Advertisement
English transcript
Books, stamps, beanie babies, movie tickets, why do people collect things? What’s the
point?
Hey collectors, Julia here for DNews.
In today’s world downsizing is big. Getting rid of clutter is trendy and people are learning
to live with less. Yet there will always be that one person you know who collects things.
Like Sheli McHugh on twitter who collects sheep things or my friend Chastity who has
kept tickets from every movie she’s been to since 1997.
So why do people do it? I turned to twitter for some personal answers.
People have all sorts of reasons. For some collecting is a way to bond with people, like
Bruivision collected coins as a hobby to share with her dad. Moiety Mouse said they
collect rocks out of curiosity about the world around them. DR. Zen collects key chains because
s/he enjoys the “thrill of the hunt.”
People like this aren’t just weird pack rats. They’re just fulfilling a natural
urge. The urge to collect is very primitive and is found throughout the animal kingdom.
Over 70 species have been documented to collect. Rats and crows. The bowerbird of Eastern Australia
and Queensland collects unusual objects as part of an elaborate courtship ritual.
So some researchers think collecting goes back to early days as humans. For our hunter-gather
ancestors, collecting food could mean the difference between life and death during a
harsh growing season or famine. So it’s not surprising this trait evolved. But collecting
beanies won’t help you survive a winter. (sorry 90s kids, they’re pretty worthless,
unless it’s a rare princess Di bear.)
So what’s going on in the brain?
Like Dr. Zen said, it’s the thrill of the hunt. When you find that thing, that rare
baseball card your brain releases a hit of dopamine. That tells your brain “yeah this
is good, do it again”. This probably helped our ancestors find food.
Finding some ripe berries made their brains go, “yup awesome, these will keep us alive,
do it again” but after a while the brain gets used to it and doesn’t release as much
dopamine the next time they found those berries. So you keep seeking. Keep hunting for that
next thrill. While that kept our ancestors alive. It keeps us seeking and collecting.
Research published in the journal Brain found the specific area of the brain responsible
for collecting behavior. The researchers identified 13 patients with focal brain lesions who exhibited
abnormal collecting behavior but performed fine on tests of intelligence, memory, and
reasoning. These patients showed no signs of abnormal collecting before the brain damage.
After using high resolution 3D MRI, the researchers found the culprit. It turns out that the brain
was damaged in a very specific place, in “a part of the frontal lobes of the cortex, particularly
on the right side”.
Speaking of abnormal collecting behavior, are you having trouble letting go of your
collection? That’s not so unusual. In fact it’s pretty biological. Dr. Loretta G Breuning,
founder of the Inner Mammal Institute describes an experiment where monkeys were given spinach
as a reward for a task. Which, ya know they liked. But when they were given a grape, their
dopamine levels spiked. After a while of getting that grape as a reward, their brains stopped
spiking with as much dopamine. So it stopped feeling as good. Then the researchers switched
back to spinach and the monkeys were NOT HAPPY. AT ALL. They missed the grapes, even if they
stopped feeling as good.
So for most of us it’s perfectly natural to not feel good about letting things go.
But sometimes, it’s a problem. Another study published in the journal Archives of General
Psychiatry, using MRI techniques, found that patients with hoarding disorder have abnormal
activity in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and insula. They had lower activity
than other people when faced with the idea of giving away stuff that didn’t belong
to them, but more activity when faced with the thought of giving away their own stuff.
The patients reported indecisiveness, and feeling like things were "not just right".
Another study published in the journal American Journal of Psychiatry, found that people who
hoard showed decreased brain activity in the posterior cingulate gyrus. An area involved
in spatial orientation and memory. This could be why some people who hoard have problems
with clutter and fear of losing their things, maybe their stuff is associated with a memory..
So some collecting, natural and benefited us back in the day. A lot of collecting and
keeping… well they make whole shows about that.
To see first hand how enthusiastic some people get about their collection, check out this
great episode from Seeker Stories all about a group of people who collect sneakers.
point?
Hey collectors, Julia here for DNews.
In today’s world downsizing is big. Getting rid of clutter is trendy and people are learning
to live with less. Yet there will always be that one person you know who collects things.
Like Sheli McHugh on twitter who collects sheep things or my friend Chastity who has
kept tickets from every movie she’s been to since 1997.
So why do people do it? I turned to twitter for some personal answers.
People have all sorts of reasons. For some collecting is a way to bond with people, like
Bruivision collected coins as a hobby to share with her dad. Moiety Mouse said they
collect rocks out of curiosity about the world around them. DR. Zen collects key chains because
s/he enjoys the “thrill of the hunt.”
People like this aren’t just weird pack rats. They’re just fulfilling a natural
urge. The urge to collect is very primitive and is found throughout the animal kingdom.
Over 70 species have been documented to collect. Rats and crows. The bowerbird of Eastern Australia
and Queensland collects unusual objects as part of an elaborate courtship ritual.
So some researchers think collecting goes back to early days as humans. For our hunter-gather
ancestors, collecting food could mean the difference between life and death during a
harsh growing season or famine. So it’s not surprising this trait evolved. But collecting
beanies won’t help you survive a winter. (sorry 90s kids, they’re pretty worthless,
unless it’s a rare princess Di bear.)
So what’s going on in the brain?
Like Dr. Zen said, it’s the thrill of the hunt. When you find that thing, that rare
baseball card your brain releases a hit of dopamine. That tells your brain “yeah this
is good, do it again”. This probably helped our ancestors find food.
Finding some ripe berries made their brains go, “yup awesome, these will keep us alive,
do it again” but after a while the brain gets used to it and doesn’t release as much
dopamine the next time they found those berries. So you keep seeking. Keep hunting for that
next thrill. While that kept our ancestors alive. It keeps us seeking and collecting.
Research published in the journal Brain found the specific area of the brain responsible
for collecting behavior. The researchers identified 13 patients with focal brain lesions who exhibited
abnormal collecting behavior but performed fine on tests of intelligence, memory, and
reasoning. These patients showed no signs of abnormal collecting before the brain damage.
After using high resolution 3D MRI, the researchers found the culprit. It turns out that the brain
was damaged in a very specific place, in “a part of the frontal lobes of the cortex, particularly
on the right side”.
Speaking of abnormal collecting behavior, are you having trouble letting go of your
collection? That’s not so unusual. In fact it’s pretty biological. Dr. Loretta G Breuning,
founder of the Inner Mammal Institute describes an experiment where monkeys were given spinach
as a reward for a task. Which, ya know they liked. But when they were given a grape, their
dopamine levels spiked. After a while of getting that grape as a reward, their brains stopped
spiking with as much dopamine. So it stopped feeling as good. Then the researchers switched
back to spinach and the monkeys were NOT HAPPY. AT ALL. They missed the grapes, even if they
stopped feeling as good.
So for most of us it’s perfectly natural to not feel good about letting things go.
But sometimes, it’s a problem. Another study published in the journal Archives of General
Psychiatry, using MRI techniques, found that patients with hoarding disorder have abnormal
activity in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and insula. They had lower activity
than other people when faced with the idea of giving away stuff that didn’t belong
to them, but more activity when faced with the thought of giving away their own stuff.
The patients reported indecisiveness, and feeling like things were "not just right".
Another study published in the journal American Journal of Psychiatry, found that people who
hoard showed decreased brain activity in the posterior cingulate gyrus. An area involved
in spatial orientation and memory. This could be why some people who hoard have problems
with clutter and fear of losing their things, maybe their stuff is associated with a memory..
So some collecting, natural and benefited us back in the day. A lot of collecting and
keeping… well they make whole shows about that.
To see first hand how enthusiastic some people get about their collection, check out this
great episode from Seeker Stories all about a group of people who collect sneakers.