Advertisement
English transcript
I don’t know if you’ve been watching the news, but by my count there have been two
disasters lately. Let’s all just chill out and wait for the third one we all know is
coming.
Hi everyone, Julian here for DNews. Have you ever noticed misfortune tends to come in groups
of three? Celebrity deaths, natural disasters, and personal problems all seem to come in
triplicate. Surely there must be a scientific explanation for the pattern.
Well there is. And that explanation is: there is no pattern, it’s just you. It’s not
the universe ticking through some equation that occasionally spits out grief in bunches,
it’s that you want to see a pattern in random information.
The phenomenon is called apophenia, and humans are guilty of it all the time. Part of the
reason we’re the most dominant species on the planet is because we see patterns and
exploit them to our advantage. That’s a great skill when it helps us derive some truth,
and a real problem when it deludes us. The examples I like are math and astrology. A
mathematical equation is really just a description of a pattern and it can be used to accurately
predict a specific outcome. Whereas astrology is combining random information into a perceived
pattern and it only makes vague predictions that can’t be tested.
So why is it that despite my insistence, I haven’t killed astrology yet? Well the reason
apophanies are so persistent is because of another human flaw: confirmation bias. We
don’t just see patterns, we see the patterns we want, and we ignore information that doesn’t
obey our pet theory. English psychologist Peter Wason first demonstrated this in the
‘60s with an experiment. He told participants that the numbers 2, 4, and 6 satisfied some
rule he had in mind, and invited them to suggest three other numbers to try and figure out
the rule. Most people only gave even ascending numbers and when they were told those numbers
followed Wason’s rule, they concluded that was the pattern. But it wasn’t, Wason’s
only rule was the numbers had to increase, but they could be even, odd, positive, negative,
integers or fractions. Most people didn’t suggest a pattern they thought might be wrong
though, they only tested answers they were already sure fit. In other words, they only
tried to confirm their bias.
Then there’s our affinity for the number three in western cultures: Christianity’s
deity comes in three forms, satisfying lists of examples have three things. But numbers
have different significances in different cultures. In China the number four is bad
luck because it sounds a lot like the word for death, and that’s true in both mandarin
and cantonese. So some chinese hotels and hospitals don’t have floors or rooms labeled
with numbers ending in 4.
When you combine our western preference for trilogies with the human tendencies for apophenia
and confirmation bias, you get the belief that bad things come in threes. The truth
is bad things happen all the time. Sometimes they come in threes, yes, but sometimes they
come by themselves, or in twos or fives. If your rules are loose enough you could correctly
say that tragedy is constant. On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone drops
to zero. How tragic is that? Notice in the intro I didn’t explicitly list what two
disasters had just happened? I figure you can watch this video at any time, and two
recent events will immediately spring to mind. I know that’s not a cheerful thought but
look at it this way: great things are happening all the time too, the only reason you’re
not hearing about it is because bad news drives up ratings. So when the universe dishes out
bad luck on a personal or grand scale, do what you can to make the situation better
for yourself or those affected, and know that two more probably aren’t around the corner
just because of some mystical “rule of threes.”
Unfortunately at the time we shot this, there was a massive earthquake in Nepal. I encourage
you to do what you can to help, and if you want to learn more, Julia’s got an explainer
on the science of it here.
Are there any other superstitions you think are actually scientifically sound? Let us
know in the comments and I’ll see you next time on DNews.
disasters lately. Let’s all just chill out and wait for the third one we all know is
coming.
Hi everyone, Julian here for DNews. Have you ever noticed misfortune tends to come in groups
of three? Celebrity deaths, natural disasters, and personal problems all seem to come in
triplicate. Surely there must be a scientific explanation for the pattern.
Well there is. And that explanation is: there is no pattern, it’s just you. It’s not
the universe ticking through some equation that occasionally spits out grief in bunches,
it’s that you want to see a pattern in random information.
The phenomenon is called apophenia, and humans are guilty of it all the time. Part of the
reason we’re the most dominant species on the planet is because we see patterns and
exploit them to our advantage. That’s a great skill when it helps us derive some truth,
and a real problem when it deludes us. The examples I like are math and astrology. A
mathematical equation is really just a description of a pattern and it can be used to accurately
predict a specific outcome. Whereas astrology is combining random information into a perceived
pattern and it only makes vague predictions that can’t be tested.
So why is it that despite my insistence, I haven’t killed astrology yet? Well the reason
apophanies are so persistent is because of another human flaw: confirmation bias. We
don’t just see patterns, we see the patterns we want, and we ignore information that doesn’t
obey our pet theory. English psychologist Peter Wason first demonstrated this in the
‘60s with an experiment. He told participants that the numbers 2, 4, and 6 satisfied some
rule he had in mind, and invited them to suggest three other numbers to try and figure out
the rule. Most people only gave even ascending numbers and when they were told those numbers
followed Wason’s rule, they concluded that was the pattern. But it wasn’t, Wason’s
only rule was the numbers had to increase, but they could be even, odd, positive, negative,
integers or fractions. Most people didn’t suggest a pattern they thought might be wrong
though, they only tested answers they were already sure fit. In other words, they only
tried to confirm their bias.
Then there’s our affinity for the number three in western cultures: Christianity’s
deity comes in three forms, satisfying lists of examples have three things. But numbers
have different significances in different cultures. In China the number four is bad
luck because it sounds a lot like the word for death, and that’s true in both mandarin
and cantonese. So some chinese hotels and hospitals don’t have floors or rooms labeled
with numbers ending in 4.
When you combine our western preference for trilogies with the human tendencies for apophenia
and confirmation bias, you get the belief that bad things come in threes. The truth
is bad things happen all the time. Sometimes they come in threes, yes, but sometimes they
come by themselves, or in twos or fives. If your rules are loose enough you could correctly
say that tragedy is constant. On a long enough timeline, the survival rate for everyone drops
to zero. How tragic is that? Notice in the intro I didn’t explicitly list what two
disasters had just happened? I figure you can watch this video at any time, and two
recent events will immediately spring to mind. I know that’s not a cheerful thought but
look at it this way: great things are happening all the time too, the only reason you’re
not hearing about it is because bad news drives up ratings. So when the universe dishes out
bad luck on a personal or grand scale, do what you can to make the situation better
for yourself or those affected, and know that two more probably aren’t around the corner
just because of some mystical “rule of threes.”
Unfortunately at the time we shot this, there was a massive earthquake in Nepal. I encourage
you to do what you can to help, and if you want to learn more, Julia’s got an explainer
on the science of it here.
Are there any other superstitions you think are actually scientifically sound? Let us
know in the comments and I’ll see you next time on DNews.