Advertisement
English transcript
There have been nearly 300 mass shootings so far this year, but you've probably only
heard about a handful. Why are we so apathetic to these incidences of mass murder?
According to federal statutes, a "mass killing" is when three or more people are killed in
one incident. The stats you hear in the news get confusing because everyone counts these
things differently, but according to director of research at the Minnesota Department of
Corrections, Grant Duwe; there were 909 mass killings from 1900 to 1999.[1] In the 90s,
it averaged a little more than 4 per year. But from 2000 to 2013, we averaged more than
11 per year.[2] And, that's using federal definitions, if we include people who were
wounded or killed by gunfire in one incident: we find 294 mass shootings occured in 2015
ALONE.[3]
Even though there are more mass killings now, we're not seeing that reflected in national
attention. We just seem… meh on the whole thing. According to Pew Research Center’s
Project for Excellence in Journalism, 29% of local news stories in 2005 were about crime,
by 2012 it had dropped to 17%.[4] Why? Because people are habituating. Habituation is the
act of psychological adaptation, we're getting used to hearing mass shootings. The story
doesn't change, and when it doesn't change, we begin to ignore it. As President Obama
intimated this week, they're becoming "routine." We literally cannot focus on each individual
crime, and that causes psychological numbness.[5]
Genocides, holocausts, ethnic cleanses, civil wars, insurgencies, all of these have become
routine… I mean, chances are you started tune out during that LIST just now! Media
theorists and psychologists call this the "issue attention cycle." As described by Anthony
Downs book Up and Down with ecology -- the "issue-attention cycle:" first, we are alarmed,
"How could this happen?!" we cry! And then move through the stages… As the problem
becomes real, we discover the solution isn't easy; after a period of intense focus, and
debate, public interest declines; and, eventually, we enter the post-problem stage. Here, quote
the issue falls into a "twilight realm of lesser attention of spasmodic recurrences
of interest." Often says Downs, by the Post-problem stage 5, we've created programs, institutions
and policies to try to solve the problem at hand… though not always[6]. In the end,
the cycle can be reinvigorated when a new iteration presents itself -- like a massive
school shooting, theater shooting, military base shooting or the like. Each narrative
is novel, and the novelty reinvigorates attention, but otherwise, school shootings are joining
the list of things we just don't have the psychological wherewithal to stick to. Humans
HAVE to habituate, without this biological mandate, every tree would be a NEW tree -- we'd
never be able to discern new information from the repeated information surrounding it.[7]
Because of habituation, MASS might be the biggest obstacle.[8] After each tragedy, the
media attempts to implement "frame changing" to move the narrative around, pulling the
novel information out of the clutter. In coverage of Columbine; the media attached faces and
names to victims; but to change the frame, Sandy Hook's coverage was led by gun control
debates raging through the country.[9] These two mass shootings weren't necessarily novel
situations, but they mixed personal stories with new coverage, and thus they stood out
in our national attention. As described by a paper in 2014's Homicide Studies, without
novel ways to tell an old story, we (and the media) pretty much ignore tragedies. Dr. Paul
Slovic, professor of psychology at the University of Oregon writes, "When it comes to eliciting
compassion, the identified individual victim, with a face and a name, has no peer.[10]"
By covering these events with numbers instead of names, by covering them as much as we do,
and by failing to create institutions and policies to fix the problems, we're stuck.
If you blame media, blame government, blame humans; you'd be right each time. To break
the cycle, we need to make a change. Ignoring it, refusing to make changes, or acknowledge
a problem and hoping the shootings stop won't work (and hasn't), but if we actively adopt
some solution to fix the mass shooting problem, future stories will be automatically frame-changed.
Hard science doesn't have an easy answer to this social issue, instead we're left with
the difficult one. Look at our failings, find a solution, and fix the problem. In Psychological
Science Agenda Dr. Slovic wrote, "The repetitiveness of such atrocities, ignored by powerful people
and nations, and by the general public, calls for explanations that may reflect some fundamental
deficiency in our humanity -- a deficiency that, once identified, might possibly be overcome."
Tell me about your feelings down below. Our sister shows Seeker and TestTube News are
covering this story today also. Even though we outlined the data, we left it to TestTube
News to answer, why are there so many mass shootings? [soundup] Thanks for watching DNews,
please subscribe, if you had a conversation with your friends about why no one seems to
care about mass shootings, share this with them and further the conversation. I'll see
you tomorrow, thanks for watching DNews.
heard about a handful. Why are we so apathetic to these incidences of mass murder?
According to federal statutes, a "mass killing" is when three or more people are killed in
one incident. The stats you hear in the news get confusing because everyone counts these
things differently, but according to director of research at the Minnesota Department of
Corrections, Grant Duwe; there were 909 mass killings from 1900 to 1999.[1] In the 90s,
it averaged a little more than 4 per year. But from 2000 to 2013, we averaged more than
11 per year.[2] And, that's using federal definitions, if we include people who were
wounded or killed by gunfire in one incident: we find 294 mass shootings occured in 2015
ALONE.[3]
Even though there are more mass killings now, we're not seeing that reflected in national
attention. We just seem… meh on the whole thing. According to Pew Research Center’s
Project for Excellence in Journalism, 29% of local news stories in 2005 were about crime,
by 2012 it had dropped to 17%.[4] Why? Because people are habituating. Habituation is the
act of psychological adaptation, we're getting used to hearing mass shootings. The story
doesn't change, and when it doesn't change, we begin to ignore it. As President Obama
intimated this week, they're becoming "routine." We literally cannot focus on each individual
crime, and that causes psychological numbness.[5]
Genocides, holocausts, ethnic cleanses, civil wars, insurgencies, all of these have become
routine… I mean, chances are you started tune out during that LIST just now! Media
theorists and psychologists call this the "issue attention cycle." As described by Anthony
Downs book Up and Down with ecology -- the "issue-attention cycle:" first, we are alarmed,
"How could this happen?!" we cry! And then move through the stages… As the problem
becomes real, we discover the solution isn't easy; after a period of intense focus, and
debate, public interest declines; and, eventually, we enter the post-problem stage. Here, quote
the issue falls into a "twilight realm of lesser attention of spasmodic recurrences
of interest." Often says Downs, by the Post-problem stage 5, we've created programs, institutions
and policies to try to solve the problem at hand… though not always[6]. In the end,
the cycle can be reinvigorated when a new iteration presents itself -- like a massive
school shooting, theater shooting, military base shooting or the like. Each narrative
is novel, and the novelty reinvigorates attention, but otherwise, school shootings are joining
the list of things we just don't have the psychological wherewithal to stick to. Humans
HAVE to habituate, without this biological mandate, every tree would be a NEW tree -- we'd
never be able to discern new information from the repeated information surrounding it.[7]
Because of habituation, MASS might be the biggest obstacle.[8] After each tragedy, the
media attempts to implement "frame changing" to move the narrative around, pulling the
novel information out of the clutter. In coverage of Columbine; the media attached faces and
names to victims; but to change the frame, Sandy Hook's coverage was led by gun control
debates raging through the country.[9] These two mass shootings weren't necessarily novel
situations, but they mixed personal stories with new coverage, and thus they stood out
in our national attention. As described by a paper in 2014's Homicide Studies, without
novel ways to tell an old story, we (and the media) pretty much ignore tragedies. Dr. Paul
Slovic, professor of psychology at the University of Oregon writes, "When it comes to eliciting
compassion, the identified individual victim, with a face and a name, has no peer.[10]"
By covering these events with numbers instead of names, by covering them as much as we do,
and by failing to create institutions and policies to fix the problems, we're stuck.
If you blame media, blame government, blame humans; you'd be right each time. To break
the cycle, we need to make a change. Ignoring it, refusing to make changes, or acknowledge
a problem and hoping the shootings stop won't work (and hasn't), but if we actively adopt
some solution to fix the mass shooting problem, future stories will be automatically frame-changed.
Hard science doesn't have an easy answer to this social issue, instead we're left with
the difficult one. Look at our failings, find a solution, and fix the problem. In Psychological
Science Agenda Dr. Slovic wrote, "The repetitiveness of such atrocities, ignored by powerful people
and nations, and by the general public, calls for explanations that may reflect some fundamental
deficiency in our humanity -- a deficiency that, once identified, might possibly be overcome."
Tell me about your feelings down below. Our sister shows Seeker and TestTube News are
covering this story today also. Even though we outlined the data, we left it to TestTube
News to answer, why are there so many mass shootings? [soundup] Thanks for watching DNews,
please subscribe, if you had a conversation with your friends about why no one seems to
care about mass shootings, share this with them and further the conversation. I'll see
you tomorrow, thanks for watching DNews.