time. The gap had narrowed by age 5, but following the vaccine schedule
is vital to preventing outbreaks. In the end, this particular celebrity and her message
are hurting public health.
Of course these are just two examples. This list of celebrity backed campaigns that affect
public health are endless. Celebrities endorse pet causes that are all over the map, from
gun control to parkinson's research to HIV prevention to cancer awareness. But even if
they support a good cause, the information they dole out isn’t always accurate. Still,
according to a 2011 University of Michigan survey, 24% of people place some value on
a celebrity’s opinion. So, what’s the answer to our first question? Should you trust
an unqualified but convincing stranger that you feel you know and trust? To be brutally
honest, no. I know that you have the internet. You can always dig deeper on a topic and have
no excuse to be ignorant. Always search for new information, avoid the human tendency
for confirmation bias, seek out expert opinions, and be willing to accept that what you thought
was unshakably right was wrong. It’s not easy, but for your health and the public’s
health, it’s the smart thing to do.
Public health misconceptions and crazy diet fads often go together and both of them drive
me insane. Worse, it looks like health food can make you fat because the world is a tragically
ironic place. Matt Lieberman explains here.
Do you take advice from celebrities or not? How’s that working out for you? Let us know
in the comments, subscribe for more, and I will see you next time on DNews.