Advertisement
English transcript
Most people, when asked about the quality of the PowerPoint presentations that they've
observed, would probably agree that most PowerPoint presentations are terrible, life-sucking wastes
of time. A lot of this has to do with the fact that most people are never taught to
use PowerPoint effectively. “Hey, you know and use a computer; you should have no problem
making a good PowerPoint presentation.” The truth is, developing effective slides
to accompany a presentation takes time and effort, and a little bit of knowledge of multimedia
learning theory doesn't hurt either. In this video I’m going to be introducing the Assertion-Evidence
Structure or AES for slide design. This is a model for structuring slides developed by
Michael Alley and his colleagues at Penn State University. As an overview, we’ll start
by examining the weaknesses of typical PowerPoint slide layouts. We’ll briefly discuss the
contributions that research in multimedia learning theory and cognitive psychology can
provide to our quest for better slides. And finally explain the Assertion-Evidence Structure
and how to use it to increase the effectiveness of your slides.
It turns out that if you have viewed any number of PowerPoint presentations, and at this point
in your career you've probably seen hundreds, it's pretty easy to identify the more effective
design when given two alternatives. But it's really difficult to just start by designing
that more effective slide. In truth, most people have never really thought seriously
about how to design effective PowerPoint presentations. For example, over here we can see a typical
topic-bullet point structure slide about the relative approach to business valuation. You
can probably tell that this second example where we’ve set off the headline from the
body of the slide is a little bit more effective. We might have a little bit more aesthetic
appeal if we add some relevant photographs, and maybe even remove the background from
those photographs, or use highlights to draw attention to the important characteristics
of our slide. But in truth, slides that contain as much text as that first example really
are ineffective. We’re going to be talking a little bit more about why this is in the
remainder of this presentation.
Let's start though by examining why it is that so many PowerPoint presentation slides
are so very ineffective. It starts with the fact that the defaults in PowerPoint don't
do us any favors. Remember that PowerPoint was developed in 1983 and was largely seen
as a vast improvement over typical overhead projectors with transparencies. But unfortunately
because we were moving from overhead projectors and transparencies to a computer-based medium;
those who were using it most often didn't really think about the additional abilities
that computer graphics provided. And so, for the most part, those default layouts that
we see with the topic-bullet point design in PowerPoint are the same types of things
that people were doing with an overhead projector and a transparency. This topic-subtopics structure
that's guided by the default slide layouts in PowerPoint is pervasive across presentation
contexts. For example, one study in the 2009 published in the journal Technical Communication
showed that 59% of industry and government presentations use this topic-subtopic structure.
63% of professional conferences; and 71% of student presentation slides, in their content
analysis, used this default topic-subtopic or topic-bullet point structure.
Well, there are a few problems with this. First, even if you have a professional theme
and relevant images on your slide, there is still way too much text in a typical default
slide layout. There are a few reasons why this large amount of text is a problem. First,
Harvard Business Review in 1998 published an article arguing that bullet lists as are
typically used in these topic-subtopics structure slides dilute thought. Essentially they make
us stupider and they make our presentations stupider because topics and bullet points
can only communicate three logical relationships. We can talk about sequence. First this happened,
then this happened, then this other thing happened. Or we can talk about priority; these
are our most important goals for the quarter. Or we can talk about membership; here is a
general topic and hear a bunch of facts that are sort of related to this general topic.
But the truth is, in our presentations often were talking about information that has relationships
that are far more complex than simply sequence, priority, or membership. But using the default
layouts in PowerPoint doesn't afford us the ability to explain these complex relationships
to our audience. But beyond simply diluting our thought and hindering us from explaining
complex relationships between ideas to our audience; presenters often, when faced with
lots of text on the screen are obligated to read that to the audience.
We have a need to read text when we see it. And our audience has a need to read that text
as well. So presenters often mirror the information on their slide with their oral presentation.
Unfortunately, cognitive psychology tells us that simultaneous speech and text are processed
by the same part of the brain; which ultimately splits attention. Now it might seem to make
intuitive sense. If you hear information you might remember it, and if you see information
you might remember it. So if you both hear and see information you ought to remember
it the best. But it turns out that research has shown this to be entirely incorrect. Researchers
in cognitive psychology, human learning, and multimedia design have found that presenting
information through both channels simultaneously overwhelms the language processor and actually
results in lower information retention. In research published in the academic journal
Applied Cognitive Psychology, Slava Kalyuga and colleagues conducted an experiment in
which they varied the presentation medium of training materials designed to teach apprentices
about types of solder and how to correctly solder various types of joints. Some participants
received written instructions only. Some received written instructions and also were read those
instructions orally. And some received instructions only orally. Well turns out, and you can see
from the graph over here, that overall, the lowest performing condition was that simultaneous
text and speech condition. It simply was overwhelming the language-processing part of the brain
to have both the information presented as written text and as spoken language. And unfortunately,
most of our PowerPoint presentations are right in this part of the graph. Simultaneous text
and speech. In reality, this research suggests that where we really want to be, is to have
most of our presentation delivered orally, through spoken speech. And this tracks well
with what we know about models of human working memory. Baddeley’s model of working memory
suggests that when we receive information through our senses are Central Executive sends
it to one of two places: either the Visuospatial Sketchpad which processes images and visual
information, or, to the Phonological Loop which processes language. We know that linguistic
information whether it’s presented in a text-based form that a person can read or
in spoken form, both types of information are processed by the Phonological Loop. This
model of working memory would suggest that we are overloading the Phonological Loop when
we are simultaneously presenting both written and spoken information. So, what can be done
about this? We know that the typical topic-subtopic structure provides too much text for the audience;
overwhelms the Phonological Loop. What can we do instead? Well, one alternative is called
the Assertion-Evidence Structure. This was developed by Michael Alley and his colleagues
at Penn State University. And it calls for a complete rethinking of the way that slides
should be designed. Rather than starting with a topic-based headline, he suggests starting
with a full-sentence Assertion. So actually tell the audience what the most important
information on your slide is. Here we can see a typical topic-bullet point slide about
the history of the iPhone. If we were to convert that to an Assertion-Evidence Structure slide
we might instead see something like this. Getting rid of the history of the iPhone topic-based
headline and replacing it with of full-sentence Assertion, “The iPhone has received four
major updates since its introduction in June 2007.” Then, rather than simply listing
the model numbers and the dates that they were released, we might visually orient the
audience using a timeline. That would provide them not only with the dates that each model
was released, but also with an image of each model so we can see the progression of the
model over time, and using a timeline, we can also see additional information like the
approximate duration of time between model releases, and the approximate time of year
that new models come out. All of this provides the audience with a much richer understanding
of the relationship between the pieces of information on the slide. And that's one of
the key strengths of the Assertion-Evidence Structure. But beyond simply allowing you
to provide your audience with a more complex understanding of the relationship between
the information points on your slide; the Assertion-Evidence Structure also provides
much better retention for the audience. One study was conducted, published in the journal
Technical Communication in 2006, that showed that simply replacing non-full-sentence Assertion
headlines with full-sentence Assertion headlines drastically improved the recall of students
who were then tested on this information later. You can see here that this example of a slide
used in a college-level geology class, more than doubled student recall simply by turning
that headline into a full-sentence Assertion headline. Similarly, this one about color
in diamonds, by changing that headline from a question about what causes color in diamonds
and instead explaining in the headline itself the things that cause color in diamonds, again
resulted in a doubling of performance when later tested about that information. So the
Assertion-Evidence Structure gives us the ability to represent more complex relationships
between ideas. It focuses the audience on the most important information that they should
take out of each section of the presentation. And finally, it results in much better retention
of your audience for the information that you’re presenting.
So now the question is, how do you implement the Assertion-Evidence Structure in your own
slides? There are three primary characteristics of the Assertion-Evidence Structure. It starts
with the guideline that all blocks of text on your slide should be no more than two lines
high. Now this guidance forces you to really think carefully about what text is important
to include on your slide. So, beyond your two-line Assertion headline, if you have any
other text on the slide: whether that's a callout, or a label of various parts of a
diagram, or any other text on the slide, all blocks should be no more than two lines. That
reduces the amount of time that your audience spends reading your slide and not listening
to what you're saying. The second key characteristic of an Assertion-Evidence Structure slide is
that the slide body should provide visual evidence that clearly supports the Assertion.
And finally, if you use animation in an Assertion-Evidence slide it should be purposeful. So it should
actually help the audience better understand the information on the slide. So for example
here's a slide that was developed by one of my students that I think is an exemplary Assertion-Evidence
Structure slide. We have a two-line Assertion headline that claims that “Construction
of the Autobahn highway system accelerated with the expansion of Nazi Germany”. On
the left we have a graph that shows the number of miles completed on the Autobahn by year.
And on the right we have a map that shows German controlled territories in Europe. So
as we step through, we have very purposeful animation so that we can see as the Autobahn
gets longer and longer we have an increasingly powerful Germany in terms of the amount of
area in Europe that they control. So we have visual evidence that is supporting a key Assertion.
So when you think about the Assertion-Evidence Structure think about: no more than two lines
in a headline that makes an Assertion, makes a claim. And then visual evidence that supports
the claim made in the headline.
One thing that you'll find when you first start using the Assertion-Evidence Structure
is that it takes a little bit more time to carefully develop your Assertion headlines.
So for example, a typical topic-subtopic slide might have a headline like “The Importance
of Bread”. This is pretty weak because we don't have any idea what the slide is about.
Why is bread important? Bread is important for what? We get closer with a question: “Why
is bread critical to peanut butter and jelly sandwiches?” Now we have some idea of where
this presentation is going but we still don't know the answer to the question. And you shouldn’t
force your audience to scour the rest of your slide trying to find an answer to the question.
It's better, and will result in better audience retention, if you instead include the full
Assertion in your headline. Something like this: “Bread serves as the handle for a
peanut butter and jelly sandwich.” Now your audience knows exactly where you're going
and what you're trying to prove to them through the use of this slide.
One thing that you'll find when you start developing these Assertion headlines is that
it takes extra time to come up with clear and concise declarative Assertion headlines.
So for example, this presentation that you're watching right now, this particular headline
went through four revisions before I felt that it was clear, concise, and communicated
the information that I wanted to communicate. After you develop your clear, concise, Assertion
headline; its next, your job, to find visual evidence that will support your Assertion.
So for example, here we have a great visual that shows how to bread is the handle for
a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. We’re not simply being told that it's critical to
a PB&J. We’re shown through this visual evidence how a peanut butter and jelly sandwich
simply wouldn't work without the bread. Effective Assertion-Evidence Structure slides have succinct
headlines and clearly relevant visual evidence. And that is the key: clearly relevant visual
evidence.
So here we have a clear and concise headline followed by visual evidence that unquestionably
supports the assertion made in the headline. Here's another one, “A supply chain moves
goods from the supplier to the customer.” And we can see the various stages in the supply
chain on this chart that was produced by the student who developed this slide. Here’s
one makes good use of visualized numeric information. So, “Identity theft is the most common consumer
complaint to the Federal Trade Commission.” We can see a list of complaints that are made
to the Federal Trade Commission and without a doubt; identity theft is the number one
in terms of number of complaints made to the FTC. Here’s one that makes really good use
of animation and we can see this explanation of how the MRI process creates a three-dimensional
image by taking successive slices of the brain and layering them together.
One thing to be careful of as you start to use the Assertion-Evidence Structure is that
your visual evidence actually supports your Assertion. Here’s an example of one, “Modular
buildings provide an inexpensive alternative with low overhead.” And our visual evidence
in this case is a photograph of a modular building. But unfortunately, although this
graphic is related to our Assertion it does not in any way support the Assertion that
it's being made. There are two key ideas in this assertion. First, modular buildings provide
an inexpensive alternative. And second, modular buildings have lower overhead compared ostensibly
to conventional construction. But that's not what this visual evidence supports. A better
version of this slide might instead include a chart or a graph showing how modular buildings
are less expensive compared to traditional construction. Maybe a second slide would provide
a chart showing how the modular buildings have lower maintenance and utility costs compared
to traditional construction - talking about overhead. So make sure that the body visual
evidence actually supports the Assertion. Here's another great example of one that's
not really an Assertion-Evidence Structure slide. This slide makes the case that of all
the people who are targeted for tax return fraud the most vulnerable are the deceased,
the elderly, and children. But rather than showing us visually how the deceased, elderly,
and children, are attacked more often in terms of tax return fraud. This simply presents
an image of a target; one of the words from the Assertion. This is not visual evidence
that clearly supports the Assertion being made. So what you'll find as you start to
implement the Assertion-Evidence Structure in your own slides; is that sometimes you
need to make your own visual evidence. Particularly with topics where there isn't visual evidence
available. For numeric information you can do this through charts and graphs, and you
might have to get creative at times to produce visual evidence that clearly supports your
Assertion headline.
Hopefully you now have a good understanding of the weaknesses of the typical topic-subtopics
structure in PowerPoint. You should have an understanding of what we can learn from research
in cognitive psychology and multimedia learning to help us improve our slides. And finally,
you should have a good handle on the Assertion-Evidence Structure and be able to begin applying it
in your own presentations.
observed, would probably agree that most PowerPoint presentations are terrible, life-sucking wastes
of time. A lot of this has to do with the fact that most people are never taught to
use PowerPoint effectively. “Hey, you know and use a computer; you should have no problem
making a good PowerPoint presentation.” The truth is, developing effective slides
to accompany a presentation takes time and effort, and a little bit of knowledge of multimedia
learning theory doesn't hurt either. In this video I’m going to be introducing the Assertion-Evidence
Structure or AES for slide design. This is a model for structuring slides developed by
Michael Alley and his colleagues at Penn State University. As an overview, we’ll start
by examining the weaknesses of typical PowerPoint slide layouts. We’ll briefly discuss the
contributions that research in multimedia learning theory and cognitive psychology can
provide to our quest for better slides. And finally explain the Assertion-Evidence Structure
and how to use it to increase the effectiveness of your slides.
It turns out that if you have viewed any number of PowerPoint presentations, and at this point
in your career you've probably seen hundreds, it's pretty easy to identify the more effective
design when given two alternatives. But it's really difficult to just start by designing
that more effective slide. In truth, most people have never really thought seriously
about how to design effective PowerPoint presentations. For example, over here we can see a typical
topic-bullet point structure slide about the relative approach to business valuation. You
can probably tell that this second example where we’ve set off the headline from the
body of the slide is a little bit more effective. We might have a little bit more aesthetic
appeal if we add some relevant photographs, and maybe even remove the background from
those photographs, or use highlights to draw attention to the important characteristics
of our slide. But in truth, slides that contain as much text as that first example really
are ineffective. We’re going to be talking a little bit more about why this is in the
remainder of this presentation.
Let's start though by examining why it is that so many PowerPoint presentation slides
are so very ineffective. It starts with the fact that the defaults in PowerPoint don't
do us any favors. Remember that PowerPoint was developed in 1983 and was largely seen
as a vast improvement over typical overhead projectors with transparencies. But unfortunately
because we were moving from overhead projectors and transparencies to a computer-based medium;
those who were using it most often didn't really think about the additional abilities
that computer graphics provided. And so, for the most part, those default layouts that
we see with the topic-bullet point design in PowerPoint are the same types of things
that people were doing with an overhead projector and a transparency. This topic-subtopics structure
that's guided by the default slide layouts in PowerPoint is pervasive across presentation
contexts. For example, one study in the 2009 published in the journal Technical Communication
showed that 59% of industry and government presentations use this topic-subtopic structure.
63% of professional conferences; and 71% of student presentation slides, in their content
analysis, used this default topic-subtopic or topic-bullet point structure.
Well, there are a few problems with this. First, even if you have a professional theme
and relevant images on your slide, there is still way too much text in a typical default
slide layout. There are a few reasons why this large amount of text is a problem. First,
Harvard Business Review in 1998 published an article arguing that bullet lists as are
typically used in these topic-subtopics structure slides dilute thought. Essentially they make
us stupider and they make our presentations stupider because topics and bullet points
can only communicate three logical relationships. We can talk about sequence. First this happened,
then this happened, then this other thing happened. Or we can talk about priority; these
are our most important goals for the quarter. Or we can talk about membership; here is a
general topic and hear a bunch of facts that are sort of related to this general topic.
But the truth is, in our presentations often were talking about information that has relationships
that are far more complex than simply sequence, priority, or membership. But using the default
layouts in PowerPoint doesn't afford us the ability to explain these complex relationships
to our audience. But beyond simply diluting our thought and hindering us from explaining
complex relationships between ideas to our audience; presenters often, when faced with
lots of text on the screen are obligated to read that to the audience.
We have a need to read text when we see it. And our audience has a need to read that text
as well. So presenters often mirror the information on their slide with their oral presentation.
Unfortunately, cognitive psychology tells us that simultaneous speech and text are processed
by the same part of the brain; which ultimately splits attention. Now it might seem to make
intuitive sense. If you hear information you might remember it, and if you see information
you might remember it. So if you both hear and see information you ought to remember
it the best. But it turns out that research has shown this to be entirely incorrect. Researchers
in cognitive psychology, human learning, and multimedia design have found that presenting
information through both channels simultaneously overwhelms the language processor and actually
results in lower information retention. In research published in the academic journal
Applied Cognitive Psychology, Slava Kalyuga and colleagues conducted an experiment in
which they varied the presentation medium of training materials designed to teach apprentices
about types of solder and how to correctly solder various types of joints. Some participants
received written instructions only. Some received written instructions and also were read those
instructions orally. And some received instructions only orally. Well turns out, and you can see
from the graph over here, that overall, the lowest performing condition was that simultaneous
text and speech condition. It simply was overwhelming the language-processing part of the brain
to have both the information presented as written text and as spoken language. And unfortunately,
most of our PowerPoint presentations are right in this part of the graph. Simultaneous text
and speech. In reality, this research suggests that where we really want to be, is to have
most of our presentation delivered orally, through spoken speech. And this tracks well
with what we know about models of human working memory. Baddeley’s model of working memory
suggests that when we receive information through our senses are Central Executive sends
it to one of two places: either the Visuospatial Sketchpad which processes images and visual
information, or, to the Phonological Loop which processes language. We know that linguistic
information whether it’s presented in a text-based form that a person can read or
in spoken form, both types of information are processed by the Phonological Loop. This
model of working memory would suggest that we are overloading the Phonological Loop when
we are simultaneously presenting both written and spoken information. So, what can be done
about this? We know that the typical topic-subtopic structure provides too much text for the audience;
overwhelms the Phonological Loop. What can we do instead? Well, one alternative is called
the Assertion-Evidence Structure. This was developed by Michael Alley and his colleagues
at Penn State University. And it calls for a complete rethinking of the way that slides
should be designed. Rather than starting with a topic-based headline, he suggests starting
with a full-sentence Assertion. So actually tell the audience what the most important
information on your slide is. Here we can see a typical topic-bullet point slide about
the history of the iPhone. If we were to convert that to an Assertion-Evidence Structure slide
we might instead see something like this. Getting rid of the history of the iPhone topic-based
headline and replacing it with of full-sentence Assertion, “The iPhone has received four
major updates since its introduction in June 2007.” Then, rather than simply listing
the model numbers and the dates that they were released, we might visually orient the
audience using a timeline. That would provide them not only with the dates that each model
was released, but also with an image of each model so we can see the progression of the
model over time, and using a timeline, we can also see additional information like the
approximate duration of time between model releases, and the approximate time of year
that new models come out. All of this provides the audience with a much richer understanding
of the relationship between the pieces of information on the slide. And that's one of
the key strengths of the Assertion-Evidence Structure. But beyond simply allowing you
to provide your audience with a more complex understanding of the relationship between
the information points on your slide; the Assertion-Evidence Structure also provides
much better retention for the audience. One study was conducted, published in the journal
Technical Communication in 2006, that showed that simply replacing non-full-sentence Assertion
headlines with full-sentence Assertion headlines drastically improved the recall of students
who were then tested on this information later. You can see here that this example of a slide
used in a college-level geology class, more than doubled student recall simply by turning
that headline into a full-sentence Assertion headline. Similarly, this one about color
in diamonds, by changing that headline from a question about what causes color in diamonds
and instead explaining in the headline itself the things that cause color in diamonds, again
resulted in a doubling of performance when later tested about that information. So the
Assertion-Evidence Structure gives us the ability to represent more complex relationships
between ideas. It focuses the audience on the most important information that they should
take out of each section of the presentation. And finally, it results in much better retention
of your audience for the information that you’re presenting.
So now the question is, how do you implement the Assertion-Evidence Structure in your own
slides? There are three primary characteristics of the Assertion-Evidence Structure. It starts
with the guideline that all blocks of text on your slide should be no more than two lines
high. Now this guidance forces you to really think carefully about what text is important
to include on your slide. So, beyond your two-line Assertion headline, if you have any
other text on the slide: whether that's a callout, or a label of various parts of a
diagram, or any other text on the slide, all blocks should be no more than two lines. That
reduces the amount of time that your audience spends reading your slide and not listening
to what you're saying. The second key characteristic of an Assertion-Evidence Structure slide is
that the slide body should provide visual evidence that clearly supports the Assertion.
And finally, if you use animation in an Assertion-Evidence slide it should be purposeful. So it should
actually help the audience better understand the information on the slide. So for example
here's a slide that was developed by one of my students that I think is an exemplary Assertion-Evidence
Structure slide. We have a two-line Assertion headline that claims that “Construction
of the Autobahn highway system accelerated with the expansion of Nazi Germany”. On
the left we have a graph that shows the number of miles completed on the Autobahn by year.
And on the right we have a map that shows German controlled territories in Europe. So
as we step through, we have very purposeful animation so that we can see as the Autobahn
gets longer and longer we have an increasingly powerful Germany in terms of the amount of
area in Europe that they control. So we have visual evidence that is supporting a key Assertion.
So when you think about the Assertion-Evidence Structure think about: no more than two lines
in a headline that makes an Assertion, makes a claim. And then visual evidence that supports
the claim made in the headline.
One thing that you'll find when you first start using the Assertion-Evidence Structure
is that it takes a little bit more time to carefully develop your Assertion headlines.
So for example, a typical topic-subtopic slide might have a headline like “The Importance
of Bread”. This is pretty weak because we don't have any idea what the slide is about.
Why is bread important? Bread is important for what? We get closer with a question: “Why
is bread critical to peanut butter and jelly sandwiches?” Now we have some idea of where
this presentation is going but we still don't know the answer to the question. And you shouldn’t
force your audience to scour the rest of your slide trying to find an answer to the question.
It's better, and will result in better audience retention, if you instead include the full
Assertion in your headline. Something like this: “Bread serves as the handle for a
peanut butter and jelly sandwich.” Now your audience knows exactly where you're going
and what you're trying to prove to them through the use of this slide.
One thing that you'll find when you start developing these Assertion headlines is that
it takes extra time to come up with clear and concise declarative Assertion headlines.
So for example, this presentation that you're watching right now, this particular headline
went through four revisions before I felt that it was clear, concise, and communicated
the information that I wanted to communicate. After you develop your clear, concise, Assertion
headline; its next, your job, to find visual evidence that will support your Assertion.
So for example, here we have a great visual that shows how to bread is the handle for
a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. We’re not simply being told that it's critical to
a PB&J. We’re shown through this visual evidence how a peanut butter and jelly sandwich
simply wouldn't work without the bread. Effective Assertion-Evidence Structure slides have succinct
headlines and clearly relevant visual evidence. And that is the key: clearly relevant visual
evidence.
So here we have a clear and concise headline followed by visual evidence that unquestionably
supports the assertion made in the headline. Here's another one, “A supply chain moves
goods from the supplier to the customer.” And we can see the various stages in the supply
chain on this chart that was produced by the student who developed this slide. Here’s
one makes good use of visualized numeric information. So, “Identity theft is the most common consumer
complaint to the Federal Trade Commission.” We can see a list of complaints that are made
to the Federal Trade Commission and without a doubt; identity theft is the number one
in terms of number of complaints made to the FTC. Here’s one that makes really good use
of animation and we can see this explanation of how the MRI process creates a three-dimensional
image by taking successive slices of the brain and layering them together.
One thing to be careful of as you start to use the Assertion-Evidence Structure is that
your visual evidence actually supports your Assertion. Here’s an example of one, “Modular
buildings provide an inexpensive alternative with low overhead.” And our visual evidence
in this case is a photograph of a modular building. But unfortunately, although this
graphic is related to our Assertion it does not in any way support the Assertion that
it's being made. There are two key ideas in this assertion. First, modular buildings provide
an inexpensive alternative. And second, modular buildings have lower overhead compared ostensibly
to conventional construction. But that's not what this visual evidence supports. A better
version of this slide might instead include a chart or a graph showing how modular buildings
are less expensive compared to traditional construction. Maybe a second slide would provide
a chart showing how the modular buildings have lower maintenance and utility costs compared
to traditional construction - talking about overhead. So make sure that the body visual
evidence actually supports the Assertion. Here's another great example of one that's
not really an Assertion-Evidence Structure slide. This slide makes the case that of all
the people who are targeted for tax return fraud the most vulnerable are the deceased,
the elderly, and children. But rather than showing us visually how the deceased, elderly,
and children, are attacked more often in terms of tax return fraud. This simply presents
an image of a target; one of the words from the Assertion. This is not visual evidence
that clearly supports the Assertion being made. So what you'll find as you start to
implement the Assertion-Evidence Structure in your own slides; is that sometimes you
need to make your own visual evidence. Particularly with topics where there isn't visual evidence
available. For numeric information you can do this through charts and graphs, and you
might have to get creative at times to produce visual evidence that clearly supports your
Assertion headline.
Hopefully you now have a good understanding of the weaknesses of the typical topic-subtopics
structure in PowerPoint. You should have an understanding of what we can learn from research
in cognitive psychology and multimedia learning to help us improve our slides. And finally,
you should have a good handle on the Assertion-Evidence Structure and be able to begin applying it
in your own presentations.