Advertisement
English transcript
Prof: Last time--so last time we discussed two factors
that limited--that retarded and limited your progress.
Remember, I'm describing that Europe was in a pretty bad
situation.
One was sort of mental--cultural,
there was a mindset that largely focused on the
supernatural and did not have that mindset to question
received wisdom and to test whatever they believed against
what they saw in reality.
The second was a food and population balance that left
vast numbers of people in conditions of near starvation.
Around 1750--around 1700, Europe started to outgrow these
limitations and we started talking about that last time.
We saw how the scientific revolution,
given great impetus by Newton, he wasn't the only one but the
fabulous success in explaining the universe that Newton's three
very simple laws-- you learned that certainly in
high school if not in junior high school--
explained how all the heavens work and that was an amazing
creation of the human mind and it had tremendous import and
started what's been called the Enlightenment.
That sort of changed the mental set into something more
progressive, and then as you've read in--I
hope in your course packet the introduction of foods from
America sort of cut down-- got rid of the physical
limitation on population and economic well being in Europe,
that the amount of food went way up.
So this--especially the food--increased the European
population.
There's all kinds of different numbers available but anywhere
from 62% up to a doubling of the European population due to the
introduction of American foods.
Now the standard belief about population at that time was that
population is a wonderful thing.
Jean-Jacques Rousseau who we've talked about,
who was abandoning his own children by the car load to
control his individual family's--
the number of children they had to cope with--
in terms when he thought about the grand--
the political system he said, "that government under
which the citizens do most increase and multiply is
infallibly the best.
Similarly, the government under which a people diminishes in
number and wastes away is the worst."
He's very clear that not only is high population good but it's
infallibly good.
Benjamin Franklin, around 1751,
argues about this.
"There were upwards of one million English souls in
America," This is before the Revolution.
"This million doubling supposed but once in 25
years," which is not a bad estimate of the doubling time of
American population at that time, due largely to
immigration.
"Doubling once every 25 years, within and another--will,
in another century be more than the people of England.
What an accession of power that will be."
And the realization of American increase in numbers and
therefore increase in power was very important in the history of
that time.
After the French and Indian War, before our Revolution that
you know of, the settlement that the English
got Canada, which was barren wasn't worth
very much at the time, and the French kept the islands
in the Atlantic which were very rich,
sugar and plantations, slavery of course.
The French kept those and the English took Canada.
Why?
To keep the Americans in check because they knew that the
Americans would get very strong.
Thomas Jefferson often said, 'population is power,' so in
1800 when the U.S.
was only ten years old, so very fragile in terms of our
military strength and everything like that.
Napoleon had recently--Spain had owned Louisiana which was
the whole vast territory to the west of the 13 colonies,
and during the Napoleonic Wars, Napoleon got charge of them.
He was going to send French troops there to occupy Louisiana
because they were such a big and important territory,
but the U.S., of course, objected.
We were having this huge population growth,
immigration, they were flooding over the
Appalachian Mountains into the territories.
The next boundary was the Mississippi River,
and America did not want any of the European powers taking
control there.
The French Ambassador in America realized that America
was growing so rapidly in power and he thought Napoleon's idea
to send troops was stupid, that Napoleon would lose the
war.
This guy was very clever, he did one thing,
he sent to Napoleon a summary of the American Census of 1800.
Remember that in The Constitution we have to take a
census.
There was one taken in 1800 and it showed such a great rate of
American population increase that that's all he had to send.
It showed that the U.S.
population was doubling every 22 years, not the 25 that
Benjamin Franklin had estimated.
Napoleon got the message immediately;
there was no way that France was going to be able to hold
Louisiana against American objections.
What did Napoleon do?
Sold it to us for a pittance, basically a pittance,
because he knew he could not hold it;
the power of population.
Now why did governments love large populations?
Why was it power?
Two things, one a lot of men and what do you do with men?
Take them into the army so you have big military power,
also more people farm more land, produce more food,
and other goods.
Then what can you do?
You can tax it, so the governments get a lot of
tax and a lot of people if they have a big population.
There was no question in anyone's mind that a big and
growing population was just a wonderful sort of thing.
What they didn't realize is one of the things that I'm trying to
get across in this class, that that system works for a
situation where you have no limitation on land or resources.
It's like I've been--I was describing for Africa where the
population was small and land was large,
then population is--can be a benefit in the way just
described.
The reality, for Europe especially,
was different.
After 1750, again largely due to the American foods,
people filled the European countrysides to overflowing
capacity.
These are quotes from various sources back then.
"Mountains spilled over with people, cities grew and the
plains became full, but this increase in population
brought more mouths to feed.
Population rose and the resources could not match the
population."
When you have more consumers then goods,
law of supply and demand, prices rose,
people couldn't afford what they previously could afford,
and poverty deepened.
In this period in Europe people often moved--migrated seasonally
to get jobs because they didn't have enough income from their
own land.
They would go to where some harvest--
they were needed to harvest or needed to work on a building
project, but at this time this
population of people wandering around looking for some sort of
work increased so much that the line between migration and
vagabondage, becoming just a vagabond,
was crossed by hundreds of thousands of Europeans.
They were just wandering around looking for some kind of work to
keep them alive for a little bit longer.
This was written--noticed and written about a lot at the time.
They flooded the highways, roads were opening up at the
time.
They flooded the highways of France, Germany,
the low countries, all of these places this was
noticed.
Children at the time--again you read there's crowded orphanages
and foundling homes, women and children--very large
number of beggars arose at this time.
Women and children begged on church steps and on roadsides.
This problem of poverty as I've mentioned was much observed,
much worried about, much commented upon,
and in fact, all of the great intellectuals
of the day, whose names we still know,
commented upon it.
You all know Edward Gibbon?
Gibbon wrote, The Decline and Fall of the
Roman Empire, one of the most famous
intellectuals of that time.
Right after that he wrote, "In the civilized world
the most numerous class is condemned to ignorance and
poverty."
Why were people poor?
Well the general consideration then: they were poor because
they were in some way deficient.
The idea was that God had given some people--
kings and aristocrats--the abilities and capability to rule
and all the others were relegated to the lower classes.
They just didn't--they had bad heredity,
they were lazy, they were "the wrong
sort," they were inherently incapable that their nature,
their human nature, they didn't really have genetic
ideas back then, was to be incapable of leading
the good kind of life.
Well, this was a nice theory and people who are upper class
enough to get an education to write about it could live
comfortably with that theory.
Then America opens up for colonization and guess what
happens?
Who moves to America?
The poorest people, especially from England.
The lower classes moved to Australia at a somewhat later
time, and then they empty out the
prisons going to Australia so they have really the lower
classes.
What happens to America?
As I've just showed you the people work hard,
they're industrious, they make a lot of money,
they get ahead, everything looks very good in
America and so the theory just didn't fit observation.
As I've mentioned, people are, by now,
paying attention to what's around them and this idea that
Americans had been so poor in England but they moved to
America and things get better.
The question arose: why were the poor so poor in
England?
Kind of an obvious question; again not the first time that
this question had been asked.
The Bible, and again sorry for--keep referring to religion
but you cannot, just cannot discuss Western
intellectual history without going there because that was the
basis of the way people thought.
What the Bible says, Ecclesiastes,
'when goods increase they are increased that eat them.'
If you have more stuff, population grows and they eat
the food.
Very close to what we'll see Malthus says later.
Edmund Burke, who as you know is now
considered the father of conservative political
philosophy: "The laboring people are only poor because
they are numerous; numbers in their nature imply
poverty."
In a fair distribution--what liberals were saying share
equally, "In a fair distribution
among a vast multitude none can have much."
He was talking against spreading the wealth because
under that condition if you spread the wealth everybody is
extremely poor.
Those kind of thoughts started people thinking about the
relationship between population and resources.
What was that?
There's this sort of a fairly new way of thinking about
things.
Where did they turn to?
Again, in the spirit of the Enlightenment,
science was the leading source of intellectual new ideas and
natural history was going on-- was getting going at that time,
studying of plants and animals in their natural habitats,
just like all your TAs for this course.
Adam Smith, among others, paid great attention to what
the naturalists were saying.
In The Wealth of Nations,
1776, "Every species of animal naturally multiples in
proportion to the means of their subsistence and no species can
ever multiply beyond it."
Then he explicitly says, "Men, like all other
animals, naturally multiply in proportion to their means of
subsistence."
So he's immediately applying an ecological law from the study of
animals to people.
Well how fast can humans multiply?
David Hume, another one of the luminous philosophers,
1742: "Almost every man who thinks he can maintain a
family will have one, and the human species at this
rate of propagation would more than double every
generation."
Adam Smith again got some of the problem;
he realized that if wages increased, if things started to
get better and wages increased, this would lead to an increase
in population.
He explicitly says, if people have more money
they're going to be able to feed their children more and they
will stay alive, and there will be a decline in
mortality, and the population will grow.
He--very surprising--did not close the circle and did not--
never apparently realized that this growth in the population
would mean more competitors for the jobs and would push wages
back down again.
That was the great achievement of Malthus--and all this
interest in what is the cause of poverty, and there were many
other things.
There was an enclosure movement in England at the time where the
lands on which the peasants had lived were being closed in and
controlled by the squires, the country squires and so
forth; a lot of other things going on.
This was the kind of argumentation that was going on
at the time.
Malthus was the one that realized that population and
wages and mortality were in a negative--what we now call a
negative feedback loop.
If wages increased, as I've just said,
then population grows and if population grows the competition
for jobs and for food and for everything else pushes wages
back down, or pushes prices back up so if
you earn the same you're still getting less.
In short, although the population could grow and the
economy on a gross scale could grow, the per capita income,
he basically said, could not grow.
In the strongest statement of this,
and he went through many editions with many different
statements, but in the strongest statement
economic progress is basically impossible;
looked at from the point of view of per capita income,
the living standards of the average person.
Malthus was very clever and thought more deeply about it and
he was aware of two contradictory changes that were
happening throughout the eighteenth century;
he writes in 1798, at the end of the eighteenth
century.
As I've mentioned and you've read there's no question that
agriculture was improving, not only American foods,
but also agronomy was coming in as a science and people were
learning, even with the same crops,
to improve the crops, to improve their livestock,
to fertilize better, to rotate fields better.
They were learning to grow more food.
Nevertheless, even though there was more food
around poverty was growing, and that was also very clear at
the time.
His argument is based on a few very simple kinds of statements.
Contrary to some previous thinkers who envisioned the
relation between population and resources as there's a fixed
amount of resources.
There's a pie.
We now use the expression pie; there's a pie and depending on
how many people there are you divide the pie into smaller and
smaller slices.
The more people, the smaller slices of the pie.
That is completely wrong and never has been correct.
All people do some kind of work and the pie grows with each
person some-- the pie grows to a certain
degree and the question is how much does the pie grow?
For instance again, in the United States at the
time, we had these vast lands to the
west where we were killing or had killed the Indians and they
were very few of them anyway, so that allowed each new
person--so as the population grows--
again when you have no limitation of resources--
a new family is living on the frontier,
the frontier becomes crowded.
American population was growing very fast;
they were having lots of kids, lots of immigrants,
where do the new people go?
They just move some miles to the west and they get a
beautiful new farm and the land is just as good as what was left
behind and they grow as much as the farmers that they left
behind.
The population increases, the gross economy increases,
and the per capita standard of living does not decrease because
this guy has the same amount of resources as the previous
generation had.
This was not the condition in Europe, or in England,
or the rest of--actually all across Eurasia.
Here the law of diminishing returns takes effect because
land starts to be limiting.
When land is limiting--people are naturally smart,
what do they do?
If there's beautiful land, fertile land by a river,
of course they farm that first, and so as the population grows
that gets taken up, all the good land comes under
the plow and is good.
Population keeps growing, well the next set of people
have to go to less good land, maybe drier land,
maybe hillier land, and their productivity is not
quite as good as the previous group that got the best land.
Population keeps growing and people have to move high on the
mountaintops, into dry areas,
into desert areas, into swampy areas,
in all kinds of areas where their production is not going to
be as high.
The average income, from say farming,
decreases as you use less good land and so things--
conditions get worse and finally all the land is used up
and there's no land for farmers whatsoever.
This is the law of diminishing returns.
If you travel around you can really see the law of
diminishing returns happen-- a mix of how people always do
some work, but when there isn't much
resource to take advantage of they can accomplish very little.
Quite a few years ago I was traveling in the highlands of
Bolivia and Peru, and a lot of native Indian
markets there-- very colorful,
tourists love to go to them-- but you watch the ladies sit
down and they have a blanket in front of them and they display
their wares and they-- it's all agricultural and
they'll have maybe a few fruits, and a little bit of this and a
little bit of that, and they have almost nothing,
almost no stock on the blanket.
They've grown this over the past say months or something;
they've walked all the way maybe even days to get to a
market, and then they have very little to sell.
Even if they could sell everything that they brought at
some sort of a profit they didn't have enough--
their total amount that they would take home was still very,
very little.
They were producing some, but not very much.
In the cities--I have to tell you one story.
I was in Lima in Peru, this same trip,
and a lot of street vendors doing stuff and I saw one guy
had a pair of socks up there, and he had some sort of a
knitting needle or something.
He was holding up the sock and as he was talking to the crowd,
jabbing the sock with his knitting needle,
and he was saying, 'You can't destroy this sock.
You can't destroy this sock.
It'll last the rest of your life.' Bash, bash,
bash.
I'm watching for a while and I'm skeptical but the socks
seemed okay.
I thought, the poor guy; I bought the pair of socks.
Those socks, I could not destroy them,
I used them for about 20 years.
It was really true.
He was making some sort of a meager living but it wasn't
good.
If he had a better job, if there were more resources
that he could utilize--his low wages would not drag down the
average.
You must realize of course that when one says a phrase like
that, that he could--there were
resources that he could utilize--
brings up a vast consideration of power and everything else.
What other resources and who gets to utilize them and so
forth.
It's a much more--of course I say a little bit and there's
much, much more to say about all of these things.
The law of diminishing returns reduces the average
productivity, but there's a counter-veiling
trend which he also was aware of that I've just mentioned.
That the productivity of the land was increasing,
again through the new foods and new agricultural technologies.
These two factors work in opposite directions,
and Malthus had to make some sort of a guess as to how these
two factors would balance out.
Which would predominate?
Would the introduction of new technology improve faster than
the law of diminishing returns decreased it,
and his conclusion was that technology would be somewhat
stronger then the law of diminishing returns so that
total productivity-- per capita productivity and
total productivity-- would indeed keep increasing.
He thought it would increase sort of at a constant sort of a
rate.
In graph terms, let me see if I can get right
to this graph--here's--this is the standard kind of graph about
Malthus.
Here is the way he thought that resources,
mostly food in his--in the case--the time that he was
talking about-- he thought they would increase
in a more or less regular way, per every year if you consider
these years.
Every year would increase by about the same amount.
He called that an arithmetic growth.
We now call it a linear growth.
He and everyone else knew that population can grow faster than
that, so you probably understand a little bit about exponential
growth.
If
…
that limited--that retarded and limited your progress.
Remember, I'm describing that Europe was in a pretty bad
situation.
One was sort of mental--cultural,
there was a mindset that largely focused on the
supernatural and did not have that mindset to question
received wisdom and to test whatever they believed against
what they saw in reality.
The second was a food and population balance that left
vast numbers of people in conditions of near starvation.
Around 1750--around 1700, Europe started to outgrow these
limitations and we started talking about that last time.
We saw how the scientific revolution,
given great impetus by Newton, he wasn't the only one but the
fabulous success in explaining the universe that Newton's three
very simple laws-- you learned that certainly in
high school if not in junior high school--
explained how all the heavens work and that was an amazing
creation of the human mind and it had tremendous import and
started what's been called the Enlightenment.
That sort of changed the mental set into something more
progressive, and then as you've read in--I
hope in your course packet the introduction of foods from
America sort of cut down-- got rid of the physical
limitation on population and economic well being in Europe,
that the amount of food went way up.
So this--especially the food--increased the European
population.
There's all kinds of different numbers available but anywhere
from 62% up to a doubling of the European population due to the
introduction of American foods.
Now the standard belief about population at that time was that
population is a wonderful thing.
Jean-Jacques Rousseau who we've talked about,
who was abandoning his own children by the car load to
control his individual family's--
the number of children they had to cope with--
in terms when he thought about the grand--
the political system he said, "that government under
which the citizens do most increase and multiply is
infallibly the best.
Similarly, the government under which a people diminishes in
number and wastes away is the worst."
He's very clear that not only is high population good but it's
infallibly good.
Benjamin Franklin, around 1751,
argues about this.
"There were upwards of one million English souls in
America," This is before the Revolution.
"This million doubling supposed but once in 25
years," which is not a bad estimate of the doubling time of
American population at that time, due largely to
immigration.
"Doubling once every 25 years, within and another--will,
in another century be more than the people of England.
What an accession of power that will be."
And the realization of American increase in numbers and
therefore increase in power was very important in the history of
that time.
After the French and Indian War, before our Revolution that
you know of, the settlement that the English
got Canada, which was barren wasn't worth
very much at the time, and the French kept the islands
in the Atlantic which were very rich,
sugar and plantations, slavery of course.
The French kept those and the English took Canada.
Why?
To keep the Americans in check because they knew that the
Americans would get very strong.
Thomas Jefferson often said, 'population is power,' so in
1800 when the U.S.
was only ten years old, so very fragile in terms of our
military strength and everything like that.
Napoleon had recently--Spain had owned Louisiana which was
the whole vast territory to the west of the 13 colonies,
and during the Napoleonic Wars, Napoleon got charge of them.
He was going to send French troops there to occupy Louisiana
because they were such a big and important territory,
but the U.S., of course, objected.
We were having this huge population growth,
immigration, they were flooding over the
Appalachian Mountains into the territories.
The next boundary was the Mississippi River,
and America did not want any of the European powers taking
control there.
The French Ambassador in America realized that America
was growing so rapidly in power and he thought Napoleon's idea
to send troops was stupid, that Napoleon would lose the
war.
This guy was very clever, he did one thing,
he sent to Napoleon a summary of the American Census of 1800.
Remember that in The Constitution we have to take a
census.
There was one taken in 1800 and it showed such a great rate of
American population increase that that's all he had to send.
It showed that the U.S.
population was doubling every 22 years, not the 25 that
Benjamin Franklin had estimated.
Napoleon got the message immediately;
there was no way that France was going to be able to hold
Louisiana against American objections.
What did Napoleon do?
Sold it to us for a pittance, basically a pittance,
because he knew he could not hold it;
the power of population.
Now why did governments love large populations?
Why was it power?
Two things, one a lot of men and what do you do with men?
Take them into the army so you have big military power,
also more people farm more land, produce more food,
and other goods.
Then what can you do?
You can tax it, so the governments get a lot of
tax and a lot of people if they have a big population.
There was no question in anyone's mind that a big and
growing population was just a wonderful sort of thing.
What they didn't realize is one of the things that I'm trying to
get across in this class, that that system works for a
situation where you have no limitation on land or resources.
It's like I've been--I was describing for Africa where the
population was small and land was large,
then population is--can be a benefit in the way just
described.
The reality, for Europe especially,
was different.
After 1750, again largely due to the American foods,
people filled the European countrysides to overflowing
capacity.
These are quotes from various sources back then.
"Mountains spilled over with people, cities grew and the
plains became full, but this increase in population
brought more mouths to feed.
Population rose and the resources could not match the
population."
When you have more consumers then goods,
law of supply and demand, prices rose,
people couldn't afford what they previously could afford,
and poverty deepened.
In this period in Europe people often moved--migrated seasonally
to get jobs because they didn't have enough income from their
own land.
They would go to where some harvest--
they were needed to harvest or needed to work on a building
project, but at this time this
population of people wandering around looking for some sort of
work increased so much that the line between migration and
vagabondage, becoming just a vagabond,
was crossed by hundreds of thousands of Europeans.
They were just wandering around looking for some kind of work to
keep them alive for a little bit longer.
This was written--noticed and written about a lot at the time.
They flooded the highways, roads were opening up at the
time.
They flooded the highways of France, Germany,
the low countries, all of these places this was
noticed.
Children at the time--again you read there's crowded orphanages
and foundling homes, women and children--very large
number of beggars arose at this time.
Women and children begged on church steps and on roadsides.
This problem of poverty as I've mentioned was much observed,
much worried about, much commented upon,
and in fact, all of the great intellectuals
of the day, whose names we still know,
commented upon it.
You all know Edward Gibbon?
Gibbon wrote, The Decline and Fall of the
Roman Empire, one of the most famous
intellectuals of that time.
Right after that he wrote, "In the civilized world
the most numerous class is condemned to ignorance and
poverty."
Why were people poor?
Well the general consideration then: they were poor because
they were in some way deficient.
The idea was that God had given some people--
kings and aristocrats--the abilities and capability to rule
and all the others were relegated to the lower classes.
They just didn't--they had bad heredity,
they were lazy, they were "the wrong
sort," they were inherently incapable that their nature,
their human nature, they didn't really have genetic
ideas back then, was to be incapable of leading
the good kind of life.
Well, this was a nice theory and people who are upper class
enough to get an education to write about it could live
comfortably with that theory.
Then America opens up for colonization and guess what
happens?
Who moves to America?
The poorest people, especially from England.
The lower classes moved to Australia at a somewhat later
time, and then they empty out the
prisons going to Australia so they have really the lower
classes.
What happens to America?
As I've just showed you the people work hard,
they're industrious, they make a lot of money,
they get ahead, everything looks very good in
America and so the theory just didn't fit observation.
As I've mentioned, people are, by now,
paying attention to what's around them and this idea that
Americans had been so poor in England but they moved to
America and things get better.
The question arose: why were the poor so poor in
England?
Kind of an obvious question; again not the first time that
this question had been asked.
The Bible, and again sorry for--keep referring to religion
but you cannot, just cannot discuss Western
intellectual history without going there because that was the
basis of the way people thought.
What the Bible says, Ecclesiastes,
'when goods increase they are increased that eat them.'
If you have more stuff, population grows and they eat
the food.
Very close to what we'll see Malthus says later.
Edmund Burke, who as you know is now
considered the father of conservative political
philosophy: "The laboring people are only poor because
they are numerous; numbers in their nature imply
poverty."
In a fair distribution--what liberals were saying share
equally, "In a fair distribution
among a vast multitude none can have much."
He was talking against spreading the wealth because
under that condition if you spread the wealth everybody is
extremely poor.
Those kind of thoughts started people thinking about the
relationship between population and resources.
What was that?
There's this sort of a fairly new way of thinking about
things.
Where did they turn to?
Again, in the spirit of the Enlightenment,
science was the leading source of intellectual new ideas and
natural history was going on-- was getting going at that time,
studying of plants and animals in their natural habitats,
just like all your TAs for this course.
Adam Smith, among others, paid great attention to what
the naturalists were saying.
In The Wealth of Nations,
1776, "Every species of animal naturally multiples in
proportion to the means of their subsistence and no species can
ever multiply beyond it."
Then he explicitly says, "Men, like all other
animals, naturally multiply in proportion to their means of
subsistence."
So he's immediately applying an ecological law from the study of
animals to people.
Well how fast can humans multiply?
David Hume, another one of the luminous philosophers,
1742: "Almost every man who thinks he can maintain a
family will have one, and the human species at this
rate of propagation would more than double every
generation."
Adam Smith again got some of the problem;
he realized that if wages increased, if things started to
get better and wages increased, this would lead to an increase
in population.
He explicitly says, if people have more money
they're going to be able to feed their children more and they
will stay alive, and there will be a decline in
mortality, and the population will grow.
He--very surprising--did not close the circle and did not--
never apparently realized that this growth in the population
would mean more competitors for the jobs and would push wages
back down again.
That was the great achievement of Malthus--and all this
interest in what is the cause of poverty, and there were many
other things.
There was an enclosure movement in England at the time where the
lands on which the peasants had lived were being closed in and
controlled by the squires, the country squires and so
forth; a lot of other things going on.
This was the kind of argumentation that was going on
at the time.
Malthus was the one that realized that population and
wages and mortality were in a negative--what we now call a
negative feedback loop.
If wages increased, as I've just said,
then population grows and if population grows the competition
for jobs and for food and for everything else pushes wages
back down, or pushes prices back up so if
you earn the same you're still getting less.
In short, although the population could grow and the
economy on a gross scale could grow, the per capita income,
he basically said, could not grow.
In the strongest statement of this,
and he went through many editions with many different
statements, but in the strongest statement
economic progress is basically impossible;
looked at from the point of view of per capita income,
the living standards of the average person.
Malthus was very clever and thought more deeply about it and
he was aware of two contradictory changes that were
happening throughout the eighteenth century;
he writes in 1798, at the end of the eighteenth
century.
As I've mentioned and you've read there's no question that
agriculture was improving, not only American foods,
but also agronomy was coming in as a science and people were
learning, even with the same crops,
to improve the crops, to improve their livestock,
to fertilize better, to rotate fields better.
They were learning to grow more food.
Nevertheless, even though there was more food
around poverty was growing, and that was also very clear at
the time.
His argument is based on a few very simple kinds of statements.
Contrary to some previous thinkers who envisioned the
relation between population and resources as there's a fixed
amount of resources.
There's a pie.
We now use the expression pie; there's a pie and depending on
how many people there are you divide the pie into smaller and
smaller slices.
The more people, the smaller slices of the pie.
That is completely wrong and never has been correct.
All people do some kind of work and the pie grows with each
person some-- the pie grows to a certain
degree and the question is how much does the pie grow?
For instance again, in the United States at the
time, we had these vast lands to the
west where we were killing or had killed the Indians and they
were very few of them anyway, so that allowed each new
person--so as the population grows--
again when you have no limitation of resources--
a new family is living on the frontier,
the frontier becomes crowded.
American population was growing very fast;
they were having lots of kids, lots of immigrants,
where do the new people go?
They just move some miles to the west and they get a
beautiful new farm and the land is just as good as what was left
behind and they grow as much as the farmers that they left
behind.
The population increases, the gross economy increases,
and the per capita standard of living does not decrease because
this guy has the same amount of resources as the previous
generation had.
This was not the condition in Europe, or in England,
or the rest of--actually all across Eurasia.
Here the law of diminishing returns takes effect because
land starts to be limiting.
When land is limiting--people are naturally smart,
what do they do?
If there's beautiful land, fertile land by a river,
of course they farm that first, and so as the population grows
that gets taken up, all the good land comes under
the plow and is good.
Population keeps growing, well the next set of people
have to go to less good land, maybe drier land,
maybe hillier land, and their productivity is not
quite as good as the previous group that got the best land.
Population keeps growing and people have to move high on the
mountaintops, into dry areas,
into desert areas, into swampy areas,
in all kinds of areas where their production is not going to
be as high.
The average income, from say farming,
decreases as you use less good land and so things--
conditions get worse and finally all the land is used up
and there's no land for farmers whatsoever.
This is the law of diminishing returns.
If you travel around you can really see the law of
diminishing returns happen-- a mix of how people always do
some work, but when there isn't much
resource to take advantage of they can accomplish very little.
Quite a few years ago I was traveling in the highlands of
Bolivia and Peru, and a lot of native Indian
markets there-- very colorful,
tourists love to go to them-- but you watch the ladies sit
down and they have a blanket in front of them and they display
their wares and they-- it's all agricultural and
they'll have maybe a few fruits, and a little bit of this and a
little bit of that, and they have almost nothing,
almost no stock on the blanket.
They've grown this over the past say months or something;
they've walked all the way maybe even days to get to a
market, and then they have very little to sell.
Even if they could sell everything that they brought at
some sort of a profit they didn't have enough--
their total amount that they would take home was still very,
very little.
They were producing some, but not very much.
In the cities--I have to tell you one story.
I was in Lima in Peru, this same trip,
and a lot of street vendors doing stuff and I saw one guy
had a pair of socks up there, and he had some sort of a
knitting needle or something.
He was holding up the sock and as he was talking to the crowd,
jabbing the sock with his knitting needle,
and he was saying, 'You can't destroy this sock.
You can't destroy this sock.
It'll last the rest of your life.' Bash, bash,
bash.
I'm watching for a while and I'm skeptical but the socks
seemed okay.
I thought, the poor guy; I bought the pair of socks.
Those socks, I could not destroy them,
I used them for about 20 years.
It was really true.
He was making some sort of a meager living but it wasn't
good.
If he had a better job, if there were more resources
that he could utilize--his low wages would not drag down the
average.
You must realize of course that when one says a phrase like
that, that he could--there were
resources that he could utilize--
brings up a vast consideration of power and everything else.
What other resources and who gets to utilize them and so
forth.
It's a much more--of course I say a little bit and there's
much, much more to say about all of these things.
The law of diminishing returns reduces the average
productivity, but there's a counter-veiling
trend which he also was aware of that I've just mentioned.
That the productivity of the land was increasing,
again through the new foods and new agricultural technologies.
These two factors work in opposite directions,
and Malthus had to make some sort of a guess as to how these
two factors would balance out.
Which would predominate?
Would the introduction of new technology improve faster than
the law of diminishing returns decreased it,
and his conclusion was that technology would be somewhat
stronger then the law of diminishing returns so that
total productivity-- per capita productivity and
total productivity-- would indeed keep increasing.
He thought it would increase sort of at a constant sort of a
rate.
In graph terms, let me see if I can get right
to this graph--here's--this is the standard kind of graph about
Malthus.
Here is the way he thought that resources,
mostly food in his--in the case--the time that he was
talking about-- he thought they would increase
in a more or less regular way, per every year if you consider
these years.
Every year would increase by about the same amount.
He called that an arithmetic growth.
We now call it a linear growth.
He and everyone else knew that population can grow faster than
that, so you probably understand a little bit about exponential
growth.
If
…