Advertisement
English transcript
Prof: Okay, now today we move--basically we
move into the twentieth century.
And there is a lot of similarity between the three
authors we will be discussing: Nietzsche, Freud and Max Weber.
You know, Durkheim will be a somewhat different kind of
story.
But all--I mean, Nietzsche, of course,
died in 1900, but he was out of action for
ten years because of mental illness, rather severe mental
illness.
He published all of his work in the nineteenth century.
Freud and Weber started to publish in the nineteenth
century.
But these three characters, in many ways,
are very important bridges towards twentieth century social
theory.
In a way they did foreshadow a great deal of theorizing,
particularly during the second half of the twentieth century,
especially in the last thirty or forty years.
I think it's also very easy to see the point of departure from
Marx-- some continuity,
but the basic point of department from Marx in the work
of Nietzsche, Freud, and Weber.
If I can put it very simply, the major departure is that
they all depart from Marx's economic reductionism--
right?--the emphasis on economic interest,
which is actually not only Marx.
Right?
It was common in Adam Smith, and Marx as well.
They depart from this and they emphasize that the problem in
modernity is not so much in the economic system;
it is much more in terms of power and consciousness.
The problem of modernity is repression, in one way or
another.
The problem of modern life is that we internalize the reasons
for our own subjugation, as such, and somehow we have to
figure out how to liberate ourselves from this internalized
subjugation.
Why do we obey orders?
Why do we actually accept that we are subjugated?
This is the central question, I think, Nietzsche,
Freud, and Weber are posing.
It's again a question which has not been really asked by the
other theorists we discussed so far.
They just had civil society as a point of reference for the
good society.
Now the problem for Nietzsche, Freud, and Weber is in us,
internally--in us, how we solve the problem within
ourselves.
So this is a kind of introducing the three authors.
In some ways one can say Nietzsche,
Freud, and Weber not only foreshadows twentieth century
social theory, but in some ways they are the
first of post-modern theorists-- right?--the theorists which are
beginning to come to terms with the oppressive nature of
modernity, and try to figure out how to
transcend that.
Now I think what I asked you to read for today is probably the
most difficult text for the semester,
The Genealogy of Morals, and you may have been greatly
frustrated by it, and probably also irritated by
it, because he's a very provocative mind.
I hope you did what I suggested; namely, you had a cursory
reading of the text before today,
and now you can go back to the text,
after my lecture notes, and I think that should help
you to find your way out and to see what he is really up to.
Now what is he up to?
Let me just foreshadow, before I get into his life and
work, and particularly in Genealogy of Morals.
There is another point in which Nietzsche, Freud,
and Weber can be understood in relationship to Marx.
In my very introductory comments, I emphasized the
difference--right?--the shift away from the economy to the
question of power and domination.
But there is a point at which there is a continuity between
them and Marx--Nietzsche, Freud and too mainly Weber;
I mean, Weber is a somewhat more complicated story.
But certainly Nietzsche and Freud are critical theorists;
critical theorists in the sense as we defined this earlier.
Right?
Critical theorists, that they are offering a
criticism of human consciousness.
What is in our mind and how did it get into our mind,
and how-- and the problem of our consciousness in
relationship to our existence.
And this is very much critical theory as it was defined by
Hegel and then the young Marx, the Hegelian Marx,
the Marx of Paris Manuscripts.
Right?
The Marx of alienation. Right?
This is very much coming from this tradition,
and the central issue is how can we subject this to critical
scrutiny?
And in Nietzsche's case, there is an incredible attempt
being made here to try to offer a critical theory which does not
really have a critical vantage point.
Right?
All critical theories of Hegel and Marx and twentieth century
critical theory do have an idea of a good society,
of an emancipated human existence, and they criticize
the reality, the society what they are
analyzing, from the point of view of this
critical vantage point.
Nietzsche is different.
He is really the most radical of critical theorists.
And in the twentieth century the theorist which builds the
most consistently on it is Michel Foucault--
right?--who tried to create a theory which is critical of
existence and our consciousness, but critical without telling
you what is good, what you should be aspiring for.
And that's exactly what Nietzsche is trying to do.
It is sort of the squaring of the circle.
Can you be critical of a situation if you cannot tell
what is the good outcome?
Right?
Can you actually subject the very notion of the good society,
the good, to critical scrutiny?
This is what he's trying to do.
Right?
To offer such a theory.
Well Freud is different. Right?
Freud is a critical theorist beyond Hegel and beyond Marx.
He does agree with Marx that we have to find some critical
analysis which is rooted in our sensuous experiences,
and somehow we have to relate the problems of our
consciousness to our sensuous experiences.
Right?
In this respect, Freud is very much in the line
of Marx's critique of Hegel.
This is not simply radicalizing your consciousness;
you have to confront your consciousness with your sensuous
experiences.
But he is different from Marx because--
I pointed this out earlier very briefly--
because in Marx, this sensuous activity is
production, it is economic activity.
For Freud it is our sexual experiences--
right?-and he offers a criticism of our consciousness
by confronting us with our repressed sexual experiences in
our earlier life.
Right?
So this is a critical theory.
Right?
He said, "What you think is in your mind is right.
No, no, no, it isn't."
Right?
You have to think about all of your experiences of your earlier
sexual life, and then when you figure out
what you repressed as bad memories,
that's when you will actually will be able to have a healthier
psychic life.
Right?
Well Weber is more complicated, and we will come back to this,
Weber's critical theory, when we get to Weber,
and to the question whether he's a critical theorist at all,
that has been highly debated.
Okay, I think now we are ready for Friedrich Nietzsche.
And I hope this makes more sense now for you--right?--what
you were reading.
Right?
And let me just emphasize one more time--
right?--the big project in Nietzsche is to offer a critical
scrutiny of human mind, but not to have any critical
vantage point.
Right?
To criticize the very principles of good society and
good, to critical scrutiny.
Where does it come from when we have the conception of good and
good society?
That is his project.
It's an incredible intellectual venture.
Right?
As I said, it is this kind of squaring of the circle,
what he does; what he does with a great deal
of power.
And he does it extremely provocatively.
I will put up a couple of quotations for it,
which are outrageous.
Don't walk out on it. Right?
Wait a little.
Hold your breath, listen.
This is outrageous what he's saying.
He's a provocateur.
He is like Rousseau; he is only worse than Rousseau.
Right?
He provokes us even more than Rousseau.
But, you know, deep down he's a very
sensitive--you know?--very humanistic human being.
Right?
He provokes you.
But if you listen carefully, you figure out there is
something what you actually can relate to it,
when you think what he's actually trying to get at.
All right, here is Nietzsche.
And let me just very briefly rush through his life.
He was born in 1844, in the small city of
Röcken in Germany, near Leipzig.
And this is very important: his father was a Lutheran
minister, and the family was all clergy, Lutheran clergy.
And he's bringing up, in a very religious sentiments,
very religious family.
And in many ways his work is a reaction against the father,
and it is a reaction against the kind of Lutheran
Christianity he was deeply internalized into.
I think this is very important to understand.
I mean, I know that most of the people in this room have strong
feelings in Judeo-Christian tradition, and he attacks also
Judeo-Christian tradition.
This is a revolt against the father.
This is a revolt against what he was brought up to.
It is an attempt to find himself.
Right?
That's what he's trying to get at.
And you have to be a little tolerant about him,
you know, and his attempt.
You did that as well.
You were revolting against your parents, and you were revolting
against some of the fundamental principles you were born into.
He actually enrolls to the University of Bonn to become a
Lutheran minister himself.
He studied theology.
As it happens to many people actually who enroll into a
seminary, doesn't take him too long to become an atheist.
Very often the seminaries are the best training grounds for
atheists.
Right?
You're beginning to see somehow the complexity of theological
thought.
This is what he experienced.
So he quits after a year.
He realizes he is on his way to become an atheist--right?--and
he will not become a minister.
Actually this happened to my brother as well.
He actually did not quit, he did finish;
he was also trained as a Lutheran minister.
But by the end of his theological training he was--I
don't think he ever confessed--but he was actually
an atheist.
So I have personal experiences--right?--what
theology can do to you.
Right?
Okay, then '68, there is a very important event
in his life.
He meets the greatest composer of his time, Richard Wagner,
and they become great friends for a time, and they become
bitter enemies later on; and it is very important why
this happened.
He is appointed as Professor of Classical Philosophy at the
University of Basel, before he got actually his
degree.
But he doesn't do it for too long.
Right?
He's only teaching for eight years in his life,
and then he retreats and he sacrifices his life to scholarly
activity-- spends a lot of time in Italy
and, if he's in Switzerland, in a small, beautiful spot,
Sils Maria.
He also meets in '73 Paul Rée,
a German philosopher, who has a great deal of impact
on him, who introduces him in '82 to
Lou Salomé, his only real but very
passionate lover.
And I will say a few words about this later on.
In '88 he becomes mentally ill.
The story of his beginning of his mental illness tells you a
lot about him.
He is in Genoa, in Italy, and then he walks on
the streets, and then he sees a carriage driver beating a horse
vengefully.
And then he suddenly cuddles the horse, beginning to cry,
and his mind is gone.
All right?
He falls deeply into mental illness.
He never recovers anymore.
It I think tells a lot about who Nietzsche as a human being
was--right?--and how actually--how much compassion he
could have with suffering.
Right?
This work, what you were reading, has a lot to do with
suffering, and gives you a devastating view what human
suffering means.
Anyway, he's in care of his mother until she dies,
and then his care, unfortunately for him,
to his sister Elisabeth.
And he dies in her home in 1900.
Now a bit about Elisabeth Nietzsche.
Here she is.
She was born two years after Nietzsche.
And she married a guy whose name was Bernhard Förster,
in 1885.
And Förster was one of these proto-Nazis.
He was a fanatic anti-Semite.
He was very attracted to this idea of the superior Aryan race,
and he actually created an Aryan colony in Paraguay,
and moved with Elisabeth to Paraguay in a pure German
community.
Some remains still exist, and if you are a devoted
neo-Nazi, you may want to visit Paraguay,
because there are some of these guys here still hanging out
there.
They look like Indians, because of course not very pure
Aryan nation; they are not blonde and blue
eyes any longer.
They intermarried with the locals.
Right?
But anyway, this is what he wanted to do.
It didn't work very well.
So at one point he committed suicide and Elisabeth returned
to Germany.
Well I think it's very important that Nietzsche,
after she got married, broke the relationship with his
sister.
He just could not stand his brother-in-law and his
anti-Semitism.
Though you will see some of the citations which sound very
anti-Semitic, he was very intolerant about
anti-Semites.
This was one of the reasons why he broke his relationship with
Richard Wager.
But in '94, Elisabeth created the Nietzsche Archive.
Nietzsche was insane, and he had a lot of unpublished
work, manuscripts.
She put it together into an archives, and she abused it as
much as she could.
She turned into a right-winger and with the rise of Nazism a
Nazi, an admirer of Hitler.
And she put together a lot of Nietzsche texts,
in order to fabricate a Nazi ideology out of Nietzsche.
And some, therefore, had been reading for a very
long time Nietzsche as an ideologue of Nazism.
So did Adolph Hitler, who actually even attended the
funeral of Elisabeth in 1935, when she died.
Well I think people who read Nietzsche carefully,
and who have seen now Nietzsche's original work
published, rather than selections by
Elisabeth, have a great deal of doubt
whether Nietzsche has anything to do with Nazism.
Though the story is complicated.
Now here we come, a nice triangle:
Lou Salomé, Paul Rée and Friedrich
Nietzsche.
Well I should show this picture after Freud.
Remember that.
Watch on it; it is a very Freudian kind of
presentation, Louis Salomé,
Paul Rée in the middle, and Friedrich Nietzsche on the
other side of the picture.
Now Lou, Paul and Friedrich.
Paul Rée actually comes from a very wealthy Jewish
family, German Jewish family.
For reasons which is beyond me, occasionally Nietzsche refers
to him, when they already broke up,
as "the English psychologist";
he was a German philosopher.
Anyway, he became very good friends, at one point.
I mean, Nietzsche was an impossible person.
He'd fall in love with people and then he broke.
Just strong love or strong hatred;
there was nothing in between.
But anyway, the idea of genealogy, which is probably the
main piece in Nietzsche's work, is coming from Paul Rée.
Then he introduced this wonderful young,
and very smart young lady, Lou Salomé,
to Nietzsche, and he falls desperately in
love with her.
This happened in '82.
She was twenty-one-years-old--as I said,
very beautiful, and wonderfully smart.
And well Nietzsche was hoping to marry her;
I mean, he was opposed to the idea of marriage,
but he's writing letters to Paul Rée--
kind of not aware that there is a relationship going on between
Paul Rée and Lou-- that he wants to marry her,
probably for two years or something.
Anyway, I think by all likelihood there is an
interesting love triangle going on here for awhile.
But Nietzsche is impossible, and Lou is a sane woman,
and at one point she just cannot take his insanity
anymore.
And he moves to Berlin--lives for awhile with Paul Rée.
And then, though she is also opposed to marriage--we are
talking late nineteenth century, right?;
very radical ideas about sexuality and marriage--but then
she still married this guy, a linguist called Andreas.
Anyway, she was also a very smart woman.
She at one point said they wrote a book
together--Rée, Nietzsche, and herself--and she
never published that.
She said this one was an experiment, a joint book by the
three.
We never--as far as I know, it never had.
Another important person in his life: Richard Wagner.
Well Nietzsche was a music fanatic already in his boyhood,
and when he read Wagner's piano transcript of Tristan and
Isolde, he just fell in love with that.
That was the music he was looking for.
Why?
He was a hero worshipper.
That's why people, some people,
read still in him a kind of proto-Nazis.
He liked strong, beautiful people who are heroic
and do heroic acts; like the Greek. Right?
A beautiful young man, powerful, and heroic,
like the gods, the Greek gods;
that's what he really admired.
And this is what he found in Wagner's music,
a rejection of the roots of Rossini kind of sentimentalism
of Italian music, and in fact the classicism and
coldness and pretentiousness in the music of Beethoven.
And what he found is something new in Wagner.
So he was attracted to Wager.
And as he was becoming actually increasingly anti-Semitic,
under the influence of his last wife,
Cosima, who was the daughter of Franz Liszt,
the composer, and was really a pretty evil
person.
And also Wagner was changing.
He was becoming in some ways kind of more Christian or
something, and he was writing this--I actually have to
confess--lovely opera, Parsifal.
Well, Nietzsche could not take it.
You know?
It was impossible for him.
So then they break.
He could not stand Wagner's anti-Semitism,
and he could not stand Parsifal,
and a kind of expression of--I don't know,
anybody ever heard Parsifal?
No.
Well not easy stuff.
It sounds like an oratorium.
It has some Bachian kind of elements in it,
and it's about the sacrifice of the lamb of God;
Jesus' sacrifice, and a performance of the mass
and the cult of Jesus' blood, as such.
I mean, anyway this was certainly--Nietzsche was not a
buyer for it.
Well just a word about his first book, The Birth of the
Tragedy--which, as I said, he was a great
admirer of the Greek civilization.
And here he--his idea is that the whole human history is
driven by the struggle between a Dionysian and Apollonian
principle.
Dionysian means--right?--your sentiments, right?
You act out of your instincts.
And Apollonian means the reason, as such.
And the book contrasts Enlightenment.
Enlightenment is reason.
It's a victory of Apollonian principle over the Dionysian
principle.
And he kind of rejected--this is also why he's also kind of
post-Modern, right?--he rejects Enlightenment and Enlightenment
excessive rationalism.
And this is why actually he liked Wager, because he thought
in Wagner the Dionysian and the Apollonian components are being
combined.
Right?
Passion and reason are put together.
And Wagner loved the book.
Then he writes a book, 1879, Human,
All Too Human, which starts from Voltaire and
the sort of reification of the free thinkers.
Now he is a free thinker.
And he also breaks with Romanticism, and follows
Rée.
And he said, "Well what we have to do
is to subject the Christian idea of good and evil to critical
scrutiny, not to accept that there is
some general principle of good."
And therefore he tries to develop The Genealogy of
Morals.
Now, as you can see, Wagner and Nietzsche are on a
collision course.
Right?
Nietzsche is now subjecting the very core of Judeo-Christian
tradition to critical scrutiny, while Wagner is writing
Parsifal and being the Holy Grail and asceticism.
Wagner assumedly even has not read the book.
He heard about it and rejected it.
He did not buy anything about this.
Now this is Nietzsche's house in Sils Maria.
He went there for the first time in '81, fell in love with
this, and spent time there until he became ill.
He also wrote The Genealogy of Morals.
He wrote to his mother, "Finally I've found the
loveliest spot on earth."
And he was greatly inspired.
This is where he wrote the book Also sprach
Zarathustra, Thus Spoke Zarathustra.
This is a kind of a book which is a central attack on
Judeo-Christian morality, what he found repressive and
wants to get out of it.
His hero is Zarathustra, which is modeled after the
Persian prophet Zoroaster, and he calls him,
"The first of immoralists; to dare to be immoral is what
you have to do."
And he tries to find a middle way--right?--between the
repressive Judeo-Christian morality and nihilism.
He wants to get--doesn't want to reject everything.
And that's where he's beginning to develop the idea of the
Übermensch.
I wish
…
move into the twentieth century.
And there is a lot of similarity between the three
authors we will be discussing: Nietzsche, Freud and Max Weber.
You know, Durkheim will be a somewhat different kind of
story.
But all--I mean, Nietzsche, of course,
died in 1900, but he was out of action for
ten years because of mental illness, rather severe mental
illness.
He published all of his work in the nineteenth century.
Freud and Weber started to publish in the nineteenth
century.
But these three characters, in many ways,
are very important bridges towards twentieth century social
theory.
In a way they did foreshadow a great deal of theorizing,
particularly during the second half of the twentieth century,
especially in the last thirty or forty years.
I think it's also very easy to see the point of departure from
Marx-- some continuity,
but the basic point of department from Marx in the work
of Nietzsche, Freud, and Weber.
If I can put it very simply, the major departure is that
they all depart from Marx's economic reductionism--
right?--the emphasis on economic interest,
which is actually not only Marx.
Right?
It was common in Adam Smith, and Marx as well.
They depart from this and they emphasize that the problem in
modernity is not so much in the economic system;
it is much more in terms of power and consciousness.
The problem of modernity is repression, in one way or
another.
The problem of modern life is that we internalize the reasons
for our own subjugation, as such, and somehow we have to
figure out how to liberate ourselves from this internalized
subjugation.
Why do we obey orders?
Why do we actually accept that we are subjugated?
This is the central question, I think, Nietzsche,
Freud, and Weber are posing.
It's again a question which has not been really asked by the
other theorists we discussed so far.
They just had civil society as a point of reference for the
good society.
Now the problem for Nietzsche, Freud, and Weber is in us,
internally--in us, how we solve the problem within
ourselves.
So this is a kind of introducing the three authors.
In some ways one can say Nietzsche,
Freud, and Weber not only foreshadows twentieth century
social theory, but in some ways they are the
first of post-modern theorists-- right?--the theorists which are
beginning to come to terms with the oppressive nature of
modernity, and try to figure out how to
transcend that.
Now I think what I asked you to read for today is probably the
most difficult text for the semester,
The Genealogy of Morals, and you may have been greatly
frustrated by it, and probably also irritated by
it, because he's a very provocative mind.
I hope you did what I suggested; namely, you had a cursory
reading of the text before today,
and now you can go back to the text,
after my lecture notes, and I think that should help
you to find your way out and to see what he is really up to.
Now what is he up to?
Let me just foreshadow, before I get into his life and
work, and particularly in Genealogy of Morals.
There is another point in which Nietzsche, Freud,
and Weber can be understood in relationship to Marx.
In my very introductory comments, I emphasized the
difference--right?--the shift away from the economy to the
question of power and domination.
But there is a point at which there is a continuity between
them and Marx--Nietzsche, Freud and too mainly Weber;
I mean, Weber is a somewhat more complicated story.
But certainly Nietzsche and Freud are critical theorists;
critical theorists in the sense as we defined this earlier.
Right?
Critical theorists, that they are offering a
criticism of human consciousness.
What is in our mind and how did it get into our mind,
and how-- and the problem of our consciousness in
relationship to our existence.
And this is very much critical theory as it was defined by
Hegel and then the young Marx, the Hegelian Marx,
the Marx of Paris Manuscripts.
Right?
The Marx of alienation. Right?
This is very much coming from this tradition,
and the central issue is how can we subject this to critical
scrutiny?
And in Nietzsche's case, there is an incredible attempt
being made here to try to offer a critical theory which does not
really have a critical vantage point.
Right?
All critical theories of Hegel and Marx and twentieth century
critical theory do have an idea of a good society,
of an emancipated human existence, and they criticize
the reality, the society what they are
analyzing, from the point of view of this
critical vantage point.
Nietzsche is different.
He is really the most radical of critical theorists.
And in the twentieth century the theorist which builds the
most consistently on it is Michel Foucault--
right?--who tried to create a theory which is critical of
existence and our consciousness, but critical without telling
you what is good, what you should be aspiring for.
And that's exactly what Nietzsche is trying to do.
It is sort of the squaring of the circle.
Can you be critical of a situation if you cannot tell
what is the good outcome?
Right?
Can you actually subject the very notion of the good society,
the good, to critical scrutiny?
This is what he's trying to do.
Right?
To offer such a theory.
Well Freud is different. Right?
Freud is a critical theorist beyond Hegel and beyond Marx.
He does agree with Marx that we have to find some critical
analysis which is rooted in our sensuous experiences,
and somehow we have to relate the problems of our
consciousness to our sensuous experiences.
Right?
In this respect, Freud is very much in the line
of Marx's critique of Hegel.
This is not simply radicalizing your consciousness;
you have to confront your consciousness with your sensuous
experiences.
But he is different from Marx because--
I pointed this out earlier very briefly--
because in Marx, this sensuous activity is
production, it is economic activity.
For Freud it is our sexual experiences--
right?-and he offers a criticism of our consciousness
by confronting us with our repressed sexual experiences in
our earlier life.
Right?
So this is a critical theory.
Right?
He said, "What you think is in your mind is right.
No, no, no, it isn't."
Right?
You have to think about all of your experiences of your earlier
sexual life, and then when you figure out
what you repressed as bad memories,
that's when you will actually will be able to have a healthier
psychic life.
Right?
Well Weber is more complicated, and we will come back to this,
Weber's critical theory, when we get to Weber,
and to the question whether he's a critical theorist at all,
that has been highly debated.
Okay, I think now we are ready for Friedrich Nietzsche.
And I hope this makes more sense now for you--right?--what
you were reading.
Right?
And let me just emphasize one more time--
right?--the big project in Nietzsche is to offer a critical
scrutiny of human mind, but not to have any critical
vantage point.
Right?
To criticize the very principles of good society and
good, to critical scrutiny.
Where does it come from when we have the conception of good and
good society?
That is his project.
It's an incredible intellectual venture.
Right?
As I said, it is this kind of squaring of the circle,
what he does; what he does with a great deal
of power.
And he does it extremely provocatively.
I will put up a couple of quotations for it,
which are outrageous.
Don't walk out on it. Right?
Wait a little.
Hold your breath, listen.
This is outrageous what he's saying.
He's a provocateur.
He is like Rousseau; he is only worse than Rousseau.
Right?
He provokes us even more than Rousseau.
But, you know, deep down he's a very
sensitive--you know?--very humanistic human being.
Right?
He provokes you.
But if you listen carefully, you figure out there is
something what you actually can relate to it,
when you think what he's actually trying to get at.
All right, here is Nietzsche.
And let me just very briefly rush through his life.
He was born in 1844, in the small city of
Röcken in Germany, near Leipzig.
And this is very important: his father was a Lutheran
minister, and the family was all clergy, Lutheran clergy.
And he's bringing up, in a very religious sentiments,
very religious family.
And in many ways his work is a reaction against the father,
and it is a reaction against the kind of Lutheran
Christianity he was deeply internalized into.
I think this is very important to understand.
I mean, I know that most of the people in this room have strong
feelings in Judeo-Christian tradition, and he attacks also
Judeo-Christian tradition.
This is a revolt against the father.
This is a revolt against what he was brought up to.
It is an attempt to find himself.
Right?
That's what he's trying to get at.
And you have to be a little tolerant about him,
you know, and his attempt.
You did that as well.
You were revolting against your parents, and you were revolting
against some of the fundamental principles you were born into.
He actually enrolls to the University of Bonn to become a
Lutheran minister himself.
He studied theology.
As it happens to many people actually who enroll into a
seminary, doesn't take him too long to become an atheist.
Very often the seminaries are the best training grounds for
atheists.
Right?
You're beginning to see somehow the complexity of theological
thought.
This is what he experienced.
So he quits after a year.
He realizes he is on his way to become an atheist--right?--and
he will not become a minister.
Actually this happened to my brother as well.
He actually did not quit, he did finish;
he was also trained as a Lutheran minister.
But by the end of his theological training he was--I
don't think he ever confessed--but he was actually
an atheist.
So I have personal experiences--right?--what
theology can do to you.
Right?
Okay, then '68, there is a very important event
in his life.
He meets the greatest composer of his time, Richard Wagner,
and they become great friends for a time, and they become
bitter enemies later on; and it is very important why
this happened.
He is appointed as Professor of Classical Philosophy at the
University of Basel, before he got actually his
degree.
But he doesn't do it for too long.
Right?
He's only teaching for eight years in his life,
and then he retreats and he sacrifices his life to scholarly
activity-- spends a lot of time in Italy
and, if he's in Switzerland, in a small, beautiful spot,
Sils Maria.
He also meets in '73 Paul Rée,
a German philosopher, who has a great deal of impact
on him, who introduces him in '82 to
Lou Salomé, his only real but very
passionate lover.
And I will say a few words about this later on.
In '88 he becomes mentally ill.
The story of his beginning of his mental illness tells you a
lot about him.
He is in Genoa, in Italy, and then he walks on
the streets, and then he sees a carriage driver beating a horse
vengefully.
And then he suddenly cuddles the horse, beginning to cry,
and his mind is gone.
All right?
He falls deeply into mental illness.
He never recovers anymore.
It I think tells a lot about who Nietzsche as a human being
was--right?--and how actually--how much compassion he
could have with suffering.
Right?
This work, what you were reading, has a lot to do with
suffering, and gives you a devastating view what human
suffering means.
Anyway, he's in care of his mother until she dies,
and then his care, unfortunately for him,
to his sister Elisabeth.
And he dies in her home in 1900.
Now a bit about Elisabeth Nietzsche.
Here she is.
She was born two years after Nietzsche.
And she married a guy whose name was Bernhard Förster,
in 1885.
And Förster was one of these proto-Nazis.
He was a fanatic anti-Semite.
He was very attracted to this idea of the superior Aryan race,
and he actually created an Aryan colony in Paraguay,
and moved with Elisabeth to Paraguay in a pure German
community.
Some remains still exist, and if you are a devoted
neo-Nazi, you may want to visit Paraguay,
because there are some of these guys here still hanging out
there.
They look like Indians, because of course not very pure
Aryan nation; they are not blonde and blue
eyes any longer.
They intermarried with the locals.
Right?
But anyway, this is what he wanted to do.
It didn't work very well.
So at one point he committed suicide and Elisabeth returned
to Germany.
Well I think it's very important that Nietzsche,
after she got married, broke the relationship with his
sister.
He just could not stand his brother-in-law and his
anti-Semitism.
Though you will see some of the citations which sound very
anti-Semitic, he was very intolerant about
anti-Semites.
This was one of the reasons why he broke his relationship with
Richard Wager.
But in '94, Elisabeth created the Nietzsche Archive.
Nietzsche was insane, and he had a lot of unpublished
work, manuscripts.
She put it together into an archives, and she abused it as
much as she could.
She turned into a right-winger and with the rise of Nazism a
Nazi, an admirer of Hitler.
And she put together a lot of Nietzsche texts,
in order to fabricate a Nazi ideology out of Nietzsche.
And some, therefore, had been reading for a very
long time Nietzsche as an ideologue of Nazism.
So did Adolph Hitler, who actually even attended the
funeral of Elisabeth in 1935, when she died.
Well I think people who read Nietzsche carefully,
and who have seen now Nietzsche's original work
published, rather than selections by
Elisabeth, have a great deal of doubt
whether Nietzsche has anything to do with Nazism.
Though the story is complicated.
Now here we come, a nice triangle:
Lou Salomé, Paul Rée and Friedrich
Nietzsche.
Well I should show this picture after Freud.
Remember that.
Watch on it; it is a very Freudian kind of
presentation, Louis Salomé,
Paul Rée in the middle, and Friedrich Nietzsche on the
other side of the picture.
Now Lou, Paul and Friedrich.
Paul Rée actually comes from a very wealthy Jewish
family, German Jewish family.
For reasons which is beyond me, occasionally Nietzsche refers
to him, when they already broke up,
as "the English psychologist";
he was a German philosopher.
Anyway, he became very good friends, at one point.
I mean, Nietzsche was an impossible person.
He'd fall in love with people and then he broke.
Just strong love or strong hatred;
there was nothing in between.
But anyway, the idea of genealogy, which is probably the
main piece in Nietzsche's work, is coming from Paul Rée.
Then he introduced this wonderful young,
and very smart young lady, Lou Salomé,
to Nietzsche, and he falls desperately in
love with her.
This happened in '82.
She was twenty-one-years-old--as I said,
very beautiful, and wonderfully smart.
And well Nietzsche was hoping to marry her;
I mean, he was opposed to the idea of marriage,
but he's writing letters to Paul Rée--
kind of not aware that there is a relationship going on between
Paul Rée and Lou-- that he wants to marry her,
probably for two years or something.
Anyway, I think by all likelihood there is an
interesting love triangle going on here for awhile.
But Nietzsche is impossible, and Lou is a sane woman,
and at one point she just cannot take his insanity
anymore.
And he moves to Berlin--lives for awhile with Paul Rée.
And then, though she is also opposed to marriage--we are
talking late nineteenth century, right?;
very radical ideas about sexuality and marriage--but then
she still married this guy, a linguist called Andreas.
Anyway, she was also a very smart woman.
She at one point said they wrote a book
together--Rée, Nietzsche, and herself--and she
never published that.
She said this one was an experiment, a joint book by the
three.
We never--as far as I know, it never had.
Another important person in his life: Richard Wagner.
Well Nietzsche was a music fanatic already in his boyhood,
and when he read Wagner's piano transcript of Tristan and
Isolde, he just fell in love with that.
That was the music he was looking for.
Why?
He was a hero worshipper.
That's why people, some people,
read still in him a kind of proto-Nazis.
He liked strong, beautiful people who are heroic
and do heroic acts; like the Greek. Right?
A beautiful young man, powerful, and heroic,
like the gods, the Greek gods;
that's what he really admired.
And this is what he found in Wagner's music,
a rejection of the roots of Rossini kind of sentimentalism
of Italian music, and in fact the classicism and
coldness and pretentiousness in the music of Beethoven.
And what he found is something new in Wagner.
So he was attracted to Wager.
And as he was becoming actually increasingly anti-Semitic,
under the influence of his last wife,
Cosima, who was the daughter of Franz Liszt,
the composer, and was really a pretty evil
person.
And also Wagner was changing.
He was becoming in some ways kind of more Christian or
something, and he was writing this--I actually have to
confess--lovely opera, Parsifal.
Well, Nietzsche could not take it.
You know?
It was impossible for him.
So then they break.
He could not stand Wagner's anti-Semitism,
and he could not stand Parsifal,
and a kind of expression of--I don't know,
anybody ever heard Parsifal?
No.
Well not easy stuff.
It sounds like an oratorium.
It has some Bachian kind of elements in it,
and it's about the sacrifice of the lamb of God;
Jesus' sacrifice, and a performance of the mass
and the cult of Jesus' blood, as such.
I mean, anyway this was certainly--Nietzsche was not a
buyer for it.
Well just a word about his first book, The Birth of the
Tragedy--which, as I said, he was a great
admirer of the Greek civilization.
And here he--his idea is that the whole human history is
driven by the struggle between a Dionysian and Apollonian
principle.
Dionysian means--right?--your sentiments, right?
You act out of your instincts.
And Apollonian means the reason, as such.
And the book contrasts Enlightenment.
Enlightenment is reason.
It's a victory of Apollonian principle over the Dionysian
principle.
And he kind of rejected--this is also why he's also kind of
post-Modern, right?--he rejects Enlightenment and Enlightenment
excessive rationalism.
And this is why actually he liked Wager, because he thought
in Wagner the Dionysian and the Apollonian components are being
combined.
Right?
Passion and reason are put together.
And Wagner loved the book.
Then he writes a book, 1879, Human,
All Too Human, which starts from Voltaire and
the sort of reification of the free thinkers.
Now he is a free thinker.
And he also breaks with Romanticism, and follows
Rée.
And he said, "Well what we have to do
is to subject the Christian idea of good and evil to critical
scrutiny, not to accept that there is
some general principle of good."
And therefore he tries to develop The Genealogy of
Morals.
Now, as you can see, Wagner and Nietzsche are on a
collision course.
Right?
Nietzsche is now subjecting the very core of Judeo-Christian
tradition to critical scrutiny, while Wagner is writing
Parsifal and being the Holy Grail and asceticism.
Wagner assumedly even has not read the book.
He heard about it and rejected it.
He did not buy anything about this.
Now this is Nietzsche's house in Sils Maria.
He went there for the first time in '81, fell in love with
this, and spent time there until he became ill.
He also wrote The Genealogy of Morals.
He wrote to his mother, "Finally I've found the
loveliest spot on earth."
And he was greatly inspired.
This is where he wrote the book Also sprach
Zarathustra, Thus Spoke Zarathustra.
This is a kind of a book which is a central attack on
Judeo-Christian morality, what he found repressive and
wants to get out of it.
His hero is Zarathustra, which is modeled after the
Persian prophet Zoroaster, and he calls him,
"The first of immoralists; to dare to be immoral is what
you have to do."
And he tries to find a middle way--right?--between the
repressive Judeo-Christian morality and nihilism.
He wants to get--doesn't want to reject everything.
And that's where he's beginning to develop the idea of the
Übermensch.
I wish
…