Advertisement
English transcript
Thanks to you guys we’ve finally hit 750,000 subscribers. That’s about the population
of Bhutan! Now, you know we love hearing all of your ideas. And some of you have been asking
for this video for a very, very, very long time. So, as a thank you for sticking with
us, we wanna know what you wanna know: what are America’s violations of international
law?
Well, international law is a little tricky. Within a country, law is based on government-sanctioned
rules. However, there is no world government to dictate the world’s rules. At best, there
are international treaties and agreements. But the United States has refused to ratify
the Rome Statute, the Vienna Convention, and a number of nuclear weapon and landmine bans.
So, how do you prosecute a country for violating a treaty it never signed? Well, disputes concerning
the limitation of rights between sovereign countries fall under supranational law, or
law that is not bound by a country’s borders. One of the only recognized bodies to judge
supranational disputes is the United Nations’ International Court of Justice.
Since the ICJ’s creation in 1946, the United States has been named as a respondent in thirteen
cases. The majority have been clarifications on existing laws and treaties, or the ICJ
simply lacked jurisdiction.
But in 1986, Nicaragua filed suit against the United States, alleging that the US had
supported the Contra rebellion against the Nicaraguan government. The US had also planted
naval mines in Nicaragua’s territorial waters. In fact, there was ample evidence that the
Contras were a CIA funded and trained rebel group, established by President Ronald Reagan’s
Administration. To fund the Contras, the US sold weapons to Iran, and assisted in the
Colombian cocaine trade. The ICJ found that the US had grossly violated international
law, and Nicaragua’s sovereignty. Nicaragua asked for $17 billion dollars in reparations.
In response, the United States withdrew its broad support of the International Court of
Justice, and as a permanent member of the UN Security Council, vetoed any attempts at
enforcing the ICJ’s judgment. To this day, Nicaragua has seen no compensation.
Roughly two years later, the United States Navy shot down an Iranian civilian aircraft
flying in Iranian airspace. 290 people died, marking the 9th worst aviation incident in
history. Iran filed suit against the US in 1989. But in 1996 the two countries reached
an agreement. The US would pay roughly $62 million dollars to the victim’s families,
in exchange for absolving them of any legal guilt. To this day, the US has not publicly
apologized to Iran.
The next important ruling against the US occurred in 1999, when the US executed two German nationals
for killing a man during a failed bank robbery. When arrested, the Germans were not informed
of their ability to seek help from their consulate, as is required by the Vienna Convention on
Consular Relations. In 2001 the ICJ ruled that the US had violated the Convention. The
US promised to never do it again.
Roughly two years later, Mexico filed suit against the US for violating that same exact
portion of the Vienna Convention. The US had arrested and sentenced 54 Mexican nationals
to death without immediately letting the Mexican consulate know. The ICJ again found the US
guilty. This time, the US was required to review and reconsider all the convictions
of Mexican nationals, and they were also responsible for making sure it never happened again. In
response, the US withdrew from the portion of the Vienna Convention that required them
to adhere to the ICJ’s ruling.
It should be clear by now that in spite of international law, the United States has been
able to avoid repercussions due to its powerful status in the global community. Still, the
US is far from the only violator, with many countries coming together to create a dangerous
state of world affairs. Without international courts, it could just be a whole lot worse.
Thanks so much for sticking with us, next stop: one million subscribers! And you can
bet we’ll have a fun video for you when the time comes. For now, you can continue
learning about America’s darker history by watching this video on which countries
America has invaded. Thanks again for watching TestTube News, don’t forget to like and
subscribe, and we’ll see you back here soon.
of Bhutan! Now, you know we love hearing all of your ideas. And some of you have been asking
for this video for a very, very, very long time. So, as a thank you for sticking with
us, we wanna know what you wanna know: what are America’s violations of international
law?
Well, international law is a little tricky. Within a country, law is based on government-sanctioned
rules. However, there is no world government to dictate the world’s rules. At best, there
are international treaties and agreements. But the United States has refused to ratify
the Rome Statute, the Vienna Convention, and a number of nuclear weapon and landmine bans.
So, how do you prosecute a country for violating a treaty it never signed? Well, disputes concerning
the limitation of rights between sovereign countries fall under supranational law, or
law that is not bound by a country’s borders. One of the only recognized bodies to judge
supranational disputes is the United Nations’ International Court of Justice.
Since the ICJ’s creation in 1946, the United States has been named as a respondent in thirteen
cases. The majority have been clarifications on existing laws and treaties, or the ICJ
simply lacked jurisdiction.
But in 1986, Nicaragua filed suit against the United States, alleging that the US had
supported the Contra rebellion against the Nicaraguan government. The US had also planted
naval mines in Nicaragua’s territorial waters. In fact, there was ample evidence that the
Contras were a CIA funded and trained rebel group, established by President Ronald Reagan’s
Administration. To fund the Contras, the US sold weapons to Iran, and assisted in the
Colombian cocaine trade. The ICJ found that the US had grossly violated international
law, and Nicaragua’s sovereignty. Nicaragua asked for $17 billion dollars in reparations.
In response, the United States withdrew its broad support of the International Court of
Justice, and as a permanent member of the UN Security Council, vetoed any attempts at
enforcing the ICJ’s judgment. To this day, Nicaragua has seen no compensation.
Roughly two years later, the United States Navy shot down an Iranian civilian aircraft
flying in Iranian airspace. 290 people died, marking the 9th worst aviation incident in
history. Iran filed suit against the US in 1989. But in 1996 the two countries reached
an agreement. The US would pay roughly $62 million dollars to the victim’s families,
in exchange for absolving them of any legal guilt. To this day, the US has not publicly
apologized to Iran.
The next important ruling against the US occurred in 1999, when the US executed two German nationals
for killing a man during a failed bank robbery. When arrested, the Germans were not informed
of their ability to seek help from their consulate, as is required by the Vienna Convention on
Consular Relations. In 2001 the ICJ ruled that the US had violated the Convention. The
US promised to never do it again.
Roughly two years later, Mexico filed suit against the US for violating that same exact
portion of the Vienna Convention. The US had arrested and sentenced 54 Mexican nationals
to death without immediately letting the Mexican consulate know. The ICJ again found the US
guilty. This time, the US was required to review and reconsider all the convictions
of Mexican nationals, and they were also responsible for making sure it never happened again. In
response, the US withdrew from the portion of the Vienna Convention that required them
to adhere to the ICJ’s ruling.
It should be clear by now that in spite of international law, the United States has been
able to avoid repercussions due to its powerful status in the global community. Still, the
US is far from the only violator, with many countries coming together to create a dangerous
state of world affairs. Without international courts, it could just be a whole lot worse.
Thanks so much for sticking with us, next stop: one million subscribers! And you can
bet we’ll have a fun video for you when the time comes. For now, you can continue
learning about America’s darker history by watching this video on which countries
America has invaded. Thanks again for watching TestTube News, don’t forget to like and
subscribe, and we’ll see you back here soon.