YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 966 lines · added Nov 26, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: Well I would like to get started.
Good morning.
In the discussion section I realized I sort of screwed my
last lecture.
It didn't come quite clearly through;
either Hegel or Marx's theory of alienation.
So I would like to come back to the theory of alienation and how
Marx gets to The Paris Manuscripts,
before we get into historical materialism.
And let me just make two introductory comments about
this.
One important point I tried to make is you have to be--
I think one purpose of my lectures in Marx is to alert you
that there were two Marx's, not just one,
and you are likely to know only about one Marx.
Right?
This is Marx, who had the theory of class
struggle and the theory of exploitation--right?--and who
was a theorist of Communism.
But you may know very little about Marx, the idealist,
the Hegelian, the humanist,
whose central idea was the notion of alienation.
Right?
Whose major concern was about the human conditions under
modernity and wanted to overcome it.
And, you know, these two very different Marx's
appeal to very different audiences.
In fact, the first Marx--the humanist,
the Hegelian, the idealist--was almost
forgotten for a very long time, and was rediscovered by the
1960s onwards, generally.
So it's very important to see that most likely that what you
heard about Marx-- and I suppose most of you have
never read any text from Marx-- is a biased view.
You only know one Marx and not both.
And my point is to try to introduce you to the complexity,
that you meet both Karl Marx.
Right?
The second point is that--what I found frustrating in the
discussion section yesterday, which was one of the worst I
did in the last couple of years--
not ever in my life I did even worse discussion sections,
but this was real bad--that, you know,
the importance and the significance of Marx's theory of
alienation did not come through.
And I obviously did a very bad job,
because there are very few texts, written in the
seventeenth, eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries, which are so powerful and so
influential, and so broadly influential,
on theories of the twentieth century,
than exactly this text on alienation.
You can think about literature--right?--and you can
see the extraordinary impact of the idea of alienation in
literature.
Some of you may have read Albert Camus,
the French novelist--The Stranger.
This is right out of the theory of alienation.
You may be familiar with Franz Kafka, right?
There you go.
That's the sense of alienation.
You may have watched ever the play, wonderful play,
of Henrik Ibsen, Peer Gynt.
That's about alienation. Right?
So in the twentieth century literature, we are full with the
senses of alienation.
And so is twentieth century social theory.
There is no twentieth century social theory without the theory
of alienation.
By the way, it's interesting, because The Paris
Manuscript, for the first time,
was published only in 1931.
Nevertheless, the idea was already beginning
to creep in earlier.
Smart people read the theory of alienation in Marx earlier;
Georg Lukács, for instance.
And then the Frankfurt School.
There is no Adorno, there is no Horkheimer,
there is no Marcuse, without the theory of
alienation.
And I can go even further.
There is no cultural theory without the theory of
alienation.
There is no Bauman, there is no Kolakowski,
without the theory of alienation.
This is a very important idea.
So I have to come back to this and to try to show you how he
arrives at this point, and why he abandons it--why the
second Marx is emerging.
And then we get, starting with the second Marx,
the first step towards the second Marx is the "Theses
on Feuerbach," what I want to talk about today.
And I'll try to economize with my time, right?
Right?
I have to learn from Adam Smith--right?--to be more
utilitarian and to make sure that means and ends do match
with each other.
Okay, let's come back to Hegel and Hegel's theory of
alienation.
Because I don't think--from the discussion section my sense was
I did not make it clear enough, what Hegel's theory is.
And well let me try to labor on this.
As I said, you know, he was an idealist,
and I hope I explained it to the extent it is necessary.
I will come back to this when I will be talking about the
"Theses on Feuerbach" and The German Ideology.
But he really thought that somehow consciousness precedes
material existence, and that's what made him into
an idealist.
How religious he was I actually don't know.
This is not a religious, not a theological proposition.
Right?
The idea is that before the physical world existed,
there has been an absolute spirit.
Right?
At the origin of the world, there is an absolute spirit
existing, and that exists in the material world as such.
And then his central idea is that you can describe the
history of the universe as a problem of alienation,
as a problem of gradual separation,
as I said, from subject and object.
This is a very important idea, and we will have to deal with
this in Marx.
And even if you are dealing with twentieth century theories,
critical theory, this is a central notion of,
you know, subject and object.
Let me try to labor on this a minute.
And I have to do it on the blackboard.
So Hegel's fundamental idea is that when you have the absolute
spirit--right?--and this is not a personal God but just the
idea.
Here this is a situation of totality.
The absolute spirit is at the same time subject and object,
united in itself.
Right?
And that's what Hegel calls totality.
And there's the term totality being used later on in critical
theory.
And we are saying we are searching for totality,
we are searching for the unity of subject and object.
Well in Hegel's, the second stage is that
subject and object are divided from each other.
There is the material world without consciousness,
and consciousness becomes absolute consciousness because
it's kind of projected the material world out of itself.
Right?
And this is the--this is the situation of alienation.
Object becomes separate.
Then, as human beings emerge, subject and object beginning to
merge.
Right?
Consciousness emerges. Right?
Consciousness--right?
These are subject--this is you--and object are the
conditions of your life.
Right?
Another person you are interacting with is an object of
your interaction.
Or the conditions of your life.
Right?
The objective conditions.
This room.
At Yale University the construction which is going out
there--right?--is our objective conditions.
Right?
And you are the subject who are reflecting on it.
But because you are gaining some consciousness,
you are beginning to conquer the objective conditions of your
life.
And what he's suggesting, that alienation will overcome
when your subject will be able to control the objective
conditions of your life.
Right?
Where your consciousness is adequate to your existence.
Right?
When you are the master of your life, you are a master of your
conditions.
It is not the conditions which rule you, but you are the master
of the conditions.
Right?
That is the key idea in Hegel.
And Marx is very much following this idea.
I mean, he of course eliminates the whole idea of absolute
spirit.
Right?
He doesn't want to deal with the idea of absolute spirit.
For him this is too speculative.
He's also bothered by the idea that you can overcome the
problem of alienation simply by thought.
Right?
Marx's project is to bring this whole idea of alienation down to
earth, to everyday experience,
to your experience and your experience of,
I would use the term, modernity, until 1944.
Marx does not have a concept of capitalism or capitalist mode of
production.
Right?
He even just vaguely thinks about private ownership.
He's really trying to conceptualize modernity,
modern industrial urban life, as distinct from earlier
communal life-- the life what we had in more
intimate communities, peasants of the villages or
whatever.
Right?
He tries to conceptualize this.
He sees this as a progress, modernity as a progress.
But we have to pay a heavy price for it,
and the price what we pay for this modernity is the separation
of subject and object.
Right?
The peasant in a village was not separated from the objective
conditions of his existence.
It was united with the objective conditions.
It was bound to the earth.
Right?
Even the slaves were not separated from the objective
conditions of their existence.
They were treated as objects.
Right?
There was no subject separated from the object.
So the unique--this is Marx, this is not Hegel anymore--
the unique feature of alienation, that you have this
separation from subject and object,
in modern conditions. Right?
And I think this is why Marx's theory of alienation survived
Marx's theory of exploitation.
That the young Marx survived the old Marx;
the first Marx survived the second Marx.
Because we can all relate more if you have a good lecturer,
and who brings more effectively to you what he's getting at.
You can relate more, you can say much more,
"Oh yeah, I feel alienated in this
class." Right?
"That makes no sense to me." Right?
"This doesn't make any sense to my life,
and I have to sit there because I'm a sociology major and I have
to take this bloody class."
Right?
Then you are alienated. Right?
And this is when you will--that's what you will say.
Right?
"I am alienated because I have to do this nonsense because
they force me to do so."
Then you are alienated.
This is exactly what Marx is getting at.
Right?
Well in a way it is your choice.
Right?
You declared a sociology major.
Right?
But then you are forced to do stuff what you don't really want
to do.
So it doesn't mean that you are not free.
You are free, but within your freedom you are
alienated because you don't control your conditions,
and it looks like that within your freedom,
within your free choice, you are forced to do stuff.
Right?
This is what Marx is trying to get at.
You think you are free, you think you are equal with
others, and you are really not free.
Because the objective conditions, what you created for
yourself--right?
You got into trouble. Right?
Who forced you to be a sociology major?
Nobody.
And then you are in the trouble that you have to do-- take
certain hurdles.
But you feel alienated and you don't feel that your whole
personality is being developed.
Right?
To put it with John Stuart Mill, you don't feel
self-development.
Then you are alienated, unduly so.
Right?
Is that a bit coming closer to it?
Makes more sense?
All right.
Now let me therefore also show you how Marx gets to it.
I think this is very important.
And I skipped all of this stuff because I was trying to get very
quickly--I was trying to get too quickly--to the notion,
Marx's theory of alienation.
And now I would like to correct this.
And I already foreshadowed in my last lecture that these are
formidable years for Marx, 1843 and 1844.
In two years his intellectual development is quite
extraordinary.
Let me follow you through of these intellectual developments.
In the summer of 1843, he writes this book,
Contributions to a Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right;
or Hegel's Philosophy of Law.
Well Hegel has gone through a long development intellectually.
He started out as a radical, an admirer of the French
Revolution, and as he was getting older he
was becoming more and more conservative and was becoming
concerned about the consequences of the French Revolution.
And as he became, you know, more conservative,
he was--he said, "Well what is happening
with the French after the French Revolution is not really what I
wanted.
Because now the French Revolution is actually splitting
the society in two classes, capital and labor."
It's not exactly the terminology what he means,
but that's what Hegel is getting at in The
Philosophy of Right.
"And who can tell who is right and who is wrong?
They are in conflict with each other.
The employers or the owners want something,
and the workers want something else.
They both represent particularistic interests.
But where is the universalistic interests?"
So asked Hegel.
There must be some universal justice.
To put it in the terminology we used in this course before,
there must be something like common good, which brings
capital and labor together.
Where will this common good come from?
And in The Philosophy of Right he offers an
interesting theory.
He said it will come from the government, it comes from the
state.
The state should represent the universal instance.
And then he said, "Well, you know, the society,
modern bourgeois society which emerged as a result of the
French Revolution, is divided into these
particularistic classes.
But we need a universal agent, a universal class,
which represents the common good, and this must be the
government, this must be the class of civil
servants."
And in the book, Philosophy of Right--
which is his kind of last major book,
writes it not long before he dies--he argues these are the
civil servants who constitute the universal class.
Now this is not a silly idea.
We do think about it this way.
And yes, I mean, he builds in many respects,
in a more sophisticated way, on Locke and Rousseau and the
idea of general will, particularly in Rousseau. Right?
And this is the state which should represent the general
will.
Right?
And we also occasionally think about it this way.
Right?
There are all these conflicts around this country,
and we expect the government to express the universal interest,
to innervate the general will.
We expect occasionally the federal government to do that,
and the federal government occasionally does it.
You have read about the Civil Rights Movement.
I mean, who was the agency which made sure that the states
actually obey the laws and integrates the schools?
It was the federal government.
Right?
It was Bobby Kennedy who went down and made sure that the
southern states do follow the rules.
Right?
We expected the government to express the universal interest.
Right?
So it's not silly.
But Marx, in a way, said, "Well,
that's not that simple.
Hegel is naïve about the government."
And he said, "Well the government is
not that non-partial as we would like it to be."
Right?
If you are rich, you have more influence on what
the government does, rather when you are poor.
Right?
There are lobbyists in Washington DC,
and you probably have very little leverage on these
lobbyists.
Big business has a lot of leverage on these lobbyists.
Right?
And they, of course, have a great deal of pressure
on what the legislature will do.
Just follow what is happening with the healthcare legislation.
Well you can call your congressman and you can send
emails, you know, and can send letters,
and ask them to do something.
But believe me, when the pharmaceutical
industry spends a lot of money and tells a senator,
you know, "Unless you vote this way or that way,
we probably may not be able to support your next electoral
campaign"-- right?--then it will make more
impact than your individual email.
Right?
Not that you should not send individual emails.
Send it. Right?
Be involved.
But be aware that the government is sent to be more
responsible for big business.
"So", he said, "How can it be
universal class?"
That's really the point what he's making in The Philosophy
of Right.
Right?
The state is not universal.
It pretends to be universal.
It has to pretend to be universal in order to be
legitimate, but really it is not universal.
And the civil servants are, of course, not a universal
class.
Occasionally they are quite corrupt.
Right?
Not in the United States, of course, but in some
countries I can think of civil servants are corrupt.
Right?
You know, and then they are offered, you know,
a free seat, you know, on a private jet,
they accept it.
And then they accepted it, they do something for the owner
of that private jet.
Right?
So there are some civil servants who are not all that
innocent--right?--and they can be influenced.
So it is not all that universal class.
They are--not all civil servants are angels.
Right?
Some of them are, some of them are not.
In fact, he concludes the unfinished book,
"that really the problem is that we don't have universal
suffrage"; writes he in 1843.
And he said, "Let's have universal
suffrage, and then if we in free
elections universally elect the representatives,
the problem will be gone."
As we know, he was not quite right.
Right?
We have all equal vote but we do not have all equal voice.
Right?
I think that's--but Marx here is still a bourgeois liberal;
as of the summer of 1843 believes the problem will be
solved.
Now let me rush through and show you the kind of
intellectual development--and I briefly pointed out to this.
These are the three important steps which follows this
abandoned manuscript.
He now enters the road of radicalization,
moves away from Hegel, and tries to carve out his own
intellectual and political project.
And he writes the paper "On the Jewish
Question" in which he says,
"Well Hegel is right.
We need something universal.
We should not allow society just to be the struggle of
particularistic interests."
Right?
This is in a way against Adam Smith's utilitarianism.
It's not enough that individuals fight each others'
interests out, and that will end up to a
universal good.
We need some universal good to be achieved, and it will not
simply achieved by particularistic interests
followed.
That is Marx's point.
But then he writes an introduction to the
Critique-- Contributions to the Critique
of Hegel's Philosophy of Right.
And in this introduction he said, "Well,
we need something; universal emancipation.
But who will bring universal emancipation to humankind?"
Right?
He's looking for an agent who can carry this out.
And in the introduction, he said, "This will be the
proletariat."
Well you may say now he's entering the wrong road--
right?--and he's entering a very--he's basically painting
himself in the corner, where he will be for the rest
of his life, trying to show that indeed the
proletariat will emancipate us all,
and will create a good society as such.
But people, when they are reading the introduction--and I
will give you a few citations from it because it's a beautiful
piece of work.
In many ways it is wonderful poetry.
He has some extraordinary framing of the problem.
But then, you know, his critics said,
"What a nonsense."
You know?
"Why on earth the proletariat?
As we all know, the workers are dumb.
I mean, you are saying that we, the critical philosophers,
we cannot emancipate humankind?
But you think that these ordinary workers,
with alienated consciousness, they will bring us an
unalienated world?
How comes?
What nonsense is this?"
So that's when he writes The Paris Manuscripts,
and tries to now bring the whole idea of alienation down to
earth, to fill it with some economic
content.
That's why now he tries to relate it to commodity
production, and make the claim that though
in modern society everybody's alienated,
but they are only the workers who are fully alienated,
and their interest is to overcome the alienation.
That's what--this is why he tries to argue that alienation
will bring the working class to emancipate humankind;
that is the project.
Of course, he never publishes the book,
because after he wrote it down, he said,
"Well"-- I suppose he said, "Well,
this is quite nicely written.
I have a couple of good ideas.
But nobody will believe me." Right?
"The working class will not go on the barricades and die
because I am telling them that they are alienated."
Right?
"They don't care about alienation.
I have to come up some-- some better reason,
you know, why the working class will revolt."
And that's the end of the young Marx.
And now he's beginning to read Adam Smith and Ricardo and
political economy.
Right?
And he's beginning to develop his theory of exploitation.
This is the young or mature Marx, and we will talk about him
very briefly.
Now just a couple of ideas here.
Right?
What about "On the Jewish Question",
what is at stake?
Bruno Bauer wrote a paper on the origins of anti-Semitism,
and he said, "We have
…

Need subtitles from another video?