Advertisement
English transcript
Prof: Okay, so now we move into the
nineteenth century.
It's unclear how long this nineteenth century lasted,
whether it lasted from 1789 until 1914, or 1815 until 1914.
Right?
But it was a relatively long century.
And yeah, John Stuart Mill was already twentieth century.
But Karl Marx did get into the middle of it;
he was born in 1818 and died in '83.
And I tried to find a picture of Marx, what you may not have
seen, when he was still quite a good-looking guy.
All right, so a few words about his family background.
His father, Karl Heinrich--no, no, Marx himself was born in
1818 in Trier, Germany, and his father was
Heinrich Marx, who was actually a lawyer,
quite a successful lawyer, but he was very much a man of
enlightenment.
He liked Voltaire and brought Marx up in the spirit of
liberalism and enlightenment.
Voltaire and Rousseau and John Stuart Mill, well these were the
guiding lights of the time.
The paternal grandfather was Marx Levy, who was a rabbi of
Trier.
But he died early, before Karl was born,
and in fact his father converted to Lutheranism.
It did not matter much.
He was not really religious.
He was quite secular and Marx, Karl Marx, brought up in a
secular family.
So I found you a picture of Trier in the early nineteenth
century.
If you look hard, you'll probably see somewhere
young Karl walking around and shopping in the marketplace of
Trier.
All right, his education.
He attended, of course, high school in
Trier.
Then in '35 he was admitted to the University of Bonn,
where he studied Greek and Roman mythology and history--
already became involved in student politics.
But he really was bored in Bonn and was attracted to go to
Berlin, which at that time was becoming a fascinating place.
And he was attending the lectures of Bruno Bauer.
Bruno Bauer was a disciple of Georg Hegel.
Bauer belonged to a group of philosophers who called
themselves "the Young Hegelians."
They were the radicals of their time, and Marx already wanted to
be a radical; he just did not know what kind
of radical he will be or should be.
In fact, he received his degree from the University of Jena.
I think I cracked already this joke in the introductory
lecture, because assumedly it was easier
to get a degree from Jena than Berlin,
and Marx was more interested already in philosophy and
radicalism than legal studies.
But he got his degree.
So here is Georg Hegel, one of the most important
philosophers of the eighteenth and nineteenth century.
He was a German philosopher; and I will talk more when we
get into Marx's own work.
He basically saw human history as the unfolding of human
consciousness, and he also characterized the
human condition as in the state of alienation in which subject
and object were separated from each other.
These are big words.
You will get comfortable with it as I'm lecturing on Marx.
Because this is very important for Hegelian philosophy--
also for Marxism, the distinction that there is
the subject, yourself, who are observing,
and the object, the others or the material
world upon which you are reflecting.
There is also another big word you will learn in the next two
or three lectures, the word of totality;
totality means when subject and object are together in one
unity, that's what is meant to be totality.
Now Hegel's idea was that subject and object became
separated, and the separation of subject
from object-- when there is seen as worth
outside of the subject as a separate object--
that is the state of alienation; alien, to be a stranger,
a stranger in the world, because what is around you
looks like strange, as different from you.
Right?
That's what he meant by alienation.
But, you know, human consciousness is
increasing, and as consciousness is increasing you will overcome
this separation of subject and objects.
Well, I'm sure it is not clear for the time being,
but we'll be laboring on this in more detail with Marx,
and hopefully it will become a little more clear.
Bruno Bauer, he is this charismatic
lecturer, the Young Hegelian whose lectures Marx attended.
And there is no Marx and Marxism without Bruno Bauer;
though most of his work is vitriolic criticism of Bruno
Bauer.
Well, Marx was quite a vitriolic guy.
He liked to use overheated language.
Occasionally it's very beautiful, the language he's
using.
Occasionally this is pretty outraging.
Okay, what about Bauer and the Left Hegelians?
As I said, you know, he kind of comes--
he's a Hegel disciple, but he tries to move beyond
Hegel and offer a critical theory of Hegel and the Hegelian
system itself.
These guys, the Young Hegelians--Bauer and his brother
and others like Feuerbach, called themselves "the
critical critics."
This is a term which comes up in Marx's work sometimes,
ironically usually.
Why was it so?
Because Hegel is seen in modern philosophy as the Founding
Father of critical theory.
You may have heard the word; if you studied philosophy I'm
sure you have heard the word.
What is critical theory?
Well the essence of critical theory is that it believes that
the major task of philosophy, to subject human consciousness
to critical scrutiny-- that there is some discrepancy
between human consciousness and the human condition.
Right?
Our consciousness does not reflect properly the human
condition, and therefore we have to criticize consciousness and
get the right consciousness.
Well who is actually the first of critical theorists?
There is some controversy about this.
There are some people who actually name Immanuel Kant,
the German philosopher, as the first of critical
theorists.
Kant made a very interesting distinction between Ding an
sich and Ding für sich;
things in themselves and things for themselves.
And one important Kant idea was that all the ideas what we have
in our mind are things for themselves,
and they do not correspond to the world around us.
The world around us is so rich that the concepts what we
develop cannot completely fit.
Therefore, in the act of cognition--when we try to
understand something--we select from the world stuff which is
important for us.
This is why it's things for themselves.
Right?
We select, in the process of cognition, of learning,
from the world elements what is useful for us.
So, I mean, in some ways already Kant suggested that
there is something problematic with the human consciousness.
Right?
We have to subject this human consciousness to critical
scrutiny, and to be aware that the
unexhausted richness of the world and reality cannot be ever
captured by the human mind.
Now others do see really Georg Hegel as the real critical
theorist, because now the central point is alienation.
Right?
Here the central point is that this is a big problem,
and unlike Kant, who was an agnostic,
he did not think we ever can develop concepts which capture
the world.
Right?
Hegel believed that if you guys, you learn my philosophy,
you will be all right.
Right?
Then you will overcome alienation.
You will get the appropriate consciousness.
Read my work.
That was--you know, to simplify it a great deal.
So anyway, he was seen as a kind of critical theorist.
Now, the Young Hegelians were the critics of the critique.
Right?
They wanted to apply Hegel's critical method on Hegel's
theory.
They said, "Why on earth Georg, Uncle Georg,
believes that his theory is the right one?
Why don't we subject this system itself to the same
critical scrutiny what Hegel suggests everything should be
subjected to: critical scrutiny?"
That is really the fundamental line of argument that greatly
influenced Marx.
Marx is, in many respects, a critical critic.
Now this is another Young Hegelian, Ludwig Feuerbach,
who had another very important impact on Marx.
Feuerbach called his approach "naturalism."
This is a term what Marx, the young Marx,
also used for a while to describe himself.
I think most of you in this room would think that Marx was a
materialist, and eventually Marx used the
term materialism, and even more specifically,
historical materialism, to describe what he was doing.
But in his early work he was shying away from materialism and
he used the term naturalism.
And naturalism really meant that you do not underestimate
the importance of consciousness in spirit,
just in the interaction with consciousness and spirit,
and the nature itself,--you pay more attention to nature.
Now Feuerbach's most important book--
I don't think it is in English--Das Wesen des
Christentums, The Essence of
Christianity, he also suggested that rather
than God creating man, man created the idea of God,
and they created the idea of God--
this is actually not all that far from Bruno Bauer,
just a more radical position.
Right?
Because it wanted to project the desperation of alienation
into the idea of God.
So, I mean, while so to say Bauer was not ready to draw the,
if I may use this term, the ontological conclusions of
his criticism of Hegel.
Feuerbach went into ontology.
Right?
Ontology means the origins of things, and he believed that in
fact the spiritual world is a reflection of humans as such.
That's why he called this naturalism, as distinct from
idealism.
And we will talk about the distinction between idealism and
materialism, or idealism as naturalism,
which is very important for Marxism,
and has been an important distinction in philosophy in the
nineteenth and early twentieth century.
I don't think in the last, you know,
fifty or a hundred years that, you know,
in philosophy there is too much discussion of idealism and
materialism, though I don't think it is
quite a useless discussion, who are idealist and who are
materialist.
And well, we will talk very briefly about this.
Let me just foreshadow. Right?
You know, you are an idealist when you think that the material
world is coming from an idea.
Right?
If you believe that there was a transcendental being like God,
and this transcendental being, by its act of will,
created the world and created humans,
then you are an idealist.
If you believe that the ideas are explaining human behavior,
then you are an idealist.
Materialists are the ones who start from the material
conditions and try to explain the ideas from the material
conditions.
Right?
Feuerbach made this provocative statement that we invented God,
rather than God creating us.
Marx goes further and he will say, "Well you have ideas
in your head.
I can tell you why you have these ideas when I look at your
material conditions."
And he will later on say that, "When I understand your
position in the class structure, and I understand your economic
interests, then I will be able to tell you
why you think the way you think." Right?
This is the materialist's approach, when you explain ideas
from the material conditions, versus the other way around.
And this comes from Feuerbach.
It is Feuerbach's inspiration.
Right?
So you bring together the critical theory of Hegel and the
Young Hegelians, radical critical theory,
and naturalism of Feuerbach, eventually pushing it further
and to say, "Let's not fool around it.
It is materialism all right."
Okay?
Now what about--let's continue with the life.
'42, he moves to Cologne, the city of Cologne,
and becomes a journalist for Rheinische Zeitung;
eventually even becomes the editor of this journal.
And what he's writing is just liberal journalism.
He's not a radical yet.
He's a bourgeois liberal.
He is writing articles about, you know, the freedom of the
press and civil liberties.
He's writing stuff what John Stuart Mill would not object to
at all.
Right?
Then '43, he marries--I again cracked this joke before--
after a long engagement, Jenny von Westphalen,
who comes from, you know, a noble family,
a very high class family-- not a Jewish family,
a high class family.
Here is a picture of them too.
Well he was graying fast. Right?
Well he was running into some political troubles very soon.
Now we will very quickly see some extraordinary years in
Marx's intellectual development.
1843, '44, '45, just three years,
it's quite extraordinary what is happening in Marx's mind and
how far he goes.
Already in '43 he is beginning to write some very important
pieces of work.
I will talk about them in a minute, when we will get to
Marx's work.
One is called A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's
Philosophy of the State, or Hegel's Philosophy of
Law, or Rights; it's translated differently.
And then he's writing a very provocative essay,
"On the Jewish Question"
in which he's beginning to distinguish himself from the
Young Hegelians.
Both of these pieces, especially "On the Jewish
Question," are unacceptable to the German
police and political establishment.
So he had to leave Germany, and he escapes and he moves to
Paris.
And here it is, 38 Rue Vaneau.
That's where he lived, and that's where Marx wrote his
extraordinary unpublished manuscript,
what is called The Paris Manuscript of 1844,
but from which you have read something,
and some of them are the jewel pieces of social science
literature.
Some of them are impenetrable, but some of them is quite
penetrable and still blows people's minds.
Okay, 1844 in Paris, he abandons this book,
The Critique of Hegel but he wrote an Introduction,
and I will talk about this later.
This, in many ways, is quite an extraordinary piece
of work.
It's a wonderful piece of poetry, and he's sort of
beginning to lay out his philosophy.
And then in the summer of '44 he completes--no,
doesn't complete, he abandons The Paris
Manuscripts; and for good reasons.
And we will talk about this, why he never published it and
never finished it; though, I mean,
it is quite a brilliant piece.
And he meets a young man, Friedrich Engels,
just twenty-four years of age, and became lifelong friends,
and they're beginning to work together.
They are writing this book, The Holy Family.
I strongly recommend you do not read it.
I have read it a number of times and suffered a lot.
So I want to save you from suffering.
But there are some very important things in The Holy
Family; just the price you have to pay
to find the jewel is very high.
Okay, and then they write many other things together.
The Communist Manifesto they write together.
The German Ideology they write together;
and many other things.
Engels was a brilliant mind.
In fact, he was a much more clearer analytic mind than Karl
Marx, and he had a much better sense of empirical reality than
Marx.
Marx was a bit of an abstract guy.
But Marx was really the genius.
Right?
Friedrich Engels was just a kind of Yale professor;
you know, that Karl Marx was a sort of a genius really.
'45, well even in Paris it is unbearable what they are doing,
so they're kicked out from Paris, and then they go to
Brussels.
And here is Engels when they met.
Well there is--to continue the work--a big change in Marx in
1945--as some people say, the epistemological break.
Until '45, until The Paris Manuscript,
Marx is still in some ways a Hegelian.
Now he's changing and he's becoming a materialist,
and he coins the term historical materialism to
describe his position.
One important piece is The Theses on Feuerbach.
I make you to read that.
I think it is a fantastic piece of work.
He again did not publish it, and I will explain to you why,
though it is brilliant, why he shied away and did not
publish it; it is in tension with the main
message what he tries to get through.
And then '45, '46, together with Engels,
they write again another unfinished manuscript,
which was published only in 1904--and even in 1904 only
partially-- The German Ideology.
Again, there are some extraordinary pieces in these
incomplete manuscripts.
Then comes the year of revolutions.
February 22- 24 in '48, a violent revolution in France.
They sit down with Engels and within a week they write The
Manifesto of the Communist Party.
They just tell what the revolution should be doing.
Well this is in a pamphlet--a pamphlet with a lot of
disturbing statements, but a pamphlet with some very
insightful, very important social analysis
as well.
A piece of work which cannot be ignored.
It can be hated.
It was loved by many but usually now it is hated.
But even if you hate it or love it, you better read it,
and you pay attention to some of the very important
statements.
And what is extraordinary--this is a pretty long manuscript.
They were writing like crazy.
I mean, I think I'm a fast writer, but I could not do it in
a week.
And a reasonably polished piece, especially in comparison
with his other work.
Now he's expelled from Brussels, but he moves to
revolutionary Paris, on March 5^(th) already.
But the revolution continues.
March 13^(th), Vienna is on fire.
Right?
But you have to wait only two days and Buda and Pest in
Hungary is on fire.
The revolution is spreading all over in Europe.
March 18^(th), it's already in Berlin.
Paris, Vienna, Buda and Pest,
Berlin, whole Europe is on fire.
This is exactly what Marx was saying will be happening.
Right there, it is happening indeed.
So Marx and Engels return to Germany.
Now they will carry out the torch of the revolution.
Well it doesn't last for--that's a picture,
a bad picture of some of the revolution in Paris.
It was quite a bloody event.
And here is The Communist Manifesto,
the First Edition--end of February 1848,
when it was printed fast and distributed widely.
Well, you know, revolution doesn't last too
long.
In October '48, Austria carries out a
counter-revolution.
They oppress the revolution in Hungary.
November the 8^(th) there is a counter-revolutionary coup in
Prussia.
The revolution is depressed.
And then December 1848--well this is not a violent
counter-revolution, but the French go and vote on
elections, and they elect a guy whose name
is Louis Napoleon Bonaparte as president of France.
It was a very stupid way to vote.
Louis Napoleon Bonaparte was the nephew of Napoleon.
His father was Napoleon's brother, younger brother,
and he was the king--he was made king of the Netherlands
until, of course, Napoleon fell and he
was ousted, and Louis Napoleon Bonaparte
grew up in Switzerland, in exile.
Was not a particularly smart person and caused a lot of
trouble in France.
Well here he is when he was president.
Later on he became an emperor of France;
Napoleon III, he renamed himself,
and kept causing trouble.
Yeah.
Well Marx returned to Paris briefly and was hoping,
you know, the French eventually will come to their senses and
overthrow this jerk.
Well the French did not come to their senses.
Right?
It looks like the French occasionally do silly political
things, like the Jacobins did.
Electing Louis Napoleon Bonaparte was not a smart thing.
But, you know, therefore they have to move to
London, and that's where he spends the rest of his life.
This is where he has another go at the big book he wants to
write.
It is called Grundrisse, and I will ask you--
it will be a little sweating to read it,
but I promise I ask you to read the most readable part of the
Grundrisse.
So if you will have troubles reading what I ask you to read,
remember the rest would be much, much worse.
Right?
So you have to enjoy reading it.
But I think it's--what I ask you to read is extremely
important to understand who the real Marx is.
Right?
There are many faces of Karl Marx, and one of--one outcome
most clearly in the Grundrisse.
Then he writes finally the book what he always wanted to
do, Das Kapital, in 1867.
Then there is another revolution in France,
the Commune, and this is a real proletarian
revolution-- very much following what Marx
and Engels wrote in The Communist Manifesto.
There are few instances in history when two people can
claim, "We wrote it down, and here the masses put it into
action."
They did it in France.
And then already in '64 Marx created a political
organization, what he called
International--International, The Workers' Organization;
eventually we refer to this as the First International--with a
Russian anarchist, whose name is Bakunin.
'71, there is this proletarian revolution inspired by The
Communist Manifesto.
They proclaim a Commune in Paris.
It's not all that different from Soviet Russ
…
nineteenth century.
It's unclear how long this nineteenth century lasted,
whether it lasted from 1789 until 1914, or 1815 until 1914.
Right?
But it was a relatively long century.
And yeah, John Stuart Mill was already twentieth century.
But Karl Marx did get into the middle of it;
he was born in 1818 and died in '83.
And I tried to find a picture of Marx, what you may not have
seen, when he was still quite a good-looking guy.
All right, so a few words about his family background.
His father, Karl Heinrich--no, no, Marx himself was born in
1818 in Trier, Germany, and his father was
Heinrich Marx, who was actually a lawyer,
quite a successful lawyer, but he was very much a man of
enlightenment.
He liked Voltaire and brought Marx up in the spirit of
liberalism and enlightenment.
Voltaire and Rousseau and John Stuart Mill, well these were the
guiding lights of the time.
The paternal grandfather was Marx Levy, who was a rabbi of
Trier.
But he died early, before Karl was born,
and in fact his father converted to Lutheranism.
It did not matter much.
He was not really religious.
He was quite secular and Marx, Karl Marx, brought up in a
secular family.
So I found you a picture of Trier in the early nineteenth
century.
If you look hard, you'll probably see somewhere
young Karl walking around and shopping in the marketplace of
Trier.
All right, his education.
He attended, of course, high school in
Trier.
Then in '35 he was admitted to the University of Bonn,
where he studied Greek and Roman mythology and history--
already became involved in student politics.
But he really was bored in Bonn and was attracted to go to
Berlin, which at that time was becoming a fascinating place.
And he was attending the lectures of Bruno Bauer.
Bruno Bauer was a disciple of Georg Hegel.
Bauer belonged to a group of philosophers who called
themselves "the Young Hegelians."
They were the radicals of their time, and Marx already wanted to
be a radical; he just did not know what kind
of radical he will be or should be.
In fact, he received his degree from the University of Jena.
I think I cracked already this joke in the introductory
lecture, because assumedly it was easier
to get a degree from Jena than Berlin,
and Marx was more interested already in philosophy and
radicalism than legal studies.
But he got his degree.
So here is Georg Hegel, one of the most important
philosophers of the eighteenth and nineteenth century.
He was a German philosopher; and I will talk more when we
get into Marx's own work.
He basically saw human history as the unfolding of human
consciousness, and he also characterized the
human condition as in the state of alienation in which subject
and object were separated from each other.
These are big words.
You will get comfortable with it as I'm lecturing on Marx.
Because this is very important for Hegelian philosophy--
also for Marxism, the distinction that there is
the subject, yourself, who are observing,
and the object, the others or the material
world upon which you are reflecting.
There is also another big word you will learn in the next two
or three lectures, the word of totality;
totality means when subject and object are together in one
unity, that's what is meant to be totality.
Now Hegel's idea was that subject and object became
separated, and the separation of subject
from object-- when there is seen as worth
outside of the subject as a separate object--
that is the state of alienation; alien, to be a stranger,
a stranger in the world, because what is around you
looks like strange, as different from you.
Right?
That's what he meant by alienation.
But, you know, human consciousness is
increasing, and as consciousness is increasing you will overcome
this separation of subject and objects.
Well, I'm sure it is not clear for the time being,
but we'll be laboring on this in more detail with Marx,
and hopefully it will become a little more clear.
Bruno Bauer, he is this charismatic
lecturer, the Young Hegelian whose lectures Marx attended.
And there is no Marx and Marxism without Bruno Bauer;
though most of his work is vitriolic criticism of Bruno
Bauer.
Well, Marx was quite a vitriolic guy.
He liked to use overheated language.
Occasionally it's very beautiful, the language he's
using.
Occasionally this is pretty outraging.
Okay, what about Bauer and the Left Hegelians?
As I said, you know, he kind of comes--
he's a Hegel disciple, but he tries to move beyond
Hegel and offer a critical theory of Hegel and the Hegelian
system itself.
These guys, the Young Hegelians--Bauer and his brother
and others like Feuerbach, called themselves "the
critical critics."
This is a term which comes up in Marx's work sometimes,
ironically usually.
Why was it so?
Because Hegel is seen in modern philosophy as the Founding
Father of critical theory.
You may have heard the word; if you studied philosophy I'm
sure you have heard the word.
What is critical theory?
Well the essence of critical theory is that it believes that
the major task of philosophy, to subject human consciousness
to critical scrutiny-- that there is some discrepancy
between human consciousness and the human condition.
Right?
Our consciousness does not reflect properly the human
condition, and therefore we have to criticize consciousness and
get the right consciousness.
Well who is actually the first of critical theorists?
There is some controversy about this.
There are some people who actually name Immanuel Kant,
the German philosopher, as the first of critical
theorists.
Kant made a very interesting distinction between Ding an
sich and Ding für sich;
things in themselves and things for themselves.
And one important Kant idea was that all the ideas what we have
in our mind are things for themselves,
and they do not correspond to the world around us.
The world around us is so rich that the concepts what we
develop cannot completely fit.
Therefore, in the act of cognition--when we try to
understand something--we select from the world stuff which is
important for us.
This is why it's things for themselves.
Right?
We select, in the process of cognition, of learning,
from the world elements what is useful for us.
So, I mean, in some ways already Kant suggested that
there is something problematic with the human consciousness.
Right?
We have to subject this human consciousness to critical
scrutiny, and to be aware that the
unexhausted richness of the world and reality cannot be ever
captured by the human mind.
Now others do see really Georg Hegel as the real critical
theorist, because now the central point is alienation.
Right?
Here the central point is that this is a big problem,
and unlike Kant, who was an agnostic,
he did not think we ever can develop concepts which capture
the world.
Right?
Hegel believed that if you guys, you learn my philosophy,
you will be all right.
Right?
Then you will overcome alienation.
You will get the appropriate consciousness.
Read my work.
That was--you know, to simplify it a great deal.
So anyway, he was seen as a kind of critical theorist.
Now, the Young Hegelians were the critics of the critique.
Right?
They wanted to apply Hegel's critical method on Hegel's
theory.
They said, "Why on earth Georg, Uncle Georg,
believes that his theory is the right one?
Why don't we subject this system itself to the same
critical scrutiny what Hegel suggests everything should be
subjected to: critical scrutiny?"
That is really the fundamental line of argument that greatly
influenced Marx.
Marx is, in many respects, a critical critic.
Now this is another Young Hegelian, Ludwig Feuerbach,
who had another very important impact on Marx.
Feuerbach called his approach "naturalism."
This is a term what Marx, the young Marx,
also used for a while to describe himself.
I think most of you in this room would think that Marx was a
materialist, and eventually Marx used the
term materialism, and even more specifically,
historical materialism, to describe what he was doing.
But in his early work he was shying away from materialism and
he used the term naturalism.
And naturalism really meant that you do not underestimate
the importance of consciousness in spirit,
just in the interaction with consciousness and spirit,
and the nature itself,--you pay more attention to nature.
Now Feuerbach's most important book--
I don't think it is in English--Das Wesen des
Christentums, The Essence of
Christianity, he also suggested that rather
than God creating man, man created the idea of God,
and they created the idea of God--
this is actually not all that far from Bruno Bauer,
just a more radical position.
Right?
Because it wanted to project the desperation of alienation
into the idea of God.
So, I mean, while so to say Bauer was not ready to draw the,
if I may use this term, the ontological conclusions of
his criticism of Hegel.
Feuerbach went into ontology.
Right?
Ontology means the origins of things, and he believed that in
fact the spiritual world is a reflection of humans as such.
That's why he called this naturalism, as distinct from
idealism.
And we will talk about the distinction between idealism and
materialism, or idealism as naturalism,
which is very important for Marxism,
and has been an important distinction in philosophy in the
nineteenth and early twentieth century.
I don't think in the last, you know,
fifty or a hundred years that, you know,
in philosophy there is too much discussion of idealism and
materialism, though I don't think it is
quite a useless discussion, who are idealist and who are
materialist.
And well, we will talk very briefly about this.
Let me just foreshadow. Right?
You know, you are an idealist when you think that the material
world is coming from an idea.
Right?
If you believe that there was a transcendental being like God,
and this transcendental being, by its act of will,
created the world and created humans,
then you are an idealist.
If you believe that the ideas are explaining human behavior,
then you are an idealist.
Materialists are the ones who start from the material
conditions and try to explain the ideas from the material
conditions.
Right?
Feuerbach made this provocative statement that we invented God,
rather than God creating us.
Marx goes further and he will say, "Well you have ideas
in your head.
I can tell you why you have these ideas when I look at your
material conditions."
And he will later on say that, "When I understand your
position in the class structure, and I understand your economic
interests, then I will be able to tell you
why you think the way you think." Right?
This is the materialist's approach, when you explain ideas
from the material conditions, versus the other way around.
And this comes from Feuerbach.
It is Feuerbach's inspiration.
Right?
So you bring together the critical theory of Hegel and the
Young Hegelians, radical critical theory,
and naturalism of Feuerbach, eventually pushing it further
and to say, "Let's not fool around it.
It is materialism all right."
Okay?
Now what about--let's continue with the life.
'42, he moves to Cologne, the city of Cologne,
and becomes a journalist for Rheinische Zeitung;
eventually even becomes the editor of this journal.
And what he's writing is just liberal journalism.
He's not a radical yet.
He's a bourgeois liberal.
He is writing articles about, you know, the freedom of the
press and civil liberties.
He's writing stuff what John Stuart Mill would not object to
at all.
Right?
Then '43, he marries--I again cracked this joke before--
after a long engagement, Jenny von Westphalen,
who comes from, you know, a noble family,
a very high class family-- not a Jewish family,
a high class family.
Here is a picture of them too.
Well he was graying fast. Right?
Well he was running into some political troubles very soon.
Now we will very quickly see some extraordinary years in
Marx's intellectual development.
1843, '44, '45, just three years,
it's quite extraordinary what is happening in Marx's mind and
how far he goes.
Already in '43 he is beginning to write some very important
pieces of work.
I will talk about them in a minute, when we will get to
Marx's work.
One is called A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's
Philosophy of the State, or Hegel's Philosophy of
Law, or Rights; it's translated differently.
And then he's writing a very provocative essay,
"On the Jewish Question"
in which he's beginning to distinguish himself from the
Young Hegelians.
Both of these pieces, especially "On the Jewish
Question," are unacceptable to the German
police and political establishment.
So he had to leave Germany, and he escapes and he moves to
Paris.
And here it is, 38 Rue Vaneau.
That's where he lived, and that's where Marx wrote his
extraordinary unpublished manuscript,
what is called The Paris Manuscript of 1844,
but from which you have read something,
and some of them are the jewel pieces of social science
literature.
Some of them are impenetrable, but some of them is quite
penetrable and still blows people's minds.
Okay, 1844 in Paris, he abandons this book,
The Critique of Hegel but he wrote an Introduction,
and I will talk about this later.
This, in many ways, is quite an extraordinary piece
of work.
It's a wonderful piece of poetry, and he's sort of
beginning to lay out his philosophy.
And then in the summer of '44 he completes--no,
doesn't complete, he abandons The Paris
Manuscripts; and for good reasons.
And we will talk about this, why he never published it and
never finished it; though, I mean,
it is quite a brilliant piece.
And he meets a young man, Friedrich Engels,
just twenty-four years of age, and became lifelong friends,
and they're beginning to work together.
They are writing this book, The Holy Family.
I strongly recommend you do not read it.
I have read it a number of times and suffered a lot.
So I want to save you from suffering.
But there are some very important things in The Holy
Family; just the price you have to pay
to find the jewel is very high.
Okay, and then they write many other things together.
The Communist Manifesto they write together.
The German Ideology they write together;
and many other things.
Engels was a brilliant mind.
In fact, he was a much more clearer analytic mind than Karl
Marx, and he had a much better sense of empirical reality than
Marx.
Marx was a bit of an abstract guy.
But Marx was really the genius.
Right?
Friedrich Engels was just a kind of Yale professor;
you know, that Karl Marx was a sort of a genius really.
'45, well even in Paris it is unbearable what they are doing,
so they're kicked out from Paris, and then they go to
Brussels.
And here is Engels when they met.
Well there is--to continue the work--a big change in Marx in
1945--as some people say, the epistemological break.
Until '45, until The Paris Manuscript,
Marx is still in some ways a Hegelian.
Now he's changing and he's becoming a materialist,
and he coins the term historical materialism to
describe his position.
One important piece is The Theses on Feuerbach.
I make you to read that.
I think it is a fantastic piece of work.
He again did not publish it, and I will explain to you why,
though it is brilliant, why he shied away and did not
publish it; it is in tension with the main
message what he tries to get through.
And then '45, '46, together with Engels,
they write again another unfinished manuscript,
which was published only in 1904--and even in 1904 only
partially-- The German Ideology.
Again, there are some extraordinary pieces in these
incomplete manuscripts.
Then comes the year of revolutions.
February 22- 24 in '48, a violent revolution in France.
They sit down with Engels and within a week they write The
Manifesto of the Communist Party.
They just tell what the revolution should be doing.
Well this is in a pamphlet--a pamphlet with a lot of
disturbing statements, but a pamphlet with some very
insightful, very important social analysis
as well.
A piece of work which cannot be ignored.
It can be hated.
It was loved by many but usually now it is hated.
But even if you hate it or love it, you better read it,
and you pay attention to some of the very important
statements.
And what is extraordinary--this is a pretty long manuscript.
They were writing like crazy.
I mean, I think I'm a fast writer, but I could not do it in
a week.
And a reasonably polished piece, especially in comparison
with his other work.
Now he's expelled from Brussels, but he moves to
revolutionary Paris, on March 5^(th) already.
But the revolution continues.
March 13^(th), Vienna is on fire.
Right?
But you have to wait only two days and Buda and Pest in
Hungary is on fire.
The revolution is spreading all over in Europe.
March 18^(th), it's already in Berlin.
Paris, Vienna, Buda and Pest,
Berlin, whole Europe is on fire.
This is exactly what Marx was saying will be happening.
Right there, it is happening indeed.
So Marx and Engels return to Germany.
Now they will carry out the torch of the revolution.
Well it doesn't last for--that's a picture,
a bad picture of some of the revolution in Paris.
It was quite a bloody event.
And here is The Communist Manifesto,
the First Edition--end of February 1848,
when it was printed fast and distributed widely.
Well, you know, revolution doesn't last too
long.
In October '48, Austria carries out a
counter-revolution.
They oppress the revolution in Hungary.
November the 8^(th) there is a counter-revolutionary coup in
Prussia.
The revolution is depressed.
And then December 1848--well this is not a violent
counter-revolution, but the French go and vote on
elections, and they elect a guy whose name
is Louis Napoleon Bonaparte as president of France.
It was a very stupid way to vote.
Louis Napoleon Bonaparte was the nephew of Napoleon.
His father was Napoleon's brother, younger brother,
and he was the king--he was made king of the Netherlands
until, of course, Napoleon fell and he
was ousted, and Louis Napoleon Bonaparte
grew up in Switzerland, in exile.
Was not a particularly smart person and caused a lot of
trouble in France.
Well here he is when he was president.
Later on he became an emperor of France;
Napoleon III, he renamed himself,
and kept causing trouble.
Yeah.
Well Marx returned to Paris briefly and was hoping,
you know, the French eventually will come to their senses and
overthrow this jerk.
Well the French did not come to their senses.
Right?
It looks like the French occasionally do silly political
things, like the Jacobins did.
Electing Louis Napoleon Bonaparte was not a smart thing.
But, you know, therefore they have to move to
London, and that's where he spends the rest of his life.
This is where he has another go at the big book he wants to
write.
It is called Grundrisse, and I will ask you--
it will be a little sweating to read it,
but I promise I ask you to read the most readable part of the
Grundrisse.
So if you will have troubles reading what I ask you to read,
remember the rest would be much, much worse.
Right?
So you have to enjoy reading it.
But I think it's--what I ask you to read is extremely
important to understand who the real Marx is.
Right?
There are many faces of Karl Marx, and one of--one outcome
most clearly in the Grundrisse.
Then he writes finally the book what he always wanted to
do, Das Kapital, in 1867.
Then there is another revolution in France,
the Commune, and this is a real proletarian
revolution-- very much following what Marx
and Engels wrote in The Communist Manifesto.
There are few instances in history when two people can
claim, "We wrote it down, and here the masses put it into
action."
They did it in France.
And then already in '64 Marx created a political
organization, what he called
International--International, The Workers' Organization;
eventually we refer to this as the First International--with a
Russian anarchist, whose name is Bakunin.
'71, there is this proletarian revolution inspired by The
Communist Manifesto.
They proclaim a Commune in Paris.
It's not all that different from Soviet Russ
…