Advertisement
English transcript
Marx is cited that once he said, "I am not a
Marxist."
And I think there is a lot of truth to it.
The reason why I carry on and on and on with Marx,
in this course, because my experience is that
many of us do have very simplistic stereotypes,
in our mind, who Karl Marx was and what his
theory is all about.
Well he was a creative scholar, a vibrant mind,
who was ready to change his mind when confronted with new
arguments or confronted with new evidence.
And there were many, many facets,
many faces of Karl Marx.
We have seen some of those.
Right?
We have seen Marx, starting as a Hegelian
idealist, being obsessed with the idea of
alienation, disappointed with Hegel's
fluffy idea of alienation, bringing it closer to home,
bringing it more down to earth, making probably some
reductionist mistake in the process,
then abandoning it and turning into a materialist somewhat
hesitantly and reluctantly.
When he starts his turn towards historical materialism in
"The Theses on Feuerbach,"
he says: "The point is to change the world.
Truth is a practical question."
Within six months, in The German Ideology,
he is a positivist social scientist.
Right?
The point where we start with our real individual and our real
actual social circumstances.
He offers testable hypotheses, to put it this way,
in modern social science language.
And in some ways he remains a positivist social scientist,
in his major works.
So he was changing his mind, and indeed he was less
doctrinaire than usually Marxists are.
And easy to be less doctrinaire--right?--if you are
one of the persons who created the doctrine.
Today we will be talking about one important component of
Marx's theory, his theory of history.
And this is also contradictory, full with tensions and
contradictions.
But it is a formidable body of propositions;
absolutely formidable.
There is actually not a single theorist I can recall who,
like Karl Marx, not only has a very specific
set of ideas in what stages human evolution,
from the very elementary societies to the most complex
one evolved.
There are many who offer typologies like this.
We have seen in Montesquieu, we have seen in Adam Smith;
there were many who did that.
But what is unique about Marx, that he has a genuine theory of
history.
He has a very powerful argument what is the exact causal
mechanism which leads the transition from one form of
society to another one; what drives historical
evolution.
Marx is genuinely the Darwin of social scientists,
in this respect.
What Darwin could do with The Evolution of Species,
Marx was capable to do in the theory of history.
It's a genuine theory. Right?
A theory, when you have an idea what are really the causal
mechanisms, what links cause to an effect.
And Marx has such a theory.
We will see when we will be discussing Weber,
whom I admire a great deal, that Weber really does not have
such a theory.
And as far I can, nobody else does.
Well the only downside of Marx's theory of history is that
history proved him to be wrong.
Well theories are not necessarily to be supported by
the facts.
Theories are there, you know, to have a tight
enough proposition and to be tested.
But what exactly the theory is will vary in Marx's own
writings, and there are some versions of
this theory which fit better the empirical reality than the
original one, and the one which became kind
of carved into stone in the literature on Marx.
And this is why I do a little comparison between The German
Ideology-- we touched upon The German
Ideology already-- and another manuscript that he
also left incomplete and unfinished.
He was working on it in 1857 and '58, and was never properly
translated, the title into English.
We always refer it to Grundrisse,
the 'eh' at the end, the sounds.
Right?
English speakers like to call it "Grundriss".
No, it is Grundrisse.
And Grundrisse means a sketch, an outline.
And that's what it is.
One-thousand pages, handwritten pages,
written in a big hurry between '57 and '58.
Like the earlier attempts to write a big book,
The Paris Manuscript and The German Ideology,
when Marx approaches the end of his title he argued,
theory--he said, "My goodness gracious,
I got it all wrong.
I have to start it all over again."
And he will start all over again, just in ten years' time,
and he will write Das Kapital.
Did he get it wrong in the Grundrisse?
That's what I will try to pose today.
And I was merciful enough that I did not ask you to read too
much from the Grundrisse.
What you read has been published as a separate little
book, under the title Pre-Capitalist Economic
Formations.
And this is probably the most accessible text in the whole
one-thousand pages.
It was put together and translated by the wonderful
British social historian, Eric Hobsbawm.
Fortunately he's still with us.
He's ninety-one-years-old, and thanks God he's strong;
and he's still traveling, if you pay him business class.
But we could get him to this class if Yale would be willing
to pay business class ticket, but Yale would not do it.
Anyway, he's sharp, good, and he was the major
social historian of the twentieth century in Britain--
not a trivial matter because the best social history was in
Britain in the twentieth century.
Anyway, he translated it, and you read his translation.
Was it difficult?
Yes.
But try the rest of the Grundrisse,
and then you will see how easy this text is.
Okay, and the point what I'm trying to make today is to show
what a fundamental shift there is in Marx's thinking from
The German Ideology to the Grundrisse.
So we will start with the initial formulation in the
Grundrisse, how he's beginning to conceive
what historical evolution is.
And this is something we did cover, so I can rush through of
it very quickly.
Right?
The idea is--what he introduces for the first time in The
German Ideology, 1845--is the concept of the
mode of production.
And you already have seen this citation.
Right?
"Man can distinguish from animals by consciousness,
by religion, or anything you like.
They, themselves begin to distinguish themselves from
animals as soon as they begin to produce,
as soon as they're beginning to change the world to fit their
human needs."
That is the fundamental insight.
And you may dismiss it but, you know, that's clearly a very
serious proposition.
Right?
That if you look at history over time, you will become very
interested how these people survived.
What did they eat?
How did they produce what they did eat?
What kind of housing did they live in?
How they did build their housing?
Right?
How they did move around?
Did they invent the wheel, or did they already know the
wheel?
Right?
These are the questions you will be asking when you are
studying a society.
Did they--could they lit a fire or they couldn't?
Right?
So you were interested in this stuff.
How did they kill the deer?
Right?
What kind of weapons they had.
What kind of instruments they used when they planted their
plants.
Right?
These are obvious questions to ask, and he said,
"That's it, that's what we want to
see."
And he said, "This mode of production
must be considered not simply as reproduction."
Right?
And I think this is a very powerful argument,
what he makes it here.
Right?
This is a definite mode of life.
Right?
When I'm suggesting mode of production, I'm not narrowly
focusing on the economy.
I am basically talking about differences in ways of life.
And differences in ways of life, as he elsewhere puts it,
well first you have to drink and eat and find shelter.
And once you are not hungry any longer, and you are not wet when
it is raining, then you start thinking.
Right?
But first you have to fill your stomach--right?--and make sure
that you are safe from the rainfall.
That's a reasonable argument.
Well there are some very important key differences,
as we proceed from The German Ideology to the
Grundrisse.
Well in The German Ideology there's one
important difference.
History is driven by increasing division of labor.
And I pointed to this in the earlier lecture.
Here he draws directly on Adam Smith.
He basically takes it over from Adam Smith.
That's what Adam Smith did.
In the Grundrisse, on the other hand,
he sees a movement, a gradual movement over
history, towards private ownership;
that's what drives the story.
"A gradual separation of the laboring subject and the
objective conditions of the worker."
That's how he describes now human history.
And doing so--separation of laboring subject and the
objective conditions of labor-- enables him in the
Grundrisse to bring back the notion of alienation.
He already seemed to have forgotten and put it on the
shelf.
Then he will forget it again.
But for this piece of work, the idea of alienation
re-interpreted as the making of private ownership and the
separation of worker and the objective conditions of work is
very crucial, very important.
There is another big difference.
In The German Ideology, Marx has a unilinear view of
history; a very deterministic,
uni-linear view of history.
And this is what will come back in later Marx,
and that dominate Marxists of various kinds.
Uni-linear means--right?--that all societies start at the same
starting point: tribal society.
They all progress through slavery, feudalism,
capitalism, with the assumption that they all will end up in
communism.
But this is a kind of uni-linear stage.
Every society will have to go through of these stages,
and there is necessity that one moves from an earlier stage to a
later stage.
And as I said, he will show the causal
mechanism how it is happening.
The Grundrisse is different.
This is a messy description of human history,
a multi-linear trajectory; and I will show you what his
multi-linear trajectory is.
The beauty of shifting from this uni-linear trajectory to
the multi-linear trajectory is that,
though Marx messes completely the logic of argument up,
but he produces a theoretical proposition what you can see
fits already in his time, the historical development,
very well, and would argue by
extension--now I will extend his argument--
it even fits better later historical evolution.
Okay, let's return now to The German Ideology
briefly, and the centrality of division of labor in this work.
Well, Marx described--right?--a mode of production between the
dialectical interaction between what he saw,
he called forces of production--and forces of
production means basically the technology,
raw materials, the labor power--and eventually
he invents a term, the relations of production.
But he identifies this with property relations in the later
work.
But he tends to use the word 'intercourse' or 'division of
labor' in The German Ideology.
Now dialectical interaction.
What on earth this word means?
I think I also mentioned once that Marx,
in a letter to Engels, once wrote: "You know,
when I don't understand something, then I say it is
dialectical."
So the idea of dialectics was not much clearer to Karl Marx
than it is to you.
Right?
But dialectics basically meant--right?--an interactive
relationship.
You know, in today's social science language we would
say--right?--that there is the causal arrow going in both ways.
Right?
It's not simply that relations of production determine
relations of production.
Certain relations of production can block the development of
forces of production, and when they change,
the new relations of production can unleash the development of
the forces of production.
So that is the dialectics--right?--
that the causal arrow, there is not simple
determination pointing from one to the other,
but there is a feedback loop.
Right?
That would be, I think, the modern social
science language, to put this one.
As I said, in the initial formulation, he really thinks
this is the division of labor, rather than property
relationships.
And I think we have seen it, he will--this comes straight
out of Adam Smith, what you have read.
Right?
The relations of different nations among themselves depends
to which each has developed these productive forces,
the division of labor and its internal intercourse.
So that's exactly--right?--what Adam Smith said.
Hunting/gathering societies, grazing societies,
agricultural societies, commercial societies,
they all correspond to different levels of division of
labor.
And that's what Marx initially tries to do in The German
Ideology.
And he deals with the question of the property relations,
but he said, "Look, property relations
also change, but these changing property
relations are simply the outcomes of the increased
division of labor."
So it's basically determined by the division of labor.
"If I understand the level of division of labor,
I will understand property relationships as well."
That sounds actually quite reasonable.
And these sections of The German Ideology,
by the way, were rediscovered by Marxists in the 1950s,
especially Marxists who were living in the Soviet Empire.
There was a formidable social scientist in Poland;
his name is Ossowski.
And Ossowski, in 1957, re-read The German
Ideology.
And until then, you know, what was carved into
stone, that, you know,
Marxist theory suggests that this is property relations which
explain everything.
And that was the project--right?--of communism.
You eliminate private ownership and everything will be fine.
Right?
No private ownership, things will be rosy.
Right?
There will be equality among people--right?--and dynamic
economic growth.
Now the Soviets eliminated private ownership.
Was it an egalitarian society?
No it wasn't.
Was it a dynamic society?
No it wasn't.
Now Ossowski was re-reading The German Ideology and
said, "Well you did not read your Marx right.
Marx doesn't say it is property relations which is crucial,
but division of labor.
So, of course, the division of labor exists in
a Communist society, just not the appropriate
division of labor, and that creates
inequalities."
Anyway, that was a very interesting debate.
Ossowski had a very great reception in western social
science circles.
Okay, anyway so this is the initial idea--right?--in The
German Ideology.
And then he proceeds, as again we have seen it.
I'll rush through of it.
He describes various modes of production this way.
Right?
There is the tribal society--very primitive means of
production: hunting, fishing, gathering.
Division of labor is very elementary.
And he uses this sexist term: "This is only a natural
division of labor between men and women.
Women gather and men hunts, because the men are strong and,
as you know, the women are weak."
Right?
And therefore this is a "natural division of
labor."
Well probably he can be forgiven;
I mean, he wrote this in 1845.
And then he moves on to slavery.
He said, "Well now the forces of production are
beginning to develop.
In a tribal society people just had enough capacity to gather,
hunt, and fish enough food to survive,
and therefore everybody had to go out gathering,
hunting, and fishing.
But now we have new technologies,
which are more productive, and therefore it becomes
possible that some people say, 'Well I am not going out
hunting.
I will get slaves, and slaves will do the work for
me.
They will be able to produce what is necessary for their
survival.
I'll give them only as much that they do not die from
hunger.
I eat the rest, and drink the rest,
and then I'll just sit at home and I am writing
philosophy.'" So ancient philosophy is born.
Right?
You're Plato, sitting at home,
and thinking, and you are writing drama and
poetry, and you create art,
because the slaves are working the fields,
producing a surplus that can be appropriated from them.
Division of labor increases as technology increased.
Well as a result, some change in property
relationships.
Right?
Now this is not a communal relationship,
we are not members of the same community, but a pretty
oppressive relationship between slave and slave owner.
And he goes on.
And then comes feudalism, and what happens with
feudalism?
Well what is the problem with the slaves?
The problem with the slaves, that they have absolutely no
interest in producing.
They were simply physically coursed to produce.
Therefore they can be pretty negligent in operating the means
of instrument.
You have to supervise them.
You beat them--right?--to make them work.
Right?
You keep killing them, you know, if they disobey.
There's struggle; you know, you have to conduct
wars all the time--right?--to get new slaves.
Therefore as technology develops, you need a labor force
which is more motivated to work harder.
So slaves are being replaced by serfs, by peasants.
And what is the big change?
The big change is that now the peasants will get a plot they
can cultivate themselves.
They actually have to work only for two or three days on the
large estate of the feudal lord, and the rest of the time they
can stay at home, cultivate their land.
They can build a house.
They can have their family.
They can marry, and their children will belong
to them, rather than to the lord.
Right?
A big change. Right?
In classical states of slavery, the children--there are no
marriage, no home.
Right?
Slaves lives in barracks. Right?
The institution of family does not exist.
I mean, you know, slavery in the south of the
United States was not quite classical slavery,
in Greece and Rome or in Egypt, but had some similarities.
Right?
Slave owners certainly had claim on the children of slaves,
and in many instances marriage was really--
not really an existing institution,
even in nineteenth century U.S.
Now the serfs are very different.
They have their family, they have their home.
They do not have a title of the land and the home,
but they have possession of the land and the home.
And therefore they have an interest.
If they don't work hard on those two days,
on the land of the landlords, they are kicked off their land.
Right?
So therefore they will have to pay more attention.
That's the idea.
But then he looks at--you know, compares--the Dark Middle Ages
in Europe--right?--the peaks of feudalism with Rome and Greece
and Athens.
And he said, "Did the division of labor
increase?"
He said, "No they, the division of labor
decreased."
I mean antiquity, that was discovered in the
Renaissance, was far superior to the Middle Ages.
The big cities, like Rome, were abandoned.
Many of you were in Rome.
Even now you see ruins. Right?
The glorious Rome--right?--was left as a grazing land for the
sheep.
Right?
Those lands--you know, they could bring water into
your homes.
Right?
The Greeks.
They had high levels of technologies.
They had highly developed industries.
This was all forgotten in the Middle Ages.
Right?
So what is the Middle Ages?
Some people said this was a step backward historically.
Right?
Inquisition, the Dark Middle Ages,
the decay of the cities; it's a step backward.
Well Marx doesn't know what to do with it.
Right?
And as I said-- pointed out, he abandons the manuscript
here.
He said, "Well the theory doesn't work.
I cannot explain this all with increasing division of
labor."
Then, of course, would be-- the fourth mode
should be capitalism.
And as he's beginning to develop the form of capitalism,
he's beginning to develop now the notion of relations of
production.
Really feudalism is superior--this idea comes up in
The German Ideology-- superior to the Middle Ages
because it had more developed relations of production,
more developed property relations.
It was a further step towards private ownership.
It was a further step because now the laborer had possessions
of the land, what they cultivated.
Well and here it comes, the classical Marxist view,
what he will change in the Grundrisse,
about historical change.
And this is, I think, a provocative,
important statement; that he said,
"If I'm looking at a mode of production,
we can characterize them by the correspondence of the forces and
relations of production.
A certain level of forces of production require a certain
type of relations of production, a certain type of relationship
between individuals."
This is, in Marx, what a hundred years later in
social sciences w
…
Marxist."
And I think there is a lot of truth to it.
The reason why I carry on and on and on with Marx,
in this course, because my experience is that
many of us do have very simplistic stereotypes,
in our mind, who Karl Marx was and what his
theory is all about.
Well he was a creative scholar, a vibrant mind,
who was ready to change his mind when confronted with new
arguments or confronted with new evidence.
And there were many, many facets,
many faces of Karl Marx.
We have seen some of those.
Right?
We have seen Marx, starting as a Hegelian
idealist, being obsessed with the idea of
alienation, disappointed with Hegel's
fluffy idea of alienation, bringing it closer to home,
bringing it more down to earth, making probably some
reductionist mistake in the process,
then abandoning it and turning into a materialist somewhat
hesitantly and reluctantly.
When he starts his turn towards historical materialism in
"The Theses on Feuerbach,"
he says: "The point is to change the world.
Truth is a practical question."
Within six months, in The German Ideology,
he is a positivist social scientist.
Right?
The point where we start with our real individual and our real
actual social circumstances.
He offers testable hypotheses, to put it this way,
in modern social science language.
And in some ways he remains a positivist social scientist,
in his major works.
So he was changing his mind, and indeed he was less
doctrinaire than usually Marxists are.
And easy to be less doctrinaire--right?--if you are
one of the persons who created the doctrine.
Today we will be talking about one important component of
Marx's theory, his theory of history.
And this is also contradictory, full with tensions and
contradictions.
But it is a formidable body of propositions;
absolutely formidable.
There is actually not a single theorist I can recall who,
like Karl Marx, not only has a very specific
set of ideas in what stages human evolution,
from the very elementary societies to the most complex
one evolved.
There are many who offer typologies like this.
We have seen in Montesquieu, we have seen in Adam Smith;
there were many who did that.
But what is unique about Marx, that he has a genuine theory of
history.
He has a very powerful argument what is the exact causal
mechanism which leads the transition from one form of
society to another one; what drives historical
evolution.
Marx is genuinely the Darwin of social scientists,
in this respect.
What Darwin could do with The Evolution of Species,
Marx was capable to do in the theory of history.
It's a genuine theory. Right?
A theory, when you have an idea what are really the causal
mechanisms, what links cause to an effect.
And Marx has such a theory.
We will see when we will be discussing Weber,
whom I admire a great deal, that Weber really does not have
such a theory.
And as far I can, nobody else does.
Well the only downside of Marx's theory of history is that
history proved him to be wrong.
Well theories are not necessarily to be supported by
the facts.
Theories are there, you know, to have a tight
enough proposition and to be tested.
But what exactly the theory is will vary in Marx's own
writings, and there are some versions of
this theory which fit better the empirical reality than the
original one, and the one which became kind
of carved into stone in the literature on Marx.
And this is why I do a little comparison between The German
Ideology-- we touched upon The German
Ideology already-- and another manuscript that he
also left incomplete and unfinished.
He was working on it in 1857 and '58, and was never properly
translated, the title into English.
We always refer it to Grundrisse,
the 'eh' at the end, the sounds.
Right?
English speakers like to call it "Grundriss".
No, it is Grundrisse.
And Grundrisse means a sketch, an outline.
And that's what it is.
One-thousand pages, handwritten pages,
written in a big hurry between '57 and '58.
Like the earlier attempts to write a big book,
The Paris Manuscript and The German Ideology,
when Marx approaches the end of his title he argued,
theory--he said, "My goodness gracious,
I got it all wrong.
I have to start it all over again."
And he will start all over again, just in ten years' time,
and he will write Das Kapital.
Did he get it wrong in the Grundrisse?
That's what I will try to pose today.
And I was merciful enough that I did not ask you to read too
much from the Grundrisse.
What you read has been published as a separate little
book, under the title Pre-Capitalist Economic
Formations.
And this is probably the most accessible text in the whole
one-thousand pages.
It was put together and translated by the wonderful
British social historian, Eric Hobsbawm.
Fortunately he's still with us.
He's ninety-one-years-old, and thanks God he's strong;
and he's still traveling, if you pay him business class.
But we could get him to this class if Yale would be willing
to pay business class ticket, but Yale would not do it.
Anyway, he's sharp, good, and he was the major
social historian of the twentieth century in Britain--
not a trivial matter because the best social history was in
Britain in the twentieth century.
Anyway, he translated it, and you read his translation.
Was it difficult?
Yes.
But try the rest of the Grundrisse,
and then you will see how easy this text is.
Okay, and the point what I'm trying to make today is to show
what a fundamental shift there is in Marx's thinking from
The German Ideology to the Grundrisse.
So we will start with the initial formulation in the
Grundrisse, how he's beginning to conceive
what historical evolution is.
And this is something we did cover, so I can rush through of
it very quickly.
Right?
The idea is--what he introduces for the first time in The
German Ideology, 1845--is the concept of the
mode of production.
And you already have seen this citation.
Right?
"Man can distinguish from animals by consciousness,
by religion, or anything you like.
They, themselves begin to distinguish themselves from
animals as soon as they begin to produce,
as soon as they're beginning to change the world to fit their
human needs."
That is the fundamental insight.
And you may dismiss it but, you know, that's clearly a very
serious proposition.
Right?
That if you look at history over time, you will become very
interested how these people survived.
What did they eat?
How did they produce what they did eat?
What kind of housing did they live in?
How they did build their housing?
Right?
How they did move around?
Did they invent the wheel, or did they already know the
wheel?
Right?
These are the questions you will be asking when you are
studying a society.
Did they--could they lit a fire or they couldn't?
Right?
So you were interested in this stuff.
How did they kill the deer?
Right?
What kind of weapons they had.
What kind of instruments they used when they planted their
plants.
Right?
These are obvious questions to ask, and he said,
"That's it, that's what we want to
see."
And he said, "This mode of production
must be considered not simply as reproduction."
Right?
And I think this is a very powerful argument,
what he makes it here.
Right?
This is a definite mode of life.
Right?
When I'm suggesting mode of production, I'm not narrowly
focusing on the economy.
I am basically talking about differences in ways of life.
And differences in ways of life, as he elsewhere puts it,
well first you have to drink and eat and find shelter.
And once you are not hungry any longer, and you are not wet when
it is raining, then you start thinking.
Right?
But first you have to fill your stomach--right?--and make sure
that you are safe from the rainfall.
That's a reasonable argument.
Well there are some very important key differences,
as we proceed from The German Ideology to the
Grundrisse.
Well in The German Ideology there's one
important difference.
History is driven by increasing division of labor.
And I pointed to this in the earlier lecture.
Here he draws directly on Adam Smith.
He basically takes it over from Adam Smith.
That's what Adam Smith did.
In the Grundrisse, on the other hand,
he sees a movement, a gradual movement over
history, towards private ownership;
that's what drives the story.
"A gradual separation of the laboring subject and the
objective conditions of the worker."
That's how he describes now human history.
And doing so--separation of laboring subject and the
objective conditions of labor-- enables him in the
Grundrisse to bring back the notion of alienation.
He already seemed to have forgotten and put it on the
shelf.
Then he will forget it again.
But for this piece of work, the idea of alienation
re-interpreted as the making of private ownership and the
separation of worker and the objective conditions of work is
very crucial, very important.
There is another big difference.
In The German Ideology, Marx has a unilinear view of
history; a very deterministic,
uni-linear view of history.
And this is what will come back in later Marx,
and that dominate Marxists of various kinds.
Uni-linear means--right?--that all societies start at the same
starting point: tribal society.
They all progress through slavery, feudalism,
capitalism, with the assumption that they all will end up in
communism.
But this is a kind of uni-linear stage.
Every society will have to go through of these stages,
and there is necessity that one moves from an earlier stage to a
later stage.
And as I said, he will show the causal
mechanism how it is happening.
The Grundrisse is different.
This is a messy description of human history,
a multi-linear trajectory; and I will show you what his
multi-linear trajectory is.
The beauty of shifting from this uni-linear trajectory to
the multi-linear trajectory is that,
though Marx messes completely the logic of argument up,
but he produces a theoretical proposition what you can see
fits already in his time, the historical development,
very well, and would argue by
extension--now I will extend his argument--
it even fits better later historical evolution.
Okay, let's return now to The German Ideology
briefly, and the centrality of division of labor in this work.
Well, Marx described--right?--a mode of production between the
dialectical interaction between what he saw,
he called forces of production--and forces of
production means basically the technology,
raw materials, the labor power--and eventually
he invents a term, the relations of production.
But he identifies this with property relations in the later
work.
But he tends to use the word 'intercourse' or 'division of
labor' in The German Ideology.
Now dialectical interaction.
What on earth this word means?
I think I also mentioned once that Marx,
in a letter to Engels, once wrote: "You know,
when I don't understand something, then I say it is
dialectical."
So the idea of dialectics was not much clearer to Karl Marx
than it is to you.
Right?
But dialectics basically meant--right?--an interactive
relationship.
You know, in today's social science language we would
say--right?--that there is the causal arrow going in both ways.
Right?
It's not simply that relations of production determine
relations of production.
Certain relations of production can block the development of
forces of production, and when they change,
the new relations of production can unleash the development of
the forces of production.
So that is the dialectics--right?--
that the causal arrow, there is not simple
determination pointing from one to the other,
but there is a feedback loop.
Right?
That would be, I think, the modern social
science language, to put this one.
As I said, in the initial formulation, he really thinks
this is the division of labor, rather than property
relationships.
And I think we have seen it, he will--this comes straight
out of Adam Smith, what you have read.
Right?
The relations of different nations among themselves depends
to which each has developed these productive forces,
the division of labor and its internal intercourse.
So that's exactly--right?--what Adam Smith said.
Hunting/gathering societies, grazing societies,
agricultural societies, commercial societies,
they all correspond to different levels of division of
labor.
And that's what Marx initially tries to do in The German
Ideology.
And he deals with the question of the property relations,
but he said, "Look, property relations
also change, but these changing property
relations are simply the outcomes of the increased
division of labor."
So it's basically determined by the division of labor.
"If I understand the level of division of labor,
I will understand property relationships as well."
That sounds actually quite reasonable.
And these sections of The German Ideology,
by the way, were rediscovered by Marxists in the 1950s,
especially Marxists who were living in the Soviet Empire.
There was a formidable social scientist in Poland;
his name is Ossowski.
And Ossowski, in 1957, re-read The German
Ideology.
And until then, you know, what was carved into
stone, that, you know,
Marxist theory suggests that this is property relations which
explain everything.
And that was the project--right?--of communism.
You eliminate private ownership and everything will be fine.
Right?
No private ownership, things will be rosy.
Right?
There will be equality among people--right?--and dynamic
economic growth.
Now the Soviets eliminated private ownership.
Was it an egalitarian society?
No it wasn't.
Was it a dynamic society?
No it wasn't.
Now Ossowski was re-reading The German Ideology and
said, "Well you did not read your Marx right.
Marx doesn't say it is property relations which is crucial,
but division of labor.
So, of course, the division of labor exists in
a Communist society, just not the appropriate
division of labor, and that creates
inequalities."
Anyway, that was a very interesting debate.
Ossowski had a very great reception in western social
science circles.
Okay, anyway so this is the initial idea--right?--in The
German Ideology.
And then he proceeds, as again we have seen it.
I'll rush through of it.
He describes various modes of production this way.
Right?
There is the tribal society--very primitive means of
production: hunting, fishing, gathering.
Division of labor is very elementary.
And he uses this sexist term: "This is only a natural
division of labor between men and women.
Women gather and men hunts, because the men are strong and,
as you know, the women are weak."
Right?
And therefore this is a "natural division of
labor."
Well probably he can be forgiven;
I mean, he wrote this in 1845.
And then he moves on to slavery.
He said, "Well now the forces of production are
beginning to develop.
In a tribal society people just had enough capacity to gather,
hunt, and fish enough food to survive,
and therefore everybody had to go out gathering,
hunting, and fishing.
But now we have new technologies,
which are more productive, and therefore it becomes
possible that some people say, 'Well I am not going out
hunting.
I will get slaves, and slaves will do the work for
me.
They will be able to produce what is necessary for their
survival.
I'll give them only as much that they do not die from
hunger.
I eat the rest, and drink the rest,
and then I'll just sit at home and I am writing
philosophy.'" So ancient philosophy is born.
Right?
You're Plato, sitting at home,
and thinking, and you are writing drama and
poetry, and you create art,
because the slaves are working the fields,
producing a surplus that can be appropriated from them.
Division of labor increases as technology increased.
Well as a result, some change in property
relationships.
Right?
Now this is not a communal relationship,
we are not members of the same community, but a pretty
oppressive relationship between slave and slave owner.
And he goes on.
And then comes feudalism, and what happens with
feudalism?
Well what is the problem with the slaves?
The problem with the slaves, that they have absolutely no
interest in producing.
They were simply physically coursed to produce.
Therefore they can be pretty negligent in operating the means
of instrument.
You have to supervise them.
You beat them--right?--to make them work.
Right?
You keep killing them, you know, if they disobey.
There's struggle; you know, you have to conduct
wars all the time--right?--to get new slaves.
Therefore as technology develops, you need a labor force
which is more motivated to work harder.
So slaves are being replaced by serfs, by peasants.
And what is the big change?
The big change is that now the peasants will get a plot they
can cultivate themselves.
They actually have to work only for two or three days on the
large estate of the feudal lord, and the rest of the time they
can stay at home, cultivate their land.
They can build a house.
They can have their family.
They can marry, and their children will belong
to them, rather than to the lord.
Right?
A big change. Right?
In classical states of slavery, the children--there are no
marriage, no home.
Right?
Slaves lives in barracks. Right?
The institution of family does not exist.
I mean, you know, slavery in the south of the
United States was not quite classical slavery,
in Greece and Rome or in Egypt, but had some similarities.
Right?
Slave owners certainly had claim on the children of slaves,
and in many instances marriage was really--
not really an existing institution,
even in nineteenth century U.S.
Now the serfs are very different.
They have their family, they have their home.
They do not have a title of the land and the home,
but they have possession of the land and the home.
And therefore they have an interest.
If they don't work hard on those two days,
on the land of the landlords, they are kicked off their land.
Right?
So therefore they will have to pay more attention.
That's the idea.
But then he looks at--you know, compares--the Dark Middle Ages
in Europe--right?--the peaks of feudalism with Rome and Greece
and Athens.
And he said, "Did the division of labor
increase?"
He said, "No they, the division of labor
decreased."
I mean antiquity, that was discovered in the
Renaissance, was far superior to the Middle Ages.
The big cities, like Rome, were abandoned.
Many of you were in Rome.
Even now you see ruins. Right?
The glorious Rome--right?--was left as a grazing land for the
sheep.
Right?
Those lands--you know, they could bring water into
your homes.
Right?
The Greeks.
They had high levels of technologies.
They had highly developed industries.
This was all forgotten in the Middle Ages.
Right?
So what is the Middle Ages?
Some people said this was a step backward historically.
Right?
Inquisition, the Dark Middle Ages,
the decay of the cities; it's a step backward.
Well Marx doesn't know what to do with it.
Right?
And as I said-- pointed out, he abandons the manuscript
here.
He said, "Well the theory doesn't work.
I cannot explain this all with increasing division of
labor."
Then, of course, would be-- the fourth mode
should be capitalism.
And as he's beginning to develop the form of capitalism,
he's beginning to develop now the notion of relations of
production.
Really feudalism is superior--this idea comes up in
The German Ideology-- superior to the Middle Ages
because it had more developed relations of production,
more developed property relations.
It was a further step towards private ownership.
It was a further step because now the laborer had possessions
of the land, what they cultivated.
Well and here it comes, the classical Marxist view,
what he will change in the Grundrisse,
about historical change.
And this is, I think, a provocative,
important statement; that he said,
"If I'm looking at a mode of production,
we can characterize them by the correspondence of the forces and
relations of production.
A certain level of forces of production require a certain
type of relations of production, a certain type of relationship
between individuals."
This is, in Marx, what a hundred years later in
social sciences w
…