YouSub
Untitled

en English

Untitled English subtitles

0 downloads · 845 lines · added Nov 26, 2015

Report a problem
What's wrong?
Advertisement

English transcript

Prof: So good morning.
Well today we have a fun topic: suicide.
Actually I didn't realize how much interest there is amongst
students in suicide.
Once we invited a professor from Australia,
who wanted to teach a course on death and suicide,
and I was very concerned that no students will take it;
and the class was full.
So it looks like suicide is a popular topic.
And I think I know why.
Because when I was your age, occasionally it occurred to my
mind, what if I commit suicide?
Right?
So I think thinking about suicide is probably something
what crossed many of yours mind.
And therefore hopefully Durkheim will be exciting for
you, and will help you to understand why did you consider
it and why you did not do it?
Right?
Or why your friends or acquaintances thought about it.
Some of them may have tried; some may have killed themselves.
Anyway, so this is about Suicide.
And as I said already before, this is a path-breaking book,
in many ways.
It's really the first rigorous empirical study of a social
phenomenon-- and a very curious social
phenomenon, and we will talk about this as
the lecture unfolds.
Because we tend to think about suicide as something very
personal--right?--and individual.
And all right, if a psychologist is interested
in suicide, it's understandable.
But why on earth a sociologist would be interested in suicide?
It is so rare, socially, fortunately--I mean,
not in some societies, but in most,
very rare.
And it looks like it's so much a question of individual
decision.
So why should a social scientist try to explain it?
So Durkheim sets for himself a very difficult task,
and he does it formidably.
I will show you that he does some spectacular methodological
innovations.
He kind of offers methodological insights,
what social scientists are excited about,
even today, well over a century after he published this book.
Okay, so that's about Suicide.
And first of all, I will ask a few general
questions.
And first of all, the question is what is
suicide?
When do we decide that a death is suicide?
And then also I would like to pose the question,
what are the reasons for social scientists to study it?
And Durkheim gives some very good reasons.
And finally, I will introduce Durkheim's
typology of suicide.
Many Durkheim scholars were struggling with this,
how to make sense of this typology?
And I will show you one way how to do it.
Sort of there are--his major types are egoistic,
altruistic, anomic and fatalistic suicide,
and I will talk about each of them in turn.
Okay, so let me start with the definition.
And this is tricky, by the way.
Also it's extremely tricky, when it comes to statistics,
to figure out what statistics do report as suicide.
When people die, especially if they do not leave
a letter behind, it's very hard to decide
whether that person actually committed suicide or it was just
an accident.
Well there are occasions when this is quite obvious.
Right?
Somebody's hanging himself, or herself,--
which is a favorite way of committing suicide,
of a certain type of people, in certain instances,
right?--and the way how somebody hanged himself makes it
quite clear that it was a suicide.
But doctors investigating the cause of death very often are
puzzled whether this is suicide or not.
So you clearly have an overdose of sleeping pills;
it's unclear whether it was an accident, accidentally you took
more pills that you should have, or whether this was actually a
suicide.
So there is a lot of problem in studying statistical data about
suicide, and very often doctors do make
judgments on the social circumstances of the person who
committed suicide.
Right?
They read Durkheim, or they have read some social
scientist.
They tell these are the kind of people, under these
circumstances, who commit suicide.
So they go to the scene, they look at the dead person,
look at the circumstances.
This is an old man whose wife just passed away very recently.
So that must be, of course, suicide.
Right?
So therefore what is suicide is being defined by the
circumstances, rather than actually by the
medical reasons.
Okay, so let's try to struggle a little bit this,
what is suicide; under what circumstances can we
talk about suicide?
And here is Durkheim's definition.
"The term suicide"-- right?--"is applied to all
cases of deaths resulting directly,
or indirectly, a positive or a negative act of
the victim himself, which he knows will produce
these results."
Well looks like a very complicated definition,
but a very full and a very good one.
And the first point is intention.
Right?
That in order to call a death suicide, there must be intention
on behalf of the person who commits suicide.
Well this intention can be varied.
Well the aim might not be necessarily self-destruction.
The aim may be something else.
For instance, you can think about suicide
bombers.
Right?
They don't want to kill themselves;
they want to kill others, but they use their body as a
weapon--right?--and they explode themselves in order to cause
harm to others.
Right?
But that's clearly a case of suicide,
because they know that they will die as a consequence of
their action, and therefore it can be called
suicide, though it is not aimed at the
person himself.
Well the act of suicide can be indirect, and in fact it can be
negative.
Sort of you--most suicide is a direct and positive action.
Right?
You jump from the fortieth floor--right?--and then you kill
yourself.
You take sleeping pills, an overdose,
and you kill yourself.
But it can be indirect and negative;
I mean, you can starve yourself to death, and that can be called
suicide, as long as your intention is to kill yourself.
Right?
So it becomes very tricky.
What do you do with people who are abusing drugs or alcohol?
Right?
They may actually die as a result of excessive alcohol or
drug consumption.
If it is not intentional, they don't want to kill
themselves; they just like
boozing--right?--they just like cocaine--right?--then it is not
suicide.
Right?
There are lots of Russians who have been dying in the last
thirty-five years; their numbers--especially
middle-age Russian men were dying like flies because they
are drinking too much vodka.
In the overwhelming majority of the cases, this is not suicide.
Right?
They are depressed; they are silly,
they think drinking vodka will help their depression,
and as a result they will get liver cancer and they will die.
Right?
So it was not suicide.
Well, if you lock yourself into your room, you take sleeping
pills and you drink a bottle of vodka in order to kill yourself,
then it was suicide.
Right?
So anyway, you have to know the consequences of your action.
You have to know that what you do will kill yourself,
in order for your act to qualify as a suicide.
So I think this is really beautifully done,
and has been extremely influential for social
scientists.
As I said, it makes a very big challenge to medical
investigators who try to determine the cause of death,
because it's very difficult to establish the intention.
Right?
And in most of the cases of suicide, you cannot be
absolutely sure of the intention.
You don't know whether this was an accident or whether it was
intentional, unless the victim of the
suicide will tell you, leaves a letter behind and
tells that I committed suicide.
Okay.
Well, as I said, it looks like that suicide is
very much a very personal action.
Right?
Well occasionally people talk about their intention to commit
suicide.
When and if they do so, they probably will not do it.
Right?
Those who are serious about suicide keep it to themselves,
and then kill themselves.
Those who talk about "I'm suicidal",
very often simply want to have attention.
Right?
And then even if they attempt suicide, often it's kind of
fake.
They're smart enough, they just take a little
overdose of sleeping pills, but not too much.
Because they already told they are suicidal--right?--their
friend rushes them to the hospital and they will be all
right.
Right?
So anyway, it's a very individual act.
You usually keep your intention to commit suicide to yourself,
rather than discussing with somebody else.
And it looks like taking your life away is really your own
business.
So the question is, why on earth people who study
society should be interested in this very individual,
very private act?
And well he said, "Look at,
for instance, the suicide rate,
how it varies across countries."
And he said there is a tremendous difference in suicide
rate across countries.
There are countries with very low, and there are other
countries with very, very high suicide rates,
relatively speaking.
Suicide is nowhere the top-ranking cause of death,
though in some countries, in certain age groups,
it can easily enter the top five causes of death.
And, on top of this, those countries where people
commit suicide tend to be countries where people committed
suicide for a long time.
It's a very stable indicator.
Scandinavian countries are ones where usually the suicide rate
is reasonably high.
My native Hungary is a country which for a very long time was
proud of being number one in committing suicide.
Right?
Well incidentally--this is not in Durkheim,
but if I may add to this--there were people who were--
of course, Durkheim inspired, and still inspires,
a lot of research on suicide.
He has been challenged on many questions, but he is still,
after 110 years, the agenda-setter on suicide
research.
If any one of you become a biologist, a sociologist,
a doctor, and want to conduct research on suicide,
you will have to cite Durkheim.
Right?
You have to start from Durkheim if you are studying this.
Well anyway, there were people inspired by
him and looked further inside countries.
And what is interesting, that within countries there are
actually gigantic differences between regions.
There are some regions in these countries with very high,
and some regions of these countries with relatively low
suicide rates, and these are pretty constant
as such.
Well I had a colleague--as I said,
it's probably not too parochial for me to refer to Hungary,
because now Hungary is I think only number two or three in the
world, in suicide rate,
but has been number one for a century.
So anyway, I had a colleague who did a detailed study in
Hungary about suicide, inspired by Durkheim,
and found that there were certain regions in the country
where the suicide rates were particularly high--
as well it was low.
And he actually could identify the type of people who committed
suicide and the way how they committed suicide,
for instance.
And that has been stable for a century, as far as it was
possible to go back in statistics.
Just to give you an example--and it will also help
us when we are looking at Durkheim's typology of suicide.
For instance, he found that male farmers,
old male farmers, living in detached farms,
when their wife passes away unexpectedly--
women are expected to live longer than men,
right?--when their wife passes away unexpectedly,
the typical way what men does: they hang themselves in the
attic; and this happens again and
again.
Detached farms, old men, wife died,
people go up and hang themselves.
Right?
Suicide, to put in another way, is a way of dying.
Right?
There are some circumstances in which in certain societies you
know that this is the answer to your problem,
that you commit suicide.
Right?
If you are a man--we are usually pretty dumb,
we don't know how to cook, we don't know how to take care
of ourselves-- you are old,
your wife died, so what do you do?
You commit suicide--right?--under certain
circumstances.
Right?
Anyway, I think this is a--this is why it makes it interesting--
right?--for social scientists, that there are interesting
social patterns, cultural patterns,
how people commit suicide.
And Durkheim will work on this as much.
And then he said there are, in fact, large,
big historical events, which do have an impact on
suicide rates.
You would think if there is a big social turmoil,
then suicide rate will go up.
You are wrong.
If there is a big social turmoil, suicide rate tends to
be going down, because there is--in times of
revolution, people don't commit suicide.
Anyway, his point is that suicide is a collective
phenomenon.
Right?
Somehow it is socially determined as a phenomenon.
Okay, now this is the typology of suicide.
And I have been struggling with this, and people who know much
more about Durkheim have been struggling with this typology.
And what of course I was trying to do,
as others were trying to do, to do a 2 x 2 table--
right?--and to put these types of suicide in this 2 x 2 table.
Durkheim, in writing about suicide, seemed to make a
distinction between the question of integration and regulation.
Right?
Integration means how tightly organized a group or society is
in which you live.
Right?
And as I already pointed out in the earlier
lecture--right?--Durkheim has this idea of normal versus
pathological.
And I will talk about this in more detail in the last lecture
on Durkheim's methodology.
He has this interesting idea that what is normal is the kind
of typical.
To put it very crudely, normal is kind of the average.
If it is too much or too little, this is pathological or
abnormal; that is the idea.
So therefore one dimension in which he uses the typology is
integration--right?--how well integrated we are into a social
group we are in.
And that can be too high or it can be too low.
Right?
And both too high integration and too low integration can be
the cause of social pathologies.
And one of the social pathologies is that you kill
yourself.
Right?
And the other dimension is regulation;
how much, how tight, how rigorous the norms are
which regulates your behavior.
Again, it can be too high or it can be too low.
And it will affect also the pathologies.
If you are away from the golden middle road--that's what
Durkheim's idea of modernity is.
If you are on the golden middle road, then you are normal.
If you deviate, you are abnormal.
This is a very problematic proposition in Durkheim,
and has been challenged.
Well the big trouble is, are these two dimensions
independent from each other, or they overlap?
And it's really they are not really completely independent
from each other.
This is why you could not put this into a 2 x 2 table--
right?--because some of the types of abnormalities can be
only understood in integration or in terms of regulation.
But anyway, I think this is probably the best way I can come
up with, or in the Durkheim literature
the best way I have read, basically using these two
dimensions as-- not as a 2 x 2 table;
sort of, to put it this way, rather than a 2 x 2 table,
it's like two dimensions.
Right?
And then you have the two types over here.
Right?
Too high and too low--right?--and you have
integration and you have regulation.
And high and low and high and low;
this is how you can do it.
Right?
You can conceptualize it.
But it doesn't work, you put it in a normal 2 x 2
table.
Okay.
Well let me start to talk about egoistic suicide.
Right?
And therefore--right?--egoistic suicide has something to do with
social integration, and it is a case when the
social integration is too low.
And he said, well the more weakened the
group to which the person who committed suicide belongs,
the less he depends on them.
And he calls this egoism. Right?
If you don't--you are yourself and you are not--do not feel
responsible to your own group, and therefore you may be
committing suicide.
Again, people who are considering suicide--
just to show the lack of egoism and the importance of the
group-- well you may think you have a
good enough reason to kill yourself: "My life doesn't
have any purpose."
"My boy or girlfriend left me, so therefore I'd rather kill
myself."
And then they say, "Well I can't really do
this to Mom."
Right?
"I cannot disappoint my parents."
Right?
So therefore you are not--you cannot act egoistically.
Right?
You belong to a group, and because the tightness,
the solidarity with the group prevents you to commit suicide.
So in order to act egoistically means that you don't care about
others, or you care first of all about yourself,
as such.
Well the solidarity can be different.
It can be religion, it can be family,
or it can be the society.
And let me speak to this.
And if this religion, family or society,
as such, offers sufficient solidarity, then you will not be
likely to commit suicide.
Okay, so let me talk about religion and suicide,
and also a bit about how religion and education are
linked together with suicide.
Durkheim does here something really path-breaking.
Though the statistical technologies were not available,
he really does the logic of multivariate statistical
analysis.
He almost does a regression model, to put it this way,
without numbers.
But that's the logic of the argument.
And then he's talking about what he calls the Jewish
exceptionalism.
Well this will be interesting, because the fundamental idea is
that, in fact, generally people who
are more educated are more likely to commit suicide.
Right?
There is also a relationship between religion and suicide.
Protestants are more likely to commit suicide;
Catholics less likely to commit suicide.
Catholics are less educated; Protestants are more educated.
Being more educated, the Protestant,
makes you more susceptible to commit suicide,
he argues.
But Jews are an exception.
Because Jewish suicide rate is generally very low,
and Jews are very highly educated.
So that's the Jewish puzzle.
Right?
Why on earth highly educated Jews don't kill themselves?
If you are--right?--a Lutheran, or a Presbyterian,
and you are educated, you kill yourself.
Right?
Why Jews don't? Right?
That's the puzzle.
What is the relationship between education and religion?
And why on earth education leads to a higher level of
suicide?
Right?
Okay, let me therefore start with this one.
Well as I said, he generally finds that there
is a higher rate of suicide among Protestants,
and lower rates among Catholics, and Jews have the
lowest suicide rates among the Judeo-Christian sphere of the
world; that's what he studied,
the European countries.
In fact, Islamic suicide rate is also low.
Well, one possible easy answer would be that there are stricter
penalties if you are Catholic and if you commit suicide;
that's why you don't commit suicide.
Right?
But that's not quite true, Durkheim argues.
Right?
In fact, all religions are against suicide;
no religion allows suicide.
Well Roman Catholics may be a little more rigorous about it.
You do not a get a religious burial.
I think most Roman Catholic priests would not bury somebody
who committed suicide, in most countries,
while Protestant ministers may perform a burial ceremony.
But I don't think if you commit suicide that really you are all
that concerned where and how you will be buried.
Right?
Now, so the question is why?
Right?
The first answer, that some religions prohibit
suicide more than others is not very persuasive,
because all religions prohibit suicide.
Well, and here he comes with the idea of integration.
He said Protestantism is a less strongly integrated church than
the Catholic Church--less of a community.
And Judaism actually even more tightly integrated,
even more so of a community.
So therefore it leaves relatively little room for
egoistic suicide, because the high level of
integration.
And here the rank order is a relatively low level among
Protestants, higher level among Catholics, and particularly high
among Jews.
Well how on earth comes education into the picture?
Well he says as the common and customary prejudice is
weakening, there is an increase in the trend of suicide.
Well it's not exactly prejudice in the most conventional sense
of the term, what he's referring to.
He's referring here to the question what we kind of
overcome with education, generally speaking.
Right?
That if you are becoming more educated, you will have less of
accepted doctrines.
Right?
Education--right?--is a critical exercise.
Right?
That's what I was trying to do in this course--
right?
…

Need subtitles from another video?