Advertisement
English transcript
Following the recent Paris attacks, an investigation is currently underway to determine if one
of the Paris attackers posed as a refugee to gain entrance through Greece. Fearing the
same might happen across the Pacific, more than half of all US governors, have called
on the Obama administration to stop providing asylum to Syrian refugees. But is this a legitimate
concern? What is the vetting process like for refugees seeking asylum in The United
States?
Well, currently the US has stated that it will accept 185,000 refugees total in the
next two years. This includes refugees from all over the world, so the effective number
of Syrian refugees is much smaller. Since the war broke out, the US has only accepted
about 1800 Syrian refugees. Though the Obama administration did state that it intends to
admit an additional 10,000 in 2016. Of those that have already been admitted, half, are
children… only 2% are single males of combat age. Now, this is not to say that terrorists
only fit a certain demographic profile. But, rather to paint the picture that the vast
majority of those admitted do fit the profile of those most vulnerable: children and the
elderly, together make up two thirds of the group.
But before they set foot on the US, asylum seekers must go through a lengthy and detailed
process. Syrian refugees must first file with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees,
which then hands applications off to the Department of Homeland Security in the US. Then the department
works with multiple law enforcement agencies which all together conduct multiple screenings,
in-person interviews abroad, and collect data on the person’s history, employment, reasons
for leaving, and more. Many argue the process is robust.
Though others have concerns. FBI Director James Comey states, “My concern there is
that there are certain gaps...in the data available to us. We can only query against
that which we have collected. And so if someone has never made a ripple in the pond in Syria...nothing
[will] show up because we have no record of them.” The collection of information is
further complicated because the US does not have a permanent diplomatic presence in Syria
and Syria’s departments cannot be relied on for information. This may help explain
why the US takes additional security measures with Syrian refugees.
This vetting process takes about two years and it can take up to three years after submitting
an application before a refugee steps foot on US soil. Which is why some argue that pretending
to be an asylum seeker would not be an efficient tactic for terrorists.
Thus, some see the vocal opposition from politicians as less about security concerns and more about
pandering to a political constituency, as The Washington Post columnist Chris Cillizza
suggested. Most governors wishing to halt asylum belong to the Republican Party. Yet
others intimate that the response is emotional - not strategic. As one governor put it, “This
is very much about the fact that 9/11 is too close in our memory.” But, aside from its
government representatives, the American people as a whole will ultimately form the communities
that refugees will become a part of. It is they who will be left to grapple with relying
more heavily on memories of tragedy or memories of the country’s immigrant roots when greeting
these newcomers.
One country that is taking in refugees and newcomers with open arms, is Germany. To see
how Syrian refugees are integrating into their society, check out our video.
Thanks for watching Seeker Daily, please subscribe.
of the Paris attackers posed as a refugee to gain entrance through Greece. Fearing the
same might happen across the Pacific, more than half of all US governors, have called
on the Obama administration to stop providing asylum to Syrian refugees. But is this a legitimate
concern? What is the vetting process like for refugees seeking asylum in The United
States?
Well, currently the US has stated that it will accept 185,000 refugees total in the
next two years. This includes refugees from all over the world, so the effective number
of Syrian refugees is much smaller. Since the war broke out, the US has only accepted
about 1800 Syrian refugees. Though the Obama administration did state that it intends to
admit an additional 10,000 in 2016. Of those that have already been admitted, half, are
children… only 2% are single males of combat age. Now, this is not to say that terrorists
only fit a certain demographic profile. But, rather to paint the picture that the vast
majority of those admitted do fit the profile of those most vulnerable: children and the
elderly, together make up two thirds of the group.
But before they set foot on the US, asylum seekers must go through a lengthy and detailed
process. Syrian refugees must first file with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees,
which then hands applications off to the Department of Homeland Security in the US. Then the department
works with multiple law enforcement agencies which all together conduct multiple screenings,
in-person interviews abroad, and collect data on the person’s history, employment, reasons
for leaving, and more. Many argue the process is robust.
Though others have concerns. FBI Director James Comey states, “My concern there is
that there are certain gaps...in the data available to us. We can only query against
that which we have collected. And so if someone has never made a ripple in the pond in Syria...nothing
[will] show up because we have no record of them.” The collection of information is
further complicated because the US does not have a permanent diplomatic presence in Syria
and Syria’s departments cannot be relied on for information. This may help explain
why the US takes additional security measures with Syrian refugees.
This vetting process takes about two years and it can take up to three years after submitting
an application before a refugee steps foot on US soil. Which is why some argue that pretending
to be an asylum seeker would not be an efficient tactic for terrorists.
Thus, some see the vocal opposition from politicians as less about security concerns and more about
pandering to a political constituency, as The Washington Post columnist Chris Cillizza
suggested. Most governors wishing to halt asylum belong to the Republican Party. Yet
others intimate that the response is emotional - not strategic. As one governor put it, “This
is very much about the fact that 9/11 is too close in our memory.” But, aside from its
government representatives, the American people as a whole will ultimately form the communities
that refugees will become a part of. It is they who will be left to grapple with relying
more heavily on memories of tragedy or memories of the country’s immigrant roots when greeting
these newcomers.
One country that is taking in refugees and newcomers with open arms, is Germany. To see
how Syrian refugees are integrating into their society, check out our video.
Thanks for watching Seeker Daily, please subscribe.