Advertisement
English transcript
Have you ever been in a crowd and a fight starts? Or seen a video of people being brutalized
while bystanders mill around? Why don't we step in and help!? What's wrong with people?
In 1964, Kitty Genovese was raped and murdered in New York City, people nearby who were aware
the crime was being committed did nothing -- psychologists called this the Bystander
Effect. According to the National Crime Victimization Survey, two-thirds of all violent crime victimizations
had a bystander. The news constantly cycles cell phone videos of fights, arrests, shootings,
brutalization, and they occasionally feature bystanders just milling around! Bystander
in full effect! What's going on here?
Psychologists have found humans in groups are less likely to come to the aid of someone
in need, even if they would have jumped to a rescue when alone. In one 2014 study, 5-year-olds
refrained from helping a "confused" experimenter when in a group, but readily assisted when
alone. Other studies have shown this extends to online environments too! But still, what
the heck? Shouldn't we want to help people all the time?
Bystander effect seems to be a combination of two things: Pluralistic Ignorance, and
Diffusion of Responsibility. Pluralistic Ignorance is the idea that without ever saying anything
to other members of the group we assume everyone is on the same page. When other people DON'T
act, we assume everyone has decided it's fine. We are social group animals, not solitary
ones, and thus, we look to those around us for the social prompts. Diffusion of Responsibility
says that we are less likely to take responsibility when others are present; because the responsibility
is now spread across everyone. This is multiplied in emergency situations: where we have to
act quickly and make decisions without being able to talk them out. It seems comical to
shout shouldn't someone do something? But that's how our minds work! We've diffused
the responsibility to the group, and what we want to do is ambiguous! Thus no one makes
a decision and we all become victims of the bystander effect.
A 1969 experiment in American Scientist, put people in a room and asked them to fill out
a questionnaire; then, researchers slowly pumped smoke into the room. When alone, 75
percent of the subjects noticed the smoke, and calmly went to report it. But, when other
researchers were in the room pretending to be subjects (who wouldn't react no matter
what happened) only 10 percent of the people reported the smoke, even when it was SO THICK
they couldn't see their questionnaire!
Security cameras have been found to reduce the strength of the bystander effect because
we want to perform a good deed for this imagined audience; but that doesn't translate to cell
phone cameras. A clinical psychologist told Boston Magazine, “We tend to get reinforced
for [recording fights with our cameras]. It can show up on the news, or get a million
hits on YouTube," or increase social status with your friends. Plus, the footage may help
an authority bring the right person to justice, or solve the issue later, which reinforces
personal recordings further!
Is there a cure for the bystander effect? Yes! Someone just has to act. If someone jumps
in the pool to save a splashing kid; takes charge and tells someone to call 911 after
an injury; or steps in to stop a fight… responsibility isn't diffused any longer,
and Pluralistic Ignorance is broken. It is easy to think you'd do something different
when watching a video at home by yourself, but standing with other people in the moment
complicates things intensely. People who do act are called active bystanders, and according
to Psychology Today, they "tend to have heightened concern for the welfare of others, greater
feelings of social responsibility and a greater commitment to moral values." As an Eagle Scout,
I was taught to step in and help, as were emergency responders, veterans, and others
in our society; but it's never easy to overcome our instincts and evolved social responses.
Psychology can get nebulous on the best of days, and while this is heavily studied, the
exact reasons we do this are still unclear. As always, more research is needed.
while bystanders mill around? Why don't we step in and help!? What's wrong with people?
In 1964, Kitty Genovese was raped and murdered in New York City, people nearby who were aware
the crime was being committed did nothing -- psychologists called this the Bystander
Effect. According to the National Crime Victimization Survey, two-thirds of all violent crime victimizations
had a bystander. The news constantly cycles cell phone videos of fights, arrests, shootings,
brutalization, and they occasionally feature bystanders just milling around! Bystander
in full effect! What's going on here?
Psychologists have found humans in groups are less likely to come to the aid of someone
in need, even if they would have jumped to a rescue when alone. In one 2014 study, 5-year-olds
refrained from helping a "confused" experimenter when in a group, but readily assisted when
alone. Other studies have shown this extends to online environments too! But still, what
the heck? Shouldn't we want to help people all the time?
Bystander effect seems to be a combination of two things: Pluralistic Ignorance, and
Diffusion of Responsibility. Pluralistic Ignorance is the idea that without ever saying anything
to other members of the group we assume everyone is on the same page. When other people DON'T
act, we assume everyone has decided it's fine. We are social group animals, not solitary
ones, and thus, we look to those around us for the social prompts. Diffusion of Responsibility
says that we are less likely to take responsibility when others are present; because the responsibility
is now spread across everyone. This is multiplied in emergency situations: where we have to
act quickly and make decisions without being able to talk them out. It seems comical to
shout shouldn't someone do something? But that's how our minds work! We've diffused
the responsibility to the group, and what we want to do is ambiguous! Thus no one makes
a decision and we all become victims of the bystander effect.
A 1969 experiment in American Scientist, put people in a room and asked them to fill out
a questionnaire; then, researchers slowly pumped smoke into the room. When alone, 75
percent of the subjects noticed the smoke, and calmly went to report it. But, when other
researchers were in the room pretending to be subjects (who wouldn't react no matter
what happened) only 10 percent of the people reported the smoke, even when it was SO THICK
they couldn't see their questionnaire!
Security cameras have been found to reduce the strength of the bystander effect because
we want to perform a good deed for this imagined audience; but that doesn't translate to cell
phone cameras. A clinical psychologist told Boston Magazine, “We tend to get reinforced
for [recording fights with our cameras]. It can show up on the news, or get a million
hits on YouTube," or increase social status with your friends. Plus, the footage may help
an authority bring the right person to justice, or solve the issue later, which reinforces
personal recordings further!
Is there a cure for the bystander effect? Yes! Someone just has to act. If someone jumps
in the pool to save a splashing kid; takes charge and tells someone to call 911 after
an injury; or steps in to stop a fight… responsibility isn't diffused any longer,
and Pluralistic Ignorance is broken. It is easy to think you'd do something different
when watching a video at home by yourself, but standing with other people in the moment
complicates things intensely. People who do act are called active bystanders, and according
to Psychology Today, they "tend to have heightened concern for the welfare of others, greater
feelings of social responsibility and a greater commitment to moral values." As an Eagle Scout,
I was taught to step in and help, as were emergency responders, veterans, and others
in our society; but it's never easy to overcome our instincts and evolved social responses.
Psychology can get nebulous on the best of days, and while this is heavily studied, the
exact reasons we do this are still unclear. As always, more research is needed.