Advertisement
English transcript
Prof: If so, then let's go on to John Locke,
another major scientist and another major founder of
political and social philosophy and theory.
I'll do again what I did with Hobbes.
We will again do briefly, for those who are not
interested in lives and history.
So first I introduce you, our friend today,
John Locke.
He was born in 1642 in Somerset.
His father was a captain in a parliamentary army;
a kind of small gentry, not particularly wealthy but
not poor either.
In '52, he went to Oxford, and it was noted that he was
"idle, unhappy and unremarkable"
in Oxford.
Well if you do not have a 4.0 at Yale, don't panic.
Right?
You still can be John Locke.
There are somebody who blossom later;
he was a late blossomer.
But by the end he was doing well, and in fact he became an
official; you know, English universities
called teachers officials.
Officers--even at Yale, you know, we are called
officers of Yale Corporation--kind of,
I think, an old English tradition.
Anyway, he was admitted, and then in '64 he gave an
address to the college.
And this is a very important address because this is when we
can learn the views of young John Locke.
And quite clear from this address that,
in fact, early in his life he was very traditionalist and
quite authoritarian: The kings are good and the
people are beasts.
So in a way he was Hobbesian.
In fact, you know, in the Two Treatises he
stays away discussing Hobbes.
But, of course, the ghost of Hobbes is all over
the place.
Right?
to take seats>>
Well, a little about the times--'49, I already mentioned,
Charles I was executed.
The monarchy was abolished for a time.
Oliver Cromwell became Lord Protector of England.
But though he was very popular among many,
he really could not control the struggle between the military
and the parliament, and the chaos--what Hobbes
experienced in the '30s and early '40s--
in some ways continued.
It was probably not as bad as before but was still very bad.
Well when Cromwell died, his son tried to become Lord
Protector-- did not succeed,
and finally it was decided to call back Charles I's son,
Charles II, to become King of England.
So the monarchy was restored.
So these will remain turbulent years, and, of course,
the kind of turbulence does color what Locke stood for.
Well, just a picture of Oliver Cromwell for you,
and then Charles II, who was King of England for
twenty-five years.
Well there is a New Haven connection to all of this.
Not all of you may know that.
But I'm sure everybody knows where Whalley Avenue is,
and where Goffe Street is.
Well this has something to do with England and John Locke.
Two of the judges of the trial of Charles I,
Edward Whalley and William Goffe, were accused of regicide.
And they escaped England in 1660, and they went to Boston.
Well they did the wrong choice, right?
They went where Harvard is, rather than going where Yale
is.
Okay?
But Boston was an unsafe place, too much under the control of
the crown.
So therefore they went to the right place, right?
And where can it be?
Of course, New Haven.
So they came to New Haven.
And you probably know where West Rock is.
Anybody was up on West Rock?
A few of them.
Well, in West Rock you see a sign which says "Judges'
Cove."
So if you go there, there is a little cove and,
according to the legends, Whalley and Goffe hided in this
cove.
So here you go, history comes back home.
Then they moved actually to Milford and lived in a house
there, and I have a picture of this house.
I don't swear my life on it that this is really the house in
which they hided, but that's what some historian
tells me.
Okay, then there is a turning point in the life of John Locke
in '66 when he meets a formidable person,
whose name was Anthony Ashley Cooper.
Well, he was a high aristocrat, but he nevertheless was
anti-Royalist.
He joined the parliamentary forces against Charles I,
and was also a member of the State Council during the
republican times.
But he supported the restoration of the monarchy in
'66, and held very high offices between 1660 and '73,
including the position of Lord Chancellor.
Well he became the Earl of Shaftesbury, out of the grace of
the King, and usually he is referred to as the Earl of
Shaftesbury.
Well in '66, he went to Oxford to have a
cure for his liver disease, and this is when he met John
Locke as a doctor.
And John Locke became his physician and,
let's put it this way, his friend.
Probably a bit of a strong statement because the social
status difference was too big to really call it as a friendship,
but I will say a word about their relationship.
And here is the Earl of Shaftesbury.
Now in '67, Locke moved to Ashley's house at Exeter House
in the Strand in London.
And I'm sure those of you who've visited London know
exactly where the Strand is; that's still where sort of the
legal establishment can be found in London.
So he lived there in his household.
Like, you know, in feudal times clients lived
with their master's house and ate on the master's table,
or with other servants' table; even high-ranking people
occasionally were not allowed to eat with the lord.
Well he became Ashley's confidant, advisor and surgeon.
He performed a surgery, and I think medical scientists
are still puzzled whether this was some path-breaking surgery
or whether he just had good luck--
that he'd helped Ashley.
Ashley had a surplus production of his liver and he implanted a
tube into his abdomen area to let this surplus flow out,
and certainly Ashley felt much better after the surgery.
Well we know that occasionally the doctors say the surgery was
successful and the patient died.
Now this was a case when the patient was cured,
but we don't know whether the surgery had anything to do with
it.
Right?
But for those of you who are in sciences,
this is just a proof that in the seventeenth century,
you know, there was really no distinction yet what sciences
are: what philosophy is, and what social sciences are.
There was a difference what theology was and the rest of
knowledge was.
But the rest of the knowledge was all the same,
and sort of Locke was also a scientist.
In '67, he wrote an essay, the "Essay on
Toleration."
And this is a departure now from Hobbes.
This actually advocates the right to dissent.
As we have seen, not that Hobbes at all cost
would have resisted every dissent.
Right?
You remember we discussed that--that Hobbes also
considered if the king does not deliver,
you can transfer your loyalty from the king to another
sovereign.
But the "Essay on Toleration"
does not simply make it as such an exceptional case,
you know, but it makes a big argument that the right of
dissent is an important individual right.
He was also then elected in '68 as a member of The Royal
Society.
The Royal Society is like what in the United States we'd call
the American Academy of Sciences--pretty hard to get
into it; was then and it is now.
In '79, he was already working on the Second Treatise.
Assumedly to some--I will talk about this--there is some debate
when the First Treatise and the Second Treatise
were written.
And that's not irrelevant, actually, the timing of the two
essays.
Well there was, on the other hand,
a conflict between Charles II and the parliament and the Earl
of Shaftesbury and, of course, by implication John
Locke.
Charles II had only illegitimate children;
he had quite a few of them, right?
I don't know whether he liked children, but it looks like he
liked the technology, at least.
>
Well therefore, you know, since the children
were all illegitimate, the legitimate heir to the
throne was his brother, James, and the only problem
with James was that he was Roman Catholic.
And we already know from Hobbes that this was a big trouble at
that time in Britain.
So the parliament, and Shaftesbury himself,
feared that Roman Catholics will restore their influence,
and therefore the parliament's role will be reduced.
And then in '73, the parliament was considering
a so-called Test Act.
And this is really an ugly act, because the Test Act meant that
you have to be tested whether you are Roman Catholic or you
belong to the Church of England, and if you are Roman Catholic
then you should not hold certain offices.
Right?
This is just straight discrimination.
But, you know, at that time it was kind of a
defense against the Vatican and the role of the Pope.
Well, because of Shaftesbury's support for this,
he was dismissed as Lord Chancellor.
Nevertheless, a few years later the
parliament does pass the Exclusion Bill,
and they are supporting James, one of the illegitimate
children of Charles, as a successor to the throne.
Well, and this is James Stuart, the brother of Charles II,
and this is the other James, the Protestant,
Shaftesbury's protégée.
Well, the Commons passed the law.
And what Charles II did?
He dismissed the parliament.
Well, Shaftesbury was arrested--put into the Tower of
London.
You probably, if you were in London,
you visited the Tower, or at least had a look at it.
And after he was released, he was smarter than to stay in
England; he went to a right place--I
actually like his taste--he went to the Netherlands.
If I had to be exiled, I would prefer to be in
Amsterdam, of all places.
>
Okay, in '83 the Whigs--the Whigs at that time were kind of
the Democratic Party.
The Tories were the Republican Party and the Whigs were the
equivalent of the Democratic Party.
Well the Whigs were accused to have been involved in a plot to
overthrow the king, and some of them were executed.
That was the Rye House Plot.
Well Locke was smart enough.
He knew he may be next in line so he also made the right
choice; he ran to Amsterdam. Right?
Well again, I don't swear that this was exactly the house where
the plot took place.
I'm even not sure that the plot took place at all,
or whether this was an invention by the authorities.
Well then there is a revolution in '88, and William of Orange
becomes the king.
Well the problem was that James II did not realize that even the
Tories will not support his religious agenda.
So he was actually overthrown, and then the Republicans and
Democrats-- I'm sorry, the Tories and
Whigs--came together and they invited William to become King
of England.
And here is, William III,
and the co-ruler, Queen Mary, his wife--was very
much involved in politics and important.
And Locke then now can return to England, and he felt safe in
1690 to do so.
Well I will talk about this later;
the Second Treatise may actually be a reflection of the
change to the House of Orange, which is a change from
absolutism to constitutional monarchy.
And therefore the Second Treatise can be read as an
ideology for a constitutional monarchy rather than absolutism.
Whether this is the case, it is being debated.
Locke died in 1704.
Interestingly, you know, his major book,
the Two Treatises on Government,
was published in 1690, but it was published
anonymously.
He was concerned enough, even at that time,
that he may run into trouble if he publishes this book.
Okay, now I will be talking about the Two Treatises
and the work now.
So this is the Two Treatises of Government,
which actually was--appeared in print in 1690,
as you can see on the First Edition.
Now, as I said, there is a debate about it,
when the First and the Second Treatise was
written.
And there are two major Locke scholars;
both spent all of their life studying Locke.
Peter Laslett suggested that the Second Treatise was
written really first, in 1679;
it was all engaged in the debates about the Exclusion
Bill.
While Richard Ashcraft--he was my colleague at UCLA at one
point; died unfortunately very young;
a brilliant scholar--actually he argued that the Second
Treatise was written in 1683.
And it is a revolutionary work--that this is really the
theory of constitutional monarchy and kind of popular
sovereignty is being formulated for the first time.
This is really in strong clash--almost absolute
negation--of Hobbes.
Well not quite absolutely; we'll discuss some overlaps
between the two arguments.
But they both agree that that the first treatise was written
in 1680, that's uncontroversial, and was published anonymously.
So the First Treatise.
Well I will not speak too much about this.
The Second Treatise is really the big text everybody
reads and cites.
But the First Treatise takes on a book published by
1680 by Robert Filmer.
This looks to me a very archaic book, but surprisingly it is
still in print.
You go on Google and you can buy Robert Filmer's book,
Patriarcha.
Well I don't necessarily recommend it because I think
this is really archaic, and I don't think it's got any
major contribution beyond challenging Locke to formulate a
strong position against; that's, I think,
the only reason why you may want to read Patriarcha.
Well he was very much for absolutism and the absolute
monarchy, and he advocated actually inequality.
He said, "God set some men above others";
and he meant men. Right?
Men are set over women, and older people,
like me, are set over younger people, like you.
Right?
And the king over everybody else, right?
So this inequality of power is coming from God.
God decided that Adam inherits the earth, and then descendents
of Adam, the sons and grandsons, receive their share of earth.
Right?
So you have to show your family tree, going back to Adam,
who received the world as a grant, and who was the first
king.
So the kings should trace their family trees back to the first
person of grace of God.
Right?
So there was a scripture argument.
Right?
God vested paternal authority in Adam, gave the earth as a
grant to him.
And the monarchical absolute power is inherited this way;
there is a descent of the monarchical power.
As I said, I see very little relevance of this argument.
So I--but certainly it was important for Locke to have a
straw man he could face his argument against--probably
spends too much time debating Filmer.
And you may have been a bit concerned about these
theological controversies and theological arguments in the
book, but otherwise he's really
formulating the first big ideas for modern democratic theory.
Okay, so now Locke engages Filmer on a number of levels.
It actually engages him on the theological level,
and he said, "Well, it's untrue that
Adam received land as a grant.
It was mankind who received the land as a grant from God."
And then he moves on and he kind of makes a more technical
argument.
He said, "Well even if we assume that it was one single
male who received land and all authority,
how on earth you can trace yourself back to this?"
This is not a real good way to legitimate somebody.
How can Charles II shows that he has the answers through this
way?
So that is not the right way to do.
And then he said, "Well, even if it could be
done, it would be silly to do that.
Right?
Just because somebody is the proper ancestor,
should not have--should not be the sovereign.
What if that person is a jerk?
Right?
Then you really want to have the right people to exercise
authority."
Right?
It's, in his time, you know, a very daring
argument.
Now let's have a look at the Second Treatise,
and the major themes--what he's engaged in.
Like Hobbes, he begins with the statement:
We are all born equal, and he has free--free and
equal.
But, as we will see, he draws a very different
conclusion than Hobbes did, or by and large a different
conclusion.
And then he does agree with Locke that we need a common
superior, a sovereign; a superior is necessary to
avoid the state of war.
Then he develops a fascinating theory of property,
what we have to deal with, and then he makes this
path-breaking argument that what we need is rule by majority.
He does not quite identify what that majority is.
Right?
This is not popular sovereignty yet, but the idea of rule by
majority for the first time is formulated by John Locke.
And acceptance of authority can be done only by consent,
and what is needed--and this is the very big contribution of
Locke-- a separation of power,
checks and balances.
Right?
This is what is completely missing in Hobbes,
and he's making this path-breaking argument.
So we are all born free and equal.
Let me speak to this a little.
Now what is political power?
And he defines the three elements of political power.
Right?
Well this is the right to make law.
There is also execution of law, and there is also--politics
means the defense of the commonwealth against outside
enemies.
There are the three functions politics is serving.
And this will be very important in his sort of divisions of
powers, as such.
Now, well if we want to understand what political power
is, we have to see the origins of
political power, and to try to understand why on
earth people from the state of nature,
where they were free and equal, move into civil society where
they surrender some of their freedom and,
we will see, will surrender some of their
equality.
So what is the origins of this equality?
Well the first argument is very much counter-Hobbes.
Right?
Men are all made by God, the omnipotent,
right?
And we are his property; a kind of theological argument.
And we are not--have not been created for the pleasures of one
another.
So there should not be any man who is a superior,
by principle.
Because we are free, right?
Locke is a liberal, right?
Hobbes is a conservative.
So what we are experiencing now is the transition of philosophy
from conservativism to liberalism;
and liberalism, of course, will emphasize
particularly freedom is the primary value.
And in the state of nature, he said, we were all governed
by reason.
And that actually sort of--because we are all
reasonable, we are born reasonable;
we are born to be able to be rational.
Right?
And we should be able to understand that we are not
supposed to harm each other.
You see, this is a very different argument than what we
have seen from Hobbes, on Tuesday.
Right?
Hobbes said that we are actually learning morality out
by interacting with others who are desiring the same stuff what
we do.
We are learning it from struggle, right?
It does not assume that this comes out of our rationality,
that we are reasonable and by nature good.
He does assume that we are reasonable.
Therefore why on earth we should not know that we should
respect others?
Well, but--and this then is where Locke comes the closest to
converge with Hobbes-- well there is on the other hand
a danger that there will be a war,
and in order to avoid war this is why we will subject ourselves
to an authority and leave the state of nature.
But he also makes a claim just to distance himself from Hobbes.
He said it's not that the state of nature is necessarily war.
We have to make a distinction between the state of war and
state of nature because in the state of nature we are good and
reasonable, but nevertheless it can turn
into a state of war.
And that's why we will have to join civil society and accept an
authority.
Well, and now comes again a very big difference.
So he accepts the danger of war--he lived in times of
war--and he accepts that we need an authority because of this.
Now, but--and now here comes the big differences.
Well we subject ourselves to authority of others,
but this has to be done by consent.
Right?
Those who are accepting a sovereign have to consent to
their subjugation, to authority.
And the last citation is also extremely important:
"Freedom of man under government is to have a standing
rule of liberty, common to everyone of that
society, and made by a legislative power
erected in it."
Right?
So the legislative power, now this is the source of
sovereign, is somehow in a proper way constituted.
Right?
This was not a problem really for Hobbes, not much,
right?
We could see that we'll be simply conferring sovereignty to
a single king.
Now Locke is very interested how the sovereign,
the source of power to pass legislation, is being
constituted.
And again he's emphasizing--which was not in
Hobbes--what is important is standing rules to assure
liberty.
Right?
Not simply survival, right?
Though we know Hobbes had it a more complex way.
But
…
another major scientist and another major founder of
political and social philosophy and theory.
I'll do again what I did with Hobbes.
We will again do briefly, for those who are not
interested in lives and history.
So first I introduce you, our friend today,
John Locke.
He was born in 1642 in Somerset.
His father was a captain in a parliamentary army;
a kind of small gentry, not particularly wealthy but
not poor either.
In '52, he went to Oxford, and it was noted that he was
"idle, unhappy and unremarkable"
in Oxford.
Well if you do not have a 4.0 at Yale, don't panic.
Right?
You still can be John Locke.
There are somebody who blossom later;
he was a late blossomer.
But by the end he was doing well, and in fact he became an
official; you know, English universities
called teachers officials.
Officers--even at Yale, you know, we are called
officers of Yale Corporation--kind of,
I think, an old English tradition.
Anyway, he was admitted, and then in '64 he gave an
address to the college.
And this is a very important address because this is when we
can learn the views of young John Locke.
And quite clear from this address that,
in fact, early in his life he was very traditionalist and
quite authoritarian: The kings are good and the
people are beasts.
So in a way he was Hobbesian.
In fact, you know, in the Two Treatises he
stays away discussing Hobbes.
But, of course, the ghost of Hobbes is all over
the place.
Right?
to take seats>>
Well, a little about the times--'49, I already mentioned,
Charles I was executed.
The monarchy was abolished for a time.
Oliver Cromwell became Lord Protector of England.
But though he was very popular among many,
he really could not control the struggle between the military
and the parliament, and the chaos--what Hobbes
experienced in the '30s and early '40s--
in some ways continued.
It was probably not as bad as before but was still very bad.
Well when Cromwell died, his son tried to become Lord
Protector-- did not succeed,
and finally it was decided to call back Charles I's son,
Charles II, to become King of England.
So the monarchy was restored.
So these will remain turbulent years, and, of course,
the kind of turbulence does color what Locke stood for.
Well, just a picture of Oliver Cromwell for you,
and then Charles II, who was King of England for
twenty-five years.
Well there is a New Haven connection to all of this.
Not all of you may know that.
But I'm sure everybody knows where Whalley Avenue is,
and where Goffe Street is.
Well this has something to do with England and John Locke.
Two of the judges of the trial of Charles I,
Edward Whalley and William Goffe, were accused of regicide.
And they escaped England in 1660, and they went to Boston.
Well they did the wrong choice, right?
They went where Harvard is, rather than going where Yale
is.
Okay?
But Boston was an unsafe place, too much under the control of
the crown.
So therefore they went to the right place, right?
And where can it be?
Of course, New Haven.
So they came to New Haven.
And you probably know where West Rock is.
Anybody was up on West Rock?
A few of them.
Well, in West Rock you see a sign which says "Judges'
Cove."
So if you go there, there is a little cove and,
according to the legends, Whalley and Goffe hided in this
cove.
So here you go, history comes back home.
Then they moved actually to Milford and lived in a house
there, and I have a picture of this house.
I don't swear my life on it that this is really the house in
which they hided, but that's what some historian
tells me.
Okay, then there is a turning point in the life of John Locke
in '66 when he meets a formidable person,
whose name was Anthony Ashley Cooper.
Well, he was a high aristocrat, but he nevertheless was
anti-Royalist.
He joined the parliamentary forces against Charles I,
and was also a member of the State Council during the
republican times.
But he supported the restoration of the monarchy in
'66, and held very high offices between 1660 and '73,
including the position of Lord Chancellor.
Well he became the Earl of Shaftesbury, out of the grace of
the King, and usually he is referred to as the Earl of
Shaftesbury.
Well in '66, he went to Oxford to have a
cure for his liver disease, and this is when he met John
Locke as a doctor.
And John Locke became his physician and,
let's put it this way, his friend.
Probably a bit of a strong statement because the social
status difference was too big to really call it as a friendship,
but I will say a word about their relationship.
And here is the Earl of Shaftesbury.
Now in '67, Locke moved to Ashley's house at Exeter House
in the Strand in London.
And I'm sure those of you who've visited London know
exactly where the Strand is; that's still where sort of the
legal establishment can be found in London.
So he lived there in his household.
Like, you know, in feudal times clients lived
with their master's house and ate on the master's table,
or with other servants' table; even high-ranking people
occasionally were not allowed to eat with the lord.
Well he became Ashley's confidant, advisor and surgeon.
He performed a surgery, and I think medical scientists
are still puzzled whether this was some path-breaking surgery
or whether he just had good luck--
that he'd helped Ashley.
Ashley had a surplus production of his liver and he implanted a
tube into his abdomen area to let this surplus flow out,
and certainly Ashley felt much better after the surgery.
Well we know that occasionally the doctors say the surgery was
successful and the patient died.
Now this was a case when the patient was cured,
but we don't know whether the surgery had anything to do with
it.
Right?
But for those of you who are in sciences,
this is just a proof that in the seventeenth century,
you know, there was really no distinction yet what sciences
are: what philosophy is, and what social sciences are.
There was a difference what theology was and the rest of
knowledge was.
But the rest of the knowledge was all the same,
and sort of Locke was also a scientist.
In '67, he wrote an essay, the "Essay on
Toleration."
And this is a departure now from Hobbes.
This actually advocates the right to dissent.
As we have seen, not that Hobbes at all cost
would have resisted every dissent.
Right?
You remember we discussed that--that Hobbes also
considered if the king does not deliver,
you can transfer your loyalty from the king to another
sovereign.
But the "Essay on Toleration"
does not simply make it as such an exceptional case,
you know, but it makes a big argument that the right of
dissent is an important individual right.
He was also then elected in '68 as a member of The Royal
Society.
The Royal Society is like what in the United States we'd call
the American Academy of Sciences--pretty hard to get
into it; was then and it is now.
In '79, he was already working on the Second Treatise.
Assumedly to some--I will talk about this--there is some debate
when the First Treatise and the Second Treatise
were written.
And that's not irrelevant, actually, the timing of the two
essays.
Well there was, on the other hand,
a conflict between Charles II and the parliament and the Earl
of Shaftesbury and, of course, by implication John
Locke.
Charles II had only illegitimate children;
he had quite a few of them, right?
I don't know whether he liked children, but it looks like he
liked the technology, at least.
>
Well therefore, you know, since the children
were all illegitimate, the legitimate heir to the
throne was his brother, James, and the only problem
with James was that he was Roman Catholic.
And we already know from Hobbes that this was a big trouble at
that time in Britain.
So the parliament, and Shaftesbury himself,
feared that Roman Catholics will restore their influence,
and therefore the parliament's role will be reduced.
And then in '73, the parliament was considering
a so-called Test Act.
And this is really an ugly act, because the Test Act meant that
you have to be tested whether you are Roman Catholic or you
belong to the Church of England, and if you are Roman Catholic
then you should not hold certain offices.
Right?
This is just straight discrimination.
But, you know, at that time it was kind of a
defense against the Vatican and the role of the Pope.
Well, because of Shaftesbury's support for this,
he was dismissed as Lord Chancellor.
Nevertheless, a few years later the
parliament does pass the Exclusion Bill,
and they are supporting James, one of the illegitimate
children of Charles, as a successor to the throne.
Well, and this is James Stuart, the brother of Charles II,
and this is the other James, the Protestant,
Shaftesbury's protégée.
Well, the Commons passed the law.
And what Charles II did?
He dismissed the parliament.
Well, Shaftesbury was arrested--put into the Tower of
London.
You probably, if you were in London,
you visited the Tower, or at least had a look at it.
And after he was released, he was smarter than to stay in
England; he went to a right place--I
actually like his taste--he went to the Netherlands.
If I had to be exiled, I would prefer to be in
Amsterdam, of all places.
>
Okay, in '83 the Whigs--the Whigs at that time were kind of
the Democratic Party.
The Tories were the Republican Party and the Whigs were the
equivalent of the Democratic Party.
Well the Whigs were accused to have been involved in a plot to
overthrow the king, and some of them were executed.
That was the Rye House Plot.
Well Locke was smart enough.
He knew he may be next in line so he also made the right
choice; he ran to Amsterdam. Right?
Well again, I don't swear that this was exactly the house where
the plot took place.
I'm even not sure that the plot took place at all,
or whether this was an invention by the authorities.
Well then there is a revolution in '88, and William of Orange
becomes the king.
Well the problem was that James II did not realize that even the
Tories will not support his religious agenda.
So he was actually overthrown, and then the Republicans and
Democrats-- I'm sorry, the Tories and
Whigs--came together and they invited William to become King
of England.
And here is, William III,
and the co-ruler, Queen Mary, his wife--was very
much involved in politics and important.
And Locke then now can return to England, and he felt safe in
1690 to do so.
Well I will talk about this later;
the Second Treatise may actually be a reflection of the
change to the House of Orange, which is a change from
absolutism to constitutional monarchy.
And therefore the Second Treatise can be read as an
ideology for a constitutional monarchy rather than absolutism.
Whether this is the case, it is being debated.
Locke died in 1704.
Interestingly, you know, his major book,
the Two Treatises on Government,
was published in 1690, but it was published
anonymously.
He was concerned enough, even at that time,
that he may run into trouble if he publishes this book.
Okay, now I will be talking about the Two Treatises
and the work now.
So this is the Two Treatises of Government,
which actually was--appeared in print in 1690,
as you can see on the First Edition.
Now, as I said, there is a debate about it,
when the First and the Second Treatise was
written.
And there are two major Locke scholars;
both spent all of their life studying Locke.
Peter Laslett suggested that the Second Treatise was
written really first, in 1679;
it was all engaged in the debates about the Exclusion
Bill.
While Richard Ashcraft--he was my colleague at UCLA at one
point; died unfortunately very young;
a brilliant scholar--actually he argued that the Second
Treatise was written in 1683.
And it is a revolutionary work--that this is really the
theory of constitutional monarchy and kind of popular
sovereignty is being formulated for the first time.
This is really in strong clash--almost absolute
negation--of Hobbes.
Well not quite absolutely; we'll discuss some overlaps
between the two arguments.
But they both agree that that the first treatise was written
in 1680, that's uncontroversial, and was published anonymously.
So the First Treatise.
Well I will not speak too much about this.
The Second Treatise is really the big text everybody
reads and cites.
But the First Treatise takes on a book published by
1680 by Robert Filmer.
This looks to me a very archaic book, but surprisingly it is
still in print.
You go on Google and you can buy Robert Filmer's book,
Patriarcha.
Well I don't necessarily recommend it because I think
this is really archaic, and I don't think it's got any
major contribution beyond challenging Locke to formulate a
strong position against; that's, I think,
the only reason why you may want to read Patriarcha.
Well he was very much for absolutism and the absolute
monarchy, and he advocated actually inequality.
He said, "God set some men above others";
and he meant men. Right?
Men are set over women, and older people,
like me, are set over younger people, like you.
Right?
And the king over everybody else, right?
So this inequality of power is coming from God.
God decided that Adam inherits the earth, and then descendents
of Adam, the sons and grandsons, receive their share of earth.
Right?
So you have to show your family tree, going back to Adam,
who received the world as a grant, and who was the first
king.
So the kings should trace their family trees back to the first
person of grace of God.
Right?
So there was a scripture argument.
Right?
God vested paternal authority in Adam, gave the earth as a
grant to him.
And the monarchical absolute power is inherited this way;
there is a descent of the monarchical power.
As I said, I see very little relevance of this argument.
So I--but certainly it was important for Locke to have a
straw man he could face his argument against--probably
spends too much time debating Filmer.
And you may have been a bit concerned about these
theological controversies and theological arguments in the
book, but otherwise he's really
formulating the first big ideas for modern democratic theory.
Okay, so now Locke engages Filmer on a number of levels.
It actually engages him on the theological level,
and he said, "Well, it's untrue that
Adam received land as a grant.
It was mankind who received the land as a grant from God."
And then he moves on and he kind of makes a more technical
argument.
He said, "Well even if we assume that it was one single
male who received land and all authority,
how on earth you can trace yourself back to this?"
This is not a real good way to legitimate somebody.
How can Charles II shows that he has the answers through this
way?
So that is not the right way to do.
And then he said, "Well, even if it could be
done, it would be silly to do that.
Right?
Just because somebody is the proper ancestor,
should not have--should not be the sovereign.
What if that person is a jerk?
Right?
Then you really want to have the right people to exercise
authority."
Right?
It's, in his time, you know, a very daring
argument.
Now let's have a look at the Second Treatise,
and the major themes--what he's engaged in.
Like Hobbes, he begins with the statement:
We are all born equal, and he has free--free and
equal.
But, as we will see, he draws a very different
conclusion than Hobbes did, or by and large a different
conclusion.
And then he does agree with Locke that we need a common
superior, a sovereign; a superior is necessary to
avoid the state of war.
Then he develops a fascinating theory of property,
what we have to deal with, and then he makes this
path-breaking argument that what we need is rule by majority.
He does not quite identify what that majority is.
Right?
This is not popular sovereignty yet, but the idea of rule by
majority for the first time is formulated by John Locke.
And acceptance of authority can be done only by consent,
and what is needed--and this is the very big contribution of
Locke-- a separation of power,
checks and balances.
Right?
This is what is completely missing in Hobbes,
and he's making this path-breaking argument.
So we are all born free and equal.
Let me speak to this a little.
Now what is political power?
And he defines the three elements of political power.
Right?
Well this is the right to make law.
There is also execution of law, and there is also--politics
means the defense of the commonwealth against outside
enemies.
There are the three functions politics is serving.
And this will be very important in his sort of divisions of
powers, as such.
Now, well if we want to understand what political power
is, we have to see the origins of
political power, and to try to understand why on
earth people from the state of nature,
where they were free and equal, move into civil society where
they surrender some of their freedom and,
we will see, will surrender some of their
equality.
So what is the origins of this equality?
Well the first argument is very much counter-Hobbes.
Right?
Men are all made by God, the omnipotent,
right?
And we are his property; a kind of theological argument.
And we are not--have not been created for the pleasures of one
another.
So there should not be any man who is a superior,
by principle.
Because we are free, right?
Locke is a liberal, right?
Hobbes is a conservative.
So what we are experiencing now is the transition of philosophy
from conservativism to liberalism;
and liberalism, of course, will emphasize
particularly freedom is the primary value.
And in the state of nature, he said, we were all governed
by reason.
And that actually sort of--because we are all
reasonable, we are born reasonable;
we are born to be able to be rational.
Right?
And we should be able to understand that we are not
supposed to harm each other.
You see, this is a very different argument than what we
have seen from Hobbes, on Tuesday.
Right?
Hobbes said that we are actually learning morality out
by interacting with others who are desiring the same stuff what
we do.
We are learning it from struggle, right?
It does not assume that this comes out of our rationality,
that we are reasonable and by nature good.
He does assume that we are reasonable.
Therefore why on earth we should not know that we should
respect others?
Well, but--and this then is where Locke comes the closest to
converge with Hobbes-- well there is on the other hand
a danger that there will be a war,
and in order to avoid war this is why we will subject ourselves
to an authority and leave the state of nature.
But he also makes a claim just to distance himself from Hobbes.
He said it's not that the state of nature is necessarily war.
We have to make a distinction between the state of war and
state of nature because in the state of nature we are good and
reasonable, but nevertheless it can turn
into a state of war.
And that's why we will have to join civil society and accept an
authority.
Well, and now comes again a very big difference.
So he accepts the danger of war--he lived in times of
war--and he accepts that we need an authority because of this.
Now, but--and now here comes the big differences.
Well we subject ourselves to authority of others,
but this has to be done by consent.
Right?
Those who are accepting a sovereign have to consent to
their subjugation, to authority.
And the last citation is also extremely important:
"Freedom of man under government is to have a standing
rule of liberty, common to everyone of that
society, and made by a legislative power
erected in it."
Right?
So the legislative power, now this is the source of
sovereign, is somehow in a proper way constituted.
Right?
This was not a problem really for Hobbes, not much,
right?
We could see that we'll be simply conferring sovereignty to
a single king.
Now Locke is very interested how the sovereign,
the source of power to pass legislation, is being
constituted.
And again he's emphasizing--which was not in
Hobbes--what is important is standing rules to assure
liberty.
Right?
Not simply survival, right?
Though we know Hobbes had it a more complex way.
But
…