Advertisement
English transcript
Prof: So Adam Smith.
And this is what I want to rush quickly through.
His life--we don't really know all that much about his life,
and it is not as colorful as Jean Jacques Rousseau.
And then his major contributions:
his theory of self-interest and how self-interest is related to
the common good, his labor theory of value,
his idea of distribution of value between labor capital and
rent, and finally (what is the most
often cited) with his theory of the invisible hand.
So here it is, Adam Smith.
About his life, he was born in 1723 in
Scotland, Kirkcaldy, just outside of Edinburgh,
which is a beautiful city.
If you did not visit it yet, I recommend that you do.
He entered the University of Glasgow,
and interestingly at that time, in the mid-eighteenth century,
for reasons which is beyond me, next to Paris and in a way
London, Edinburgh was the center of the
Scottish Enlightenment.
Then he also went to Oxford, in Balliol College,
and in 1751 he was appointed at the University of Glasgow as a--
Glasgow I would not recommend as a tourist destination,
by the way >
--he became a professor of logic, and then he became a
professor of moral philosophy, believe it or not.
Right?
The person who is known about self-interest and the invisible
hand, his major first job was professor of moral philosophy,
of ethics.
And, in 1759, he published a book,
the book called The Theory of Moral Sentiments,
which is a book on ethics.
Well we will see this is a big issue, whether this book was
written out of expediency; he wrote it just because he
wanted to justify that he's a professor of moral philosophy
and he didn't really believe in it because he was an economist,
a rational choice economist, or was he really a moralist?
That's one of the big questions I think what scholars on Adam
Smith are debating.
He traveled in Europe, and this may have been a
turning point in his life.
He meets Voltaire and Quesnay, a major economist of his time,
and other representatives of French Enlightenment.
And French Enlightenment may have actually influenced him and
pushed him, after the return of Glasgow, to Kirkcaldy for
awhile; he went back and that's where
he mainly wrote The Wealth of Nations, and that's the most
important book.
But I think in order to understand Adam Smith,
we have to come to terms with the apparent tension between
The Theory of Moral Sentiments and The Wealth
of Nations.
Is this the same author, or these are two different
authors?
Is it the same theory, or there are two different
theories offered to us?
And that's I think very complicated.
He passed away in 1790.
Well I wanted to find you some figures about--pictures about
his life.
The only thing what I could find is a memorial on the site
where the house stood in Kirkcaldy, where he wrote The
Wealth of Nations.
So it's not only Yale University which is turning
buildings down; even the British do turn all
buildings down, even if they should not have
done so.
Right?
It would be so nice to visit the house where The Wealth of
Nations was written.
But if you go to Kirkcaldy, well you can visit that site
and to have a look.
Okay, so as I said, Adam Smith seemed to have two
faces.
Regularly, normally today, if you take economics classes,
he is presented as the person who is advocating the
self-interested individual and a committed theorist of the
self-regulating markets, of the invisible hand-- as
little government as possible, pursue just your self-interest,
and your self-interest will lead to the common good.
So he is the sort of inspiration for neoclassical
economics and rational choice theory, and methodological
individualism, to put it this way.
But he has this book, The Theory of Moral
Sentiments, in which he is writing about
sympathy as an important motivation for human action.
And is this just a concession to his job, or is there
something deep in him which also saw the need for a helping hand
by the public authorities?
That's the big puzzle we have to struggle with.
Well there are other people who are more qualified to give you
the most authentic interpretation of Smith.
I'll try to do my best. Okay?
Well and indeed The Wealth of Nations looks like about
self-interested individuals and the invisible hand.
I will present you enough citations that you see it.
I will also show you why it is possible.
Some of Smith's interpreters will suggest that this is the
same Mill, and in fact The Wealth of
Nations is just an extension of The Theory of Moral
Sentiments, rather than a contradiction to
it.
This is not the majority view.
Right?
Today, among economists in particular, the majority view is
that you should not really pay much attention to The Theory
of Moral Sentiments.
The Wealth of Nations gives you the real source
and inspiration, and this is what guides
neoclassical economics.
But you may find some economists who disagree,
and you will find a number of political philosophers who will
disagree and will say that this is not the real Adam Smith who
is presented to you by neoclassical economists.
And I don't want to take a position in this.
I'm not sufficiently a Smith scholar to be able to do so.
But I will present you the argument both ways,
and you can make up your mind where you stand on this.
So The Theory of Moral Sentiments--just very
briefly what this is.
He does ask the central question: How can we make moral
judgment?
How can we tell good from evil, good for bad?
Well it's a very important issue and question.
Many founding theorists of modern social theory were
dealing with this.
The most important one, we will talk about him at
great--in fifteen minutes--is Frederick Nietzsche,
of course; the genealogy of morals.
This is the central question: Where does our conception of
good and evil come from?
But Adam Smith already here asked this question,
and he said, well "what's the
solution?"
That inside you there is an inner person.
You are two people.
You act, and there is somebody inside you who is watching you,
and that inside you will tell you, "You did something
wrong; that was not the right thing to
do."
And I think you should be able to relate to this.
I can.
There is very often inner self, in myself, which tells me that
was a mistake I did, that was a foolish thing I did,
I should not have done so.
I know people who have a very small impartial internal
spectator.
I know people who have very great difficulties telling ever
that I made a mistake.
There are some people who always blame others if things go
wrong.
Well I think they have a moral problem, I would say.
So what about yourself?
You may have a moral problem if your inner self never tells you
that you were wrong, and you are always liking to
blame others if things went wrong.
Then you have a problem, an ethical problem;
at least this is Adam Smith's argument.
Right?
Simple and persuasive.
Then he says--this is something which is kind of inspired by
Hobbes--we are led by passion.
But now he is not emphasizing fear.
He said, "also by sympathy."
That's crucial, and that's the crucial notion
for those who emphasize that in fact Adam Smith in The Wealth
of Nations is the same Adam Smith as in The Theory of
Moral Sentiments.
Because Adam Smith, those who argue for one Adam
Smith rather than two Adam Smiths,
say that he has a theory of humans which is a sympathetic
theory of humans.
What drives us, that we have sympathy for
others, other people's sympathies, that in interacting
with others we are seeking other people's sympathy.
Right?
We try to please people.
We want to impress people.
We want to have a reputation; we want to have a good
reputation.
We want to act honorably.
So we are seeking sympathy.
We have a sympathy--we have an understanding of other people's
human conditions--but we are also expecting others to
understand us and value us.
Right?
And I think this is a very important and intriguing idea,
which I will show, try to show you later on,
may not be completely inconsistent by the idea that
seeking self-interest is leading to the common good.
Right?
Because indeed, if self-interest implies that I
also want others to respect and evaluate me,
the self-interest also implies that I want to do good to
others.
This is in your self-interest, that you can say at the end of
the day, "I am a good person."
Then, in fact, pursuing these self-interests
may not be all that different from the common good because it
is inside you.
And this, I think, is the way how he is being
read.
And he introduces the notion for the first time of the
concept invisible hand in The Theory of Moral Sentiments.
But here the invisible hand is not what you are told Adam
Smith's theory of the invisible hand is.
It's not the laissez-faire free market.
It's the hand of God. Right?
God guides us to have a proper balance between passion and
sympathy, and that is somehow God's will, what we follow.
In fact, I will talk about this later on.
A big deal is made out of Adam Smith's theory of the invisible
hand.
The term, the word, invisible hand,
the term, comes up three times in his work.
Right?
And in each time he's using it in a different meaning.
The way how we understand invisible hand comes from a
section once, in one sentence,
in The Wealth of Nations.
And in fact it is specifically about foreign trade and
international trade, not about the role of the
government in domestic affairs, but it's about free trade,
free international trade.
And this is the context in which he's using the invisible
hand, as it is being interpreted mostly today by Adam Smith
theorists.
Right?
So it's intriguing, isn't it?
Watch yourself when you are coining a term because a term
occasionally can stick and then it will be always attributed to
you, even if you use it once in your
life.
Okay?
Well The Wealth of Nations.
Well these are kind of the Table of Contents.
He writes about the division of labor and determination of
prices, accumulation of capital.
He writes about the evaluation of societies:
hunting, raising agriculture, and commercial societies.
He never used the term capitalism;
modern economy was commercial industrial society for him.
And then he offers a criticism of mercantilism.
That's where he offers an argument for free international
trade, and that's where he introduces the notion of the
invisible hand.
And then something is on taxation, what I will not talk
about.
So self-interest and the common good;
one of the big issues we have to discuss when we are faced
with Adam Smith.
And the arguments are if you are interacting with each other,
do not expect benevolence.
Right?
Do not expect that somebody else will be charitable to you.
There is also saying if you are seeking
self-interest--specifically in the citations I have;
for instance, choosing your employment.
If you chose it rationally, this will be in the common
good.
And I will try to explain why you seeking self-interest in
finding the job which is best for you is also the best for
society.
And then he says, well the individuals are the
better judges of their own interests than any statement or
lawgiver.
As little state as possible--that's where it is
coming from, and we will see how he argues the case.
So do not expect benevolence.
Okay, this is a very frequently cited sentence from Adam Smith.
It's not in the text I assigned for this course.
Well, "It is not the benevolence of the butcher,
the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner from,
but the very self-interest of the butcher."
I go to the restaurant, I do not expect the cook to
prepare me a good meal because I need a good meal and I expect
the cook to like me.
Right?
I want him to cook a good meal because then I will give a tip.
It is in the self-interest of the waiter to serve me well and
serve me good food.
Otherwise I will not go back again and I will not give a tip.
I will punish.
It is appealing to the self-interest of the person for
whom I expect something, and not is benevolence.
Well he said well we address ourselves not to the humanity of
the people, not to their self-love, but we want people to
take advantage of this.
This is an interesting issue, by the way, even in everyday
life.
I'm sure in this room there are people who think about this
differently.
Just to give you a very personalized example.
My wife occasionally tells me, "This person is not a good
friend of yours because this person only calls you when that
person needs you."
And this does happen.
And my answer always is--and I think in this way,
deep in my heart, I'm a Smithian--"I don't
want friends, I don't want anybody,
who do not see an advantage in interacting with me.
I want people who actually act out of self-interest seeking my
relationship.
It will be a bad relationship if my friends always think that
it cost them to talk to me, and they do not benefit from
the relationship with me."
Right?
I don't want my children just to act out of love and sort of
be a pain in the neck for them.
Right?
I want my children to see that having me as a father is
beneficial for them.
That's a good relationship.
Good relationships are always based on self-interest.
You don't want to have a lover who does not enjoy being your
lover.
Therefore you want people acting out of self-interest.
And I think that's what he's getting at here.
He said even the beggar--here actually the citation says,
"The beggars are the ones who are dependent only upon
benevolence."
But then he qualifies it, he says, "But even for the
beggar it is not quite true." Right?
The beggar will make some tricks in which,
in fact, actually will appeal to your self-interest,
that you are a charitable person or what.
Now self-interest in employment.
He said well it's a very good example.
He said when you are choosing an occupation,
of course you want to have a big job, you want to be
well-paid.
Right?
Those of you who are an economics major,
you may want to have some nice job at some brokerage firm in
Wall Street, and with a Yale Bachelor's
Degree you would like to earn $100,000.00 a year.
Right?
But why would you earn $100,000.00?
Because the employer gets a lot out of these skills what you get
out of Yale, and therefore it will be in the
interest of the society that you get the highest possible salary
because you make the greatest contribution to the common good;
otherwise you would not be paid that high.
Okay?
So therefore you will try to find that occupation in which
you get the highest possible reward,
but you will get only the highest possible reward because
you make the utmost contribution you can,
with your talent, with your hard work,
and with your skills, to the common good.
This is Adam Smith's argument.
It's a persuasive argument actually.
Right?
Well I can go on; it's not all that important.
Now this is very important too, I find.
"Individuals are the better judge of their own
interests than anybody else." Right?
And well this is I think again extremely important,
and I'm sure this classroom is divided fifty/fifty percent
along these views.
Right?
He said well the individuals in the local situations are simply
better judges to what is their interest than any statement or
lawgiver.
Right?
People should judge for themselves what they want and it
should not be a government which imposes it on them.
Right?
This is a big debate right now, for instance about the
healthcare insurance, the healthcare reform.
Should we let it up to people to decide whether they want to
have an insurance or not?
Should we expect people to be individually responsible for
themselves, to take charge of their life?
Or should it be the government, or should it be a statesman,
the lawgiver, the Congress who takes care of
people?
And he clearly takes a position no, I think people are the best
judges of their feelings.
Now the labor theory of value.
And let me rush through of it.
This is important.
His point of departure comes from John Locke,
as we have seen, and it is leading directly to
Karl Marx.
Karl Marx radicalizes his position, but the point of
departure is clearly Adam Smith.
And the argument about the labor theory of value:
the labor is the measure of all values.
And then he said, "The whole produce belongs
to the labor."
And so far Marx completely agrees with him;
and we will see when we will be discussing Marx.
But then he departs from it because he asks the question,
where does the profit and rent come from?
Marx asked this question as well, and he says exploitation;
those who earn profit exploit the workers.
But Adam Smith has a different view.
He says well those who will lend capital and those who offer
land also deserve part of the value.
Now let's see how this contradiction can be resolved,
how he's dealing with this.
How can that all value is created by labor and belongs to
the laborer, and nevertheless the capitalist
pockets profit and the landowner pockets rent for the land?
Then here this is very much John Locke: "The value of
any commodity belongs to the person who possesses it,
and if it is not for use or consumption but exchange,
then the value of this commodity is equal to the amount
of labor which has to be put into this."
"Labor is therefore," he said,
"the real measure of the exchangeable value of all
commodities."
Right?
Commodities can have a use value, they can be very useful,
and they can have very little labor in it, like fresh air;
though by now we know fresh air needs quite a bit of labor too.
Right?
But the exchange, how the exchange it,
will be guided, according to Smith,
by labor.
Few people accept today the labor theory of value;
Smith or Marx, no matter what.
And it belongs to the whole laborer.
This is a very interesting argument.
He said--and this is again John Locke--
"The property of every man is his own labor,
and therefore every value is created by this labor,
and therefore it has to belong to the person who owns the
labor."
"But."
he said, "this is true for societies before capital is
being accumulated and before land is privately owned."
Right?
So this is really an argument for ancient societies,
without capital accumulation and without private ownership of
the land.
In these conditions, if there is no capital
accumulation and no private ownership,
land is commonly owned, then the whole produced labor
belongs to the laborer.
This is where he, Marx, will depart dramatically
from Adam Smith.
So where does the profit and rent come?
Well are capitalists simply exploiting the workers?
He said, "No, there is a distribution of
value between labor, capital and rent."
Right?
And this is reasonable, because the capitalist offers
capital in order-- in fact, advances capital to
the laborer, takes risks with this
advancement of the capital, supervises the labor
process--and therefore it should claim some profit from capital;
otherwise would be a fool not to advance its capital.
And the same goes for land actually.
Landowners also will have to give the land a site in which
production takes place, and therefore they really
should be able to collect some rent on this land.
Well finally the invisible hand.
There are three conceptions of this--I briefly pointed this
out-- in The Theory of Moral Sentiments.
He said this is really God which gives us a sense of
sympathy and creates a balance between passion,
desires, and hunger for more, and self-restraint to respect
others and earn respect from others.
Right?
And then, of course, in The Wealth of
Nations, this appears to be the free marketplace.
And then finally he had a manuscript, History of
Astronomy, and he said the invisible hand
is the hand of Jupiter; the hand of Jupiter because
people, as long as they are ignorant,
phenomena-- lightening for instance,
what they don't-- cannot explain--attribute to
the will of Jupiter.
Right?
Superstition; the invisible hand is
superstition.
Okay?
So what is fun, that three instances where the
notion of the invisible hand is used,
in each case a different meaning, and in none of the
cases exactly the same meaning as we normally understand it.
Okay, I think I'm now moving over to John Stuart Mill,
and to utilitarianism.
And he's
…
And this is what I want to rush quickly through.
His life--we don't really know all that much about his life,
and it is not as colorful as Jean Jacques Rousseau.
And then his major contributions:
his theory of self-interest and how self-interest is related to
the common good, his labor theory of value,
his idea of distribution of value between labor capital and
rent, and finally (what is the most
often cited) with his theory of the invisible hand.
So here it is, Adam Smith.
About his life, he was born in 1723 in
Scotland, Kirkcaldy, just outside of Edinburgh,
which is a beautiful city.
If you did not visit it yet, I recommend that you do.
He entered the University of Glasgow,
and interestingly at that time, in the mid-eighteenth century,
for reasons which is beyond me, next to Paris and in a way
London, Edinburgh was the center of the
Scottish Enlightenment.
Then he also went to Oxford, in Balliol College,
and in 1751 he was appointed at the University of Glasgow as a--
Glasgow I would not recommend as a tourist destination,
by the way >
--he became a professor of logic, and then he became a
professor of moral philosophy, believe it or not.
Right?
The person who is known about self-interest and the invisible
hand, his major first job was professor of moral philosophy,
of ethics.
And, in 1759, he published a book,
the book called The Theory of Moral Sentiments,
which is a book on ethics.
Well we will see this is a big issue, whether this book was
written out of expediency; he wrote it just because he
wanted to justify that he's a professor of moral philosophy
and he didn't really believe in it because he was an economist,
a rational choice economist, or was he really a moralist?
That's one of the big questions I think what scholars on Adam
Smith are debating.
He traveled in Europe, and this may have been a
turning point in his life.
He meets Voltaire and Quesnay, a major economist of his time,
and other representatives of French Enlightenment.
And French Enlightenment may have actually influenced him and
pushed him, after the return of Glasgow, to Kirkcaldy for
awhile; he went back and that's where
he mainly wrote The Wealth of Nations, and that's the most
important book.
But I think in order to understand Adam Smith,
we have to come to terms with the apparent tension between
The Theory of Moral Sentiments and The Wealth
of Nations.
Is this the same author, or these are two different
authors?
Is it the same theory, or there are two different
theories offered to us?
And that's I think very complicated.
He passed away in 1790.
Well I wanted to find you some figures about--pictures about
his life.
The only thing what I could find is a memorial on the site
where the house stood in Kirkcaldy, where he wrote The
Wealth of Nations.
So it's not only Yale University which is turning
buildings down; even the British do turn all
buildings down, even if they should not have
done so.
Right?
It would be so nice to visit the house where The Wealth of
Nations was written.
But if you go to Kirkcaldy, well you can visit that site
and to have a look.
Okay, so as I said, Adam Smith seemed to have two
faces.
Regularly, normally today, if you take economics classes,
he is presented as the person who is advocating the
self-interested individual and a committed theorist of the
self-regulating markets, of the invisible hand-- as
little government as possible, pursue just your self-interest,
and your self-interest will lead to the common good.
So he is the sort of inspiration for neoclassical
economics and rational choice theory, and methodological
individualism, to put it this way.
But he has this book, The Theory of Moral
Sentiments, in which he is writing about
sympathy as an important motivation for human action.
And is this just a concession to his job, or is there
something deep in him which also saw the need for a helping hand
by the public authorities?
That's the big puzzle we have to struggle with.
Well there are other people who are more qualified to give you
the most authentic interpretation of Smith.
I'll try to do my best. Okay?
Well and indeed The Wealth of Nations looks like about
self-interested individuals and the invisible hand.
I will present you enough citations that you see it.
I will also show you why it is possible.
Some of Smith's interpreters will suggest that this is the
same Mill, and in fact The Wealth of
Nations is just an extension of The Theory of Moral
Sentiments, rather than a contradiction to
it.
This is not the majority view.
Right?
Today, among economists in particular, the majority view is
that you should not really pay much attention to The Theory
of Moral Sentiments.
The Wealth of Nations gives you the real source
and inspiration, and this is what guides
neoclassical economics.
But you may find some economists who disagree,
and you will find a number of political philosophers who will
disagree and will say that this is not the real Adam Smith who
is presented to you by neoclassical economists.
And I don't want to take a position in this.
I'm not sufficiently a Smith scholar to be able to do so.
But I will present you the argument both ways,
and you can make up your mind where you stand on this.
So The Theory of Moral Sentiments--just very
briefly what this is.
He does ask the central question: How can we make moral
judgment?
How can we tell good from evil, good for bad?
Well it's a very important issue and question.
Many founding theorists of modern social theory were
dealing with this.
The most important one, we will talk about him at
great--in fifteen minutes--is Frederick Nietzsche,
of course; the genealogy of morals.
This is the central question: Where does our conception of
good and evil come from?
But Adam Smith already here asked this question,
and he said, well "what's the
solution?"
That inside you there is an inner person.
You are two people.
You act, and there is somebody inside you who is watching you,
and that inside you will tell you, "You did something
wrong; that was not the right thing to
do."
And I think you should be able to relate to this.
I can.
There is very often inner self, in myself, which tells me that
was a mistake I did, that was a foolish thing I did,
I should not have done so.
I know people who have a very small impartial internal
spectator.
I know people who have very great difficulties telling ever
that I made a mistake.
There are some people who always blame others if things go
wrong.
Well I think they have a moral problem, I would say.
So what about yourself?
You may have a moral problem if your inner self never tells you
that you were wrong, and you are always liking to
blame others if things went wrong.
Then you have a problem, an ethical problem;
at least this is Adam Smith's argument.
Right?
Simple and persuasive.
Then he says--this is something which is kind of inspired by
Hobbes--we are led by passion.
But now he is not emphasizing fear.
He said, "also by sympathy."
That's crucial, and that's the crucial notion
for those who emphasize that in fact Adam Smith in The Wealth
of Nations is the same Adam Smith as in The Theory of
Moral Sentiments.
Because Adam Smith, those who argue for one Adam
Smith rather than two Adam Smiths,
say that he has a theory of humans which is a sympathetic
theory of humans.
What drives us, that we have sympathy for
others, other people's sympathies, that in interacting
with others we are seeking other people's sympathy.
Right?
We try to please people.
We want to impress people.
We want to have a reputation; we want to have a good
reputation.
We want to act honorably.
So we are seeking sympathy.
We have a sympathy--we have an understanding of other people's
human conditions--but we are also expecting others to
understand us and value us.
Right?
And I think this is a very important and intriguing idea,
which I will show, try to show you later on,
may not be completely inconsistent by the idea that
seeking self-interest is leading to the common good.
Right?
Because indeed, if self-interest implies that I
also want others to respect and evaluate me,
the self-interest also implies that I want to do good to
others.
This is in your self-interest, that you can say at the end of
the day, "I am a good person."
Then, in fact, pursuing these self-interests
may not be all that different from the common good because it
is inside you.
And this, I think, is the way how he is being
read.
And he introduces the notion for the first time of the
concept invisible hand in The Theory of Moral Sentiments.
But here the invisible hand is not what you are told Adam
Smith's theory of the invisible hand is.
It's not the laissez-faire free market.
It's the hand of God. Right?
God guides us to have a proper balance between passion and
sympathy, and that is somehow God's will, what we follow.
In fact, I will talk about this later on.
A big deal is made out of Adam Smith's theory of the invisible
hand.
The term, the word, invisible hand,
the term, comes up three times in his work.
Right?
And in each time he's using it in a different meaning.
The way how we understand invisible hand comes from a
section once, in one sentence,
in The Wealth of Nations.
And in fact it is specifically about foreign trade and
international trade, not about the role of the
government in domestic affairs, but it's about free trade,
free international trade.
And this is the context in which he's using the invisible
hand, as it is being interpreted mostly today by Adam Smith
theorists.
Right?
So it's intriguing, isn't it?
Watch yourself when you are coining a term because a term
occasionally can stick and then it will be always attributed to
you, even if you use it once in your
life.
Okay?
Well The Wealth of Nations.
Well these are kind of the Table of Contents.
He writes about the division of labor and determination of
prices, accumulation of capital.
He writes about the evaluation of societies:
hunting, raising agriculture, and commercial societies.
He never used the term capitalism;
modern economy was commercial industrial society for him.
And then he offers a criticism of mercantilism.
That's where he offers an argument for free international
trade, and that's where he introduces the notion of the
invisible hand.
And then something is on taxation, what I will not talk
about.
So self-interest and the common good;
one of the big issues we have to discuss when we are faced
with Adam Smith.
And the arguments are if you are interacting with each other,
do not expect benevolence.
Right?
Do not expect that somebody else will be charitable to you.
There is also saying if you are seeking
self-interest--specifically in the citations I have;
for instance, choosing your employment.
If you chose it rationally, this will be in the common
good.
And I will try to explain why you seeking self-interest in
finding the job which is best for you is also the best for
society.
And then he says, well the individuals are the
better judges of their own interests than any statement or
lawgiver.
As little state as possible--that's where it is
coming from, and we will see how he argues the case.
So do not expect benevolence.
Okay, this is a very frequently cited sentence from Adam Smith.
It's not in the text I assigned for this course.
Well, "It is not the benevolence of the butcher,
the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner from,
but the very self-interest of the butcher."
I go to the restaurant, I do not expect the cook to
prepare me a good meal because I need a good meal and I expect
the cook to like me.
Right?
I want him to cook a good meal because then I will give a tip.
It is in the self-interest of the waiter to serve me well and
serve me good food.
Otherwise I will not go back again and I will not give a tip.
I will punish.
It is appealing to the self-interest of the person for
whom I expect something, and not is benevolence.
Well he said well we address ourselves not to the humanity of
the people, not to their self-love, but we want people to
take advantage of this.
This is an interesting issue, by the way, even in everyday
life.
I'm sure in this room there are people who think about this
differently.
Just to give you a very personalized example.
My wife occasionally tells me, "This person is not a good
friend of yours because this person only calls you when that
person needs you."
And this does happen.
And my answer always is--and I think in this way,
deep in my heart, I'm a Smithian--"I don't
want friends, I don't want anybody,
who do not see an advantage in interacting with me.
I want people who actually act out of self-interest seeking my
relationship.
It will be a bad relationship if my friends always think that
it cost them to talk to me, and they do not benefit from
the relationship with me."
Right?
I don't want my children just to act out of love and sort of
be a pain in the neck for them.
Right?
I want my children to see that having me as a father is
beneficial for them.
That's a good relationship.
Good relationships are always based on self-interest.
You don't want to have a lover who does not enjoy being your
lover.
Therefore you want people acting out of self-interest.
And I think that's what he's getting at here.
He said even the beggar--here actually the citation says,
"The beggars are the ones who are dependent only upon
benevolence."
But then he qualifies it, he says, "But even for the
beggar it is not quite true." Right?
The beggar will make some tricks in which,
in fact, actually will appeal to your self-interest,
that you are a charitable person or what.
Now self-interest in employment.
He said well it's a very good example.
He said when you are choosing an occupation,
of course you want to have a big job, you want to be
well-paid.
Right?
Those of you who are an economics major,
you may want to have some nice job at some brokerage firm in
Wall Street, and with a Yale Bachelor's
Degree you would like to earn $100,000.00 a year.
Right?
But why would you earn $100,000.00?
Because the employer gets a lot out of these skills what you get
out of Yale, and therefore it will be in the
interest of the society that you get the highest possible salary
because you make the greatest contribution to the common good;
otherwise you would not be paid that high.
Okay?
So therefore you will try to find that occupation in which
you get the highest possible reward,
but you will get only the highest possible reward because
you make the utmost contribution you can,
with your talent, with your hard work,
and with your skills, to the common good.
This is Adam Smith's argument.
It's a persuasive argument actually.
Right?
Well I can go on; it's not all that important.
Now this is very important too, I find.
"Individuals are the better judge of their own
interests than anybody else." Right?
And well this is I think again extremely important,
and I'm sure this classroom is divided fifty/fifty percent
along these views.
Right?
He said well the individuals in the local situations are simply
better judges to what is their interest than any statement or
lawgiver.
Right?
People should judge for themselves what they want and it
should not be a government which imposes it on them.
Right?
This is a big debate right now, for instance about the
healthcare insurance, the healthcare reform.
Should we let it up to people to decide whether they want to
have an insurance or not?
Should we expect people to be individually responsible for
themselves, to take charge of their life?
Or should it be the government, or should it be a statesman,
the lawgiver, the Congress who takes care of
people?
And he clearly takes a position no, I think people are the best
judges of their feelings.
Now the labor theory of value.
And let me rush through of it.
This is important.
His point of departure comes from John Locke,
as we have seen, and it is leading directly to
Karl Marx.
Karl Marx radicalizes his position, but the point of
departure is clearly Adam Smith.
And the argument about the labor theory of value:
the labor is the measure of all values.
And then he said, "The whole produce belongs
to the labor."
And so far Marx completely agrees with him;
and we will see when we will be discussing Marx.
But then he departs from it because he asks the question,
where does the profit and rent come from?
Marx asked this question as well, and he says exploitation;
those who earn profit exploit the workers.
But Adam Smith has a different view.
He says well those who will lend capital and those who offer
land also deserve part of the value.
Now let's see how this contradiction can be resolved,
how he's dealing with this.
How can that all value is created by labor and belongs to
the laborer, and nevertheless the capitalist
pockets profit and the landowner pockets rent for the land?
Then here this is very much John Locke: "The value of
any commodity belongs to the person who possesses it,
and if it is not for use or consumption but exchange,
then the value of this commodity is equal to the amount
of labor which has to be put into this."
"Labor is therefore," he said,
"the real measure of the exchangeable value of all
commodities."
Right?
Commodities can have a use value, they can be very useful,
and they can have very little labor in it, like fresh air;
though by now we know fresh air needs quite a bit of labor too.
Right?
But the exchange, how the exchange it,
will be guided, according to Smith,
by labor.
Few people accept today the labor theory of value;
Smith or Marx, no matter what.
And it belongs to the whole laborer.
This is a very interesting argument.
He said--and this is again John Locke--
"The property of every man is his own labor,
and therefore every value is created by this labor,
and therefore it has to belong to the person who owns the
labor."
"But."
he said, "this is true for societies before capital is
being accumulated and before land is privately owned."
Right?
So this is really an argument for ancient societies,
without capital accumulation and without private ownership of
the land.
In these conditions, if there is no capital
accumulation and no private ownership,
land is commonly owned, then the whole produced labor
belongs to the laborer.
This is where he, Marx, will depart dramatically
from Adam Smith.
So where does the profit and rent come?
Well are capitalists simply exploiting the workers?
He said, "No, there is a distribution of
value between labor, capital and rent."
Right?
And this is reasonable, because the capitalist offers
capital in order-- in fact, advances capital to
the laborer, takes risks with this
advancement of the capital, supervises the labor
process--and therefore it should claim some profit from capital;
otherwise would be a fool not to advance its capital.
And the same goes for land actually.
Landowners also will have to give the land a site in which
production takes place, and therefore they really
should be able to collect some rent on this land.
Well finally the invisible hand.
There are three conceptions of this--I briefly pointed this
out-- in The Theory of Moral Sentiments.
He said this is really God which gives us a sense of
sympathy and creates a balance between passion,
desires, and hunger for more, and self-restraint to respect
others and earn respect from others.
Right?
And then, of course, in The Wealth of
Nations, this appears to be the free marketplace.
And then finally he had a manuscript, History of
Astronomy, and he said the invisible hand
is the hand of Jupiter; the hand of Jupiter because
people, as long as they are ignorant,
phenomena-- lightening for instance,
what they don't-- cannot explain--attribute to
the will of Jupiter.
Right?
Superstition; the invisible hand is
superstition.
Okay?
So what is fun, that three instances where the
notion of the invisible hand is used,
in each case a different meaning, and in none of the
cases exactly the same meaning as we normally understand it.
Okay, I think I'm now moving over to John Stuart Mill,
and to utilitarianism.
And he's
…