Advertisement
English transcript
Prof: Let's get going with John Stuart Mill.
Let me just one more time to say John Stuart Mill is
formidably influential, very influential on our days.
He's the ultimate of liberalism.
And in some ways, among all the authors we will
be reading this semester, he's the most consistent,
the clearest one and the most consistent of them all.
He draws the line to the logical conclusions,
no matter what it is.
Right?
And taking his point of departure from Adam Smith--
Locke, Adam Smith and then Bentham--
he pushes the line of utilitarianism to its most
logical conclusions, and he's extremely influential
on what we call now neoclassical economics,
and he was exactly the person, who made many people who were
liberals and Democrats in the 1960s and '70s,
to change and create what they called neo-conservativism or
neo-liberalism and went over to the Republican Party.
It was an important dividing line.
Mill's staunch insistence on individual liberty,
and what follows from this staunch insistence for the role
of the state and how far states can interfere with individuals.
That was really, I think, the dividing line in
which many people who were on the political left,
center left, or occasionally far left,
by the late 1960s, early '70s, seeing stuff like
the affirmative action, the War on Poverty,
they changed their lines.
They said, "Look, the Democratic Party,
liberalism, really betrays liberalism.
That's not liberalism.
Read John Stuart Mill.
That's when you will know what real liberalism is."
Right?
Anyway, so I think this is why his message is very much alive.
And I'm sure that this classroom is divided by people.
Some people subscribe to John Stuart Mill's liberalism.
Others probably do think that he emphasizes too much
individual liberties and there is much more of a role to
implement the general good by the government.
Okay, I mean, I think we left it right here
last week.
These are the main themes of his book on utilitarianism,
the way how he departs from Bentham--
a very important change that he's beginning to emphasize
there are higher happinesses we can seek.
It is not simply quantity but quality of happiness is what we
seek.
A very important contribution, I think,
and this is an idea which is only touched upon by Adam Smith
but really not properly developed,
and certainly completely missing in Bentham.
It is really Mill's contribution which is very
important for contemporary economic theory,
neoclassical economics.
They call this preferences, that we have preferences,
and therefore individuals will attach different values to
different utilities.
And this really comes from the work of John Stuart Mill,
when he makes this distinction between legality and justice,
and what is legal is not necessarily just,
and what is just is necessarily approved by laws.
And then justice and expediency: what is expedient is
not necessarily just, and well just may have its cost
and may not be the fastest way to get there.
Right?
Okay, so let's labor our way through of this,
and leave time to look at the questions.
Well the idea is that we are human beings and therefore we
have a capacity to have higher appetites than the animal
appetites.
Right?
So we have imagination, what animals don't have.
We have moral sentiments, and these moral sentiments may
lead us in our choices.
Right?
Now you can see--I mentioned that about Adam Smith,
that Adam Smith might have had this theory of sympathetic
humans, which in a way pointed this
direction.
This is very central for John Stuart Mill.
And therefore, he emphasizes there is a
qualitative difference between human and simply animal
appetites.
So therefore you simply cannot do what Bentham did,
simply add up appetites and to say if more appetites are
satisfied, better off the society is.
The chief good, so he argues,
is virtue.
Be virtuous and then you will feel good;
you will be happier if you are virtuous, as such.
But, you know, these are all qualifications of
the kind of elementary utilitarianism;
I think qualifications but, by the way, most rational
choice theorists and most neoclassical economists will
also agree with.
Those who are critiques of neo-liberals and utilitarianism
very often kind of caricature their position,
not really understanding that following John Stuart Mill--
they do understand that there is a qualitative differences
between utilities.
But otherwise he remains by the utilitarian principle.
We are rational actors, we are self-interested,
we know what our needs are, and we can make good judgments
whether the price we have to pay in order to satisfy our needs is
worth for us.
Right?
That is the fundamental idea of utilitarianism,
which is, thank you, very healthy today.
There are many people who disagree with it.
There are many people who agree with it.
Right?
But this is all John Stuart Mill's addition.
And now a bit on higher happiness.
Well the pleasure of the beast might be felt as degrading by a
human being.
Right?
We want to have some--we have higher needs than just the
animal needs.
So you go to a five-star restaurant where they serve you
a little food.
It will be delicious, but it will be unlike these
Italian family restaurants down the road on Wooster Street where
they give you food what you can hardly eat which satisfies your
animal appetites.
Right?
So anyway, we have higher needs, higher appetites.
We want to see our food served in a special way.
We just don't feed our belly, as such.
And there are the pleasures of the intellect and imagination;
I think we already have seen this in Rousseau,
how important imagination is.
And if you are in comparative literature or English,
of course the aesthetic theories of Schiller,
the German poet, who emphasized how important
actually imagination and play is in figuring out what beauty is.
All right, and then a bit on quality of pleasures.
Right?
Really the question is what kind of pleasure satisfies us,
rather than just the quantity.
And I think this is a very powerful point.
Well few humans would consent to be changed into any of the
lower animals.
Right?
No intelligent being would consent to be a fool,
even though they should be persuaded that a fool is better
satisfied than a lot of man; it's easier to satisfy
occasionally a fool.
And this is really beautiful: "It's better to be a human
being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied."
Right?
"Better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool
satisfied."
Bingo, right?
He got it.
I think that's very beautifully done, powerfully done.
Think about it.
Very hard to disagree with this.
Right?
You want to be Socrates and dissatisfied,
rather than just being satisfied by your needs.
Well I don't want to dwell too much on the issue of justice and
legalities.
Quite obvious, that there are differences
between justice and legality.
Well it is unjust if anybody's deprived from his personal
liberty or property, even if that's what the law
tells you.
I mean, Communist government confiscated property from
people, and they did it legally, but John Stuart Mill will say
they did it unjustly.
Right?
It was legally done, but unjustly.
Right?
It was against the sense of justice of people who are being
deprived from their property.
And there are laws which do not exist,
though they should exist, because some of the individual
rights are not properly defended,
and you really should have such laws.
And, of course, for him there has not been in
his time sufficient laws to protect the rights of women or
the rights of slaves.
Well also today we are concerned about whether we have
proper protection in this country for individual liberties
against surveillance techniques, for instance,
which were used very recently in the United States.
Many people think we need very stricter controls on the
government, whether they can listen to our telephone
conversations.
Right?
We want to have very clear laws which define exactly what
torture is.
We may be uncertain whether the laws are sufficiently clear.
Right?
So therefore you need occasionally laws which protects
human rights.
This argument can be used actually for affirmative action,
that you may need occasionally laws which kind of eliminates
the inequalities of people's freedoms.
Some people are less free than others because they start from a
different starting point.
Then you can use John Stuart Mill's argument then to say you
need a law which will protect these people and make sure they
are free enough, that you create an equality of
freedom; that would be his argument.
And there are laws which exist but they should not exist.
There are bad and unjust laws.
Well we debate this issue a great deal.
I'm sure there are some people in this country who do think
that the government should not kill.
Right?
There are some people who are against the death penalty.
Probably the majority is for the death penalty,
but there is probably a minority in this room--
I don't want to ask you to show hands,
though I might >
--but I'm sure there are some people who think the government
should not kill people.
I'm one of those.
I don't think that's right.
I think life is sacred.
I believe sufficiently in Hobbes' First Law of Nature,
no government should kill.
So death penalty, I don't think it's right.
But you can argue it's necessary to defend other
people's freedom.
Right?
But I think John Stuart Mill probably would have been unhappy
with the death penalty.
So you may want to change legislation.
Right?
You may want to have a legislation which eliminates the
death penalty.
Or another issue is let's say--again I'm sure this
audience here is divided on the question of abortion.
There are some people who believe that abortion should be
prohibited by law because you should defend the freedom and
right of existence of the unborn child.
Right?
There are others who argue the freedom argument on the other
side.
Right?
They say, "No, you should not prohibit
abortion because you should defend the liberty of the woman
who carries the child."
Right?
Well, these are just examples that these issues are talking to
very contemporary issues.
All right, justice and equality.
Well this is a very interesting idea, what he's playing around.
He said we have actually a sense that justice is somehow
related to equality-- that we occasionally feel that
some degree of inequality is already unjust.
Even if it is legally achieved by legal means,
we may see it is unjust.
Usually inequalities are explained and justified by
expediency.
Right?
You have to create these high levels of inequality because you
have to create incentives.
We just heard this debate the last couple of weeks.
If you try to limit the bonuses the guys on Wall Street do get,
you do a lot of damage because these hot brokers will be hired
by the competition.
Therefore they have to get these hundred million dollar
bonuses; otherwise the business will be
hurt.
Right?
And there were banks which were paying back billions of dollars
to the federal government so the federal government cannot
intervene and cannot overrule how much bonuses they pay.
Right?
Expediency, right?
They say, "Oh give me a break about this justice stuff,
that this is unfair that somebody earns a hundred million
dollars.
They should earn, because otherwise the
competition gets them."
Right?
Well this is the argument of expediency, not the argument of
justice.
Right?
All right, well there are different components of justice.
Well the first and most important one:
"It is unjust to deprive anyone of his personal liberty
and property."
That's the most important point in John Stuart Mill.
He's staunchly defending individual liberty.
The second one: "Legal right is deprived,
may be rights which ought not to have belonged to him."
Right?
There may be privileges--I mean, in contemporary societies
this is much less common.
In his time there were a lot of laws which defended people's
privileges--feudal privileges, what he wanted to get rid of.
Right?
They were unjust.
Well he also then suggests that each person should obtain what
he or she deserves, even if it is not guaranteed by
law.
Well how far you go with this argument--it again can be very
controversial.
You can say, "Well you need a welfare
state.
You have to provide the basic goods and services for
everybody."
You know, this argument can be used.
You have to provide housing.
You should not let anybody without shelter,
or you should not let anybody without healthcare.
That would be consistent with John Stuart Mill.
And then he said, "Well it is unjust if you
break faith."
Right?
You promise somebody I will do it, and then you take your word
back.
That's unjust; you should not do that.
And finally--this is very important--justice cannot be
partial.
Right?
It has to be blind and has to be equal to all parties.
And now justice and expediency.
I again don't want to labor on this.
This is obvious, that what is expedient is not
necessarily just.
Expedient is if you reach that goal with minimum effort,
but occasionally you don't--you better not make shortcuts;
making those shortcuts may be unjust and unfair.
And then, of course, sympathy.
Right?
We are all capable to sympathize, not only with people
we know but with the whole humankind we have sympathy.
Sympathy for our country and our mankind.
It's a bit like Rousseau's l'amour propre idea.
I think I'll probably skip this one.
I think it's quite obvious why justice and expediency do have a
complicated relationship.
And now on the other book, On Liberty.
Right?
Well while Bentham only emphasized that we are seeking
pleasure, Mill emphasized self-development.
He said we have to--in our lifetime, we have to develop our
capacities.
Right?
And what follows from this, individualism and liberty;
these are the major values, rather than just satisfying our
needs.
Well this is an extremely important idea,
and very much an idea of John Stuart Mill.
We should not take freedom as granted.
And he said, "Be very careful of rulers
who identify with the people.
It does not guarantee freedom, because it can lead to the
tyranny of the majority.
You have to defend the rights of the individuals,
the rights of the minorities, that they should be also free
to choose."
This follows very logically from his argument of these
higher happinesses, preferences,
arrived at by individual judgments--
not superimposed by government but individuals decide what is
the higher value they attach to a utility.
And therefore it can be minorities which do have
different preferences, and we have to respect those
preferences.
That's very crucially important ideas.
And individual liberty should always take precedence over
short-term utilitarian consideration.
Right?
The main value is that individually that--
believe me, this is not a contradiction,
it follows very logically from the idea of preferences and from
the idea that there are qualitative differences between
utilities, and you are the only one who
can decide what is worse for you.
Nobody else can make a decision, a judgment for you.
This is consistent with Adam Smith, by the way.
And then freedom of expression.
There is nobody whom we will read who stands so strongly for
freedom of expression--complete, unlimited freedom of
expression.
And the United States comes very close to this,
and this is the only country in the world which comes so close
to it.
In other countries which are democratic, free,
and liberal, freedom of speech may be
limited.
Hate speech may be actually limited.
Right?
Denying the Holocaust and you end up in jail in Germany.
Right?
But in the U.S., we are very close to the
Millian idea.
And he said this is absolutely necessary to have total freedom
of speech because an opinion, which suppressed right,
then we lose the opportunity to exchange truths for error.
So therefore it's obvious that it's non-controversial--that
truth, even if it's unpleasant, should be allowed to be spoken.
Right?
What is more problematic should we allow to people to speak
falsehood?
I mean, we know that the Holocaust existed.
Should we allow those crazy people to tell us,
against all this strong evidence what we have,
that there was no Holocaust?
He argues yes we should, because this is the only way
how we can find out the error, if we talk about this.
It's a very controversial argument.
As I said, there are not many countries in this world which do
subscribe to it.
Right?
So, and he said we have to listen to both sides;
that's the only way how we find out what the truth is.
And tyranny by the majority.
Well this is a very, very important argument;
namely, one of the major evils of a mass democratic society is
a tyranny of the majority.
There will be a very strong tendency to suppress dissent and
to create conformity with the majority views.
And he said well, we have to try to resist it,
and we have to emphasize individuality.
Conformism is moral repression.
Right?
There's a lot of pressure on you to conform with the
major--the mainstream, as such, and he said this is
one of the big evils what we have to resist.
We have to defend individual liberties, and we have to fight
against intervention; legal or non-legal
intervention.
Right?
He did not live in a mass communication society,
but he would have been outraged how the media tries to brainwash
people and put into a conformist behavior on people.
Right?
He wanted to defend people's individual choices of lifestyles
and sexual preferences and whatever you name;
it has to be defended.
And this is very important.
This is a clear extension, very clearly argued--
Adam Smith did basically agree with this,
but he did not put it so strongly and so clearly--
"Therefore intervention by a government is only permissible
if injury has taken place."
The government cannot limit individual liberties,
only if that causes injury.
And he said, "Look, believe me,
I'm not indifferent.
I am for compassion.
All what I am asking you is tolerance.
Respect other people's choices.
Do feel compassion, but don't try to make decisions
for others; don't impose your will on
others."
That's I think the--and conformity, he really disliked
conformity.
It's a century ahead of his time.
This becomes a very big issue in the 1960s and '70s,
that conformism is an evil, and he already writes about
this in the mid-nineteenth century.
And well interference.
The only justification is self-protection.
Right?
This is very much in line of Hobbes' argument.
And therefore he said, "I'm not for indifference,
but I am for permissiveness, for tolerance as such."
Well we should help each other, but that's different than to
impose our will or our taste or our preferences on other people.
Right?
"Neither one person, nor any number of person,
is warranted in saying to other human creatures of ripe
years"-- that's different with
children--"that he shall not do with his life for his own
benefit what he chooses to do with it."
Right?
A very strong argument, and very troubling.
You know?
What do you think about drug use?
Right?
Well if John Stuart Mill errs, he errs on the libertarian
side.
He probably would be arguing for the decriminalization of
most of the drugs, on these grounds.
It's people's choice.
If they know that they hurt their life, this is their story.
Now very briefly on his views on women.
And I don't have to introduce you to the background.
You know that in the mid-nineteenth century women did
not have equal rights, even not in England,
not in the United States.
They not only did not have the right to vote,
but they actually did not have the right to own property,
as such.
Well as I mentioned, Harriet Taylor,
his lover and wife, was a radical feminist--as far
as we know, an extremely smart woman.
She was more radical than Smith, because she actually,
as I pointed out, opposed even the institution of
marriage.
So what are the major themes in this book?
The first point is "marriage is the only
remaining case of slavery."
Well it's not true of course.
Slavery has existed elsewhere, and unfortunately de facto
still exists around the world.
But he said, you know, "The subjugation
of
…
Let me just one more time to say John Stuart Mill is
formidably influential, very influential on our days.
He's the ultimate of liberalism.
And in some ways, among all the authors we will
be reading this semester, he's the most consistent,
the clearest one and the most consistent of them all.
He draws the line to the logical conclusions,
no matter what it is.
Right?
And taking his point of departure from Adam Smith--
Locke, Adam Smith and then Bentham--
he pushes the line of utilitarianism to its most
logical conclusions, and he's extremely influential
on what we call now neoclassical economics,
and he was exactly the person, who made many people who were
liberals and Democrats in the 1960s and '70s,
to change and create what they called neo-conservativism or
neo-liberalism and went over to the Republican Party.
It was an important dividing line.
Mill's staunch insistence on individual liberty,
and what follows from this staunch insistence for the role
of the state and how far states can interfere with individuals.
That was really, I think, the dividing line in
which many people who were on the political left,
center left, or occasionally far left,
by the late 1960s, early '70s, seeing stuff like
the affirmative action, the War on Poverty,
they changed their lines.
They said, "Look, the Democratic Party,
liberalism, really betrays liberalism.
That's not liberalism.
Read John Stuart Mill.
That's when you will know what real liberalism is."
Right?
Anyway, so I think this is why his message is very much alive.
And I'm sure that this classroom is divided by people.
Some people subscribe to John Stuart Mill's liberalism.
Others probably do think that he emphasizes too much
individual liberties and there is much more of a role to
implement the general good by the government.
Okay, I mean, I think we left it right here
last week.
These are the main themes of his book on utilitarianism,
the way how he departs from Bentham--
a very important change that he's beginning to emphasize
there are higher happinesses we can seek.
It is not simply quantity but quality of happiness is what we
seek.
A very important contribution, I think,
and this is an idea which is only touched upon by Adam Smith
but really not properly developed,
and certainly completely missing in Bentham.
It is really Mill's contribution which is very
important for contemporary economic theory,
neoclassical economics.
They call this preferences, that we have preferences,
and therefore individuals will attach different values to
different utilities.
And this really comes from the work of John Stuart Mill,
when he makes this distinction between legality and justice,
and what is legal is not necessarily just,
and what is just is necessarily approved by laws.
And then justice and expediency: what is expedient is
not necessarily just, and well just may have its cost
and may not be the fastest way to get there.
Right?
Okay, so let's labor our way through of this,
and leave time to look at the questions.
Well the idea is that we are human beings and therefore we
have a capacity to have higher appetites than the animal
appetites.
Right?
So we have imagination, what animals don't have.
We have moral sentiments, and these moral sentiments may
lead us in our choices.
Right?
Now you can see--I mentioned that about Adam Smith,
that Adam Smith might have had this theory of sympathetic
humans, which in a way pointed this
direction.
This is very central for John Stuart Mill.
And therefore, he emphasizes there is a
qualitative difference between human and simply animal
appetites.
So therefore you simply cannot do what Bentham did,
simply add up appetites and to say if more appetites are
satisfied, better off the society is.
The chief good, so he argues,
is virtue.
Be virtuous and then you will feel good;
you will be happier if you are virtuous, as such.
But, you know, these are all qualifications of
the kind of elementary utilitarianism;
I think qualifications but, by the way, most rational
choice theorists and most neoclassical economists will
also agree with.
Those who are critiques of neo-liberals and utilitarianism
very often kind of caricature their position,
not really understanding that following John Stuart Mill--
they do understand that there is a qualitative differences
between utilities.
But otherwise he remains by the utilitarian principle.
We are rational actors, we are self-interested,
we know what our needs are, and we can make good judgments
whether the price we have to pay in order to satisfy our needs is
worth for us.
Right?
That is the fundamental idea of utilitarianism,
which is, thank you, very healthy today.
There are many people who disagree with it.
There are many people who agree with it.
Right?
But this is all John Stuart Mill's addition.
And now a bit on higher happiness.
Well the pleasure of the beast might be felt as degrading by a
human being.
Right?
We want to have some--we have higher needs than just the
animal needs.
So you go to a five-star restaurant where they serve you
a little food.
It will be delicious, but it will be unlike these
Italian family restaurants down the road on Wooster Street where
they give you food what you can hardly eat which satisfies your
animal appetites.
Right?
So anyway, we have higher needs, higher appetites.
We want to see our food served in a special way.
We just don't feed our belly, as such.
And there are the pleasures of the intellect and imagination;
I think we already have seen this in Rousseau,
how important imagination is.
And if you are in comparative literature or English,
of course the aesthetic theories of Schiller,
the German poet, who emphasized how important
actually imagination and play is in figuring out what beauty is.
All right, and then a bit on quality of pleasures.
Right?
Really the question is what kind of pleasure satisfies us,
rather than just the quantity.
And I think this is a very powerful point.
Well few humans would consent to be changed into any of the
lower animals.
Right?
No intelligent being would consent to be a fool,
even though they should be persuaded that a fool is better
satisfied than a lot of man; it's easier to satisfy
occasionally a fool.
And this is really beautiful: "It's better to be a human
being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied."
Right?
"Better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool
satisfied."
Bingo, right?
He got it.
I think that's very beautifully done, powerfully done.
Think about it.
Very hard to disagree with this.
Right?
You want to be Socrates and dissatisfied,
rather than just being satisfied by your needs.
Well I don't want to dwell too much on the issue of justice and
legalities.
Quite obvious, that there are differences
between justice and legality.
Well it is unjust if anybody's deprived from his personal
liberty or property, even if that's what the law
tells you.
I mean, Communist government confiscated property from
people, and they did it legally, but John Stuart Mill will say
they did it unjustly.
Right?
It was legally done, but unjustly.
Right?
It was against the sense of justice of people who are being
deprived from their property.
And there are laws which do not exist,
though they should exist, because some of the individual
rights are not properly defended,
and you really should have such laws.
And, of course, for him there has not been in
his time sufficient laws to protect the rights of women or
the rights of slaves.
Well also today we are concerned about whether we have
proper protection in this country for individual liberties
against surveillance techniques, for instance,
which were used very recently in the United States.
Many people think we need very stricter controls on the
government, whether they can listen to our telephone
conversations.
Right?
We want to have very clear laws which define exactly what
torture is.
We may be uncertain whether the laws are sufficiently clear.
Right?
So therefore you need occasionally laws which protects
human rights.
This argument can be used actually for affirmative action,
that you may need occasionally laws which kind of eliminates
the inequalities of people's freedoms.
Some people are less free than others because they start from a
different starting point.
Then you can use John Stuart Mill's argument then to say you
need a law which will protect these people and make sure they
are free enough, that you create an equality of
freedom; that would be his argument.
And there are laws which exist but they should not exist.
There are bad and unjust laws.
Well we debate this issue a great deal.
I'm sure there are some people in this country who do think
that the government should not kill.
Right?
There are some people who are against the death penalty.
Probably the majority is for the death penalty,
but there is probably a minority in this room--
I don't want to ask you to show hands,
though I might >
--but I'm sure there are some people who think the government
should not kill people.
I'm one of those.
I don't think that's right.
I think life is sacred.
I believe sufficiently in Hobbes' First Law of Nature,
no government should kill.
So death penalty, I don't think it's right.
But you can argue it's necessary to defend other
people's freedom.
Right?
But I think John Stuart Mill probably would have been unhappy
with the death penalty.
So you may want to change legislation.
Right?
You may want to have a legislation which eliminates the
death penalty.
Or another issue is let's say--again I'm sure this
audience here is divided on the question of abortion.
There are some people who believe that abortion should be
prohibited by law because you should defend the freedom and
right of existence of the unborn child.
Right?
There are others who argue the freedom argument on the other
side.
Right?
They say, "No, you should not prohibit
abortion because you should defend the liberty of the woman
who carries the child."
Right?
Well, these are just examples that these issues are talking to
very contemporary issues.
All right, justice and equality.
Well this is a very interesting idea, what he's playing around.
He said we have actually a sense that justice is somehow
related to equality-- that we occasionally feel that
some degree of inequality is already unjust.
Even if it is legally achieved by legal means,
we may see it is unjust.
Usually inequalities are explained and justified by
expediency.
Right?
You have to create these high levels of inequality because you
have to create incentives.
We just heard this debate the last couple of weeks.
If you try to limit the bonuses the guys on Wall Street do get,
you do a lot of damage because these hot brokers will be hired
by the competition.
Therefore they have to get these hundred million dollar
bonuses; otherwise the business will be
hurt.
Right?
And there were banks which were paying back billions of dollars
to the federal government so the federal government cannot
intervene and cannot overrule how much bonuses they pay.
Right?
Expediency, right?
They say, "Oh give me a break about this justice stuff,
that this is unfair that somebody earns a hundred million
dollars.
They should earn, because otherwise the
competition gets them."
Right?
Well this is the argument of expediency, not the argument of
justice.
Right?
All right, well there are different components of justice.
Well the first and most important one:
"It is unjust to deprive anyone of his personal liberty
and property."
That's the most important point in John Stuart Mill.
He's staunchly defending individual liberty.
The second one: "Legal right is deprived,
may be rights which ought not to have belonged to him."
Right?
There may be privileges--I mean, in contemporary societies
this is much less common.
In his time there were a lot of laws which defended people's
privileges--feudal privileges, what he wanted to get rid of.
Right?
They were unjust.
Well he also then suggests that each person should obtain what
he or she deserves, even if it is not guaranteed by
law.
Well how far you go with this argument--it again can be very
controversial.
You can say, "Well you need a welfare
state.
You have to provide the basic goods and services for
everybody."
You know, this argument can be used.
You have to provide housing.
You should not let anybody without shelter,
or you should not let anybody without healthcare.
That would be consistent with John Stuart Mill.
And then he said, "Well it is unjust if you
break faith."
Right?
You promise somebody I will do it, and then you take your word
back.
That's unjust; you should not do that.
And finally--this is very important--justice cannot be
partial.
Right?
It has to be blind and has to be equal to all parties.
And now justice and expediency.
I again don't want to labor on this.
This is obvious, that what is expedient is not
necessarily just.
Expedient is if you reach that goal with minimum effort,
but occasionally you don't--you better not make shortcuts;
making those shortcuts may be unjust and unfair.
And then, of course, sympathy.
Right?
We are all capable to sympathize, not only with people
we know but with the whole humankind we have sympathy.
Sympathy for our country and our mankind.
It's a bit like Rousseau's l'amour propre idea.
I think I'll probably skip this one.
I think it's quite obvious why justice and expediency do have a
complicated relationship.
And now on the other book, On Liberty.
Right?
Well while Bentham only emphasized that we are seeking
pleasure, Mill emphasized self-development.
He said we have to--in our lifetime, we have to develop our
capacities.
Right?
And what follows from this, individualism and liberty;
these are the major values, rather than just satisfying our
needs.
Well this is an extremely important idea,
and very much an idea of John Stuart Mill.
We should not take freedom as granted.
And he said, "Be very careful of rulers
who identify with the people.
It does not guarantee freedom, because it can lead to the
tyranny of the majority.
You have to defend the rights of the individuals,
the rights of the minorities, that they should be also free
to choose."
This follows very logically from his argument of these
higher happinesses, preferences,
arrived at by individual judgments--
not superimposed by government but individuals decide what is
the higher value they attach to a utility.
And therefore it can be minorities which do have
different preferences, and we have to respect those
preferences.
That's very crucially important ideas.
And individual liberty should always take precedence over
short-term utilitarian consideration.
Right?
The main value is that individually that--
believe me, this is not a contradiction,
it follows very logically from the idea of preferences and from
the idea that there are qualitative differences between
utilities, and you are the only one who
can decide what is worse for you.
Nobody else can make a decision, a judgment for you.
This is consistent with Adam Smith, by the way.
And then freedom of expression.
There is nobody whom we will read who stands so strongly for
freedom of expression--complete, unlimited freedom of
expression.
And the United States comes very close to this,
and this is the only country in the world which comes so close
to it.
In other countries which are democratic, free,
and liberal, freedom of speech may be
limited.
Hate speech may be actually limited.
Right?
Denying the Holocaust and you end up in jail in Germany.
Right?
But in the U.S., we are very close to the
Millian idea.
And he said this is absolutely necessary to have total freedom
of speech because an opinion, which suppressed right,
then we lose the opportunity to exchange truths for error.
So therefore it's obvious that it's non-controversial--that
truth, even if it's unpleasant, should be allowed to be spoken.
Right?
What is more problematic should we allow to people to speak
falsehood?
I mean, we know that the Holocaust existed.
Should we allow those crazy people to tell us,
against all this strong evidence what we have,
that there was no Holocaust?
He argues yes we should, because this is the only way
how we can find out the error, if we talk about this.
It's a very controversial argument.
As I said, there are not many countries in this world which do
subscribe to it.
Right?
So, and he said we have to listen to both sides;
that's the only way how we find out what the truth is.
And tyranny by the majority.
Well this is a very, very important argument;
namely, one of the major evils of a mass democratic society is
a tyranny of the majority.
There will be a very strong tendency to suppress dissent and
to create conformity with the majority views.
And he said well, we have to try to resist it,
and we have to emphasize individuality.
Conformism is moral repression.
Right?
There's a lot of pressure on you to conform with the
major--the mainstream, as such, and he said this is
one of the big evils what we have to resist.
We have to defend individual liberties, and we have to fight
against intervention; legal or non-legal
intervention.
Right?
He did not live in a mass communication society,
but he would have been outraged how the media tries to brainwash
people and put into a conformist behavior on people.
Right?
He wanted to defend people's individual choices of lifestyles
and sexual preferences and whatever you name;
it has to be defended.
And this is very important.
This is a clear extension, very clearly argued--
Adam Smith did basically agree with this,
but he did not put it so strongly and so clearly--
"Therefore intervention by a government is only permissible
if injury has taken place."
The government cannot limit individual liberties,
only if that causes injury.
And he said, "Look, believe me,
I'm not indifferent.
I am for compassion.
All what I am asking you is tolerance.
Respect other people's choices.
Do feel compassion, but don't try to make decisions
for others; don't impose your will on
others."
That's I think the--and conformity, he really disliked
conformity.
It's a century ahead of his time.
This becomes a very big issue in the 1960s and '70s,
that conformism is an evil, and he already writes about
this in the mid-nineteenth century.
And well interference.
The only justification is self-protection.
Right?
This is very much in line of Hobbes' argument.
And therefore he said, "I'm not for indifference,
but I am for permissiveness, for tolerance as such."
Well we should help each other, but that's different than to
impose our will or our taste or our preferences on other people.
Right?
"Neither one person, nor any number of person,
is warranted in saying to other human creatures of ripe
years"-- that's different with
children--"that he shall not do with his life for his own
benefit what he chooses to do with it."
Right?
A very strong argument, and very troubling.
You know?
What do you think about drug use?
Right?
Well if John Stuart Mill errs, he errs on the libertarian
side.
He probably would be arguing for the decriminalization of
most of the drugs, on these grounds.
It's people's choice.
If they know that they hurt their life, this is their story.
Now very briefly on his views on women.
And I don't have to introduce you to the background.
You know that in the mid-nineteenth century women did
not have equal rights, even not in England,
not in the United States.
They not only did not have the right to vote,
but they actually did not have the right to own property,
as such.
Well as I mentioned, Harriet Taylor,
his lover and wife, was a radical feminist--as far
as we know, an extremely smart woman.
She was more radical than Smith, because she actually,
as I pointed out, opposed even the institution of
marriage.
So what are the major themes in this book?
The first point is "marriage is the only
remaining case of slavery."
Well it's not true of course.
Slavery has existed elsewhere, and unfortunately de facto
still exists around the world.
But he said, you know, "The subjugation
of
…